Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutJ. Orchards VMT Analysis, dated November 10, 2025 Memorandum Date: November 10, 2025 To: Stephanie Hill, Senior VP of Development, Bishop Ranch From: Andy Kosinski, PE and Ashlee Takushi, RSP1, Fehr & Peers Subject: Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis This Technical Memorandum presents the effects of the Orchards Mixed-Use Development (“Project”) at 6001 Bollinger Canyon Road in San Ramon, California on vehicle miles traveled (VMT). The Project proposes a mix of single-family housing, multi-family housing, and retail uses to replace a corporate headquarters campus, which is currently vacant. Because the Project’s density is consistent with the development density established in the City’s 2040 General Plan, the Project’s VMT has already been analyzed and disclosed in the 2040 General Plan EIR. That EIR disclosed a Significant and Unavoidable VMT impact and provides Mitigation Measure TRA-2, which reduces VMT impacts through the application of TDM measures and project design features that would reduce VMT and participation in a regional VMT impact fee program or exchange/banking program, if and when one is implemented. [Note to Reviewer: we understand that no project-level VMT analysis is required due to the Project relying on the 15183 exemption. The below project-level analysis has been prepared for use in case there is a "peculiar characteristic" of the project which means it does not generally fit within the GP EIR analysis.] The project-level VMT analysis results in the following impacts: • Residential Component: Less Than Significant With Mitigation as follows: o Integration of affordable and below market rate housing o Providing community-based travel planning • Retail Component: Less Than Significant An analysis of the cumulative impact on VMT of the Project’s residential component was not needed given the Project’s significant impact is fully mitigable, nor was it needed for the retail component as the Project’s impact is less-than-significant. This memorandum begins with a project description, followed by the analysis methodology, and finishes with the impact analysis. Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 2 Project Description The Project includes construction of 230 single-family detached residences, 138 single-family attached residences, 58 accessory dwelling units (ADU), 2,084-units of multi-family housing units, and 125,000 square feet of retail, which is assumed to be regional-serving in nature. While some ADUs are anticipated to be built at a later time, we assumed that all ADUs will be built at opening to present an analysis that is consistent with other project analyses. There is an existing 1,397,520 square foot corporate headquarters campus onsite that was vacated in late Summer 2024 and will be demolished as part of the Project. Overview of SB 743 California Senate Bill 743 On September 27, 2013, California Governor Jerry Brown signed Senate Bill (SB) 743 into law and started a process that changed the way transportation impact analysis is conducted as part of CEQA compliance. These changes include elimination of automobile delay, LOS, and other similar measures of vehicular capacity or traffic congestion as a basis for determining significant impacts under CEQA. According to SB 743, these changes are intended to “more appropriately balance the needs of congestion management with statewide goals related to infill development, promotion of public health through active transportation, and reduction of greenhouse gas emissions.” In December 2018, the State Office of Planning and Research (OPR) completed an update to the CEQA Guidelines to implement the requirements of SB 743. The Guidelines state that VMT must be the metric used to determine significant transportation impacts. The Guidelines require all lead agencies in California to use VMT-based thresholds of significance in CEQA documents published after July 2020. The OPR Guidelines recommend developing screening criteria for development projects that meet certain criteria that can readily lead to the conclusion that they would not cause a significant impact on VMT. The OPR Guidelines also recommend evaluating VMT impacts using an efficiency-based version of the metric, such as VMT per resident for residential developments and/or VMT per worker for office or other employment-based developments. On July 15, 2020, the Contra Costa Transportation Authority (CCTA) adopted criteria, standards, and thresholds for the assessment of VMT (CCTA, Approval of the Vehicle Miles Traveled Analysis Methodology for Land Use Projects in the Growth Management Program, July 15, 2020). The methods and thresholds adopted by CCTA follow the guidance and recommendations of OPR pertaining to the implementation of SB 743. As the City of San Ramon has not yet formally adopted its own VMT criteria, standards, or thresholds at the time this report was prepared, this assessment follows current OPR and CCTA guidance related to VMT. VMT Screening Assessment Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 3 According to CCTA’s Technical Procedures,1 screening thresholds can be used to quickly identify projects that can be expected to cause a less than significant impact without conducting a detailed study. VMT impacts would be less than significant for a project if any of the identified screening criteria outlined below are met: 1. CEQA Exemption – Any project exempt from CEQA is not required to conduct a VMT analysis. 