HomeMy WebLinkAboutG. CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist (wo Appendices), dated December 1, 2025Orchards Project
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency
Checklist
City of San Ramon, Contra Costa County, California
State Clearinghouse Number 2022060549
PREPARED FOR:
City of San Ramon
7000 Bollinger Canyon Road
San Ramon, CA 94583
925.973.2562
Contact: Cindy M. Yee, AICP, Division Manager
PREPARED BY:
FirstCarbon Solutions
2999 Oak Road, Suite 250
Walnut Creek, CA 94597
925.357.2562
Contact: Mary Bean, Project Director
Maddie Dolan, Project Manager
December 1, 2025
•• • FCS
An ADEC Innovation
Attachment G
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS iii
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Table of Contents
Acronyms and Abbreviations v
1 - Introduction 1
1.1 - CEQA Assessment 1
1.2 - Summary of Results 1
2 - Project Description 3
2.1 - Location and Setting 3
2.2 - Project Background 13
2.3 - Project Characteristics 13
2.4 - Approvals 23
3 - CEQA Guidelines Section 15183: Projects Consistent With a Community
Plan or Zoning 25
4 - Environmental Checklist 27
4.1 Aesthetics 28
4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources 35
4.3 Air Quality 40
4.4 Biological Resources 61
4.5 Cultural and Tribal Cultural Resources 73
4.6 Energy 84
4.7 Geology and Soils 92
4.8 Greenhouse Gas Emissions 103
4.9 Hazards and Hazardous Materials 108
4.10 Hydrology and Water Quality 118
4.11 Land Use and Planning 129
4.12 Mineral Resources 133
4.13 Noise 135
4.14 Population and Housing 148
4.15 Public Services 151
4.16 Recreation 159
4.17 Transportation 162
4.18 Utilities and Service Systems 170
4.19 Wildfire 177
4.20 Mandatory Findings of Significance 181
5 - List of Preparers 185
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
iv FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Appendix A: 2040 General Plan EIR
Appendix B: Air Quality, GHG, and Energy Supporting Information
Appendix C: Biological Resources Supporting Information
Appendix D: Cultural Resources Supporting Information
Appendix E: Geology and Soils Supporting Information
Appendix F: Hazards and Hazardous Materials Supporting Information
Appendix G: Hydrology and Water Quality Supporting Information
Appendix H: Noise Supporting Information
Appendix I: Transportation Supporting Information
Tables
Table 1: Neighborhood District Unit Mix 20
Table 2: Neighborhood District Parking 21
Table 3: Annual Project Construction Exhaust Emissions–Unmitigated 49
Table 4: Average Daily Project Construction Exhaust Emissions–Unmitigated 50
Table 5: Summary of the Health Impacts at the Maximally Exposed Individual
Receptors During Project Construction 54
Table 6: Summary of the Cumulative Health Impacts During Project Construction
at the Maximally Exposed Individual 56
Table 7: Transportation Demand Management Measures 168
Exhibits
Exhibit 1: Regional Location Map 5
Exhibit 2: Local Vicinity Map 7
Exhibit 3: General Plan Land Use Map 9
Exhibit 4: Zoning Map 11
Exhibit 5: Site Plan 15
Exhibit 6: Phasing Plan 17
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS v
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS
µg/m3 micrograms per cubic meter
°F degrees Fahrenheit
°C degrees Celsius (Centigrade)
ABAG Association of Bay Area Governments
ADT Average Daily Traffic
ADU accessory dwelling unit
APN Assessor’s Parcel Number
AQMP Air Quality Management Plan
ARB California Air Resources Board
BART Bay Area Rapid Transit
Bay Area Air District Bay Area Air Quality Management District
BERD Built Environment Resource Directory
BMP Best Management Practice
BMR Below Market Rate
CAA Clean Air Act
CAAQS California Ambient Air Quality Standards
CalEEMod California Emissions Estimator Model
CAL FIRE California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection
CALGreen California Green Building Standards Code
Cal/OSHA California Occupational Safety and Health Administration
CAP Climate Action Plan
CBC California Building Standards Code
CBTP Community-Based Travel Plan
CCA Community Choice Aggregate
CCAA California Clean Air Act
CCCWP Contra Costa County Clean Water Program
CCTA Contra Costa Transportation Authority
CDFW California Department of Fish and Wildlife
Central San Central Contra Costa Sanitary District
CEQA California Environmental Quality Act
CFC California Fire Code
CGS California Geologic Survey
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
vi FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
CHL California Historic Landmarks
CIP Capital Improvement Program
CNDDB California Natural Diversity Database
CNEL Community Noise Equivalent Level
CNPS Inventory CNPS Inventory of Rare Plants
CPHI California Points of Historical Interest
CRA Cultural Resources Assessment
CRHR California Register of Historical Resources
CWA Clean Water Act
DMU-S Downtown Mixed-Use South
DOF California Department of Finance
DPM diesel particulate matter
DSRSD Dublin San Ramon Services District
DTSC California Department of Toxic Substances Control
du/acre dwelling units per acre
DWR California Department of Water Resources
EBMUD East Bay Municipal Utilities District
EIR Environmental Impact Report
EPA United States Environmental Protection Agency
ESL Environmental Screening Level
FAR floor area ratio
FCS FirstCarbon Solutions
FEIR Final Environmental Impact Report
FEMA Federal Emergency Management Agency
FHSZ Fire Hazard Severity Zone
FTA Federal Transit Administration
GHG greenhouse gas
GSP Groundwater Sustainability Plan
HCP Habitat Conservation Plan
HMUPA Hazardous Materials Unified Program Agency
HRA Health Risk Assessment
HVAC heating, ventilation, and air conditioning
IPaC Information for Planning and Consultation
LCI California Governor’s Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation
Ldn day/night average sound level
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS vii
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Leq equivalent continuous sound level
LHMP Local Hazard Mitigation Plan
LID Low Impact Development
Lmax maximum noise/sound level
MBTA Migratory Bird Treaty Act
MCE Marin Clean Energy
MEI Maximally Exposed Individual
MEIR Maximally Exposed Individual Resident
MEIW Maximally Exposed Individual Worker
MM Mitigation Measure
mph miles per hour
MWELO Model Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance
NAAQS National Ambient Air Quality Standards
NAHC Native American Heritage Commission
NCCP National Community Conservation Plan
NHMRR National Hazardous Materials Route Registry
NOx oxides of nitrogen
NPDES National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System
NRHP National Register of Historic Places
NWIC Northwest Information Center
OEHHA Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment
PG&E Pacific Gas and Electric Company
PM2.5 particulate matter less than 2.5 microns in diameter
PM10 particulate matter less than 10 microns in diameter
PPV peak particle velocity
PRIMP Paleontological Resources Impact Mitigation Program
REC Recognized Environmental Condition
ROG reactive organic gases
RPS Renewable Portfolio Standard
RWQCB Regional Water Quality Control Board
SCH State Clearinghouse
SFBAAB San Francisco Bay Area Air Basin
SIP State Implementation Plan
SLF Sacred Lands File
SRA State Responsibility Area
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
viii FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
SRMC San Ramon Municipal Code
SRPCSD San Ramon Parks and Community Services Department
SRPD San Ramon Police Department
SRVFPD San Ramon Valley Fire Protection District
SRVUSD San Ramon Valley Unified School District
State Water Board California State Water Resources Control Board
SVP Society of Vertebrate Paleontology
SWPPP Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan
TAC toxic air contaminant
TCR Tribal Cultural Resources
TDM Transportation Demand Management
UCMP University of California Museum of Paleontology
UGB Urban Growth Boundary
USACE United States Army Corps of Engineers
USGS United States Geologic Survey
UST underground storage tank
UWMP Urban Water Management Plan
VHFHSZ Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone
VMT Vehicle Miles Traveled
VOC volatile organic compound
Orchards Project
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist
FCS 1
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
1 - INTRODUCTION
This California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist,
and attached supporting documents have been prepared to examine whether and to what extent the
proposed Orchards Project (proposed project), includes project-specific significant effects which are
peculiar to the project or its site.
1.1 - CEQA Assessment
The following Consistency Checklist has been prepared pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15183
(Projects Consistent with a Community Plan or Zoning) to determine whether the proposed project
has project-specific significant effects that would preclude the use of an exemption and require
additional environmental review.
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 is a statutory exemption from CEQA which mandates that projects
that are consistent with the development density established by existing zoning, community plan or
general plan policies for which a Final EIR was certified (in this case, the San Ramon 2040 General
Plan Final EIR (FEIR), State Clearinghouse [SCH] Number 2022060549) shall not require additional
environmental review, except as might be necessary to examine whether there are project-specific
significant impacts which are peculiar to the project or its site.
1.2 - Summary of Results
The Consistency Checklist confirms that the proposed project’s potential impacts on all environmental
factors have been previously analyzed and mitigated, consistent with the San Ramon 2040 General
Plan (2040 General Plan) and other regulatory frameworks. Therefore, no further CEQA review is
required.
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Orchards Project
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist
FCS 3
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2 - PROJECT DESCRIPTION
2.1 - Location and Setting
2.1.1 - Location
The approximately 91.5-acre site is located at 6001 Bollinger Canyon Road in the City of San Ramon
(City), in Contra Costa County (County), California. The project site is bounded by Bollinger Canyon
Road to the north, existing commercial and office development to the east, existing residential
development to the south, and Interstate 680 (I-680) to the west. The project site corresponds to
Assessor’s Parcel Number (APN) 213-120-008 (Exhibit 1 and Exhibit 2). The proposed project is
within the City of San Ramon General Plan 2040 Planning Area.
2.1.2 - Environmental Setting
Existing Land Use Activities
The project site is currently developed with the Chevron Park Campus, which consists of 13 vacant
commercial office buildings, one vacant mechanical/maintenance building, and a telecommunications
tower, totaling approximately 1.48 million square feet. The Chevron Campus Park includes paved
parking, driveways, and walkway areas throughout the site. The project site also includes various
landscaped areas and a man-made pond near the center of the site.
Surrounding Land Uses
The project site is surrounded by commercial uses to the north, commercial uses, a parking lot, and a
senior living home to the east, residential uses to the south, and Highway I-680 and residential and
commercial uses to the west. Exhibit 2 shows an aerial view of the site and surrounding uses.
2.1.3 - Land Use Designation and Zoning
The project site is currently designated Downtown Mixed-Use South (DMU-S) in both the General
Plan and zoning code (Exhibit 3 and Exhibit 4). The purpose of the DMU-S land use is to encourage a
mixed-use neighborhood, extending the activity of City Center across Bollinger Canyon Road with
shops, offices, and a diversity of housing opportunities with walkable streets, parks and trails. General
Plan Policy 4.7.I-5 indicates that the DMU-S zone envisions up to 2,900 residential units, including
both the proposed Orchards project and residential development in Bishop Ranch 1, as well as a
landscape corridor to serve as a buffer to the existing neighborhood to the south and connectively to
the Iron Horse Trail as an extension of the City’s Walking District. This zoning district allows for a
density of 20-60 dwelling units per acre and a minimum floor area ratio (FAR) of 1.25. As described in
further detail below, the proposed project is requesting a waiver of the minimum FAR through the
State Density Bonus Law.
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Sourc e: Cens us 2000 Data, The California Sp atial Inform ation Library (CaSIL).
!
·|}þ12
·|}þ29
·|}þ37
·|}þ4 ·|}þ4
C o n tr a C o s t a C o u nt y
A l a m e d a C o un t y
!"#$580
·|}þ92
·|}þ24
!"#$680
!"#$780
·|}þ160
CarquinezStrait
!"#$80
!"#$80
Mount DiabloState Park
Napa CountySolano County
!"#$580
!"#$80
Solano
C
o
u
n
t
y
Vallejo
Richmond
San Pablo
Pinole Martinez
Pleasant Hill
LafayetteOrinda
El Cerrito
Albany
Berkeley
MoragaPiedmont
Oakland
Alameda
Walnut Creek
Concord
Clayton
Pittsburg
Benicia
Denverton
Cordelia
Alamo
Danville
San Ramon
Dublin
Pleasanton LivermoreFairview
Hayward
San Leandro
Antioch
Bay Point
·|}þ242!"#$
!"#$680
680
·|}þ13!"#$580
!"#$880
N
a
p
a
R
i
v
e
r
¥5 0 52.5
Miles
F C S
!
Text
Projec t Site
Projec t Site
O R C H A R D S P R O J E C T C E Q A G U I D E L I N E S S E C T I O N 1 5 1 8 3 C O N S I S T E N C Y C H E C K L I S TCITY OF SAN RAMON
24910040 • 07/2025 | 1_regional.m xd
Exhibit 1Regional Loc ation Map
Legend
City of San Ram on
. \
,_-.. ,"'
#-' ,"' ,....... .. ........ __ ,,,,,, , \ ,,,,,.----........ ___ .. ___ ... __ , ·,
/ .... _______ . • ,· \
'·
V
~...-·,!'!1 ... -",•,, ~ -· ~ -' ' --' ...... -· -· , ......
• ) . , I .
I ' • . . I
\
\ . \ . \ . \ .
\
\ .
\ . ----- ----------, ..
\
\
\
1-
\
'·
• . <
---.. -.. -.. -.. "' ·,
• '· -·
-·
.,. .,,,,. -,,,,,. -. -. '· .-
-· --,,,,,.-,,,,,.-
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Source: ESRI Aerial Imag ery . Contra Costa County .
Trib of So
u
t
h
S
a
n
R
a
m
o
n
Norri
s
C
r
e
e
k
Bollinger Ca
n
y
o
n
R
d
B
i
s
h
o
p
D
r
W
a
l
n
u
t
D
r
S
u
n
s
e
t
D
r
Ascot Dr
S
a
n
R
a
m
o
n
V
a
l
l
e
y
B
l
v
d
Al
c
o
s
t
a
B
l
v
d
C
a
m
i
n
o
R
a
m
o
n
B
r
o
a
d
m
o
o
r
D
r
Mor
g
a
n
D
r
680
Canyon LakesGolf Course
Central Park
Memorial Park
Athan DownsParkBishop Ranch RegionalOpen Space Preserve
MontevideoElementary School
Iron HorseMiddle School
Ir
o
n
H
o
r
s
e
R
e
g
i
o
n
a
l
T
r
a
i
l
1,000 0 1,000500
Feet
F C S
Legend
Project Site
O R C H A R D S P R O J E C T C E Q A G U I D E L I N E S S E C T I O N 1 5 1 8 3 C O N S I S T E N C Y C H E C K L I S TCITY OF SAN RAMON
24910040 • 12/2025 | 2_local_v icinity .mxd
Exhibit 2Local Vicinity Map
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
24910040 • 12/2025 | 3_GPLU.m xd
Exhibit 3
Source : ESRI Ae rial Im age ry . City of San Ram on. Contra Costa County .
O R C H A R D S P R O J E C T C E Q A G U I D E L I N E S S E C T I O N 1 5 1 8 3 C O N S I S T E N C Y C H E C K L I S T
Trib of So
u
t
h
S
a
n
R
a
m
o
n
Bollinger Ca
n
y
o
n
R
d
W
a
l
n
u
t
D
r
S
u
n
s
e
t
D
r
Ascot Dr
S
a
n
R
a
m
o
n
V
a
l
l
e
y
B
l
v
d
C
A
M
I
N
O
R
a
m
o
n
680
Bishop
D
r
Ma
r
k
e
t
P
l
Ascot Dr
Oakham
D
r
T
o
b
y
R
d
L
o
n
g
h
o
r
n
D
r
M
o
r
g
a
n
D
r
S
o
m
b
r
e
r
o
C
i
r
Ir
o
n
H
o
r
s
e
R
e
g
i
o
n
a
l
T
r
a
i
l
650 0 650325
Fe e t
F C S
Ge ne ral Plan Land Use Map
CIT Y OF SAN RAMON
Legend
Proje ct SiteGeneral Plan Land Use DesignationsDowntown Mixe d-Use - South (DMU-S)
Low Me dium De nsity Re side ntial (3.00 - 6.00 du/ac)
Me dium De nsity Re side ntial (6.00 - 15.00 du/ac)
Me dium High De nsity (15.00 - 30.00 du/ac)
Mixe d Use - City Ce nte r (FAR 0.70)
Mixe d Use - Com m e rcial Em phasis (FAR 0.7 -2.0)
Ope n Space (FAR 0.10)
Park s (FAR 0.10) - Include s publicly -owne d ope n-space
Public and Se m ipublic (FAR 0.35)
Re tail Shopping (FAR 0.35)
T horoughfare Com m e rcial (FAR 0.5)
------
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
24910040 • 12/2025 | 4_z on in g .m xd
Exhibit 4
Source: ESRI Aerial Im ag ery. City of San Ram on . Con tra Costa Coun ty.
O R C H A R D S P R O J E C T C E Q A G U I D E L I N E S S E C T I O N 1 5 1 8 3 C O N S I S T E N C Y C H E C K L I S T
Trib of So
u
t
h
S
a
n
R
a
m
o
n
Bollinger Ca
n
y
o
n
R
d
W
a
l
n
u
t
D
r
Ascot Dr
S
a
n
R
a
m
o
n
V
a
l
l
e
y
B
l
v
d
C
A
M
I
N
O
R
a
m
o
n
680
Bishop
D
r
Ma
r
k
e
t
P
l
Ascot Dr
Oakham
D
r
T
o
b
y
R
d
L
o
n
g
h
o
r
n
D
r
M
o
r
g
a
n
D
r
S
o
m
b
r
e
r
o
C
i
r
650 0 650325
Feet
F C S
Z on in g Map
CITY OF SAN RAMON
Legend
Project SiteZoning Designations
CC - Com m un ity Com m ercial
CC-H - Com m un ity Com m ercial (with a Heig h t Overlay)
CCMU - City Cen ter Mixed Use
CT - Th oroug h fare Com m ercial
DMU-S - Down town Mixed-Use South
MU - Mixed Use - Com m ercial Em ph asis
OS-1 - Open Space
P - Parks an d Recreation
PS - Public an d Sem ipublic
RH - Hig h Den sity Residen tial
RM - Medium -Den sity Residen tial
RMH - Medium -Hig h Den sity Residen tial
RS-10 - Sin g le-Fam ily Residen tial
RS-D - Sin g le-Fam ily Residen tial
Ir
o
n
H
o
r
s
e
R
e
g
i
o
n
a
l
T
r
a
i
l
[cil -----D
----D --D
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 13
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2.2 - Project Background
2.2.1 - General Plan
The City certified the General Plan EIR (SCH Number 2022060549) and adopted the City of San
Ramon General Plan 2040 on December 12, 2023.
As part of the General Plan 2040 update process, the City adopted the General Plan 2040 which
includes 11 respective General Plan elements, amended the San Ramon Village Specific Plan,
repealed the North Camino Ramon Specific Plan, and updated the San Ramon Zoning Ordinance
(collectively referred to in the General Plan EIR as the 2040 General Plan). The 2040 General Plan
elements include: Land Use; Housing; Traffic and Circulation; Safety; Open Space and Conservation;
Parks and Recreation; Public Facilities and Utilities; Noise, Air Quality and Greenhouse Gas (GHG)
Emissions, Growth Management, and Economic Development. The General Plan 2040 update
process also included updates to the San Ramon Zoning Ordinance to ensure consistency with the
updated General Plan. The 2040 General Plan serves as the long-term blueprint for development
across the Planning Area.
