Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutF. Applicant’s Response to ARB Comments, dated September 9, 20251 ORCHARDS Architectural Review Board: Response to Comments The Orchards site plan has been shaped through an extensive public process beginning in the fall of 2022, when Sunset acquired Chevron Park. From the outset, Sunset undertook a collaborative and iterative design effort, presenting a range of land use concepts that were refined in response to feedback from the Planning Commission, City Council, and community members. Key considerations throughout this process included the siting of Standard Park, the creation of a vibrant and successful retail environment, the integration of walking opportunities, and the provision of a diverse range of housing types. A preliminary site plan was shared with the community at an open house prior to the submission of formal application materials in fall 2024. Following submittal, the Architectural Review Board held three meetings to review the plan, with particular focus on site design, architecture, and neighborhood character. May 8th ARB Meeting 1. Need additional consideration of the social connectivity between the different districts, and how the districts connect. Create social gathering nodes and points beyond just pathways and sidewalks. Consider the site layout and relationship between single-family, multi-family and retail uses to enhance community interaction and neighborhood identity. Orchards is a connected network of parks, plazas, paseos, and greenways that shapes a vibrant, multi-generational community where people of all ages can connect with each other and with nature. The central neighborhood park—an open space framed by rowhomes and patios—offers flexible lawns for community events and daily neighborly interaction, complemented by smaller play areas and intimate paseos that layer programs and amenities at a variety of scales to support multi-generational use. Heritage oak tree parks anchor the Perimeter Greenway with shade, seating, and succession planting, while larger nodes such as Standard Park provide a central lawn, playgrounds, and a retail plaza activated with dining and social gathering. A continuous 12-foot multi-use path along Sunset Drive and the Perimeter Greenway links these destinations, buffered by tree canopies, stormwater landscapes, and woodland planting that add shade, beauty, and resilience. Together, these experiences create a safe, engaging public realm where walking feels intuitive and rewarding, and where open spaces invite play, rest, celebration, and connection—fostering a welcoming, multi-generational environment for families, children, elders, and the broader community. 2. Create an entry point into the Neighborhood District so there is a sense of arrival; this will create a better transition from the Neighborhood District to the Higher Density areas. Create community and social connectivity by extending the green path space and providing wide, multimodal access across multi-family, single-family and retail areas. Additional attention needs to be paid to the pathway connection from Sunset Drive into the Neighborhood District and widening these paths. The intention is for Orchards to feel like a community without distinct boundaries 2 between the Districts. The intersection has been upgraded to include: • A 12’ wide east-west multi-use path connecting to a Heritage Oak Tree Park to enhance connectivity • Added a raised table intersection • A landscaped setback along the Single-Family Row Homes on the south side of the intersection 3. Link the community via a network of nodes and green spaces. The east-west connection within the Neighborhood District needs to be enhanced. The intersection has been upgraded to include: • A 12’ wide east-west multi-use path connecting to a Heritage Oak Tree Park • Landscaped setbacks frame the northern and southern edge of the Single-Family Row Homes • The paseo in the Single-Family Row Homes has been expanded 4. The Board requested additional information regarding how the Multi-Family and Mixed- Use Districts will be used in the short term. We anticipate the existing buildings will be demolished in the first phase of construction. Our intention is to maintain the Bollinger Canyon landscaped frontage and northern parking lots while the Neighborhood District is developed. This preserves visual aesthetics for the community and offers an opportunity for temporary activation. The site’s zoning allows for Commercial Recreation – Outdoor which could include outdoor sports and other types of recreation as interim uses before the apartment and retail developments occur. 5. Add green spaces along the single-family sidewalks to define the neighborhood. At Orchards, streets form the backbone of layout, placemaking, and mobility—serving as both connectors and open spaces where people can move, linger, and gather. They include sidewalks with gracious planting on both sides and are designed to create a comfortable and accessible public realm. The network links the Mixed-Use, Multi-Family, and Neighborhood Districts, anchored by Sunset Drive’s 12-foot multi-use path that connects north to City Center, south to neighborhoods and the Perimeter Greenway, and east to the Iron Horse Trail. Homes and businesses face streets, paseos, and parks, ensuring a friendly pedestrian environment, while cars are tucked into garages, auto courts, or internal streets. Together, streets and open spaces—including parks, plazas, and paseos— create a resilient, people-first framework that integrates ecology, connectivity, and community life. 3 6. Provide additional connectivity linking the Project to the Iron Horse Trail as people will heavily utilize this east-west movement. The site plan includes 4 eastern connection points: Along Bollinger Canyon Road, from the Mixed-Use District which will connect to Heritage Park and Belmont Village, adjacent to the Townhomes, and adjacent to the Single-Family Court Homes. 