2. Small Projects – Small projects can be presumed to cause a less-than-significant VMT impact. Small projects are defined as having 10,000 square feet or less of non-residential space or 20 residential units or less, or otherwise generating less than 836 VMT per day. 3. Local-Serving Uses – Projects that consist of local-serving uses can generally be presumed to have a less-than-significant impact absent substantial evidence to the contrary, since these types of projects will primarily draw users and customers from a relatively small geographic area that will lead to short-distance trips and trips linked to other destinations. 4. Projects Located in Transit Priority Areas (TPAs) – Projects located within a TPA can be presumed to have a less-than-significant impact absent substantial evidence to the contrary. 5. Projects Located in Low VMT Areas – Projects located within a low VMT-generating area can be presumed to have a less-than-significant impact absent substantial evidence to the contrary. Criterion #1: CEQA Exemption Per the “CEQA Processing Approach for the Orchard Project in the City of San Ramon, CA” memorandum dated March 20, 2025, and prepared by FCS, the Project’s density is consistent with the DMU-S designation under the City’s 2040 General Plan, which makes the project eligible for a State CEQA Guidelines 15183 consistency analysis. The City’s 2040 General Plan EIR determined a significant and unavoidable VMT impact with TDM measures outlined in a mitigation measure, noting that feasible TDM options listed in the EIR to reduce VMT below CCTA thresholds shall be implemented for individual projects facilitated by the 2040 General Plan. The Project description is consistent with the land use assumptions evaluated in the General Plan Environmental Impact Report (EIR). The Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) analysis for the Project was conducted using the same methodology and thresholds applied in the General Plan EIR, and is thus consistent with existing analyses conducted for the Project. Therefore, it is reasonable to conclude that the Project is able to rely on the General Plan EIR impact analysis, impact disclosures, and statements of overriding consideration per CEQA Guidelines 15183. This provision requires that the project be subject to any mitigation measures identified in the General Plan EIR. [Note to Reviewer: we understand that no project-level VMT analysis is required due to the Project relying on the 15183 exemption. The below project-level analysis has been prepared for use in case there is a "peculiar characteristic" of the project which means it does not generally fit within the GP EIR analysis.] 1 Contra Costa Transportation Authority. November 2022. Technical Procedures. https://ccta.net/wp- content/uploads/2023/01/CCTA_Technical_Procedures_Nov2022.pdf Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 4 Assessment Result: Criterion #1 potentially met, with analysis in Criterion #5 provided to support a CEQA Exemption under State CEQA Guidelines 15183. Criterion #2: Small Projects The proposed Project includes construction of 230 single-family detached residences, 138 single- family attached residences, 58 accessory dwelling units (ADU), 2,084-units of multi-family housing units, and 125,000 square feet of retail. Assessment Result: Criterion #2 not met. Criterion #3: Local-Serving Use The proposed Project includes retail that is anticipated to draw regional trips. Assessment Result: Criterion #3 not met. Criterion #4: Transit Priority Area Based on the definitions cited in the criteria, a transit priority area means a site within a one half-mile area an existing major transit stop or an existing stop along a high-quality transit corridor. A ‘major transit stop’ is a site containing an existing rail transit station, a ferry terminal served by either a bus or rail transit service, or the intersection of two or more major bus routes with a frequency of service interval of 20 minutes or less during the morning and afternoon peak commute periods. A ‘high- quality transit corridor’ means a corridor with fixed route bus service with service intervals no longer than 15 minutes during peak commute hours. Four County Connection fixed route buses, Route 35, Route 96X, Route 97X, and Route 335, stops within a half-mile of the proposed Project site. The bus stop within a half-mile of the Project site does not meet the requirements of a major transit stop. Route 35 and Route 96X run on weekdays with 30- minute service intervals. Roue 97X runs on weekdays with a 60-minute service interval. Route 335 runs on 40-minute service interval. The proposed Project is not within a half-mile of an existing high quality transit station or an existing stop along a high quality transit corridor and therefore not located in a Transit Priority Area. Assessment Result: Criterion #4 not met. Criterion #5: Low VMT Area An analysis