2.3 - Project Characteristics
2.3.1 - Project Summary
Project Overview
The proposed project consists of three districts: the Neighborhood District, Mixed-Use District, and
the Multi-Family District, which would include a multi-family affordable housing building (Exhibit 5).
Each district would be developed in phases. All three districts combined would total approximately
2,510 residential units (including multi-family apartments, stacked flats, townhomes, single-family
homes, vertical mixed-use units, and accessory dwelling units [ADUs]), 125,000 square feet of new
retail, commercial and entertainment uses, and approximately 15 acres of open space, including a
2.5-acre centralized park space and additional pocket parks and recreational amenities.
For the purposes of this document, development of the Neighborhood District as well as demolition,
grading, and hydroseeding of an ‘Interim Area’ (Exhibit 6) are analyzed at a project-level as a first
phase (Phase 1 or Project-level analysis). The Interim Area is located on part of the Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family District. It would be demolished, graded, and hydroseeded to support future
development of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts, with the development of those districts not
being approved as part of this project. The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District are analyzed
at a program level, as specific site plans for these districts would be developed in later phases and
are too speculative to evaluate at this time.
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Source: William Hezmalhalch Architects, Inc. DBA WHA. January 21, 2025.
F C S
Exhibit 5
24910040 • 07/2025 | 5_site_plan.cdr
Site Plan
C I T Y O F S A N R A M O N
O R C H A R D S P R O J E C T C E Q A G U I D E L I N E S S E C T I O N 1 5 1 8 3 C O N S I S T E N C Y C H E C K L I S T
Feet
0 0 0 0
LEGEND
NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT
~ Single-Family court Homes (42 Total) 1w1 + 10 ADUSJ
(11) Plan 1
(10) Plan 2
(10) Plan 3
(11) Plan 4
~ Single-Family Homes (130 Tolan
(42) Plan 1
• (44) Plan 2
• (44) Plan 3
~ Sjngle-Famuy Row Homes (58 Tolan
(20) Plan 1
• (20) Plan 2
• (18) Plan 3
~ Attached Row Townhomes (26 Buildings)
• 138 Units lwl +4BJADUsl
(7) Building 100 I 4-Plex
(2) Building 200 I 4-Plex
(5) Building 300 I 5-Plex
(6) Building 400 I 6-Plex
(1) Building 500 I 6-Plex
(5) Building 600 I 7-Plex
~ MULTI-FAMILY DISTRICT
Affordable Housing
• Building H
• Proposed Gang Mailbox Location
~ 0 50 100 200
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Feet
0 0 0 0
24910040 • 10/2025 | 6_phasing_plan.cdrF C S
Phasing Plan
Exhibit 6
Source: William Hezmalhalch Architects, Inc. DBA WHA. September 10, 2025.
C I T Y O F S A N R A M O N
O R C H A R D S P R O J E C T C E Q A G U I D E L I N E S S E C T I O N 1 5 1 8 3 C O N S I S T E N C Y C H E C K L I S T
Multi-Family Affordable Housing Building
to be Processed Under a Separate Application.
EX ISTING TO
REMAIN
INTERIM
CONDITION
-~ -
I
.I
-
. ... ~
-
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 19
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2.3.2 - Designation of Multi-Family District and Mixed-Use District
The program-level analysis in this document includes designation of the Multi-Family and Mixed-Use
Districts. Future development under the Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District combined would
not exceed 2,084 residential units.
Mixed-Use District
The 11.3-acre Mixed-Use District, located in the northeast portion of the project site, would consist of
residential communities with ground floor retail, entertainment and commercial uses complementary
to City Center Bishop Ranch across Bollinger Canyon Road. The Mixed-Use District would have two
retail-lined streets, one north–south and one east–west, leading to Standard Park. The retail streets
have wide sidewalks and are lined with active, pedestrian-oriented uses including retail shops,
restaurants and outdoor seating.
This programmatic analysis of the Mixed-Use District accounts for a maximum of 619 residential
units, 388,097 square feet of mixed-use development, 35,717 square feet of open space, and 69,303
square feet of private streets.
Multi-Family District
The 26-acre Multi-Family District, located in the northwest portion of the project site, would consist of
communities that may be developed into apartments, condominiums, senior or affordable housing,
offering a variety of housing options and would include Standard Park, a 2.5-acre park that would
serve as a gathering place for residents and visitors. It is activated by the retail district and offers
playground amenities for children and a flexible lawn allowing for a variety of uses. A wide, multiuse
pathway along Sunset Drive connects the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts with the
Neighborhood District to the south.
This programmatic analysis of the Multi-Family District accounts for a maximum of 1,465 residential
units, 711,164 square feet of multi-family residential development, including the proposed multi-family
affordable housing building (Building H), 210,861 square feet of open space (including a 2.5-acre
centralized park), and 214,407 square feet of private streets.
2.3.3 - Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area
The project-level analysis in this document evaluates the following project elements:
1. Demolition of the Neighborhood District of the Interim Area
2. Grading and hydroseeding of the Interim Area
3. Complete construction of the Neighborhood District Development
Interim Area
The Interim Area, as shown in Exhibit 6, would be demolished, graded, and hydroseeded, in
preparation for later phases of development under the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District. While the
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
20 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
demolition and grading will be approved as part of the project-level analysis, future development in
this area is only being analyzed at the program level. The Existing to Remain area shown in Exhibit 6
will not undergo any demolition, tree removal, or grading, and will remain as-is until a future project
under the Mixed-Use and/or Multi-Family District is approved.
Neighborhood District
The proposed project includes the construction of a 54-acre Neighborhood District, located in the
southern portion of the project site that would total 368 residential dwelling units, including single-
family homes, townhomes, single-family homes, and vertical mixed-use units, as shown in Table 1.
Up to 58 ADUs would also be constructed. The Neighborhood District Development would have a
FAR of 0.41.
As shown in Exhibit 4, the attached Row Townhomes would be located in the northern portion of the
Neighborhood District; Single-Family Detached Homes would be located at the east and west ends of
the Neighborhood District; Single-Family Row Homes would be located in the center of the
Neighborhood District; and Single-Family Court Homes would be located along the southern portion
of the Neighborhood District. Exhibit 5 depicts the proposed layout; Exhibit 6 depicts the proposed
housing types.
Table 1: Neighborhood District Unit Mix
Unit Type Number of Units ADUs
Total Residential
Units
Single-family Court Homes 42 10 52
Single-family Detached Homes 130 — —
Single-family Row Homes 58 — —
Attached Row Townhomes 138 48 186
Total 368 58 426
Notes:
ADU = accessory dwelling unit
Source: William Hezmalhalch Architects, Inc. DBA WHA. 2025.
Amenities
The Neighborhood District would include three publicly accessible parks and open space amenities in
addition to private open space, for a total of 397,184 square feet, or 9.12 acres of parkland. A
greenway and multiuse trail would wrap the perimeter of the proposed project with connections to the
Heritage Oak Tree Parks, which are designed around the existing heritage oak trees on the site. The
pathway includes passive and active recreational activities.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 21
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Additionally, the Neighborhood District would include two pocket parks within the Townhome
community.
Circulation
The main access to the Neighborhood District would be provided by the existing Chevron Drive.
Another access point would be provided via a connection to the office building parking lot to the east
of the project site. Sidewalks are proposed along all roadways. The proposed greenway multiuse trail
would be a new addition to the City’s Walking District.
Parking
Parking in the Neighborhood District would be provided as shown in Table 2.
Table 2: Neighborhood District Parking
Unit Type
Covered
Spaces in
Garage/DU
Uncovered
Space in
Driveway/DU
Total Covered and
Uncovered Spaces
Guest Parking Total
Spaces
Provided
On-
Street
EV/
ADA
Single-family
Court Homes
3 2 210 64 — 274
Single-family
Detached
Homes
2 2 520 161 — 681
Single-family
Row Homes
2 — 116 101 — 217
Attached Row
Homes
2 — 368 35 2 405
Total — — 1,214 361 2 1,577
Notes:
ADA = Americans with Disabilities Act
DU = dwelling unit
EV = electric vehicle
Source: William Hezmalhalch Architects, Inc. DBA WHA. 2025.
Storm Drainage
Bio-treatment areas for stormwater would be provided throughout the east and west greenways of the
project site. These were designed in accordance with the applicable C.3 guidelines within the Contra
Costa County Clean Water Program (CCCWP).
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
22 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Utilities
Water
Potable water service would be provided by East Bay Municipal Utilities District (EBMUD) via existing
water lines at the project site.
Wastewater
Wastewater treatment services would be provided by Central Contra Costa Sanitary District (Central
San) via existing sanitary sewer lines at the project site.
Electricity and Natural Gas
Electricity would be provided by Marin Clean Energy (MCE) via existing Pacific Gas and Electric
Company (PG&E) power lines, unless individual residents elect to have PG&E provided. Natural gas
would be provided by PG&E via existing gas lines.
2.3.4 - Affordable Housing
The proposed project would comply with the City’s Inclusionary Housing Ordinance and would also
qualify for the benefits provided by State Density Bonus Law by providing sufficient on-site affordable
housing. Specifically, the Neighborhood District’s on-site affordable housing obligation will be satisfied
through a stand-alone affordable housing development on a 1.8-acre parcel in the Multi-Family
District, shown in Exhibit 5 as “Building H.” The Multi-Family Residential and Mixed-Use Development
will provide on-site affordable housing as obligated by the City’s Inclusionary Housing Ordinance and
a Development Agreement.
State Density Bonus Waivers
The development provides sufficient affordable housing on-site to qualify for the State Density Bonus
Law, including incentives/concessions and unlimited waivers. The proposed project would utilize a
waiver to seek relief from the minimum required FAR. The proposed project’s density would be 47.2
dwelling units per net acre, which exceeds the applicable minimum General Plan residential density
of 20 dwelling units per acre. However, the proposed Neighborhood District Development would have
a FAR of 0.41 which is less than the minimum required sitewide FAR and therefore would request a
waiver under the State Density Bonus Law of the required minimum sitewide FAR of 1.25 in DMU-
South zone, as compliance with this development standard would make construction of the proposed
project physically infeasible.
Additionally, the proposed project is also requesting to waive the City’s Objective Design Standards
for Multi-Family Residential and Mixed-Use Development.1
1 City of San Ramon. 2024. Objective Design Standards for Multi-Family Residential and Mixed-Use Development.
November 12, 2024.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 23
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2.3.5 - Phasing and Construction
The proposed project would be developed over a 20-year period, beginning with the Neighborhood
District Development and followed by the affordable multi-family housing units within the Multi-Family
District. The Mixed-Use District and the remainder of the Multi-Family District would be phased over
time to allow for residential absorption. Phasing would be subject to market conditions.
2.4 - Approvals
The proposed project requires the following discretionary approvals from the City:
• Development Plan
• Vesting Tentative Map
• Architectural Review Permit
• Tree Removal Permit
• Development Agreement
The following administrative actions would also be required from the City:
• Grading Permits
• Building Permits
• Certificates of Occupancy; and
• Other City approvals as necessary to develop the proposed project.
Other agencies with permitting or regulatory authority over the proposed project include:
• EBMUD
• San Francisco Bay Regional Water Quality Control Board (San Francisco Bay RWQCB)
• Bay Area Air Quality Management District
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Orchards Project
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist
FCS 25
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
3 - CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183: PROJECTS
CONSISTENT WITH A COMMUNITY PLAN OR
ZONING
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 mandates that projects which are consistent with the development
density established by existing zoning, community plan, or general plan policies for which an EIR was
certified shall not require additional environmental review, except as might be necessary to examine
whether there are project-specific significant effects which are peculiar to the project or its site. This
streamlines the review of such projects and reduces the need to prepare repetitive environmental
studies.
Proposed Project Qualifies for No Further Environmental
Review under CEQA Guidelines Section 15183
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 applies to the project since it meets all of the requirements of
subsection (d)(1) and (d)(2) as explained below.
(d)(1)(C) The project is consistent with the San Ramon 2040
General Plan.
The proposed project is consistent with the development density established by existing general plan
policies identified in the certified San Ramon 2040 General Plan Final EIR, SCH Number
2022060549.
(d)(2) An EIR was certified by the lead agency for the zoning
action, the community plan, or the general plan.
The San Ramon 2040 General Plan Final EIR, SCH Number 2022060549, was certified on
December 12, 2023.
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Orchards Project
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist
FCS 27
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
4 - ENVIRONMENTAL CHECKLIST
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183(b) states that:
(b) In approving a project meeting the requirements of this section, a public agency shall
limit its examination of environmental effects to those which the agency determines,
in an initial study or other analysis:
(1) Are peculiar to the project or the parcel on which the project would be located;
(2) Were not analyzed as significant effects in a prior FEIR on the zoning action,
general plan, or community plan, with which the project is consistent;
(3) Are potentially significant off-site impacts and cumulative impacts which were not
discussed in the prior FEIR prepared for the general plan, community plan or
zoning action; or
(4) Are previously identified significant effects which, as a result of substantial new
information which was not known at the time the FEIR was certified, are
determined to have a more severe adverse impact than discussed in the prior
FEIR.
The following pages of this document contain an Environmental Checklist that examines the project’s
potential for project-specific environmental effects that are peculiar to the project or its site within the
parameters outlined at CEQA Guidelines Section 15183(b). Impacts that were analyzed in the prior
EIR are not peculiar to the project or its site and do not require further review. The “prior EIR” used for
comparison is the 2040 General Plan FEIR certified by the City on December 12, 2023, including all
impact determinations and significance thresholds utilized therein.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
28 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More
Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.1 Aesthetics
Except as provided in Public Resources Code Section 21099, would the project:
a) Have a substantial adverse
effect on a scenic vista?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Substantially damage
scenic resources, including,
but not limited to, trees,
rock outcroppings, and
historic building within a
State Scenic Highway?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
c) In non-urbanized areas,
substantially degrade the
existing visual character or
quality of public views of the
site and its surroundings?
(Public views are those that
are experienced from
publicly accessible vantage
point). If the project is in an
urbanized area, would the
project conflict with
applicable zoning and other
regulations governing
scenic quality?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
d) Create a new source of
substantial light or glare
which would adversely
affect day or nighttime
views in the area?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 29
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
a) Scenic Vista
Would the project: Have a substantial adverse effect on a scenic vista?
Summary of 2040 General Plan FEIR
The 2040 General Plan FEIR identifies scenic views of the hills of Hidden Valley Open Space and
Tassajara Valley to the east; Mount Diablo to the northeast; the Diablo Range foothills to the north;
the Las Trampas Regional Wilderness to the northwest; and Bishop Ranch Regional Preserve to the
west. The 2040 General Plan does not designate these views of these natural features as “vistas.”
However, the 2040 General Plan FEIR does designate 12 viewpoint locations as scenic views,
particularly hillside areas. These public views are largely limited by intervening development,
topography, and landscaping. Development facilitated by the 2040 General Plan is expected to occur
within already urbanized areas, with land uses ranging up to five stories tall. The 2040 General Plan
Land Use Element and Open Space and Conservation Element contains policies for ensuring the
protection of scenic views, including Policy 4.6-I-17 (Clustered Development); Policy 4.8-I-9 (Park and
Recreational Amenities); and Policy 8.3-I-13 (Viewshed Criteria). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan
FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The project site is not within the vicinity of a scenic vista and there are no identified scenic vistas
within the General Plan Area. However, the project site is located 140 feet from a scenic viewpoint
designated as View #8 in Figure 3.1.2 of the 2040 General Plan FEIR. From View #8, there are
existing views of the Bishop Ranch Open Space Preserve that are impacted by the project site, which
is located 0.69 mile southwest of the project site.2 Views of the Preserve from View #8 are partially
screened by existing trees and buildings on-site. Designation of the proposed Mixed-Use District and
Multi-Family Districts would not in itself impact views of the Bishop Ranch Open Space Preserve.
Furthermore, because the project site is already developed with office buildings, it is not expected
that future development under the proposed Mixed-Use District and Muti-Family Districts would
create additional screening of the Bishop Ranch Open Space Preserve beyond existing conditions.
As concluded by the 2040 General Plan, compliance with Policy 4.6-I-17 (Clustered Development)
would maximize the preservation of visible open space; implementation of Policy 4.8-I-19 (Park and
Recreational Amenities) through well-designed buildings and landscaping; and Policy 8.3-I-13
(Viewshed Criteria) to manage views of the natural hillsides surrounding the City would ensure that
impacts to scenic views are less than significant. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that
are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was
not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
2 City of San Ramon. 2023. 2040 General Plan Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR). Pages 3.1-6 through 3.1-10.
November.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
30 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area)
As discussed above, the project site is located between the General Plan designated View #8 and the
Bishop Ranch Open Space Preserve, and existing trees and buildings partially obstruct views of the
Bishop Ranch Open Space Preserve from View #8.
Demolition and grading that would occur on the Interim Area would result in an increased visibility of
the Bishop Ranch Open Space Preserve and would not create an adverse impact.
The proposed Neighborhood District includes buildings ranging from 26 to 34 feet tall, similar or
shorter than the buildings currently on-site. Furthermore, the Existing to Remain area at the northern
portion of the project site contains trees that would remain in place until sites are developed under
future applications, to maintain a screening effect for the proposed buildings (Exhibit 6). As such,
construction of the Neighborhood District would not significantly alter views of the Bishop Ranch
Open Space Preserve from View #8 beyond existing conditions.
As the proposed project is consistent with the General Plan’s zoning designation and density and
does not introduce new or more severe environmental effects than those previously analyzed, it does
not include any potentially significant impacts that are peculiar to the project or its site pursuant to
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183.
Thus, any impacts to scenic vistas would be less than significant. Therefore, there are no
environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim
Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not result in a new or
more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
b) State Scenic Highways
Would the project: Substantially damage scenic resources, including, but not limited to,
trees, rock outcroppings, and historic building within a State Scenic
Highway?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The City is bisected from north to south by the Interstate 680 (I-680) Highway, an officially designated
State Scenic Highway, with urban development occurring on both sides. Views eastward of I-680 are
obscured by walls, trees, and other landscaping not designated as scenic resources, which would
therefore not be impacted by development under the 2040 General Plan. Views westward of I-680
include adjacent neighborhoods, landscaping, open space, and distant hilltops, which could be
impacted by buildout of the 2040 General Plan, which would result in intervening development that
could obscure scenic westward views. However, it was determined that compliance with the City’s
Tree Preservation Guidelines and the 2040 General Plan Open Space and Conservation Element
(including Policy 8.7-1-3 (Archaeological Resources Assessment) and Policy 8.7-I-4 (Officially Listed
Historic Resources)), would ensure that trees and historic buildings within a State Scenic Highway
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 31
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
are not damaged by new development. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that
impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site is adjacent to the I-680, a designated State Scenic Highway. As previously
mentioned, views eastward of the I-680 are obscured by walls, trees, and other landscaping not
designated as scenic resources, and would therefore not be impacted by the proposed project.