7. Consider adding green space to the Neighborhood District, such as a landscape island strip or small park to break up grid of the homes to the south. At Orchards, streets form the backbone of layout, placemaking, and mobility—serving as both connectors and open spaces where people can move, linger, and gather. They include sidewalks with gracious planting on both sides and are designed to create a comfortable and accessible public realm. The network links the Mixed-Use, Multi-Family, and Neighborhood Districts, anchored by Sunset Drive’s 12-foot multi-use path that connects north to City Center, south to neighborhoods and the Perimeter Greenway, and east to the Iron Horse Trail. Homes and businesses face streets, paseos, and parks, ensuring a friendly pedestrian environment, while cars are tucked into garages, auto courts, or internal streets. Together, streets and open spaces—including parks, plazas, and paseos— create a resilient, people-first framework that integrates ecology, connectivity, and community life. 8. Consider adding community green space on the eastern edge of the Project site. The eastern edge of the site provides required stormwater treatment for the community. 9. The Board suggested studying the programing of community space for different age groups and identifying age-appropriate amenities. Orchards is a connected network of parks, plazas, paseos, and greenways that shapes a vibrant, multi-generational community where people of all ages can connect with each other and with nature. The central neighborhood park—an open space framed by rowhomes and patios—offers flexible lawns for community events and daily neighborly interaction, complemented by smaller play areas and intimate paseos that layer programs and amenities at a variety of scales to support multi-generational use. Heritage Oak Tree Parks anchor the Perimeter Greenway with shade, seating, and succession planting, while larger nodes such as Standard Park provide a central lawn, playgrounds, and a retail plaza activated with dining and social gathering. A continuous 12-foot multi-use path along Sunset Drive and the Perimeter Greenway links these destinations, buffered by tree canopies, stormwater landscapes, and woodland planting that add shade, beauty, and resilience. Together, these experiences create a safe, engaging public realm where walking feels intuitive and rewarding, and where open spaces invite play, rest, celebration, and connection—fostering a welcoming, multi-generational environment for families, children, elders, and the broader community. 4 10. The Board was supportive of the path around the perimeter of the Orchards. 11. Consider the massing and building height along Bollinger Canyon Rd.; break up the multi-family building massing and vary the height of the buildings so that it does not read as one massive box. The Design Guidelines provide general massing parameters for the multi-family and mixed-use communities. Specific design for each community will be submitted for review. 12. Study the safety of pedestrians crossing Bollinger Canyon Road and improvements that will enhance and improve this intersection. Bollinger Canyon Road is a significant arterial road serving San Ramon. Our transportation consultant provided recommendations to improve the intersection for pedestrians including enhanced striping and modified signals. The site plan offers multiple east-west connection points for residents and visitors to access the Iron Horse Trail Pedestrian Bridge as an alternate to at grade crossing. 13. Wider sidewalks will enhance the pedestrian experience and attract foot traffic to retail along Bollinger Canyon Road. The Design Guidelines contemplate a 15’ to 30’ setback, which includes space for parallel parking, sidewalks, landscaping, and outdoor areas. 14. Create a mixed-use pedestrian plaza along the Bollinger Canyon Road frontage which will provide more visibility into the Project and draw people in. The Retail will be visible from Bollinger Canyon and will benefit from limited grade differential. Emergency Vehicle Access for Parcels A1 and A2 is via Bollinger Canyon Road which limits the placement of permanent improvements. The Design Guidelines contemplate interior retail plazas, which connect to and activate Standard Park. 15. On Parcel E fronting the park, consider adding ground floor retail storefronts to face the central park which will activate the park area. The park feels like it is being blocked from the Neighborhood District by the multi-family building. Sunset met with the community as part of the site planning process, which informed the park placement. The park location balances connections with the retail while maintaining privacy for residents in the Neighborhood District. The site plan contemplates a 40’ setback along Sunset Drive at Parcel E. 5 June 5th ARB Meeting Site Design 1. The Board supports the Applicant’s Project amendment to expand the pedestrian corridor on the Project’s east/west roadway by reducing the on-site vehicular parking to one side of the road. The Applicant should continue to address opportunities to expand the pedestrian/multi-use trail on the Project’s north/south (Sunset Drive) roadway; 2. Continue to study and address pedestrian crossing solutions on northbound/southbound Bollinger Canyon Road leading into the Project; Bollinger Canyon Road is a significant arterial road serving San Ramon. Our transportation consultant provided recommendations to improve the intersection for pedestrians including enhanced striping and modified signals. The site plan offers multiple east-west connection points for residents and visitors to access the Iron Horse Trail Pedestrian Bridge as an alternate to at grade crossing. 3. The Project site is less noisy as you move further east, away from the freeway. The Applicant should consider locating outdoor uses and public spaces in the less noisy area of the Project site; The site plan evolved from a series of meetings with the community, including discussions related to the Perimeter Greenway and the preservation of the Heritage Oak Trees. 