is required to ascertain whether the Project is located in a low VMT area. The analysis is presented below. VMT Analysis As shown above, the project does meet the criteria to rely on the General Plan EIR findings per CEQA Guidelines 15153 provisions. The General Plan EIR disclosed a significant and unavoidable transportation VMT impact and identified Mitigation Measure TRA-2, which reduces VMT impacts through the application of TDM measures and project design features that would reduce VMT and Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 5 participation in a regional VMT impact fee program or exchange/banking program, if and when one is implemented. [Note to Reviewer: we understand that no project-level VMT analysis is required due to the Project relying on the 15183 exemption. The below project-level analysis has been prepared for use in case there is a "peculiar characteristic" of the project which means it does not generally fit within the GP EIR analysis.] VMT Impact Thresholds The San Ramon General Plan includes the following threshold of significance for a project that replaces existing VMT-generating land uses: - If the replacement leads to a net overall decrease in VMT, the project would lead to a less- than-significant transportation impact. If the project leads to a net overall increase in VMT, then the CCTA Technical Procedures thresholds should apply. If a less-than-significant impact is not identified using the above threshold, the following analysis should be conducted: - For housing projects: the project generated Home-Based VMT per resident constitutes a significant impact if it is higher than 85% of the Home-Based VMT per resident in the subject municipality or 85% of the existing countywide average Home-Based VMT per resident, whichever is less stringent. - For regional-serving projects: the project generated VMT constitutes a significant impact if the baseline project generated total VMT per service population is higher than 85% of the existing countywide average total VMT per service population. Projects that are unable to mitigate their project-specific VMT impacts to less-than-significant levels require a Cumulative VMT analysis. Cumulative VMT impacts should be considered significant if there is a net increase in the total study area VMT normalized to the number of people within the study area, when comparing cumulative without project to cumulative with project conditions. Project-Level VMT Analysis Results Total VMT The City’s General Plan criteria require analysis of total VMT for a redevelopment project as a first step. Total VMT provides a broader view of how a project affects overall travel demand at a regional scale and helps to understand the absolute impact of the project on the transportation network. Table 1 shows that the construction of the Project would increase total VMT at both the county and regional levels, therefore a Baseline VMT analysis using the per capita method is required. Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 6 Table 1. Total VMT Results Scenario Existing no Project1 Existing with Project Net Change Net Increase in VMT? Total Countywide VMT 26,454,736 26,470,444 15,708 Yes Total Regionwide VMT 171,019,826 171,066,607 46,781 Yes Notes: 1. Assumes Corporate Headquarters is fully occupied Source: CCTA Travel Demand Model, Fehr & Peers, 2025. Baseline VMT Analysis Fehr & Peers used the CCTA travel demand model to estimate average daily vehicle miles of travel for the proposed Project. Per CCTA guidance, daily home-based VMT per capita and home-work VMT per worker was used to evaluate project generated VMT for the project. The weekday daily average home-based VMT per capita for the Project, city, and county, and project VMT per service population2 are presented in Table 2. Our analysis assumed that the existing corporate headquarters was fully occupied for Existing no Project conditions. Based on this analysis, the Project is estimated to generate 16.7 home-based VMT per capita, exceeding the applicable threshold. The Project is estimated to generate 3.7 VMT per service population, which is below the applicable threshold. 2 Service population is residents plus workers plus retail visitors. Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 7 Table 2. Per Capita VMT Results Geography 2024 Base Year Residential Land Uses1 City of San Ramon Average VMT 18.7 Contra Costa County Average VMT 17.1 15% below city average VMT (least stringent) 15.9 Project TAZ VMT 16.7 Below Threshold? No Regional Serving Land Uses2 Countywide VMT (Existing no Project) 47,989,039 Countywide Service Population3 (Excluding Retail Visitors) 1,605,206 Countywide Estimated Retail Visitors4 1,253,329 Countywide Service Population3 (Including Retail Visitors)4 2,858,535 Countywide VMT per Service Population 16.8 15% Below Countywide Average 14.3 Project Total VMT 15,408 Project Estimated Retail Employees5 250 Project Estimated Retail Visitors6 3,970 Project Service Population3 2,360 Project VMT per Service Population 3.7 Below Threshold? Yes Notes: 1. For residential land uses, the VMT metric applied in this analysis is Home-Based VMT per Capita. 