Furthermore, per the findings of the Phase I Cultural Resources Assessment (Phase I CRA) prepared
by FirstCarbon Solutions on September 26, 2025, there are no officially listed historic resources
within the vicinity of the project site that would be impacted by development of the proposed project.3
Thus, the proposed project would have less than significant impacts to resources within a State
Scenic Highway. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed
project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
c) Visual Character
Would the project: In non-urbanized areas, substantially degrade the existing visual
character or quality of public views of the site and its surroundings?
(Public views are those that are experienced from publicly accessible
vantage point). If the project is in an urbanized area, would the
project conflict with applicable zoning and other regulations
governing scenic quality?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The City is considered an urbanized area. Given that buildout of the 2040 General Plan Area
prioritizes infill development and redevelopment projects in already developed areas, it was
determined that compliance with the following policies would reduce impacts to less than significant:
Policy 4.6-I-9 (360-Design Principles); Policy 4.8-I-2 (Natural Features); Policy 4.8-I-5 (Complete
Streets Networks); Policy 4.8-I-8 (Views of the Natural Landscape); Policy 4.8-I-9 (Public Roadways);
Policy 4.8-I-12 (Drought-Tolerant Landscaping); and Policy IP 11.5.2-7 (Neighborhood Compatibility),
which address design, compatibility, preservation of natural features, landscape standards, public art,
and other scenic quality metrics. Future development under the General Plan would also be required
to comply with the Site Planning and Project Design Standards specified under Title D of the San
Ramon Municipal Code and Zoning Code. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that
impacts would be less than significant.
3 FirstCarbon Solutions (FCS). 2025. Phase I Cultural Resources Assessment. The Orchards Project. Page 26.
September.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
32 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
As previously mentioned, the project site is in an urbanized area. Designation of the Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family Districts would be compatible with the existing DMU-S land use designation, which is
designed to promote an integrated transit-oriented and mixed-use neighborhood extending from City
Center along Bollinger Canyon Road and include a variety of housing types. The proposed Mixed-
Use and Multi-Family Districts are intended to include these uses and would be in close proximity to
existing transit routes on Bollinger Canyon Road.
The maximum density permitted under the DMU-S is 60 dwelling units per acre (du/ac) or 5,490 units
for the 91.5-acre project site. The maximum number of units permitted under the Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family Districts combined would be 2,084. The Neighborhood District proposes 426 units,
meaning the maximum number of units proposed under the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts
would be well within the number of units permitted at the project site.
Because designation of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts does not include any project
construction, it would be too speculative at this time to evaluate specific impacts related to
compatibility with policies governing scenic quality. Future development of the Mixed-Use and Multi-
Family Districts would be required to comply with General Plan policies and programs, as well as
development and design standards in the Orchards Design Guidelines. For example, buildings would
not exceed the permitted height of 85 feet for the DMU-S zone. Therefore, there are no environmental
effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-
Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact
that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project includes the demolition, grading, and tree removal of the Interim Area. However, the
northern edge of the Interim Area would be shielded by a large number of trees in the northern portion
of the project site, which would remain untouched at this time. The remainder of the Interim Area
would be shielded by the Neighborhood District and the landscaping proposed around its perimeter.
As such, the Interim Area would not impact the visual character of the area.
Development of the Neighborhood District would comply with General Plan policies and programs
and would adhere to development and design standards in the Municipal Code, specifically
development standards for Downtown Mixed-Use South development as stipulated in Title D, Division
D2, Chapter III Mixed-Use Zones of the San Ramon Municipal Code.4
4 City of San Ramon. 2025. Title D Zoning. Division D2 Allowable Land Uses and Zoning Standards. Chapter III Mixed-Use
Zones. Chapter III—Mixed-Use Zones. Website: https://online.encodeplus.com/regs/sanramon-ca/doc-
viewer.aspx?secid=5418#secid-5418. Accessed October 29, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 33
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
The DMU-S land use designation allows for a density range between 20-60 du/acre. The proposed
Neighborhood District, in combination with the anticipated development of the Mixed-Use and Multi-
Family Districts, would have a density of 47.2 du/acre. The DMU-S land use designation requires a
minimum FAR of 1.25. The proposed Neighborhood District would result in a FAR of 0.41, lower than
the minimum FAR permitted for the land use. However, the proposed Neighborhood District would be
eligible for a waiver under the State’s Density Bonus Law due to providing sufficient on-site affordable
housing units to qualify for the State Density Bonus Law (see Section 2.3.4 Affordable Housing).
The maximum building height limit for the DMU-S zone is up to 85 feet. The Neighborhood District
proposes buildings ranging from 26 to 34 feet tall, consistent with the DMU-S zone. The proposed
Neighborhood District would contain similar height or shorter than the buildings currently on the site.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed
Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood
District plus Grading of Interim Area would not result in a new or more severe
adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR. d)
Light or Glare
Would the project: Create a new source of substantial light or glare which would
adversely affect day or nighttime views in the area?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Light and glare levels within the City are consistent with suburban and urbanized development, with
the presence of stationary sources such as streetlights, exterior building lights, and lighted signs in
addition to mobile sources such as motor vehicle headlights. Although the 2040 General Plan FEIR
notes that new development could result in increased stationary sources of lighting, enforcement
Section D3-7(H) (Light Fixtures); Section D3-7(C)(Lighting Plan); and Section D5-5(2)(b) (Hillside,
Creek, and Ridgelines Areas) in addition to 2040 General Plan Policy 4.8-I-3 (Citywide Lighting
Standards) address lighting impacts. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts
would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
Designation of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would not include any approved development
and therefore, would not include new sources of light and glare. While designation of these districts
anticipates development at a future time, it would be too speculative to analyze specific light and
glare impacts at this time. Although new development resulting from the 2040 General Plan is
expected to generate an increase in new lighting, conformance with refined citywide lighting
standards stipulated in Policy 4.8-I-3, in addition to applicable policies outlined in the San Ramon
Municipal Code, would reduce impacts related to light and glare. Future development under the
Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would be required to comply with these policies. Therefore,
there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
34 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the
2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed Neighborhood District would contribute to an increase in stationary light sources and
mobile light sources. However, development of the Neighborhood District is required to comply with
refined citywide lighting standards stipulated in Policy 4.8-I-3 and applicable policies in the San
Ramon Municipal Code to reduce impacts related to light and glare. Thus, the proposed
Neighborhood District would result in less than significant impacts to light and glare and would be
consistent with the General Plan. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to
the proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood
District Development plus Grading of Interim Area would not result in a new or more severe adverse
impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
None.
Conclusion
With regard to Aesthetics, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 35
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources
In determining whether impacts to agricultural resources are significant environmental effects, lead
agencies may refer to the California Agricultural Land Evaluation and Site Assessment Model (1997)
prepared by the California Dept. of Conservation as an optional model to use in assessing impacts
on agriculture and farmland. In determining whether impacts to forest resources, including
timberland, are significant environmental effects, lead agencies may refer to information compiled by
the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection regarding the State’s inventory of forest
land, including the Forest and Range Assessment Project and the Forest Legacy Assessment
project; and forest carbon measurement methodology provided in Forest Protocols adopted by the
California Air Resources Board.
Would the project:
a) Convert Prime Farmland,
Unique Farmland, or
Farmland of Statewide
Importance (Farmland), as
shown on the maps
prepared pursuant to the
Farmland Mapping and
Monitoring Program of the
California Resources
Agency, to nonagricultural
use?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Conflict with existing zoning
for agricultural use, or a
Williamson Act Contract?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
c) Conflict with existing zoning
for, or cause rezoning of,
forest land (as defined in
Public Resources Code
Section 12220(g)),
timberland (as defined by
Public Resources Code
Section 4526), or
timberland zoned
No impact No No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
36 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
Timberland Production (as
defined by Government
Code Section 51104(g))?
d) Result in the loss of forest
land or conversion of forest
land to non-forest use?
No impact No No No No
e) Involve other changes in
the existing environment
which, due to their location
or nature, could result in
conversion of Farmland, to
nonagricultural use or
conversion of forest land to
non-forest use?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
a) Conversion of Important Farmland
Would the project: Convert Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide
Importance (Farmland), as shown on the maps prepared pursuant to
the Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program of the California
Resources Agency, to nonagricultural use?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
As noted by the 2040 General Plan FEIR, the General Plan Area contains approximately 5,927 acres
of Important Farmland, including 5,838 acres of Farmland of Local Importance, 60 acres of Unique
Farmland, and 29 acres of Prime Farmland. Therefore, the General Plan accounted for the
conversion of agricultural land. The project site was not identified as agricultural land in the General
Plan. While the majority of new development facilitated by the 2040 General Plan would be primarily
through infill development, and would therefore result in no impact to existing agricultural lands, the
2040 General Plan contains policies for minimizing impacts associated with the conversion of Prime
Farmland and Unique Farmland to nonagricultural use within the General Plan Area.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 37
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site is classified as Urban and Builtup Land and the proposed project would be infill
development consistent with the land use designations identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.5
Therefore, development of the proposed project would not result in any environmental effects that are
peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe
adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
b) Agricultural Zoning and Williamson Act Contracts
Would the project: Conflict with existing zoning for agricultural use, or a Williamson Act
Contract?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan Area contains land designated as Open Space, Rural Conservation, or Park,
which allow for agricultural activities. Although some agricultural lands are under an active Williamson
Act Contract, these lands are located outside of the infill development sites targeted within the Urban
Growth Boundary (UGB). The General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than
significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site is zoned as DMU-S and is not subject to a Williamson Act Contract, consistent with
the General Plan. Therefore, development of the proposed project would not result in any
environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project would not result
in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan
FEIR.
c) Forest Zoning
Would the project: Conflict with existing zoning for forest land or timberland zoned
Timberland Production (as defined by Government Code Section
51104(g))?
5 Department of Conservation. 2025. California Important Farmland Finder. Website:
https://maps.conservation.ca.gov/DLRP/CIFF/. Accessed August 12, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
38 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan Area does not contain land identified as forest land or timberland. As such,
development facilitated by the 2040 General Plan would not conflict with existing zoning for forest
land or timberland and there would be no impact.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site does not contain land zoned as forest land or timberland. Therefore, development of
the proposed project would not result in any environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed
project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
d) Conversion of Forest Land
Would the project: Result in the loss of forest land or conversion of forest land to non-
forest use?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
As previously mentioned, the 2040 General Plan Area does not contain land identified as forest land.
Therefore, there would be no loss in forest land or conversion of forest land to non-forest use and
there would be no impact.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site is within the 2040 General Plan Area and thus does not contain forest land or
timberland. Therefore, development of the proposed project would not result in any environmental
effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or
more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
e) Pressures to Convert Farmland or Forest Land
Would the project: Involve other changes in the existing environment which, due to their
location or nature, could result in conversion of Farmland, to
nonagricultural use or conversion of forest land to non-forest use?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan Area does not contain land identified as forest land or agricultural land on the
project site. There are 5,927 acres of Important Farmland within the 2040 General Plan Area. As
noted within the 2040 General Plan FEIR, new development would be required to comply with 2040
General Plan Policy 8.5-I-1 (Evaluation of Impacts) and Policy 8.5-I-5 (Designate Land for Rural
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 39
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Conservation for Compatibility with Adjoining Agricultural Uses) to reduce impacts that would result in
the conversion of Farmland to nonagricultural uses. Therefore, the General Plan FEIR concluded that
impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
As previously mentioned, the project site consists of Urban/Builtup land and is an infill site that is not
on or near Farmland or forest land. Therefore, development of the proposed project would not result
in any environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
None.
Conclusion
With regard to Agriculture and Forestry Resources, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
40 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More
Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.3 Air Quality
Where available, the significance criteria established by the applicable air quality management
district or air pollution control district may be relied upon to make the following determinations.
Would the project:
a) Conflict with or obstruct
implementation of the
applicable air quality plan?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Result in a cumulatively
considerable net increase
of any criteria pollutant for
which the project region is
nonattainment under an
applicable federal or State
ambient air quality
standard?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
c) Expose sensitive receptors
to substantial pollutant
concentrations?
Less than
significant with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
d) Result in other emissions
(such as those leading to
odors or) adversely
affecting a substantial
number of people?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
Environmental Setting
The project site is located in the City of San Ramon and is within the San Francisco Bay Area Air
Basin (SFBAAB) which covers Alameda, Contra Costa, Marin, Napa, San Francisco, San Mateo,
Santa Clara, and parts of Solano and Sonoma counties and is under the Bay Area Air Quality
Management District’s (Bay Area Air District’s) jurisdiction. The SFBAAB is bordered by the Pacific
Ocean to the west and surrounded by coastal and inland mountain ranges that influence local airflow
and pollutant dispersion.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 41
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
The region has a Mediterranean climate with mild, wet winters and warm, dry summers. Prevailing
westerly and northwesterly winds, driven by marine influences, generally help disperse pollutants
inland. In summer and early fall, high temperatures and sunlight promote ozone formation, and
occasional inversions can trap this pollution near the surface, particularly in inland valleys. In winter,
strong temperature inversions are more frequent, limiting vertical air mixing and allowing fine
particulate matter (PM₂.₅) from wood-burning, traffic, and other sources to accumulate. Topography
and seasonal weather create distinct microclimates; coastal areas benefit from stronger ventilation,
while sheltered interior areas are more prone to pollutant buildup.
Existing Air Quality
The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) administers national air quality programs
under the authority of the federal Clean Air Act (CAA), which mandates the establishment of National
Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) for the six criteria pollutants: ozone, CO, NO₂, SO₂,
particulate matter (PM₁₀, and PM₂.₅), and lead. To meet and maintain these standards, each state is
required to develop a State Implementation Plan (SIP), which is updated periodically to reflect current
emissions inventories, planning strategies, and regulatory developments reported by local air quality
agencies.
Criteria pollutant emissions primarily stem from combustion sources and have been linked to serious
respiratory and cardiovascular conditions, especially in vulnerable populations. Another classification
of pollutants includes toxic air contaminants (TACs), such as diesel particulate matter and benzene,
which pose additional health risks including cancer and neurological damage, and are managed
through targeted controls rather than ambient air quality standards.
In California, the California Air Resources Board (ARB) oversees State and regional air pollution
control efforts and enforces the California Clean Air Act (CCAA). Under the CCAA, ARB sets
California Ambient Air Quality Standards (CAAQS), which include the federal criteria pollutants and
additional contaminants such as sulfates, hydrogen sulfide, vinyl chloride, and visibility-reducing
particulate matter. CAAQS are typically more stringent than NAAQS, reflecting California’s
commitment to enhanced air quality protection.
To assess air pollution levels and overall air quality in the SFBAAB, the Bay Area Air District operates
an extensive network of ambient air quality monitoring stations distributed across the nine-county
region. The monitoring network plays a critical role in measuring ambient air pollutant levels and
tracking trends. These data support the development of air quality management strategies. The
stations continuously measure concentrations of key pollutants, including:
Data from these stations are collected, validated, and reported on an ongoing basis to provide a
comprehensive understanding of air quality. The network employs standardized measurement
techniques and adheres to protocols set by the ARB and the EPA to ensure accuracy and
comparability of data. Because of periodic exceedances of ozone and particulate matter standards,
the SFBAAB is designated as a nonattainment area under both CCAA and federal CAA requirements.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
42 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
a) Air Quality Plan Conflict
Would the project: Conflict with or obstruct implementation of the applicable air quality
plan?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan FEIR analyzed the consistency of the 2040 General Plan with the
assumptions and objectives of the 2017 Bay Area Clean Air Plan (the regional Air Quality
Management Plan [AQMP]) to determine whether implementation of the 2040 General Plan would
interfere with the region’s ability to comply with federal and State air quality standards. To
demonstrate consistency with the 2017 Clean Air Plan, the Bay Area Air District recommends
satisfying the following questions: (1) does the project support the primary goals of the AQMP; (2)
does the project include applicable control measures from the AQMP; and (3) does the project disrupt
or hinder implementation of any AQMP control measures.
According to the analysis in the 2040 General Plan FEIR—which included a consistency analysis of
all of the policies in the 2040 General Plan against the control measures contained with the 2017
Clean Air Plan—the 2040 General Plan would be consistent with the three criteria for evaluating
consistency with the 2017 Clean Air Plan, and would not conflict with or obstruct implementation of
the applicable air quality plan. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would
be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The 11.3-acre Mixed-Use District would consist of residential communities with ground floor retail,
entertainment and commercial uses complementary to City Center Bishop Ranch across Bollinger
Canyon Road. The 26-acre Multi-Family District would consist of communities that may be developed
into apartments, condominiums, senior or affordable housing, offering a variety of housing options
and would include Orchards Park, a 2.5-acre park that would serve as a gathering place for residents
and visitors. The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District are expected to be developed under
separate projects over the longer-term future and would be subject to future project-level CEQA
analysis.
As discussed above, the 2040 General Plan FEIR analyzed the policies contained within the 2040
General Plan against the control measures contained within the 2017 Clean Air Plan and concluded
that the policies would demonstrate consistency with the control measures of the 2017 Clean Air
Plan. Individual development projects within the Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District would be
required to implement relevant and applicable policies from the 2040 General Plan. Therefore, the
Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District would be consistent with the 2017 Clean Air Plan and
would not conflict with or obstruct implementation of the applicable AQMP, and impacts would be less
than significant. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed
Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 43
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the
2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-Level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The current Bay Area Air District attainment plan is the 2017 Clean Air Plan, which is the regional
AQMP for the SFBAAB for attaining NAAQS. A project would be judged to conflict with or obstruct the
2017 Clean Air Plan implementation if it would result in substantial new regional emissions not
foreseen in the air quality planning process.
The Bay Area Air District’s 2022 CEQA Guidelines outline the following criteria that should be used for
determining a project’s consistency with the AQMP.
• Criterion 1: Does the project support the primary goals of the AQMP?
• Criterion 2: Does the project include applicable control measures from the AQMP?
• Criterion 3: Does the project disrupt or hinder implementation of any AQMP control measures?
Primary Goals of the Air Quality Management Plan
The primary goals of the 2017 Clean Air Plan are to attain air quality standards, reduce population
exposure to unhealthy air and protect the public health in the Bay Area, and reduce GHG emissions
and protect the climate.
As discussed under Impact 4.3(b), the Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a cumulatively considerable net increase of any criteria pollutant during project construction
or operation and, therefore, would not impede the 2017 Clean Air Plan’s goal to attain air quality
standards. Therefore, the proposed project supports the 2017 Clean Air Plan’s goal to attain air
quality standards.
As discussed under Impact 4.3(c), implementation of the Neighborhood District plus Grading of
Interim Area would not expose sensitive populations to unhealthy air during project construction or
operation, and therefore, the Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area supports the 2017
Clean Air Plan’s goal to reduce population exposure to unhealthy air and protect public health in the
Bay Area.