4. The multi-family building located immediately south of Standard Park blocks the visibility of the park from the Neighborhood District and the north/south flow of residents to the park. To further enhance this central gathering space, the multi-family building should be pulled back on the west side to open up visibility into the park; Sunset met with the community as part of the site planning process, which informed the park placement. The park location balances connections with the retail while maintaining privacy for residents in the Neighborhood District. The site plan contemplates a 40’ setback along Sunset Drive at Parcel E. 5. Add additional pedestrian connection points from Standard Park to the various surrounding Districts; The site plan’s pedestrian realm includes sidewalks throughout with opportunities to meander and connect to the varying open space areas including the Heritage Oak Parks, Standard Park, and the Perimeter Greenway. 6. Incorporate a monument/landmark art piece in Standard Park that can create an accent for the Project; Orchards Public Art program will identify opportunities to seamlessly integrate art within the community. 6 7. Consider the longevity and long-term viability of the heritage oak trees, and the usability of this public space located near the oak trees due to the freeway noise; it may be better to replace the trees with units so that the frontage along Sunset Drive can be opened up to create more neighborhood/community space; and The site plan evolved from a series of meetings with the community, including discussions related to the Perimeter Greenway and the preservation of the Heritage Oak Trees. 8. Consider enhanced landscape opportunities within the C3 areas; utilize native plants. Biotreatment areas within Orchards are integrated into the Perimeter Greenway, designed as seamless extensions of the Riparian Woodland palette. The overhead canopy is dominated by Western Sycamores, interwoven with the evergreen foliage of Saratoga Laurel and the seasonal color of Black Tupelo and Box Elder. The striking red bark of Strawberry Tree adds sculptural form, while Redbuds provide spring bloom. At the understory, woodland perennials and groundcovers tolerant of periodic inundation extend the woodland habitat into functional stormwater infrastructure. This creates landscape systems that manage runoff while offering habitat and seasonal beauty. 7 The Board members provided the following comments on Architecture: Orchards Neighborhood Commentary applicable to multiple housing typologies including roof and porch design, site layout, and materials and color selections have been consolidated. 1. Expand the front stoop/patio/porch as much as possible along frontage of the sidewalk. Consider enlarging and wrapping porches to engage people on the ground plane; Overview: The variation in porches are designed to incorporate variety in the neighborhood. The three elevation styles contain a mix of small, medium, and large porches. The design team evaluated the porch dimensions from a visual and functional perspective. Many of the porches were already maximized for site conditions which include utility easements and lot dimensions. Porches at the Court Plan 1 and Court Plan 2 have been expanded to create variation in the street scene. 2. Consider an option to locate front entry ways on the second story with wider steps and stoops which will enhance engagement with the sidewalk; This “San Francisco Victorian” entry is not feasible. An uncovered stair is a waterproofing issue and creates the need for a second interior stair that reduces the floor area of the homes. The homes currently have covered decks at the second levels that activate the streetscape. 3. The architecture throughout the Neighborhood District appears to be monotonous. To break up the monotony, the Board recommends considering the following enhances throughout the District: The architecture is consistent, compatible, and harmonious, creating a calm, friendly sense of place versus a wide variety of different architectural forms, details and color schemes. The design intent is timeless and traditional with a modern viewpoint. a. Incorporating a variety of materials for the front porch posts; Overview for all districts: The designs incorporate a variety of porch solutions for variety, containing single posts, double posts, and stucco columns. Below are examples across the four housing types: • Townhomes: The Elevation B already incorporates stucco columns for Plan 3 to vary the material at the porches. • Row Homes: For Plan 2, one elevation style, likely the B elevation, could be stucco, and the Elevation A could be the double posts to increase variety. • Single-Family Homes are already varied per plan with single posts, double posts, and stucco columns. 8 • Court Homes are likewise varied already, with single posts, double posts, direct beam engagement with walls, and beam extensions over posts. b. Enhancing different elements of the roof design including varying the shed roof over the front door, introducing a hip roof option into the current gable-heavy design, adding dormers, adding relief to the eaves in the front elevation, and alternative roof accent materials such as metal; The vision of the neighborhood district is a timeless, modern design to reflect the history of San Ramon’s pear orchards. As such, the primary roof forms are gables. Some hip roofs have been incorporated into porches. Dormers are not consistent with the vision of the community and reduce the availability of solar. Metal roofs are not consistent with the vision of the community. c. Provide additional tones to the color palette. The current colors are subdue and monotonous with accents only limited to doors; No two house with the same elevation and color palette will be plotted next to each other. The vibrance and contrast of select colors in each scheme have been adjusted to achieve a greater level of variety and range in the community. d. Add additional designs to garage doors so that there is variety; Townhomes have additional garage door styles interspersed within the same building to create a more varied row of garage doors. The other districts all provide variety with different garage doors for different elevation styles, with different color palettes. e. Add additional balcony railing designs; The townhome buildings include multiple railing designs to create variety. The Court Plan 2 is the only other home with a railing, which is different for each elevation. 