2. For regional serving land uses (i.e. retail uses), the VMT metric applied in this analysis is Total VMT per Service Population. 3. Service population is residents plus workers plus retail visitors 4. Estimated by converting countywide retail employees from the model (78,925) to square footage using a ratio of 2 retail employees per ksf (employee factor derived from ITE Trip Generation Manual, 11th Edition, by dividing the trip generation rate per ksf by the trip generation rate per employee for LU 820 Shopping Center (>150k), which is the most similar land use with the available data to make the calculation). The resulting square footage was then converted to total trips by applying the 67.52 daily automobile trip generation rate per ksf from the ITE Trip Generation Manual for LU 821 Shopping Plaza (40-150k - no supermarket), from which employee trips were subtracted assuming two trips per employee per day (an inbound and an outbound), and then assuming an average of 0.5 visitors per remaining daily auto trip based on the fact that each visitor makes two auto trips (an inbound and an outbound). 5. A ratio of 2 employees per ksf was applied to 125 ksf of project retail. Factor derived from ITE Trip Generation Manual, 11th Edition, by dividing the trip generation rate per ksf by the trip generation rate per employee for LU 820 Shopping Center (>150k). 6. For the project retail visitor estimate, the retail ksf was available directly (125 ksf), and was converted to total trips by applying the 67.52 daily automobile trip generation rate per ksf from the ITE Trip Generation Manual 11th Edition for LU 821 Shopping Plaza (40-150k - no supermarket), from which Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 8 employee trips were subtracted assuming two trips per employee per day (an inbound and an outbound), and then assuming an average of 0.5 visitors per remaining daily auto trip based on the fact that each visitor makes two auto trips (an inbound and an outbound). Source: CCTA Travel Demand Model, 2025; Fehr & Peers, 2025. This baseline VMT for the Existing with Project scenario is above the Home-Based VMT per Capita threshold. Therefore, the Project is expected to have a significant impact pertaining to Home-Based VMT, if not mitigated. The project VMT per Service Population for the Project scenario is below the VMT per Service Population threshold. Therefore, the Project is expected to have a less-than-significant impact pertaining to Regional Serving VMT. VMT Mitigation Measures The Project’s home-based VMT per capita would result in a significant CEQA transportation impact. The Project would be required to mitigate just over 5 percent of its home-based VMT to result in a less-than-significant impact. The mitigation measures to reduce home-based VMT to less-than- significant are summarized in Table 3. Reduction of residential VMT is primarily achieved through implementation of Transportation Demand Management (TDM) Programs. TDM refers to strategies that motivate alternatives to automobile travel, either through positive incentives for walking, biking, and transit, or through adding additional costs to automobile use at the project site. Fehr & Peers developed the TDM+ tool that estimates a percent reduction in VMT due to a single TDM strategy as well as the combination of multiple TDM strategies. TDM+ incorporates the effects of numerous land use and design strategies as well as various travel incentives and disincentives. The VMT reductions applied in TDM+ are based on strategies identified in the Handbook for Analyzing GHG Emission Reductions, Assessing Climate Vulnerabilities, and Advancing Health and Equity, California Air Pollution Control Officers Association (CAPCOA), August 2021.3 The TDM+ tool was used to analyze the Project’s VMT reduction potential. Attachment A documents the TDM analysis assumptions and calculations, and Attachment B includes excerpts from the CAPCOA Handbook documenting each strategy. 3 This report is a resource for local agencies to quantify the benefit, in terms of reduced travel demand, of implementing various TDM strategies. Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 9 Table 3. VMT Results Measure Description Project Implementation Effect on VMT Reduction Maximum VMT Reduction T-4. Integrate Affordable and Below Market Rate Housing This measure requires below market rate (BMR) housing. BMR housing provides greater opportunity for lower income families to live closer to job centers and achieve a jobs/housing match near transit. It is also an important strategy to address the limited availability of affordable housing that might force residents to live far away from jobs or school, requiring longer commutes. -3.9%-28.6% T-23. Provide Community- Based Travel Planning This measure will target residences in the plan/community with community-based travel planning (CBTP). CBTP is a residential-based approach to outreach that provides households with customized information, incentives, and support to encourage the use of transportation alternatives in place of single occupancy vehicles, thereby reducing household VMT and associated GHG emissions. -2.3%-2.3% Total Project VMT Reduction from TDM1 -6.1% Reduction Required to Reduce Project VMT Below Threshold -5.0% Note: 