Finally, as discussed under Impact 4.8(a), implementation of the Neighborhood District plus Grading
of Interim Area would not result in direct or indirect emissions of GHGs that would cause significant
impacts, and therefore, the Neighborhood District supports the 2017 Clean Air Plan’s goal to reduce
GHG emissions and protect the climate.
As demonstrated, the Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would meet the primary
goals of the of the 2017 Clean Air Plan and would be consistent with Criterion 1.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
44 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Applicable Control Measures
The 2017 Clean Air Plan contains 85 control measures that describe specific actions to reduce air
pollutants and GHG emissions at the local, regional, and global levels. To establish compliance with
the Clean Air Plan, the Neighborhood District would be required to comply with applicable Clean Air
Plan control measures, listed below:6
• BL1: Green Buildings;
• BL2: Decarbonize Buildings;
• BL4: Urban Heat Island Migration;
• EN1: Decarbonize Electricity Generation;
• EN2: Decrease Electricity Demand;
• NW2: Urban Tree Planting;
• WA3: Green Waste Diversion;
• WA4: Recycling and Waste Reduction;
• SS36: Particulate Matter from Trackout;
• TR9: Bicycle and Pedestrian Access and Facilities.
The Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would comply with the above control
measures as specified below:
• For consistency with Clean Air Plan Measures BL1, BL2, EN1, and EN2, development within
the Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would comply with the latest energy
efficiency standards, such as the 2022 California Title 24 Energy Code. In addition, the
Neighborhood District would be constructed as all-electric and would not utilize natural gas. It
would be served by MCE, which provides electricity options that are more renewable than
PG&E’s (although PG&E would deliver energy through existing power lines, and maintain the
lines). In 2024, MCE’s Light Green option procured 69 percent of the electricity it provides from
eligible renewables. The MCE Deep Green Option offers 100 percent of the electricity it
provides from eligible renewables.7 Therefore, the energy use and indirect GHG emissions
associated with the building’s energy would originate from a greater portion of renewable
energy than what is currently required by the Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS).
• For consistency with Clean Air Plan Measures BL4 and NW2, the Neighborhood District would
include park space, including three publicly accessible parks and open space amenities in
addition to private open space. A greenway and multiuse trail would wrap the perimeter with
6 Bay Area Air Quality Management District (Bay Area Air District). 2017. Final 2017 Clean Air Plan. Website:
https://www.baaqmd.gov/plans-and-climate/air-quality-plans/current-
plans#:~:text=The%202017%20Plan%20includes%20a,climate%20pollutants%20in%20the%20near%2D. Accessed
November 11, 2025.
7 Marin Clean Energy. 2025. Where Your Energy Comes From. Website: https://mcecleanenergy.org/energy-sources/.
Accessed November 13, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 45
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
connections to the Heritage Oak Tree Parks, which are designed around the existing heritage
oak trees on the site.
• For consistency with Clean Air Plan Measures WA3 and WA4, the Neighborhood District would
utilize a waste service provider compliant with Assembly Bill (AB) 341, Senate Bill (SB) 939,
and SB 1374 requirements.
• For consistency with Clean Air Plan Measure SS36, the Neighborhood District plus Grading of
Interim Area would be required to comply with Policy 12.6-I-3 and Policy 12.6-I-5 of the 2040
General Plan which would require construction and grading activities to limit fugitive dust and
particulate pollution related to construction equipment by including particulate emissions
reduction measures in Grading Manual Standards and compliance with Bay Area Air District
basic Best Management Practices for construction-related fugitive dust.
• For consistency with Clean Air Plan Measure TR9, the proposed project would construct
sidewalks along all roads. In addition, a greenway and multiuse trail would wrap the perimeter
of the Neighborhood District with connections to the Heritage Oak Tree Parks, which are
designed around the existing heritage oak trees on-site. The pathway includes passive and
active recreational activities.
Accordingly, implementation of the Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
conflict with any applicable measures under the 2017 Clean Air Plan given the implementation of
Policy 12.6-I-3 and Policy 12.6-I-5 of the 2040 General Plan for dust control measures, and would
therefore be consistent with Criterion 2.
Hindrance of Implementation of AQMP Control Measures
The Neighborhood District would not preclude extension of a transit line or bike path, propose
excessive parking beyond parking requirements, or otherwise create an impediment or disruption to
implementing any AQMP control measures, as discussed above. The Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area would not disrupt or hinder the implementation of any AQMP control
measures and would therefore be consistent with Criterion 3.
Overall, the Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would demonstrate consistency with
all three criterion as outlined by the Bay Area Air District for demonstrating that it would not conflict
with or obstruct implementation of the applicable AQMP, and impacts would be less than significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
46 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
b) Air Quality Standard, Criteria Pollutants
Would the project: Result in a cumulatively considerable net increase of any criteria
pollutant for which the project region is nonattainment under an
applicable federal or State ambient air quality standard?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan FEIR analyzed the potential impacts related to air quality that could occur
from development under the 2040 General Plan.
Construction activities would involve activities that would result in air pollution emissions from dust,
fumes, equipment exhaust and other air contaminants. The 2040 General Plan includes Policy 12.6-I-
3 and Policy 12.6-1-5 which require measures to reduce fugitive dust during construction and grading
activities, and compliance with Bay Area Air District CEQA guidance and thresholds as part of
conditions of approval and CEQA review for subsequent development projects. The 2040 General
Plan FEIR identified Mitigation Measure (MM) AQ-1, which requires an evaluation of criteria pollutant
emissions during the construction phase for projects that are subject to CEQA and exceed screening
sizes in the Bay Area Air District’s CEQA Guidelines. If the evaluation finds that construction-related
criteria air pollutants exceed the Bay Area Air District’s thresholds, then the project shall mitigate the
impacts to a less than significant level. With implementation of MM AQ-1, overall cumulative
construction criteria pollutant emissions impacts would be less than significant.
Operational activities would be from mobile sources as well as natural gas usage and area sources.
The 2040 General Plan includes a number of policies intended to reduce emissions from mobile
sources. In addition, the 2040 General Plan FEIR identified MM AQ-2 which requires an evaluation of
project-specific operational emissions in accordance with the Bay Area Air District’s CEQA
Guidelines. If the evaluation finds that operational-related air pollutants exceed the Bay Area Air
District’s thresholds, then the project shall mitigate the impacts to a less than significant level. With
implementation of MM AQ-2, overall cumulative operational criteria pollutant emissions impacts would
be less than significant.
Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts from construction and operation
would be less than significant after incorporation of mitigation.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The 11.3-acre Mixed-Use District would consist of residential communities with ground floor retail,
entertainment and commercial uses complementary to City Center Bishop Ranch across Bollinger
Canyon Road. The 26-acre Multi-Family District would consist of communities that may be developed
into apartments, condominiums, senior or affordable housing, offering a variety of housing options
and would include Orchards Park, a 2.5-acre park that would serve as a gathering place for residents
and visitors. The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District are expected to be developed under
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 47
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
separate projects over the longer-term future and would be subject to future project-level CEQA
analysis.
Development of the Mixed-Use District and the Multi-Family District would include construction
activities that would result in air pollution emissions from dust, fumes, equipment exhaust and other
air contaminants. Individual development within the Mixed-Use District and the Multi-Family District
would be required to comply with the City’s 2040 General Plan Policy 12.6-I-3 and Policy 12.6-1-5,
which would require measures to reduce fugitive dust during construction and grading activities;
compliance with Bay Area Air District CEQA guidance and thresholds as part of conditions of
approval; and CEQA review for subsequent development projects.
The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District are expected to be developed under separate
projects over the longer-term future and would be subject to future project-level CEQA analysis. The
2040 General Plan FEIR identified MM AQ-1 which requires an evaluation of criteria pollutant
emissions during the construction phase for projects that are subject to CEQA and exceed screening
sizes in the Bay Area Air District’s CEQA Guidelines. If the evaluation finds that construction-related
criteria air pollutants exceed the Bay Area Air District’s thresholds, then the project shall mitigate the
impacts to a less than significant level. The 2040 General Plan FEIR identified MM AQ-2, which
requires an evaluation of project-specific operational emissions in accordance with the Bay Area Air
District’s CEQA Guidelines. If the evaluation finds that operational-related air pollutants exceed the
Bay Area Air District’s thresholds, then the project shall mitigate the impacts to a less than significant
level.
Therefore, all individual development projects subject to CEQA would be required to conduct a
project-level evaluation of construction- and operational-related emissions and mitigate emissions to
less than significant levels. Accordingly, construction- and operational-related emissions associated
with the Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District would be less than significant. There are no
environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The
proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or more severe
adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
A technical assessment evaluating potential project construction- and operational-related air quality
impacts was conducted for the proposed project and is provided herein. The evaluation follows Bay
Area Air District methodology for assessing air quality impacts and utilizes the thresholds of
significance and other guidance identified in its 2022 CEQA Air Quality Guidelines. According to the
Bay Area Air District, the thresholds of significance represent the allowable emissions each project
can generate without causing a cumulatively considerable contribution to regional air quality impacts.
Therefore, a project that would not exceed the Bay Area Air District thresholds of significance on a
project level also would not be considered to result in a cumulatively considerable contribution to
these regional air quality impacts. Construction- and operational-related impacts are discussed
separately below.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
48 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Construction
Fugitive Dust Emissions
Construction-related activities, such as soil disturbance, grading, and material hauling result in
fugitive dust emissions (e.g., PM2.5 and PM10). PM10/PM2.5 (fugitive dust) is recognized to impact local
communities. The Bay Area Air District does not have a numerical threshold of significance for fugitive
dust particulate matter emissions. Instead, the Bay Area Air District bases the determination of
significance for fugitive dust on implementing feasible and effective control measures. For a project to
have a less than significant impact related to construction-related fugitive dust emissions, it must
implement all of the Bay Area Air District’s Best Management Practices (BMPs).
Implementation of Policy 12.6-I-3 and Policy 12.6-I-5 would require plans and projects to comply with
Bay Area Air District’s CEQA guidance and thresholds as part of conditions of approval and CEQA
review, which would include basic BMPs for construction-related fugitive dust emissions in
accordance with Bay Area Air District standards. Therefore, in compliance with 2040 General Plan
Policy 12.6-I-3 and Policy 12.6.-I-5, the Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area shall
implement BMPs to control fugitive dust and, therefore, impacts related to short-term construction
fugitive dust emissions would be less than significant.8
Exhaust Emissions
Construction emissions were quantified and estimated using CalEEMod Version 2022.1.1. As
described in the Project Description, the construction analysis evaluated the construction-related
activities associated with the Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area. The following project
characteristics and assumptions were utilized in the analysis:
• Construction emissions were estimated for the demolition, grading and hydroseeding of the
Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area which was assumed to be 67.82 acres.
Construction activities were assumed to begin in June 2026 and conclude in April 2027.
- Demolition activities were conservatively estimated to include demolishing up to 1.927 million
square feet of existing office buildings, which represents a worst-case scenario.
- Grading and site preparation (including hydroseeding) would occur across the entire 67.82-
acre area.
• Construction emissions were estimated for building construction, architectural coatings and
paving throughout the 54-acre Neighborhood District which would include a total of 426
residential dwelling units including single-family homes, ADUs and townhomes.
- Building construction was assumed to begin in April 2027 and conclude in July 2031.
- Construction of the Neighborhood District would include approximately 23.2 acres of paved
roadways.
8 Bay Area Air Quality Management District (Bay Area Air District). 2022. CEQA Guidelines. Website:
https://www.baaqmd.gov/~/media/files/planning-and-research/ceqa/ceqa-guidelines-2022/ceqa-guidelines-chapter-5-
project-air-quality-impacts_final-pdf.pdf?rev=de582fe349e545989239cbbc0d62c37a&sc_lang=en. Accessed August 21,
2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 49
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Although it does not form the basis of the evaluation or conclusion in this document, it is reasonable
to assume that future improvements in technology would be incorporated into regulatory requirements
related to equipment and fuels. Accordingly, should the construction schedule move to later years or
take longer, construction emissions would be expected to decrease because of mandatory
compliance with improvements in technology and more stringent regulatory requirements that would
affect future construction equipment and fuels (therefore, the analysis represents a worst-case,
conservative approach). Additional details on the assumptions and inputs are included in the
CalEEMod output reports (Appendix B).
Table 3 shows the annual construction-related criteria air pollutant exhaust emissions associated with
the Neighborhood District Plus the Grading of the Interim Area (in tons per year). As shown, all
estimated emissions are well below the annual thresholds of significance for construction exhaust.
Table 3: Annual Project Construction Exhaust Emissions–Unmitigated
Construction Year
Criteria Air Pollutant Emissions (tons/year)
ROG NOX
PM10
(Exhaust)
PM2.5
(Exhaust)
2026 0.23 2.90 0.09 0.08
2027 0.26 1.95 0.07 0.06
2028 0.22 1.42 0.04 0.03
2029 0.21 1.35 0.04 0.03
2030 5.76 2.78 0.05 0.05
2031 2.88 0.70 0.02 0.02
Significance Threshold
(tons/year) 10 10 15 10
Exceeds Significance Threshold? No No No No
Notes:
lbs = pounds
NOX = oxides of nitrogen
PM10 = particulate matter less than 10 microns in diameter (includes only exhaust-related emissions)
PM2.5 = particulate matter less than 2.5 microns in diameter (includes only exhaust-related emissions)
ROG = reactive organic gases
Source: Appendix B
Table 4 shows the average daily construction-related criteria air pollutant exhaust emissions
associated with the Neighborhood District Plus the Grading of the Interim Area (in pounds per day).
As shown, all estimated emissions are well below the average daily thresholds of significance for
construction exhaust.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
50 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Table 4: Average Daily Project Construction Exhaust Emissions–Unmitigated
Construction Year
Criteria Air Pollutant Emissions (lbs/day)
ROG NOX
PM10
(Exhaust)
PM2.5
(Exhaust)
2026 2.97 37.62 1.21 1.06
2027 2.02 14.95 0.52 0.48
2028 1.66 10.91 0.32 0.26
2029 1.59 10.37 0.29 0.26
2030 44.12 21.29 0.42 0.39
2031 43.24 10.50 0.26 0.24
Significance Threshold (lbs/day) 54 54 82 54
Exceeds Significance Threshold? No No No No
Notes:
lbs = pounds
NOX = oxides of nitrogen
PM10 = particulate matter less than 10 microns in diameter (includes only exhaust-related emissions)
PM2.5 = particulate matter less than 2.5 microns in diameter (includes only exhaust-related emissions)
ROG = reactive organic gases
The average daily emissions per year were derived by taking total emissions for each year and dividing by the number of
working days in the same year.
Source: Appendix B
Overall, construction-related fugitive dust and exhaust emissions would be below all applicable
thresholds of significance and impacts from construction would be less than significant.
Operation
The residential buildings constructed as a part of the Neighborhood District would be associated with
ongoing operational emissions including from area, energy, and mobile sources. Area sources would
include emissions from architectural coatings, consumer products, and landscape equipment. For
building energy, there are no on-site emissions of criteria pollutants because the residential buildings
to be constructed in the Neighborhood District would be all-electric and would not utilize natural gas
for building heat or hot water. Building operations would only result in indirect emissions related to
electricity production. Mobile sources would include exhaust and road dust emissions from the
vehicles that would travel to and from the project site.
The Bay Area Air District developed screening criteria for criteria air pollutants and precursors. These
screening criteria provide lead agencies with a conservative indication of whether implementing a
proposed project could result in potentially significant criteria air pollutants and precursor impacts. If
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 51
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
all screening criteria for criteria air pollutants and precursors are met by a proposed project, then the
lead agency would not need to perform a detailed assessment of the project’s criteria air pollutant and
precursor emissions. The Neighborhood District would include only residential land uses; however,
the residential uses include multiple types of residential (single-family, townhomes, and ADUs).
Therefore, the Bay Area Air District’s Mixed Land Use Screening Tool for Criteria Pollutants and
Precursors was used for the screening level analysis.9
The proposed project meets the screening criteria detailed in the Bay Area Air District’s 2022 CEQA
Guidelines as discussed below:
• The Mixed Land Use Screening Tool for Criteria Pollutants and Precursors was used and the
Neighborhood District would not exceed operational thresholds (according to the tool). It was
assumed that the Neighborhood District would include the development of 230 single-family
homes, 138 condo-townhomes, and 58 ADUs (modeled as low-rise apartments, consistent with
the traffic analysis). See Appendix B for additional documentation.
• Operational activities would not include stationary sources or industrial sources subject to Bay
Area Air District rules and regulations.
• Operational activities would not overlap with construction-related activities.
Therefore, operational-related impacts from criteria air pollutant emissions would be less than
significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
c) Sensitive Receptors
Would the project: Expose sensitive receptors to substantial pollutant concentrations?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Development facilitated by the 2040 General Plan would result in diesel particulate matter (DPM)
emissions from off-road, heavy-duty equipment from construction-related activities. Future projects
facilitated by the 2040 General Plan would be required to implement relevant and applicable General
Plan policies to reduce emissions, including Policy 12.6-I-3 and Policy 12.6-G-5, which would require
dust reduction measures during grading and construction. In addition, the 2040 General Plan EIR
identified MM AQ-3, which requires future development projects subject to CEQA review to coordinate
with the City to determine whether a construction Health Risk Assessment (HRA) would need to be
9 Bay Area Air Quality Management District (Bay Area Air District). 2025. CEQA Thresholds and Guidelines Update.
Website: https://www.baaqmd.gov/plans-and-climate/california-environmental-quality-act-ceqa/updated-ceqa-guidelines.
Accessed November 13, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
52 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
performed for projects with construction timelines greater than two months and within 1,000 feet of
sensitive receptors, in order to identify and reduce potential risk exposure to nearby sensitive
receptors. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that construction-related impacts would
be less than significant after incorporation of mitigation.
Development facilitated by the 2040 General Plan would also accommodate additional residential and
nonresidential development which could be associated with ongoing TAC and/or DPM emissions.
Future projects facilitated by the 2040 General Plan would be required to implement relevant and
applicable General Plan policies to reduce emissions, including Policy 12.5-I-1, Policy 12.6.I-1 and
Policy 12.6.I-2, which aim to reduce air pollution and public exposure to hazardous air contaminants
by aligning project reviews and approvals with CEQA standards, GHG emission reduction targets,
and Bay Area Air District thresholds. The policies also emphasize proper siting of emission sources
and careful evaluation of hazardous material handling in new developments to protect sensitive land
uses and public health. In addition, the 2040 General Plan EIR identified MM AQ-4, which requires
that potential risk exposure to nearby sensitive receptors from the operation phase of discretionary
development projects be identified and reduced. In addition, MM AQ-4 requires that applicants for
commercial land uses that would generate substantial diesel truck travel (i.e., 100 diesel trucks per
day or 40 or more trucks with diesel-powered transport refrigeration units per day) to determine the
appropriate level of operational HRA required. If required, the operational HRA shall be prepared in
accordance with the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) and Bay Area Air
District requirements and include mitigation to reduce the exposure risk to an acceptable level.
Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that operational-related impacts would be less
than significant after incorporation of mitigation.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The 11.3-acre Mixed-Use District would consist of residential communities with ground floor retail,
entertainment and commercial uses complementary to City Center Bishop Ranch across Bollinger
Canyon Road. The 26-acre Multi-Family District would consist of communities that may be developed
into apartments, condominiums, senior or affordable housing, offering a variety of housing options
and would include Orchards Park, a 2.5-acre park that would serve as a gathering place for residents
and visitors. The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District are expected to be developed under
separate projects over the longer-term future and would be subject to future project-level CEQA
analysis.
Development of the Mixed-Use District and the Multi-Family District would include construction
activities that would result in air pollution emissions from dust, fumes, equipment exhaust and other
air contaminants that could expose nearby sensitive receptors to elevated concentrations of TACs
and/or DPM. Individual development within the Mixed-Use District and the Multi-Family District would
be required to comply with the City’s 2040 General Plan Policy 12.6-I-3 and Policy 12.6-1-5 which
would require measures to reduce fugitive dust during construction and grading activities, and
compliance with Bay Area Air District CEQA guidance and thresholds as part of conditions of approval
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 53
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
and CEQA review for subsequent development projects. Future projects facilitated by the 2040
General Plan would also be required to implement relevant and applicable General Plan policies to
reduce operational emissions, including Policy 12.5-I-1, Policy 12.6.I-1 and Policy 12.6.I-2, which aim
to reduce air pollution and public exposure to hazardous air contaminants by aligning project reviews
and approvals with CEQA standards, GHG emission reduction targets, and Bay Area Air District
thresholds. The policies also emphasize proper siting of emission sources and careful evaluation of
hazardous material handling in new developments to protect sensitive land uses and public health.
The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District are expected to be developed under separate
projects over the longer-term future and would be subject to future project-level CEQA analysis. To
address construction-related impacts, the 2040 General Plan FEIR identified MM AQ-3, which
requires future development projects subject to CEQA review to coordinate with the City to determine
whether a construction HRA would need to be performed for projects with construction timelines
greater than two months and within 1,000 feet of sensitive receptors, in order to identify and reduce
potential risk exposure to nearby sensitive receptors. If the evaluation finds that construction-related
air pollutants exceed the Bay Area Air District’s thresholds, then the project shall mitigate the impacts
to a less than significant level.
To address operational-related impacts, the 2040 General Plan EIR identified MM AQ-4 which
requires that potential risk exposure to nearby sensitive receptors from the operation phase of
discretionary development projects be identified and reduced. In addition, MM AQ-4 requires that
applicants for commercial land uses that would generate substantial diesel truck travel (i.e., 100
diesel trucks per day or 40 or more trucks with diesel-powered transport refrigeration units per day) to
determine the appropriate level of operational HRA required. If required, the operational HRA shall be
prepared in accordance with the OEHHA and Bay Area Air District requirements and include
mitigation to reduce the exposure risk to an acceptable level. If the evaluation finds that operation-
related air pollutants exceed the Bay Area Air District’s thresholds, then the project shall mitigate the
impacts to a less than significant level.
Therefore, all individual development projects subject to CEQA would be required to conduct a
project-level evaluation of construction- and operational-related health risk impacts to nearby
sensitive receptors and mitigate emissions and exposures to less than significant levels. Accordingly,
construction- and operational-related impacts associated with the Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family
District would be less than significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or
more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
54 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Project-LEVEL Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
An assessment evaluating potential construction- and operational-related air quality impacts to
nearby sensitive receptors from implementation of the Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim
Area was conducted and is provided herein. Construction and operation are discussed separately
below.
Construction
An HRA evaluating potential project construction-related health risks to nearby sensitive receptors
was conducted for the Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area. Details on the
assumptions and inputs are included in Appendix B. The HRA follows Bay Area Air District
methodology for assessing potential impacts and utilizes the thresholds of significance identified in
their 2022 CEQA Air Quality Guidelines. The project site is located within 1,000 feet of sensitive
receptors, including residences to the west and south, and employment establishments with worker
receptors to the north and east. Because of the presence of residential and worker receptors,
construction emissions have the potential to result in significant health risks from construction-related
TAC and/or PM2.5 emissions.
Table 5 presents a summary of the Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area’s
construction cancer risk, chronic non-cancer hazard, and predicted annual PM2.5 concentration
impacts at the Maximally Exposed Individual Resident (MEIR) and the Maximally Exposed Worker
(MEIW). The MEIR is the residential receptor that would experience the highest health effects from
the Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area’s construction and the MEIW is the worker
receptor that would experience the highest health effects from the Neighborhood District plus Grading
of the Interim Area’s construction. As shown in Table 4, the potential health risks would not exceed the
Bay Area Air District’s thresholds of significance, and impacts would be less than significant.
Table 5: Summary of the Health Impacts at the Maximally Exposed Individual
Receptors During Project Construction
Project Construction Impacts Maximally Exposed Individual Receptor Risks
Receptors
Cancer Risk
(per million) Chronic HI
PM2.5
Concentration
(µg/m3)
Project Construction Impacts at MEIR 6.43 <0.01 0.1039
Project Construction Impacts at MEIW 0.77 <0.01 0.09607
Bay Area Air District Single Source Threshold of
Significance
10 1 0.3
Threshold Exceeded? No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 55
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Project Construction Impacts Maximally Exposed Individual Receptor Risks
Receptors
Cancer Risk
(per million) Chronic HI
PM2.5
Concentration
(µg/m3)
Notes:
µg/m3 = micrograms per cubic meter
HI = hazard index
MEIR = Maximally Exposed Individual Resident
MEIW = Maximally Exposed Individual Worker
PM2.5 = particulate matter less than 2.5 microns in diameter
Project risks and hazards are for diesel exhaust, which does not have an established Acute Reference Exposure Level.
The MEIR was found to be a residence located approximately 50 feet to the south of the project site.
The MEIW was found to be an industrial establishment located approximately 150 feet to the west of the project site.
Source: Appendix B
Health Risk Assessment–Cumulative (Project Construction Plus Existing Sources)
The Bay Area Air District also recommends assessing the cumulative impacts at the most impacted
nearby receptors from a project’s construction-related health risks and PM2.5 concentrations in
combination with existing sources of TACs and PM2.5 concentrations within 1,000 feet of the proposed
project.
To conduct a cumulative HRA, the Bay Area Air District provides several tools for use in identifying the
existing sources of air pollution and associated health risks near a project site. These tools include
the Stationary Source Screening Map10 which provides the location of all the stationary sources
permitted by the Bay Area Air District; the Roadway Screening Data Layers which provide estimated
cancer risk, hazards estimates and PM2.5 concentrations at varying distances from all Bay Area
highways and surface streets; and Rail and Railyard Screening Data Layers which provide estimated
cancer risks, hazards estimates, and PM2.5 concentrations at varying distances from diesel
locomotives and select railyards. Outputs from the Bay Area Air District screening tools are
documented in Appendix B.
Table 6 presents the cumulative health risks at the MEIR (which is the most impacted nearby
receptor, also known as the maximally exposed individual [MEI]). As shown, health risks and PM2.5
concentrations would be below the Bay Area Air District’s cumulative thresholds of significance and
impacts would be less than significant.
10 Bay Area Air Quality Management District (Bay Area Air District). 2024. Stationary Source Screening Map. Website:
https://baaqmd.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=845658c19eae4594b9f4b805fb9d89a3. Accessed
July 10, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
56 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Table 6: Summary of the Cumulative Health Impacts During Project Construction at
the Maximally Exposed Individual
Source
Cancer Risk
(per million)
Chronic Hazard
Index
Maximum
Annual PM2.5
Concentration
(µg/m3)
On-site MEI
Project Construction 6.43 < 0.01 0.10
Stationary Sources 50 0.09 0.04
Roadways 12.63 0.03 0.23
Rail Lines and Rail Yards 0 0 0
Cumulative Health Risks at On-site MEI 69.06 < 0.12 0.4
Bay Area Air District Cumulative Thresholds of
Significance
100 10 0.8
Threshold Exceedance? No No No
Notes:
Bay Area Air District = Bay Area Air Quality Management District
PM2.5 = particulate matter less than 2.5 microns in diameter
µg/m3 = micrograms per cubic meter
Bay Area Air District = Bay Area Air Quality Management District
MEI = Maximally Exposed Individual
TAC = toxic air contaminant
Project and stationary source risks and hazards are for diesel exhaust, which does not have an established Acute Reference
Exposure Level.
Stationary source values were calculated at the centroid of the facility; however, the distances from each stationary source
and the MEI varies up to distances greater than 1,000 feet. Because emissions and associated health risks have been
demonstrated to diminish with distance, the values shown in the table are conservative and actual health risks would be
expected to be much lower.
Facility ID 7237 is located at the project site at 6001 Bollinger Road and is assumed to be decommissioned during project
demolition. Therefore, the stationary source values do not include Facility ID 7237.
Source: Appendix B
Operation
As the development proposed within the Neighborhood District does not constitute a commercial
development that is expected to result in 100 or more daily diesel truck trips or involve 40 or more
trucks equipped with diesel-powered transport refrigeration units, 2040 General Plan FEIR MM AQ-4
would not apply.
The proposed residential development is not expected to generate substantive DPM or TAC
emissions during operational activity because ongoing emissions would primarily involve passenger
vehicle use with no heavy-duty truck activity, resulting in minimal localized air pollutant contributions.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 57
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
The residences within the Neighborhood District would not have stationary sources or on-site sources
of TACs during operation. Traffic generated by the residences of the Neighborhood District would
consist mostly of light-duty gasoline-powered vehicles, which are not a significant source of TAC and
air pollutant emissions. Thus, the Neighborhood District would not result in significant health impacts
to nearby sensitive receptors during operation, and operational-related impacts would be less than
significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
d) Odors
Would the project: Result in other emissions (such as those leading to odors or)
adversely affecting a substantial number of people?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
All diesel fuel and oil odors would be limited to the construction period and would be temporary.
During operations, all new development, including those typically producing objectionable odors (i.e.,
agricultural uses, wastewater treatment plants, food manufacturing plants), would be required to
demonstrate consistency with San Ramon Zoning Ordinance D3 8(L). Therefore, the 2040 General
Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The 11.3-acre Mixed-Use District would consist of residential communities with ground floor retail,
entertainment and commercial uses complementary to City Center Bishop Ranch across Bollinger
Canyon Road. The 26-acre Multi-Family District would consist of communities that may be developed
into apartments, condominiums, senior or affordable housing, offering a variety of housing options
and would include Orchards Park, a 2.5-acre park that would serve as a gathering place for residents
and visitors. The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District are expected to be developed under
separate projects over the longer-term future and would be subject to future project-level CEQA
analysis.
Odor impacts could occur if the Mixed-Use District or the Multi-Family District introduce a new odor
source near existing receptors. The Bay Area Air District provides a list of recommended odor
screening distances for specific odor-generating facilities. According to the Bay Area Air District,
neither residential nor commercial uses are odor-generating facilities.
Potential sources that may emit odors during construction activities include exhaust from diesel
construction equipment. However, because of the temporary nature of these emissions, the
intermittent nature of construction activities, and the highly diffusive properties of diesel PM exhaust,
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
58 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
nearby receptors would not be affected by diesel exhaust odors associated with project construction.
Odors from these sources would be localized and generally confined to the immediate area
surrounding the project site. The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District would utilize typical
construction techniques, and the odors would be typical of most construction sites and temporary in
nature. Thus, the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would not introduce a new odor source near
existing receptors during construction.
The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District would involve the development of residential and
commercial uses; operations could lead to odors from associated vehicle exhaust and waste
disposal. However, such odors generated by operation would be small in quantity and duration and
would not pose an objectionable odor impact to future and existing receptors. Thus, Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family Districts would not introduce a new odor source near existing receptors during
construction or operation and impacts would be less than significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or
more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-Level Analysis (Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area)
Similar to the impacts evaluated and disclosed in the 2040 General Plan FEIR, construction and
operation of the proposed project would not create objectionable odors.
Potential sources that may emit odors during construction activities include exhaust from diesel
construction equipment. However, because of the temporary nature of these emissions, the
intermittent nature of construction activities, and the highly diffusive properties of DPM exhaust,
nearby receptors would not be significantly affected by diesel exhaust odors associated with project
construction. Odors from these sources would be localized and generally confined to the immediate
area surrounding the project site. The Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area would
utilize typical construction techniques, and the odors would be typical of most construction sites and
temporary in nature. Thus, the Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area would not
introduce a new odor source near existing receptors during construction.
During operation, the Neighborhood District could include activities that might lead to odors from
associated vehicle exhaust and waste disposal. However, such odors generated by project operation
would be small in quantity and duration and would not pose an objectionable odor impact to future
and existing receptors. Furthermore, the Neighborhood District consists of residential uses which are
not considered odor-generating uses according to the 2040 General Plan FEIR, as noted above.
Therefore, impacts associated with construction-generated and operational-generated odors would
be considered less than significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 59
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Applicable 2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
MM AQ-1 Reduce Construction Criteria Pollutant Emissions
To reduce temporary increases in criteria air pollutant emissions during the
construction phase for discretionary development projects that are subject to CEQA
and exceed the screening sizes in the Bay Area Air Quality Management District11
(BAAQMD) CEQA Guidelines, the City shall require such projects to evaluate project-
specific construction emissions in conformance with the BAAQMD methodology. If
construction-related criteria air pollutants exceed the BAAQMD thresholds of
significance, the project applicant shall mitigate the impacts to a less than-significant
level.
MM AQ-2 Reduce Operational Criteria Pollutant Emissions
To reduce long-term increases in air pollutants during the operation phase for
discretionary development projects that are subject to CEQA and exceed the
screening sizes in the Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD) CEQA
Guidelines, the City shall require such projects to evaluate project- specific operation
emissions in conformance with BAAQMD CEQA Guidelines. If operation- related air
pollutants exceed the BAAQMD-adopted thresholds of significance, the project
applicant shall mitigate the impact to a less than significant level.
MM AQ-3 Conduct and Implement Construction Health Risk Assessment
To identify and reduce potential risk exposure to nearby sensitive receivers during
construction of individual projects (excluding ADUs, single-family residences, and
duplexes) where construction activities would (a) occur within 1,000 feet of sensitive
receptors, (b) last longer than two months, and (c) not utilize equipment rated US
EPA Tier 4 for equipment of 50 horsepower or more, construction equipment fitted
with Level 3 Diesel Particulate Filters for all equipment of 50 horsepower or more,
and/or alternative fuel construction equipment, the project applicant shall coordinate
with the City to determine whether a construction Health Risk Assessment (HRA)
shall be performed. If an HRA is to be performed, the HRA shall determine potential
risk and compare the risk to the following BAAQMD thresholds:
• Non-compliance with Qualified Community Risk Reduction Plan
• Increased cancer risk of > 10.0 in a million
• Increased non-cancer risk of > 1.0 Hazard Index (Chronic or Acute)
• Ambient PM2.5 increase of > 0.3 µg/m3 annual average
11 Now referred to as Bay Area Air District.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
60 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
If risk exceeds the thresholds, measures such as requiring the use of Tier 4 engines,
Level 3 Diesel Particulate Filters, and/or alternative fuel construction equipment shall
be incorporated to reduce the exposure risk to acceptable levels.
Conclusion
With regard to Air Quality, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 61
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.4 Biological Resources
Would the project:
a) Have a substantial adverse
effect, either directly or
through habitat
modifications, on any
species identified as a
candidate, sensitive, or
special-status species in
local or regional plans,
policies, or regulations, or
by the California
Department of Fish and
Wildlife or United States
Fish and Wildlife Service?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Have a substantial adverse
effect on any riparian
habitat or other sensitive
natural community identified
in local or regional plans,
policies, and regulations or
by the California
Department of Fish and
Wildlife or United States
Fish and Wildlife Service?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
c) Have a substantial adverse
effect on State or federally
protected wetlands
(including, but not limited to,
marsh, vernal pool, coastal,
etc.) through direct removal,
filling, hydrological
interruption, or other
means?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
62 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
d) Interfere substantially with
the movement of any native
resident or migratory fish or
wildlife species or with
established native resident
or migratory wildlife
corridors, or impede the use
of wildlife nursery sites?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
e) Conflict with any local
policies or ordinances
protecting biological
resources, such as a tree
preservation policy or
ordinance?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
f) Conflict with the provisions
of an adopted Habitat
Conservation Plan, Natural
Community Conservation
Plan, or other approved
local, regional, or State
Habitat Conservation Plan?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
a) Special-status Species
Would the project: Have a substantial adverse effect, either directly or through habitat
modifications, on any species identified as a candidate, sensitive, or
special-status species in local or regional plans, policies, or
regulations, or by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife or
United States Fish and Wildlife Service?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The General Plan Area is mostly built out, which limits suitable habitat for special-status species. The
Plan Area contains some sensitive ecological communities such as oak woodlands which are
preserved within rural conservations, parks, and open space areas. Riparian corridors such as creeks
and drainages support special-status species such as the California red-legged frog, California tiger
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 63
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
salamander, Alameda whipsnake, and special-status raptors such as the Cooper’s hawk and northern
harrier within the Plan Area.
Development proposed under the 2040 General Plan would consist primarily of infill within already
urbanized zones, thereby minimizing direct impacts on areas of ecological significance. While the
Plan increases allowable densities, existing development limits the need for significant new utility
installations. However, temporary construction activities within riparian habitats have the potential to
impact aquatic resources and sensitive natural habitats. Isolated trees and vegetation in urbanized
areas may serve as nesting habitat for migratory birds or roosting areas for special-status bats. Bats
such as pallid bat, western red bat, Townsend’s big-eared bat, and western mastiff bat may use urban
features like trees and abandoned buildings for roosting.
To address risks to special-status species, the 2040 General Plan includes comprehensive
environmental protections. General Plan Policies such as 4.6-I-6, 4.6-I-7, and 8.1-G-1 through 8.3-I-7
establish requirements for biological surveys, agency coordination, and mitigation strategies prior to
construction. The 2040 General Plan EIR anticipated potential impacts associated with development
implementing the General Plan and identified mitigation measures that would be applicable to future
development. In certifying the 2040 General Plan EIR, the City found that with implementation of
these policies and mitigation measures, impacts on special-status species would be less than
significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site and surrounding area are fully developed and surrounded by development.
The proposed project is located on a typical infill site that is consistent with the development
anticipated in the General Plan. A Tree Inventory Report prepared by HortScience in October 2022
found 3,084 trees within the project site, including 46 species such as Deodar cedar (Cedrus
deodara), hackberry (Celtis occidentalis), evergreen ash (Fraxinus uhdei), fruitless white mulberry
(Morus alba ‘Fruitless’), London plane (Platanus x hispanica), and coast redwood (Sequoia
sempervirens) (Appendix C). Trees are dispersed throughout the site.