4. Incorporating additional siding materials such as standing seam metal, shingles, and stained cedars as an alternative to board and batten; Metal, stained siding, masonry and brick are not feasible or consistent with the vision of the community. The board and batten spacing varies between the elevation styles (16” O.C. vs 12” O.C.). Only one elevation style per housing typology includes lap siding. 5. Enhance corner side elevations due to high visibility; The original design incorporated enhanced elevations and materials along visible faces and edges and above fence lines. The Detached Rows have been updated to include additional siding material on the sides as enhanced elevations. 9 6. Due to the east/west orientation of the homes and height of buildings, yard space will be in full shade. Consider orienting homes north/west in order to maximize sun exposure; Homes are oriented per the site plan and create variety in massing and orientation. Designing an entire neighborhood for optimal shade and solar orientation is not feasible given the required density. 7. The neighborhood site design needs to create more visibility and relationship to/from the public territory. Orient buildings to enhance the public’s visibility of the townhome’s public space and Standard Park. Create opportunities to have interaction between neighborhoods by adding pedestrian connections and pulling back building corners to open up visibility; and A mid-block east-west pedestrian connection is incorporated in the Detached Rows. 8. Create north-south connection to the center core; and The Orchards neighborhood is organized into three main districts—the Mixed-Use District, the Multi-Family District, and the Neighborhood District—all of which prioritize pedestrian and bicycle safety while ensuring efficient circulation for vehicles. A 12-foot-wide multi-use pathway along Sunset Drive will connect pedestrians and cyclists north to the City Center and south into the neighborhood, with direct links to the Perimeter Greenway. Homes and businesses will front onto streets, paseos, trails, and parks, creating an engaging pedestrian realm framed by porches, stoops, and storefronts. Vehicular access will be accommodated but discreetly managed through encapsulated parking garages, auto courts, and internal streets. This approach supports a walkable neighborhood where local destinations can be easily reached without reliance on a car. The result will be a safe, welcoming, and multi-modal community for all residents and visitors. 9. Add landscape/vegetation to car alleyways. It is infeasible to add interior landscaping/vegetation to the car alleyways due to utility constraints. 10 Single-Family Row Homes The Neighborhood District architecture comments provided for the Attached Row Townhomes are also applicable to the Single-Family Row Homes in addition to the following comments: 1. The short stucco portion above the front elevation porch (such as on Elevation C) appears awkward and dies right into the roofline. The short stucco portion should either be increased or modified; The design team feels this feature is acceptable and provides a unique look to the homes. Additionally, the way the porches are situated and designed makes the stucco feel like a solid block running all the way to the ground, not just to the roof. 2. Consider additional accents such as vents to break up monotony in architecture, warming up elevations with the use of stained wood, wood balusters on the porch railings, cornice returns on the front elevations into the side elevations, and additional accents that would be use to create more active space on the ground level. Stained wood, gable end vents, wood balusters, or cornice returns are not consistent with the community’s design intent. Single-Family Homes The Neighborhood District architecture comments provided for the Attached Row Townhomes are also applicable to the Single-Family Homes in addition to the following comments: 1. The short stucco portion above the front elevation porch appears awkward and dies right into the roofline. The short stucco portion should either be increased or modified; The way the Plan 3 Elevation C porch is situated and designed makes the stucco feel like a solid architectural element running all the way to the ground, not just to the roof. 2. Enhance the corner side elevations with elements such as wrapped porches and popouts on the second floor so they do not appear so flat; There is no space for wrapped porches for the Single-Family Homes due to vision triangles. Popouts are not compatible with the clean, elegant vision of the community. Additionally, popouts would require a revision to the development standards to have smaller setbacks. There may also be conflicts with a PUE. 11 Single-Family Court Homes The Neighborhood District architecture comments provided for the Attached Row Townhomes are also applicable to the Single-Family Court Homes in addition to the following comments: 1. Take advantage of 4 ft. side and rear yard setbacks allowed for ADUs by re-orienting the unit to give more usable space at the end of the driveway courtyard; consider the relationship between plan 3 and 4, and what space there is available at end of court in relation to ADU setback; rotating the building will provide opportunities to add a front window and porch; The ADU has been rotated and set back toward the trail with the front door toward the court. 2. On the Plan 4, consider the useability and alternative options to the 12’ high ceiling adjacent to the side yard; The 12’ single story element is a desirable feature, adds to the uniqueness of the home, and is not a prominent visual element from public view.