1.Total Project VMT Reduction is a multiplicative reduction Source: CAPCOA Handbook for Analyzing Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reductions, Assessing Climate Vulnerabilities, and Advancing Heath and Equity, California Air Pollution Control Officers Association (CAPCOA), 2021, Fehr & Peers, 2025. Based on the Handbook for Analyzing GHG Emission Reductions, Assessing Climate Vulnerabilities, and Advancing Health and Equity, implementing the strategies in Table 3, i.e. Integrate Affordable and Below Market Rate Housing (assuming 387 of the 2,084 multi-family units are affordable), and Provide Community-Based Travel Planning, would reduce the Project’s home-based VMT by 6.1 percent. The General Plan EIR disclosed a significant and unavoidable transportation VMT impact and identified Mitigation Measure TRA-2, which reduces VMT impacts through the application of TDM measures and project design features that would reduce VMT and participation in a regional VMT impact fee program or exchange/banking program, if and when one is implemented. The TDM measures proposed above comply with and are consistent with the General Plan Mitigation Measure TRA-2. Assessment Result: Criterion #5 not met for Residential but met for Regional-Serving Uses. T-4 Locational Context Urban, Suburban Scale of Application Project/Site Type of VMT affected: Project-generated trips Max VMT reduction:28.60% Percent of multi-family units permanently dedicated as affordable 18.6%percent user input (default value = 0-0.286) Percent reduction in VMT for qualified units compared to market rate units -28.6%percent constant (default value = -0.286) Change in VMT -5.31%percent reduction Sources: Land Use - T-4. Integrate Affordable and Below Market Rate Housing This measure requires below market rate (BMR) housing. BMR housing provides greater opportunity for lower income families to live closer to job centers and achieve a jobs/housing match near transit. It is also an important strategy to address the limited availability of affordable housing that might force residents to live far away from jobs or school, requiring longer commutes. The quantification method for this measure accounts for VMT reductions achieved for multifamily residential projects that are deed restricted or otherwise permanently dedicated as affordable housing. (1)Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE). 2021. Trip Generation Manual. 11th Edition. ITE 2021. Available: https://www.ite.org/technical-resources/topics/trip-and-parking- generation/ (2)National Center for Sustainable Transportation. Affordable Housing in Transit-Oriented Developments: Impacts on Driving and Policy Approaches. April 2017. Available: https://escholarship.org/uc/item/487994z4 Formula: % Change in VMT = Percent of multi-family units permanently dedicated as affordable * Percent reduction in VMT for qualified units compared to market rate units Attachment A Adjustment to T-4 T-4 Integrate Affordable and Below Market Rate Housing A -5.31%Unadjusted Change in VMT from T-4 B 368 project single-family units C 2084 project multi-family units D 2 factor of SFH VMT per household / multifamily VMT per household (this is conservatively high) E -3.9%Adjusted Change in VMT from T-4 E = A * C/(BD + C) Value "A" above applies to multifamily housing only and we need to convert this to a VMT reduction for all residential. Affordable units will be located solely in multi-family buildings, which have lower VMT per household than SFH, therefore in the calculation below we not only account for zero reduction in VMT for single family homes (SFH) but also apply a factor to account for SFH VMT per household being higher than multifamily pre- any TDM measures. T-23 Locational Context Urban, Suburban Scale of Application Plan/Community Type of VMT affected: Household trips Max VMT reduction:2.30% Residences in plan/community 2510 residence user input (default value = 0-99999) Residences in plan/community targeted with CBTP 2510 residence user input (default value = 0-99999) Percent of targeted residences that participate 19.0%percent constant (default value = 0.19) Percent vehicle trip reduction by participating residences 12.0%percent constant (default value = 0.12) Adjustment factor from vehicle trips to VMT 1.000 unitless constant (default value = 1) Change in VMT -2.28%percent reduction Sources: Trip Reduction Programs ‐ T‐23. Provide Community‐Based Travel Planning This measure will target residences in the plan/community with community-based travel planning (CBTP). CBTP is a residential-based approach to outreach that provides households with customized information, incentives, and support to encourage the use of transportation alternatives in place of single occupancy vehicles, thereby reducing household VMT and associated GHG emissions. (1) Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC). 2021. Plan Bay Area 2050, Supplemental Report. (forthcoming) Formula: % Change in VMT = - ( Residences in plan/community targeted with CBTP / Residences in plan/community ) * Percent of targeted residences that participate * Percent vehicle trip reduction by participating residences * Adjustment factor from vehicle trips to VMT Attachment B