FirstCarbon Solutions (FCS) conducted a field survey on July 22, 2025, as well as an associated
literature review for the proposed project. Species observed within the project site consist of American
crow (Corvus brachyrhynchos), scrub jay (Aphelocoma californica), mourning dove (Zenaida
macroura), and house finch (Haemorhous mexicanus). Plants were all ornamental types found in
business parks that have been abandoned. Landscaping has not been maintained.
The California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB), California Natural Plant Society (CNPS)
Inventory of Rare Plants (CNPS Inventory), and Information for Planning and Consultation (IPaC)
identified 73 special-status plant species and 29 special-status animals within the Diablo, California
United States Geologic Survey (USGS) Topographic Quadrangle Map and the eight surrounding
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
64 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
quadrangles. As discussed above, the project site is composed of development and ornamental
vegetation. Because of the high level of anthropogenic disturbances and impacted vegetation within
the project site, the site does not contain suitable habitat to support special-status plant species, as
discussed in greater detail in the Special-status Species Evaluation Tables (Appendix C). Habitat
types necessary to support special-status plant species include meadows, seeps, chenopod scrub,
foothill grassland, vernal pools, and alkaline soils, none of which the project site contains. Habitat
needed to support most special-status wildlife species include sandy washes, alluvial fans, pin-oak
woodlands, desert scrub, rivers, marshes, annual grasslands, chaparral, and redwood habitats, none
of which the project site contains.
There is potential for special-status bat species, such as Townsend’s big-eared bat (Corynorhinus
townsendii ) and western mastiff bat (Eumops perotis californicus) to be present on-site. The project
site contains large quantities of ornamental trees suitable for roosting habitat. Additionally, abandoned
buildings on-site could provide suitable roosting habitat for bats. Although no special-status plant or
wildlife species were identified during the field surveys, there is a low potential for the Townsend’s big-
eared bat and western mastiff bat to be present within the site.
Furthermore, the numerous ornamental trees within the project site could provide suitable habitat for
a variety of non-special-status nesting bird species. As such, construction activities that occur during
the avian nesting season (generally February 1 to August 31) or bat roosting season (April 15 to
August 15) could disturb nesting sites for bird species protected under the Fish and Game Code or
Migratory Bird Treaty Act (MBTA) or roosting bats protected under California Fish and Game Code
Section 4150. The removal of trees and abandoned buildings during the nesting and roosting
seasons could result in direct harm to nesting birds and roosting bats, while noise, light, and other
man-made disturbances may cause nesting birds or roosting bats to abandon their nests/roosts,
resulting in a potentially significant impact.
The proposed project is consistent with the type and scope of development anticipated in the 2040
General Plan EIR, As such, the applicant is required to implement General Plan EIR MM BIO-1 and
MM BIO-2, which require pre-construction bird surveys and the implementation of avoidance and
minimization measures if individuals are found. The proposed project would be required to adhere to
federal and State regulations that protect nesting and migratory birds. In compliance with MM BIO-1
and as described in this analysis, the applicant shall hire a qualified Biologist to conduct pre-
construction surveys and implement avoidance measures, if necessary, lowering impacts to nesting
birds to less than significant. Per MM BIO-2, the proposed project would be required to perform pre-
construction roosting bat surveys prior to construction and implement avoidance measures if roosting
bats are found present within the site, lowering impacts to bats to less than significant. No additional
or project-specific mitigation is required.
Therefore, with implementation of MM BIO-1 and MM BIO-2, development of the site would be
consistent with the anticipated impacts in the General Plan and would not result in significant
environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project would not result
in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan
EIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 65
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
b) Riparian Habitat and Sensitive Natural Communities
Would the project: Have a substantial adverse effect on any riparian habitat or other
sensitive natural community identified in local or regional plans,
policies, and regulations or by the California Department of Fish and
Wildlife or United States Fish and Wildlife Service?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan notes the presence of freshwater forested and shrub wetlands primarily along
Tassajara Creek and Bollinger Canyon, as well as numerous riverine features such as Alamo Creek,
South San Ramon Creek, and various drainage canals throughout the Plan Area. It was determined
that General Plan buildout would primarily consist of infills in already urbanized areas that are unlikely
to contain wetlands or riparian zones. However, it was determined that some projects may intersect
sensitive habitats and waterways. Such developments may require permits from regulatory agencies
like the United States Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), California Department of Fish and Wildlife
(CDFW), and the Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB), in accordance with federal and
State laws including Sections 404 and 401 of the Clean Water Act (CWA), the Porter-Cologne Water
Quality Control Act, and the California Fish and Game Code Section 1600 et seq.
For projects near wetlands, streams, or riparian areas, the 2040 General Plan EIR requires an
aquatic resources delineation to establish jurisdictional boundaries in compliance with State and
federal policies. Permit issuance for grading and construction activities requires confirmation that
such work will not cause erosion, sedimentation, or other harmful off-site effects. On sites larger than
one acre, developers must implement a Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) and BMPs
as required by the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) to mitigate potential
impacts during storm events. Additionally, the San Ramon Municipal Code mandates erosion and
stormwater control measures and the submittal of plans prior to the issuance of grading permits.
Development within or adjacent to sensitive habitats could pose direct impacts through vegetation
removal, hydrological changes, and pollutant runoff, or indirect effects like soil compaction and dust
generation. To mitigate these impacts, the 2040 General Plan includes several guiding and
implementing policies in its Open Space, Conservation, and Safety Elements. These measures aim to
minimize disruption to creeks and riparian zones and require permitting and environmental review by
appropriate agencies. Therefore, it was determined that, through adherence to the General Plan’s
policies and applicable environmental regulations, potential impacts to wetlands and riparian habitats
would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site does not contain any riparian habitat or other sensitive natural community. The site is
completely developed, and the nearest aquatic resource is located 0.8 mile east and is separated
from the site by commercial development and roadways. The site does contain a concrete-lined,
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
66 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
man-made pond. However, the pond is not expected to be regulated as State- or federally- protected
waters or wetlands under CWA Sections 404/401, Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, or Fish
and Game Code Sections 1602 et seq., because the pond has been excavated within developed
habitat for the purpose of on-site beautification and contains actively managed landscaping, and is
therefore hydrologically disconnected from natural flows. Therefore, development of the proposed
project would not result in any environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The
proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
c) Federally Protected Wetlands
Would the project: Have a substantial adverse effect on State or federally protected
wetlands (including, but not limited to, marsh, vernal pool, coastal,
etc.) through direct removal, filling, hydrological interruption, or
other means?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
For projects near wetlands, streams, or riparian areas, the 2040 General Plan EIR requires an
aquatic resources delineation to establish jurisdictional boundaries. Permit issuance for grading and
construction activities requires confirmation that such work will not cause erosion, sedimentation, or
other harmful off-site effects. On sites larger than one acre, developers must implement a SWPPP
and BMPs as required by the NPDES to mitigate potential impacts during storm events. Additionally,
the San Ramon Municipal Code mandates erosion and stormwater control measures and the
submittal of plans prior to the issuance of grading permits.
The 2040 General Plan notes the presence of freshwater forested and shrub wetlands primarily along
Tassajara Creek and Bollinger Canyon. The General Plan EIR determined that plan development
would primarily consist of infills in already urbanized areas that are unlikely to contain wetlands.
However, some projects may intersect waterways and wetlands. Such developments may require
permits from regulatory agencies like the USACE, CDFW, and the RWQCB, in accordance with
federal and State laws including Sections 404 and 401 of the CWA, the Porter-Cologne Water Quality
Control Act, and the California Fish and Game Code Section 1600 et seq.
It was determined that development within or adjacent to aquatic habitats could pose direct impacts
through vegetation removal, hydrological changes, and pollutant runoff, or indirect effects like soil
compaction and dust generation. To mitigate these impacts, the 2040 General Plan includes several
guiding and implementing policies in its Open Space, Conservation, and Safety Elements. These
measures aim to minimize disruption to creeks and riparian zones and require permitting and
environmental review by appropriate agencies. Therefore, it was determined that, through adherence
to the General Plan’s policies and applicable environmental regulations, potential impacts to wetlands
and riparian habitats would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 67
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
As stated above, the project site contains a concrete-lined, man-made pond. This feature is not
expected to be considered a State- or federally protected wetland pursuant to CWA Sections 404/401
and/or Fish and Game Code Section 1602. There are no other water features on-site. Therefore,
development of the proposed project would not result in any environmental effects that are peculiar to
the proposed project. Therefore, the proposed project would not result in a new or more severe
adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
d) Fish or Wildlife Movement
Would the project: Interfere substantially with the movement of any native resident or
migratory fish or wildlife species or with established native resident
or migratory wildlife corridors, or impede the use of wildlife nursery
sites?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Wildlife movement corridors in the General Plan Area are primarily located in riparian zones, creeks,
and open spaces found within local and regional parks. These corridors support migratory species
such as fish, birds, and sensitive amphibians and reptiles, including the Alameda whipsnake
(Masticophis lateralis euryxanthus), California tiger salamander (Ambystoma californiense), and
California red-legged frog (Rana draytonii).
The 2040 General Plan does not propose changes to existing land use designations for Rural
Conservation, Parks, or Open Space, which include key creek and riparian zones. Therefore, the
2040 General Plan would not facilitate permanent development within established wildlife movement
corridors. Development will be concentrated in urbanized areas and focused on infill sites already
containing structures or pavement, away from sensitive habitat zones.
Policies in the 2040 General Plan, such as Policy 8.3-1-2 and others listed under Impact 4.4(b),
promote the preservation and restoration of riparian corridors and require development setbacks from
creek protection zones and wetlands. These policies aim to protect and maintain the ecological
integrity of wildlife corridors. Additionally, guiding and implementing policies from the Open Space and
Conservation Element support a cohesive network of open space, further enhancing opportunities for
uninterrupted wildlife movement.
Therefore, it was determined that the 2040 General Plan will avoid development in natural corridors
and emphasize habitat protection through strategic policies and land use designations. Therefore,
construction-related impacts on wildlife movement corridors will be less than significant with
adherence to General Plan policies and land use designations.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
68 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site is entirely developed and is surrounded by urban development in all directions. Based
on the July 22, 2025 field survey, the project site does not contain any natural features that could
serve as a suitable corridor for wildlife or fish movement. As discussed in Impact 4.4(a) above, the
implementation of MM BIO-1 and MM BIO-2 would reduce any potential impacts to nesting birds and
roosting bats from the proposed project to less than significant levels. Therefore, development of the
site as proposed would not result in significant environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed
project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
e) Conflict with Local Policies or Ordinances
Would the project: Conflict with any local policies or ordinances protecting biological
resources, such as a tree preservation policy or ordinance?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan EIR determined that development under the 2040 General Plan could occur
on properties with mature trees, including street trees. Any removal or modification of these trees is
regulated by Chapter 2 of Division D5 in the San Ramon Municipal Code, which defines "protected
trees" and outlines their protection standards. These regulations require permits, arborist reports, and
proper procedures for tree removal and replacement. Additional measures, such as tree protection
during construction grading, are also mandated under San Ramon Municipal Code Section D5-12.
The 2040 General Plan includes Policies COS-2.3 through COS-2.6, which require the preservation
of native oak woodlands and encourages native plantings around reservoirs and streams, that further
protect local vegetation. With adherence to 2040 General Plan policies and San Ramon Municipal
Code ordinances such as Chapter 2 of Division D5, impacts to biological resources from development
are expected to be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The Tree Inventory Report prepared by HortScience in October 2022 identified 3,084 trees within the
project site. Of the 3,084 trees on-site, 2,608 trees were identified as protected trees under San
Ramon Municipal Code Section D5. The proposed project would be required to adhere to the City’s
Tree Preservation Ordinance, which requires removal permits for any protected tree on-site proposed
for removal. Therefore, with adherence to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance and by obtaining
tree removal permits for protected trees slated for removal on-site, the development of the site as
proposed would not result in significant environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 69
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR. Impacts would be less than significant.
f) Habitat Conservation Plan/Natural Community Conservation Plan
Would the project: Conflict with the provisions of an adopted Habitat Conservation Plan,
Natural Community Conservation Plan, or other approved local,
regional, or State Habitat Conservation Plan?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
No Habitat Conservation Plans (HCPs) or Natural Community Conservation Plans (NCCPs) have
been adopted within the General Plan Area. Consequently, none apply to the 2040 General Plan. As
a result, it was determined that development and policy implementation under the 2040 General Plan
would not conflict with any adopted local, regional, or State HCP, and therefore would result in no
related impacts.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site is not located within a HCP or NCCP area; therefore, development of the site would
not result in any significant environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The
proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
MM BIO-1 Conduct Pre-Construction Bird Surveys and Implement Avoidance and
Minimization Measure
For construction activities initiated during the bird nesting season (February 1–
September 15) involving removal of vegetation that could potentially serve as habitat
for special-status bird species or other nesting bird habitat, including abandoned
structures and other man-made features, a pre-construction nesting bird survey shall
be conducted no more than 14 days prior to initiation of ground disturbance and
vegetation removal activities. The nesting bird pre-construction survey shall be
conducted on foot and shall include a buffer around the construction site at a
distance determined by a qualified Biologist. The survey shall be conducted by a
Biologist familiar with the identification of avian species known to occur in California
Bay Area communities (i.e., qualified Biologist). If nests are found, an avoidance
buffer shall be determined by a qualified Biologist dependent upon the species, the
proposed work activity, and existing disturbances associated with land uses outside
of the site. The buffer shall be demarcated by the Biologist with bright orange
construction fencing, flagging, construction lathe, or other means to demarcate the
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
70 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
boundary. All construction personnel shall be notified as to the existence of the buffer
zone and to avoid entering the buffer zone during the nesting season. No ground-
disturbing activities shall occur within the buffer until the Biologist has confirmed that
breeding/nesting is completed, and the young have fledged the nest. Encroachment
into the buffer shall occur only at the discretion of the qualified Biologist on the basis
that the encroachment will not be detrimental to an active nest. A report summarizing
the pre-construction survey(s) shall be prepared by a qualified Biologist and shall be
submitted to the City prior to the commencement of construction activities.
Future project site plans shall include a statement acknowledging compliance with
the federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act (MBTA) and California Fish and Game Code that
includes avoidance of active bird nests and identification of Best Management
Practices (BMPs) to avoid impacts to active nests, including checking for nests prior
to construction activities during February 1 to September 15 and what to do if an
active nest is found so that the nest is not inadvertently impacted during grading or
construction activities.
MM BIO-2 Conduct Pre-construction Roosting Bats Surveys and Implement Avoidance
Measures Prior to Removal
Prior to the removal or alteration of trees and structures that may serve as roosting
habitat for special-status bat species, a qualified Biologist shall conduct a focused
survey of all trees and structures to be removed or impacted by construction activities
to determine whether active roosts of special-status bats are present on-site. The
survey shall be conducted during seasonal periods of bat activity (March 1 through
October 15). The Biologist shall have access to all structures and interior attics, as
needed. If a colony of bats is found roosting in any structure, tree or other habitat,
further surveys, such as night emergent surveys, shall be conducted sufficient to
determine the species present and the type of roost (day, night, maternity, etc.).
Tree or structure removal shall be planned for either the spring or the fall and timed
to ensure both suitable conditions for the detection of bats and adequate time for tree
and/or structure removal to occur during seasonal periods of bat activity exclusive of
the breeding season, as described below. Trees and/or structures containing suitable
potential bat roost habitat features shall be clearly marked or identified. If no bat
roosts are found, the results of the survey will be documented and submitted to the
City within 30 days of the survey, after which no further action will be required. If day
roosts are present, the Biologist shall prepare a site-specific roosting bat protection
plan to be implemented by the contractor following the City’s approval. The plan shall
incorporate the following guidance as appropriate:
• When possible, removal of trees/structures identified as suitable roosting habitat
shall be conducted during seasonal periods of bat activity, including the following:
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 71
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
- Between September 1 and about October 15, or before evening temperatures
fall below 45 degrees Fahrenheit and/or more than 0.5 inch of rainfall within 24
hours occurs.
- Between March 1 and April 15, or after evening temperatures rise above 45
degrees Fahrenheit and/or no more than 0.5 inch of rainfall within 24 hours
occurs.
• If a tree /structure must be removed during the maternity season and is identified
as potentially containing a colonial maternity roost, then a qualified Biologist shall
conduct acoustic emergence surveys or implement other appropriate methods to
further evaluate if the roost is an active maternity roost. Under the Biologist’s
guidance, the contractor shall implement measures that consist of (or exceed) the
following:
- If it is determined that the roost is not an active maternity roost, then the roost
may be removed in accordance with the other requirements of this measure.
- If it is found that an active maternity roost of a colonial roosting species is
present, the roost shall not be disturbed during the maternity season (April 15 to
August 31) or until the maternity roost has dispersed.
○ Tree removal procedures shall be implemented using a two-step tree removal
process. This method is conducted over two consecutive days and works by
creating noise and vibration by cutting non-habitat branches and limbs from
habitat trees using chainsaws only (no excavators or other heavy machinery)
on day one. The noise and vibration disturbance, together with the visible
alteration of the tree, is very effective in causing bats that emerge nightly to
feed to not return to the roost that night. The remainder of the tree is removed
on day two.
○ Prior to the demolition of vacant structures within the project site, a qualified
Biologist shall conduct a focused habitat assessment of all structures to be
demolished. The habitat assessment shall be conducted enough in advance to
ensure the commencement of building demolition can be scheduled during
seasonal periods of bat activity (see above), if required. If no signs of day
roosting activity are observed, no further actions will be required. If bats or
signs of day roosting by bats are observed, a qualified Biologist will prepare
specific recommendations such as partial dismantling to cause bats to
abandon the roost, or humane eviction, both to be conducted during seasonal
periods of bat activity, if required. Should maternity roosts be observed the
roost shall not be disturbed during the maternity season (April 15 to August 31)
or until maternity roost has dispersed. If project schedules do not allow for
maternity season avoidance, a bat habitat mitigation and monitoring plan shall
be developed to reduce risks to bat pups and consultation with CDFW would
be required.
• If the qualified Biologist determines a roost is used by a large number of bats
(large hibernaculum), bat boxes shall be installed near the project site. The
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
72 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
number of bat boxes installed will depend on the size of the hibernaculum and
shall be determined through consultation with California Department of Fish and
Wildlife (CDFW). If a maternity colony has become established, all construction
activities shall be postponed within a 500-foot buffer around the maternity colony
until it is determined by a qualified Biologist that the young have dispersed. Once it
has been determined that the roost is clear of bats, the roost shall be removed
immediately.
Conclusion
With regard to Biological Resources, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan EIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan EIR.
4. MM BIO-1 and MM BIO-2 from the 2040 General Plan EIR would be required and would
reduce potential impacts to below a level of significance consistent with the analysis in the
2040 General Plan EIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 73
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More
Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.5 Cultural and Tribal Cultural Resources
Would the project:
a) Cause a substantial
adverse change in the
significance of a historical
resource as pursuant to
Section 15064.5?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
b) Cause a substantial
adverse change in the
significance of an
archaeological resource
pursuant to Section
15064.5?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
c) Disturb any human
remains, including those
interred outside of formal
cemeteries?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
Would the project cause a substantial adverse change in the significance of a Tribal Cultural
Resource, defined in Public Resources Code Section 21074 as either a site, feature, place, cultural
landscape that is geographically defined in terms of the size and scope of the landscape, sacred
place, or object with cultural value to a California Native American tribe, and that is:
d) Listed or eligible for listing
in the California Register of
Historical Resources, or in
a local register of historical
resources as defined in
Public Resources Code
Section 5020.1(k), or
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
74 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More
Severe
Adverse
Impact?
e) A resource determined by
the lead agency, in its
discretion and supported by
substantial evidence, to be
significant pursuant to
criteria set forth in
subdivision (c) of Public
Resources Code Section
5024.1. In applying the
criteria set forth in
subdivision (c) of Public
Resource Code Section
5024.1, the lead agency
shall consider the
significance of the resource
to a California Native
American tribe.
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
The analysis in this section is based, in part, on the Phase I CRA prepared by FCS in September
2025 for the Orchards Project. The confidential Phase I CRA complies with MM CR-1, MM CR-2 and
MM CR-3 of the 2040 General Plan EIR and can be requested by qualified personnel upon request
(Appendix D).
Northwest Information Center
On Junel 24, 2025, a records search was conducted at the Northwest Information Center (NWIC) at
Sonoma State University, located in Rohnert Park, California, for the proposed project and a 0.5-mile
radius beyond the project boundaries. The current inventories of the National Register of Historic
Places (NRHP), the California Register of Historical Resources (CRHR), the California Historical
Landmarks (CHL) list, the California Points of Historical Interest (CPHI) list, and the California Built
Environment Resource Directory (BERD) for Contra Costa County were also reviewed to determine
the existence of previously documented local historic resources. The results of the records search
indicate that no cultural resources have been recorded within the project boundaries, nor within the
0.5-mile search radius. In addition, 10 area-specific survey reports are on file with the NWIC for the
project site and its 0.5-mile search radius, two of which (S-000229 and S-000830) address the project
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 75
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
site, indicating that the project has been previously surveyed for cultural resources. Report S-000830
addresses the site in its entirety.
Native American Heritage Commission
On June 20, 2025, FCS sent a request to the Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC) in an
effort to determine whether any sacred sites are listed on its Sacred Lands File (SLF) for the project
site. A response was received on June 20, 2025, indicating that the SLF search was negative for
Native American cultural resources in the immediate project site. The NAHC included a list of 45
Tribal representatives available for consultation. To ensure that all Native American knowledge and
concerns over potential Tribal Cultural Resources (TCRs) that may be affected by the proposed
project are addressed, a letter containing project information and requesting any additional
information was sent to each Tribal representative on July 24, 2025. One response was received from
Lucy Beyhan of the Confederated Villages of Lisjan Nation on September 7, 2025; their
recommendation is that caution be taken with exempting this project due to its proximity to a historic
creek (the nearest recorded creek is South San Ramon Creek; however, it is completely hardscaped).
They also requested a copy of the site-specific report and access to the full project report when
available. No additional responses have been received to date.12
Pedestrian Survey
On July 17, 2025, FCS Cultural Resources Specialist Anthony Martin conducted a pedestrian survey
to identify any unrecorded cultural resources within the project boundary. The entirety of the site is
developed and served as the corporate campus for Chevron Energy. At the center of the property are
14 office buildings (labeled Building A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, J, K, L, T, V, and W), several courtyards
and a large decorative fountain/pool. The property is surrounded by landscape features and is
bordered by parking lots on the northern, southern, western and eastern perimeters, with an auto
access road to the north along Bollinger Canyon Road and to the east, along Bishop Ranch 1 Loop
Road. A hiking trail is located on the southern border of the site, which connects to the Iron Horse
Regional Trail. Overview shots of the project area were taken from the northeast, northwest,
southeast and southwest corners, which showcase the office buildings, the courtyard, and the
surrounding landscape and hardscape features. Visibility of the exposed soil was nonexistent since
the entirety of the project site is landscaped and/or hardscaped; thus, inspection of the soil for cultural
resources was not possible. The landscaped areas within the courtyard are overgrown and at varying
degrees of plant mortality due to abandonment.
Survey conditions were documented using digital photographs. During the survey, Mr. Martin
examined all areas of the exposed ground surface for prehistoric artifacts (e.g., fire-affected rock,
milling tools, flaked stone tools, toolmaking debris, ceramics), soil discoloration and depressions that
might indicate the presence of a cultural midden, faunal and human osteological remains, and
12 Please note that FCS Tribal outreach was for additional information regarding the project site that can be added to the
analysis in the Phase I CRA and does not constitute government-to-government consultation pursuant to SB 18 and AB
52.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
76 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
features indicative of the former presence of structures or buildings (e.g., postholes, standing exterior
walls, foundations) or historic debris (e.g., glass, metal, ceramics).
One historic era ship propeller belonging to the tanker SS Hillyer Brown (active 1953-1985) was
found south of Building B. According to the plaque, the SS Hillyer Brown was a Chevron-operated T-2
tanker, and the propeller was retained following the vessel’s decommissioning as a tribute to the
company's long service history. The installation of the propeller and marker are commemorative in
nature but does not constitute a significant historic resource as defined by CEQA Guidelines Section
15064.5. The propeller may be of historical interest to Chevron or maritime organizations, but its
treatment and dispossession do not warrant additional analysis.
a) Historical Resources
Would the project: Cause a substantial adverse change in the significance of a
historical resource as pursuant to Section 15064.5?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan EIR determined that two known historical resources were identified within the
2040 General Plan Area. In addition to these known historical resources, there may be other yet
unidentified resources within the General Plan Area that are age-eligible for listing in the NRHP,
CRHR, or locally. The 2040 General Plan would facilitate development of residential, commercial,
office, institutional, and industrial land uses that could in turn result in the conversion of existing
properties and structures to new uses. With relatively limited opportunities for new development in the
City, the 2040 General Plan emphasizes infill and reuse development within the city limits and
encourages higher-density and mixed-use projects where appropriate. It also includes potential
incorporation of adjacent unincorporated areas within the UGB. Construction is associated with such
potential. As such, it was determined that effects on historical resources can only be determined once
a specific project has been proposed.
Demolition or other structural alteration associated with development facilitated by the 2040 General
Plan has the potential to impair historical built environment resources. Consequently, it was
determined that damage to or destruction of historical resources could occur as a result of
development under the proposed 2040 General Plan. In order to assess impacts to historical
resources which occur through development under the General Plan, each project would need to be
assessed as it is proposed. MM CR-1 requires the preparation of a historical resources evaluation
prior to approval for projects involving buildings 45 years or older. It was determined that
implementation of 2040 General Plan Guiding Policy 8.7-G-1; 1.2, 1.4 and 1.5 and Guiding Policy 6.5-
G-1; 1.11 and 1.12 and MM CR-1 would reduce potential impacts related to historical resources.
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The results of the NWIC records search did not identify any historical resources within the project
boundaries or within the 0.5-mile search radius. Additionally, the pedestrian survey failed to identify
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 77
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
any historical resources as defined by CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.5. There are no buildings
over 45 years in age at the project site. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar
to the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse
impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
b) Archaeological Resources
Would the project: Cause a substantial adverse change in the significance of an
archaeological resource pursuant to Section 15064.5?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan EIR determined that the effects on archaeological resources are only known
once a specific development has been proposed because the effects are highly dependent on both
the individual development site conditions and the characteristics of the proposed ground-disturbing
activity. Consequently, damage to or destruction of cultural resources could occur as a result of
development under the proposed 2040 General Plan. In order to ensure that development within San
Ramon does not have a detrimental effect on archaeological resources, each future project would
need to be assessed once the project location and design concept is available. As such, an
archaeological resources assessment is required by MM CR-2 for projects involving ground
disturbance. Potential future development occurring under the 2040 General Plan may include site
preparation, demolition and construction activities, which could uncover cultural resources that were
previously unknown. MM CR-3 requires that future projects stop work in the event of unanticipated
cultural resources discoveries during construction. It was determined that implementation of 2040
General Plan Guiding Policy 8.7-G-1; 1.3 and 1.4 and Guiding Policy 6.5-G-1; 1.12 and MM CR-2 and
MM CR-3 would reduce potential impacts related to historical resources.
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
A Phase I CRA was prepared for the proposed project in compliance with MM CR-2. Results from the
NWIC indicate that no archaeological resources have been recorded within the project boundaries or
the 0.5-mile search radius. Additionally, the pedestrian survey failed to identify any archaeological
resources. While there are no known archaeological resources within the project site, it is possible
that project-related earthmoving and construction activities could unearth previously undiscovered
archaeological resources. Archaeological resources can include but are not limited to stone, bone,
wood, or shell artifacts or features, including hearths and structural elements. Damage or destruction
of these resources would be a potentially significant impact. Nevertheless, the Phase I CRA analysis
for archaeological resources determined that the proposed project adheres to the 2040 General Plan
Guiding Policy 8.7-G-1; 1.3 and 1.4 and Guiding Policy 6.5-G-1; 1.12 and MM CR-2. As the possibility
remains for unanticipated cultural resources to be discovered during project construction, General
Plan MM CR-3 applies to the proposed project, preventing impacts to archaeological resources.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed
project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in
the 2040 General Plan EIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
78 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
c) Human Remains
Would the project: Disturb any human remains, including those interred outside of
formal cemeteries?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan EIR determined human burials outside of formal cemeteries can occur in
prehistoric archaeological contexts. Excavations during construction activities could have the potential
to disturb these resources that could include Native American burial sites. As such, ground-disturbing
activities that may occur within San Ramon (the General Plan Area) during implementation of the
2040 General Plan have the potential to unearth previously unidentified human remains. In addition,
all development projects are also subject to California Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5 and
Public Resources Code Section 5097.98. Thus, implementation of 2040 General Plan Guiding Policy
8.7-G-1 and Guiding Policy 6.5-G-1; 1.6 and MM CR-2 and MM CR-3 would reduce potential impacts
related to human remains to a less than significant level.
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Results from the NWIC failed to identify any human remains and/or cemeteries within the project site
or a 0.5-mile radius. While it is highly unlikely that the presence of human remains exists within or
near the project site, there is always the possibility that subsurface construction activities associated
with the proposed project, such as grading or trenching, could potentially damage or destroy
previously undiscovered human remains. In the event of the accidental discovery or recognition of
any human remains, CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.5, Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5, and
Public Resources Code Sections 5097.94 and 5097.98 must be followed. While there are no known
human remains within the project site, implementation of 2040 General Plan Guiding Policy 8.7-G-1
and Guiding Policy 6.5-G-1; 1.6 and General Plan MM CR-2 and MM CR-3 would reduce potential
impacts related to human remains. MM CR-2 has been satisfied with the preparation of the Phase I
CRA. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The
proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
d) Listed or Eligible Tribal Cultural Resources
Would the project: Cause a substantial adverse change in the significance of a Tribal
Cultural Resource, defined in Public Resources Code Section 21074
as either a site, feature, place, cultural landscape that is
geographically defined in terms of the size and scope of the
landscape, sacred place, or object with cultural value to a California
Native American Tribe, and that is listed or eligible for listing in the
California Register of Historical Resources, or in a local register of
historical resources as defined in Public Resources Code Section
5020.1(k)?
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 79
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
e) Lead Agency Determined Tribal Cultural Resources
Would the project: Cause a substantial adverse change in the significance of a Tribal
Cultural Resource, defined in Public Resources Code Section 21074
as either a site, feature, place, cultural landscape that is
geographically defined in terms of the size and scope of the
landscape, sacred place, or object with cultural value to a California
Native American Tribe, and that is a resource determined by the lead
agency, in its discretion and supported by substantial evidence, to
be significant pursuant to criteria set forth in subdivision (c) of
Public Resources Code Section 5024.1?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan determined that ground-disturbing activities associated with future
development projects could expose previously unidentified subsurface TCRs during project
construction, creating a potentially significant impact. However, it was determined that implementation
of 2040 General Plan Guiding Policy 8.7-G-1 and Policy 8.7-1.8 would reduce potential impacts
related to TCRs. Furthermore, MM CR-4, which requires suspension of work around TCRs identified
during construction, was identified for projects under the 2040 General Plan. It was determined that
with implementation of relevant policies and MM CR-4, impacts would be less than significant.
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The records search conducted at the NWIC, which included a search of the CRHR, failed to identify
pre-contact resources within the project boundaries or the 0.5-mile search radius of the project site.
Furthermore, the NAHC SLF search results were positive for TCRs within the project boundaries. As
described above, as part of the PI-CRA, FCS received a response from the Confederated Villages of
Lisjan Nation on September 7, 2025, recommending that caution be taken with exempting this project
due to its proximity to a historic creek (the nearest recorded creek is South San Ramon Creek;
however, it is completely hardscaped). AB 52 consultation is required for all projects for which a
Notice of Preparation, Notice of a Mitigated Negative Declaration, or Notice of Negative Declaration is
filed or issued. As none of these notices apply to the CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency
Checklist, AB 52 is not required for the proposed project. Should any undiscovered TCRs be
encountered during project construction, implementation of 2040 General Plan Guiding Policy 8.7-G-1
and MM CR-4 would be required. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to
the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact
that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
80 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2040 General Plan EIR Mitigation Measures
MM CR-2 Prepare an Archaeological Resources Assessment Prior To Project Approval
and Implement Mitigation Prior To and During Construction13
An archaeological resources assessment for projects involving ground disturbance
shall be prepared as follows:
• Assessments shall include a California Historical Resources Information System
records search at the Northwest Information Center (NWIC) and a Sacred Lands
File search maintained by the Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC). The
records searches will characterize the results of previous cultural resource surveys
and disclose any cultural resources that have been recorded and/or evaluated in
and around a project site. A Phase I pedestrian survey shall be undertaken at a
project site that is on previously undeveloped land in order to locate any surface
cultural materials. By performing a records search, consultation with the NAHC,
and a Phase I survey, a qualified Archaeologist shall be able to classify a project
site as having high, medium, or low sensitivity for archaeological resources.
• If the Phase I archaeological survey identifies resources that may be affected by a
project, the archaeological resources assessment shall also include Phase II
testing and evaluation. If resources are determined significant or unique through
Phase II testing and site avoidance is not possible, appropriate site-specific
mitigation measures shall be identified in the Phase II evaluation. These measures
shall include, but would not be limited to, a Phase III data recovery program,
avoidance, or other appropriate actions to be determined by a qualified
Archaeologist in consultation with the City and any interested Tribes, as stated in
the 2040 General Plan Tribal Consultation Implementation Program outlined by
Guiding Policy ENV-5 and Guiding Policy 8.7 G-1. If significant archaeological
resources cannot be avoided, impacts may be reduced to less than-significant
levels by adding fill soils on top of the sites rather than cutting into cultural
deposits. Alternatively, and/or in addition, a data collection program may be
warranted, including mapping the location of artifacts, surface collection of
artifacts, or excavation of the cultural deposit to characterize the nature of the
buried portions of sites. Curation of the excavated artifacts or samples shall occur
as specified by the Archaeologist in consultation with the City and any interested
Tribes. As stated in the 2040 General Plan Tribal Consultation Implementation
Program outlined by Guiding Policy ENV-5 and Guiding Policy 8.7-G-1, the final
disposition of artifacts not directly associated with Native American graves shall be
negotiated during consultation with interested Tribes. If Native American Tribes do
not accept the artifact, it shall be offered to an institution staffed by qualified
professionals, as determined by the City Planner. Artifacts include material
13 MM CR-2 has been satisfied by the completion of the Phase I CRA.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 81
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
recovered from all phases of work, including the initial survey, testing, indexing,
data recovery, and monitoring.
MM CR-3 Stop Work in the Event of Unanticipated Cultural Resources Discoveries
During Construction
If cultural resources are encountered during ground-disturbing activities for a project,
work in the immediate area shall be halted and an Archaeologist meeting the
Secretary of the Interior’s Professional Qualification Standards for archaeology in
either prehistoric or historic archaeology shall be contacted immediately to evaluate
the find. If necessary, the evaluation may require preparation of a treatment plan and
archaeological testing for CRHR eligibility. If the discovery proves to be significant
under CEQA and cannot be avoided by a project, additional work such as excavating
the cultural deposit to fully characterize its extent, and collecting and curating artifacts
may be warranted to mitigate any significant impacts to cultural resources. In the
event that archaeological resources of Native American origin are identified during
project construction, a qualified Archaeologist will consult with the City to begin
Native American consultation procedures.
MM CR-4 Suspend Work Around Tribal Cultural Resources Identified During
Construction
In the event that cultural resources of Native American origin are identified during
construction of a project implemented under the 2040 General Plan, all earth-
disturbing work in the vicinity of the find shall be temporarily suspended or redirected
until an Archaeologist has evaluated the nature and significance of the find as a
cultural resource and an appropriate local Native American representative is
consulted. If the City, in consultation with local Native Americans, determines that the
resource is a Tribal Cultural Resource and, thus, significant under CEQA, a mitigation
plan shall be prepared and implemented in accordance with State guidelines and in
consultation with local Native American group(s). The mitigation plan shall include
avoidance of the resource or, if avoidance of the resource is infeasible, the plan shall
outline the appropriate treatment of the resource in coordination with the appropriate
local Native American Tribal representative and, if applicable, a qualified
Archaeologist. Examples of appropriate mitigation for Tribal Cultural Resources
include, but are not limited to, protecting the cultural character and integrity of the
resource, protecting traditional use of the resource, protecting the confidentiality of
the resource, or heritage recovery.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
82 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2040 General Plan EIR Policies
Guiding Policy 6.5-G-1: Create and maintain a high-quality publicly accessible park and trail
system for San Ramon.
Policy 6.5-I-11 Seek partnership opportunities with the private sector and with other public agencies
to enhance park facilities and provide recreational activities. In 2013, the Parks
Community Services Department established a Partnership Program to provide the
private sector with various levels of sponsorship opportunities for City events,
facilities, and programs. Where possible, seek out partnerships with the private
sector and/or local historic preservation groups, such as the San Ramon Historic
Foundation, to fund and facilitate the preserve local historic resources that are of
value to the community.
Policy 6.5-I-12 Identify, document and seek to preserve and protect sites of historic interest.
Guiding Policy 8.7-G-1: Identify, evaluate, and preserve the archaeological, paleontological
and historic resources that are found within the San Ramon Planning Area.
Policy 8.7-1.2 Prepare Historical Resources Evaluations for projects involving structures 45 years or
folder and implement mitigation prior to and during construction.
Policy 8.7-1.3 Conduct Archaeological Resources Assessment prior to project approval and
implement identified mitigation prior to and during construction and include a policy to
stop work in the event of unanticipated cultural resources discoveries during
construction.
Policy 8.7-1.4 Protect and maintain the integrity of officially listed historic resources.
Policy 8.7-1.5 Review any proposals to nominate resources for eligibility for listing on national or
State historic registers. Discretion should be used in reviewing such nominations to
ensure that resources have significant historic value and have been appropriately
evaluated.
Policy 8.7-1.6 As a standard condition of approval, require all development projects involving
grading and excavation to implement appropriate measures in the event that burial
sites or human remains are encountered during earthwork activities.
Policy 8.7-1.7 Perform required consultation with the appropriate Tribal organization(s) as part of
projects subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). For projects
involving a General Plan Amendment, the development of a Specific Plan (or
amendment), or designating open space, provide Tribal consultation opportunities in
accordance with State law.
Policy 8.7-1.8 Require Tribal monitor(s) during all activities in areas with cultural resources of
interest to local Native American Tribes when requested. Cultural resources may
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 83
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
include a sanctified cemetery, place of worship, religious or ceremonial site, or sacred
shrine. Both monitors shall observe grading, ground-disturbing, and other
earthmoving activities.
Conclusion
With regard to Cultural resources and Tribal Cultural Resources, the Consistency Checklist
demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan EIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified, which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan EIR.
4. MM CR-3 and MM CR-4 from the 2040 General Plan EIR would be required and would reduce
potential impacts to below a level of significance consistent with the analysis in the 2040
General Plan EIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
84 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More
Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.6 Energy
Would the project:
a) Result in potentially
significant environmental
impact due to wasteful,
inefficient, or unnecessary
consumption of energy
resources, during project
construction or operation?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Conflict with or obstruct a
State or local plan for
renewable energy or energy
efficiency?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
Buildout of the 2040 General Plan would consume energy primarily in the form of fuel consumption.
All new development would be required to comply with applicable ARB regulations regarding the
accelerated retrofitting, repowering, or replacement of heavy-duty diesel on- and off-road equipment,
and restricted idling of heavy-duty diesel motor vehicles; the provisions of California Code of
Regulations Title 13, sections 2449 and 2485, prohibiting diesel-fueled commercial and off-road
vehicles from idling for more than five minutes; and EPA Construction Equipment Fuel Efficiency
Standards per 40 Code of Federal Regulations Parts 1039, 1065, and 1068. Therefore, the General
Plan FEIR concluded that impacts from construction would be less than significant.
During operation, all new development would be required to comply with applicable 2040 General
Plan policies targeting GHG reductions (which have the co-benefit of reducing energy demand and
fuel use), particularly those related to vehicle trip reductions. These include Policy 4.6-I-G-1 (High-
Density Compatible Uses in the Mixed-Use Land Use Designation); Policy 5.6-I-7 (Mix of Uses and
Complete Streets Concepts to Reduce VMT); Policy 5.7-I-3 (Bicycle and Pedestrian Connectivity to
the Iron Horse Trail); Policy 5.7-I-5 (Bicycle Parking, Storage, and Support Facilities); Policy 12.4-I-3
(CEQA Policy for Disclosing Air Quality and Climate Change Impacts); Policy 12.4-I-4 (Mitigation
Measures Consistent with City CAP); Policy 12.4-I-5 (Implementation of Bay Area Air District BMPs
and GHG Reductions); Policy 12.5-I-2 (Infill and Mixed-Use Development for Walkable and Bicycle-
Friendly Communities with Access to Transit); Policy 12.5-I-4 (Jobs-to-Housing Ratio); Policy 12.8-I-8
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 85
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
(Use of Recycled Materials and Composting); and Policy 7.5-I-9 (Compliance with Municipal Code’s
Construction and Demolition Debris Diversion Requirements). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan
FEIR concluded that impacts during operation would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The 11.3-acre Mixed-Use District would consist of residential communities with ground floor retail,
entertainment and commercial uses complementary to City Center Bishop Ranch across Bollinger
Canyon Road. The 26acre Multi-Family District would consist of communities that may be developed
into apartments, condominiums, senior or affordable housing, offering a variety of housing options
and would include Orchards Park, a 2.5-acre park that would serve as a gathering place for residents
and visitors. The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District are expected to be developed under
separate projects over the longer-term future and would be subject to future project-level CEQA
analysis.
Construction
Construction of the Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District would require the use of heavy-duty
construction equipment and vehicles and would be associated with worker commute trips and
materials delivery. These activities would consume diesel fuel, gasoline, and electricity (for limited on-
site uses such as lighting or small tools).
Energy use during construction would be temporary in nature, and equipment used would be typical
of construction projects in the region. Construction contractors would be required to demonstrate
compliance with applicable ARB regulations that restrict the idling of heavy-duty diesel motor vehicles
and govern the accelerated retrofitting, repowering, or replacement of heavy-duty diesel on- and off-
road equipment. Development within the Multi-Use District and Multi-Family District would also be
required to comply with California’s Green Building Standards (CALGreen) construction waste
management practices to recycle 65 percent of all construction and demolition debris.
It is anticipated that fuel efficiency of the construction vehicle fleet would increase over time due to
advancement in technologies and regulations. As such, the amount of fuel consumed during
construction would decrease over time. In addition, construction of the Mixed-Use District and Multi-
Family District would not be unusual as compared to the local and regional demand for energy
resources. There are no unusual project characteristics indicating that construction equipment would
be less energy-efficient than at comparable construction sites in the region or State. Therefore,
construction-related impacts would be less than significant.
Operation
Long-term operation of the Mixed-Use District and the Multi-Family District would include electricity
use for lighting, appliances, heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC), common areas,
cooking, space heating, water heating, and electric vehicle (EV) charging stations. It is anticipated
that the proposed project would be served by MCE for electricity use. Currently, MCE offers clean
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
86 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
energy that is sourced from options ranging from 69 percent to 100 percent renewable energy (in
2024). This exceeds the State’s current mandate for renewable energy 2030 requirements set forth in
SB 100 (SB 100 requires energy providers to procure 60 percent of electricity needs from eligible
renewable sources by 2030). EV parking would be required to be provided in compliance with State
requirements, helping to support the transition to electric transportation and reducing GHG emissions
tied to fuel combustion.
All buildings would be required to be designed and constructed to comply with the State’s Building
Energy Efficiency Standards, which reduce energy consumption through enhanced insulation,
efficient HVAC systems, lighting, and appliances. Therefore, operational-related impacts would be
less than significant.
Accordingly, the Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District would not result in the wasteful,
inefficient, or unnecessary consumption of energy resources during project construction or operation,
and impacts would be less than significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or
more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-Level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area would result in energy use during
construction and operation, which are discussed separately below.
Construction
Construction of the Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area would involve demolition,
site preparation, grading, and the construction of roads and building of structures, which would
require the use of heavy-duty construction equipment and vehicles and would be associated with
worker commute trips and materials delivery. These activities would consume diesel fuel, gasoline,
and electricity (for limited on-site uses such as lighting or small tools) as is typical for similar
development.
Energy use during construction would be temporary in nature, and equipment used would be typical
of construction projects in the region. Construction contractors would be required to demonstrate
compliance with applicable ARB regulations that restrict the idling of heavy-duty diesel motor vehicles
and govern the accelerated retrofitting, repowering, or replacement of heavy-duty diesel on- and off-
road equipment. The Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area would also be required to
comply with CALGreen construction waste management practices to recycle 65 percent of all
construction and demolition debris.
The Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area is anticipated to begin construction in
June 2026 and conclude in July 2031. It is anticipated that fuel efficiency of the construction vehicle
fleet will increase over time due to advancement in technologies and regulations. As such, the
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 87
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
amount of fuel consumed during construction would decrease over time if the construction were to
occur at a later date than anticipated. In addition, construction of the Neighborhood District plus
Grading of the Interim Area would not be unusual as compared to the local and regional demand for
energy resources. There are no unusual project or project site characteristics indicating construction
equipment would be less energy-efficient than at comparable construction sites in the region or State.
Therefore, construction-related impacts associated with the Neighborhood District plus Grading of the
Interim Area would be less than significant.
Operation
Long-term operation of the Neighborhood District would include electricity use for lighting, appliances,
HVAC, common areas, cooking, space heating, water heating, and EV charging stations. The
Neighborhood District would be constructed as all-electric. It is anticipated that the proposed project
would be served by MCE for electricity use. MCE offers clean energy that is sourced from options
ranging from 69 percent to 100 percent renewable energy (in 2024). This exceeds the State’s current
mandate for renewable energy 2030 requirements set forth in SB 100 (SB 100 requires energy
providers to procure 60 percent of electricity needs from eligible renewable sources by 2030). EV
parking would be provided in compliance with State requirements, helping to support the transition to
electric transportation and reducing GHG emissions tied to fuel combustion.
All buildings would be designed and constructed to comply with the 2022 Building Energy Efficiency
Standards, which reduce energy consumption through enhanced insulation, efficient HVAC systems,
lighting, and appliances. The site plan would include pedestrian and bicycle connectivity, thereby
indirectly reducing transportation energy efficiencies. The proposed project would include water
efficient landscaping to reduce energy use associated with landscaping. Therefore, operational-
related impacts associated with the Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area would be
less than significant.
Accordingly, the Neighborhood District would not result in the wasteful, inefficient, or unnecessary
consumption of energy resources, during project construction or operation, and impacts would be less
than significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
88 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
b) Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Standards Consistency
Would the project: Conflict with or obstruct a State or local plan for renewable energy or
energy efficiency?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan was evaluated for compliance with the relevant provisions of CALGreen (Title
24, Part 11) and the California Building Energy Efficiency Standards. As noted within the 2040
General Plan FEIR, policy conformance with applicable energy or energy efficiency plans would be
limited to operational impacts. All new development would be required to comply with CALGreen (Title
24 Part 11) requirements for mandatory minimum environmental performance standards for all
ground-up new nonresidential and residential structures and major renovations, per the requirements
of San Ramon Municipal Code Title 14 and Strategy E-1 from the San Ramon Climate Action Plan
(CAP), which calls for an increase in the use of energy conservation features in new and existing
development projects, such as obtaining energy from renewable energy sources and installing low-
emission equipment.
In addition, new development would be required to comply with California Building Energy Efficiency
Standards (Title 24 Part 6) through incorporation of sustainability and energy efficiency measures
such as high-efficiency lighting and HVAC systems, low-flow water fixtures, dual-paned windows, and
water efficient landscaping and irrigation systems. Thus, the 2040 General Plan would ensure
consistency with the goals and policies established by SB 100 and CALGreen, which include
monitoring by the City for compliance with Title 24 standards. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR
concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The 11.3-acre Mixed-Use District would consist of residential communities with ground floor retail,
entertainment and commercial uses complementary to City Center Bishop Ranch across Bollinger
Canyon Road. The 26-acre Multi-Family District would consist of communities that may be developed
into apartments, condominiums, senior or affordable housing, offering a variety of housing options
and would include Orchards Park, a 2.5-acre park that would serve as a gathering place for residents
and visitors. The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District are expected to be developed under
separate projects over the longer-term future and would be subject to future project-level CEQA
analysis.
SB 100 supports the reduction of GHG emissions from the electricity sector by accelerating the
State’s RPS and requires electricity providers to increase procurement from eligible renewable
energy resources to 33 percent of total retail sales by 2020, 60 percent by 2030, and 100 percent by
2045. The City is part of the MCE CCA, which provides electricity primarily from clean, renewable
sources. The City would continue to reduce its use of nonrenewable energy resources. The electricity
generated by renewable resources provided by MCE continues to increase to comply with SB 100
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 89
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
requirements for electricity providers to increase procurement from eligible renewable energy
resources to 33 percent of total retail sales by 2020, 60 percent by 2030, and 100 percent by 2045.
As stated above, it is anticipated that the Mixed-Use District and the Multi-Family District would be
served by MCE for electricity use. MCE offers clean energy that is sourced from options ranging from
69 percent to 100 percent renewable energy (in 2024). This exceeds the State’s current mandate for
renewable energy 2030 requirements set forth in SB 100 (SB 100 requires energy providers to
procure 60 percent of electricity needs from eligible renewable sources by 2030). Therefore, the
Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District would be consistent with SB 100.
CALGreen (Title 24 Part 11) institutes mandatory minimum environmental performance standards for
all ground-up new nonresidential and residential structures and major renovations. In addition, the
California Building Energy Efficiency Standards (Title 24 Part 6) establish energy efficiency standards
for residential and nonresidential buildings in order to reduce California’s energy demand. The City
has adopted State energy conservation plans, including CALGreen (Title 24 Part 11), pursuant to San
Ramon Municipal Code Title 14. Additionally, Strategy E-1 from the City’s CAP calls for an increase in
the use of energy conservation features in new and existing development projects, such as obtaining
energy from renewable energy sources and installing low-emission equipment. Therefore, operations
associated with development within the Mixed-Use District and the Multi-Family District would be
designed to comply with the CALGreen energy source standards, and would be required to
demonstrate compliance with the CALGreen Standards by implementing sustainability and energy
efficiency measures such as high-efficiency lighting and HVAC systems, low-flow water fixtures, dual-
paned windows, and water efficient landscaping and irrigation systems. During plan check, the City
building department will ensure that new projects within the Mixed-Use District and the Multi-Family
District include all required Title 24 energy efficiency standards. Therefore, the Mixed-Use District and
the Multi-Family District would be consistent with CALGreen and the State’s Building Energy
Efficiency Standards.
Overall, the Mixed-Use District and the Multi-Family District represent typical development in the area
and would not conflict with or obstruct implementation of a State or local plan for renewable energy,
and impacts would be less than significant. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are
peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-
Family District designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-Level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The Neighborhood District is evaluated for compliance with SB 100, the relevant provisions of
CALGreen (Title 24, Part 11) and the California Building Energy Efficiency Standards in determining
whether it would conflict with or obstruct a State or local plan for renewable energy or energy
efficiency.
SB 100 supports the reduction of GHG emissions from the electricity sector by accelerating the
State’s RPS and requires electricity providers to increase procurement from eligible renewable
energy resources to 33 percent of total retail sales by 2020, 60 percent by 2030, and 100 percent by
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
90 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2045. The City is part of the MCE CCA, which provides electricity primarily from clean, renewable
sources. The City would continue to reduce its use of nonrenewable energy resources. The electricity
generated by renewable resources provided by MCE continues to increase to comply with SB 100
requirements for electricity providers to increase procurement from eligible renewable energy
resources to 33 percent of total retail sales by 2020, 60 percent by 2030, and 100 percent by 2045.
As stated above, it is anticipated that the Neighborhood District would be served by MCE for
electricity use. MCE offers clean energy that is sourced from options ranging from 69 percent to 100
percent renewable energy (in 2024). This exceeds the State’s current mandate for renewable energy
2030 requirements set forth in SB 100 (SB 100 requires energy providers to procure 60 percent of
electricity needs from eligible renewable sources by 2030). Therefore, the Neighborhood District
would be consistent with SB 100.
CALGreen (Title 24 Part 11) institutes mandatory minimum environmental performance standards for
all ground-up new nonresidential and residential structures and major renovations. In addition, the
California Building Energy Efficiency Standards (Title 24 Part 6) establish energy efficiency standards
for residential and nonresidential buildings in order to reduce California’s energy demand. The City
has adopted State energy conservation plans, including CALGreen (Title 24 Part 11), pursuant to San
Ramon Municipal Code Title 14. Additionally, Strategy E-1 from the San Ramon CAP calls for an
increase in the use of energy conservation features in new and existing development projects, such
as obtaining energy from renewable energy sources and installing low-emission equipment.
Therefore, operations associated with development within the Neighborhood District would be
designed to comply with the energy source standards of the CALGreen and would be required to
demonstrate compliance with the CALGreen Standards by implementing sustainability and energy
efficiency measures such as high-efficiency lighting and HVAC systems, low-flow water fixtures, dual-
paned windows, and water efficient landscaping and irrigation systems. During plan check, the City
building division will ensure that new projects within the Neighborhood District include all required
Title 24 energy efficiency standards. Therefore, the Neighborhood District would be consistent with
CALGreen and the State’s Building Energy Efficiency Standards.
Overall, the Neighborhood District plus Grading of the Interim Area would not conflict with or obstruct
implementation of a State or local plan for renewable energy, and impacts would be less than
significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
None.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 91
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Conclusion
With regard to Energy, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
92 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.7 Geology and Soils
Would the project:
a) Directly or indirectly cause potential substantial adverse effects, including the risk of loss, injury,
or death involving:
i) Rupture of a known
earthquake fault, as
delineated on the most
recent Alquist-Priolo
Earthquake Fault
Zoning Map issued by
the State Geologist for
the area or based on
other substantial
evidence of a known
fault? Refer to Division
of Mines and Geology
Special Publication 42?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
ii) Strong seismic ground
shaking?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
iii) Seismic-related ground
failure, including
liquefaction?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
iv) Landslides? Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Result in substantial soil
erosion or the loss of
topsoil?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 93
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
c) Be located on a geologic
unit or soil that is unstable,
or that would become
unstable as a result of the
project, and potentially
result in on- or off-site
landslide, lateral spreading,
subsidence, liquefaction or
collapse?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
d) Be located on expansive
soil, as defined in Table 18-
1-B of the Uniform Building
Code (1994), creating
substantial direct or indirect
risks to life or property?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
e) Have soils incapable of
adequately supporting the
use of septic tanks or
alternative wastewater
disposal systems where
sewers are not available for
the disposal of
wastewater?
No impact No No No No
f) Directly or indirectly
destroy a unique
paleontological resource or
site or unique geologic
feature?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No MM GEO-1
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
94 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
a) Earthquake Hazards
Would the project: Directly or indirectly cause potential substantial adverse effects,
including the risk of loss, injury or death involving: (i)Rupture of a
known earthquake fault, as delineated on the most recent Alquist-
Priolo Earthquake Fault Zoning Map issued by the State Geologist
for the area or based on other substantial evidence of a known fault;
(ii) Strong Seismic Ground Shaking; (iii) Seismic-related ground
failure, including liquefaction; or (iv) Landslides.
i) Fault Rupture
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The General Plan Area lies within the San Francisco Bay Area, which contains numerous earthquake
faults with the potential for surface rupture, including the Calaveras Fault extending north–south, west
of Interstate 680 (I-680) and the Pleasanton Fault extending north–south, east of the I-680. To
mitigate impacts associated with surface rupture, implementation of mandatory California Building
Standards Code (CBC) requirements and 2040 General Plan policies would minimize risks
associated with personal injury and property damage as a result of fault rupture. Relevant policies
include Policy 9.20I-1 (Site Risk Assessment); Policy 9.1-I-3 (Comprehensive Geologic Studies); and
Policy 9.2-I-5 (Geotechnical Field Review During Construction). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan
FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
As noted in the program-level Feasibility Level Geotechnical Evaluation, there are no known active
faults at the Orchards project site (Appendix E).14 The closest earthquake fault zone, the northern
segment of the Calaveras Fault, is located approximately 0.3 mile southwest of the project site. The
Geotechnical Evaluation concluded that there was no evidence of faulting on the project site, and that
fault surface rupture is not a significant geologic hazard at the project site.
Pursuant to Policy 9.1-I-3 (Comprehensive Geologic Studies), the proposed project would be required
to follow the recommendations provided in the Geotechnical Evaluation to reduce risks related to fault
rupture. Through compliance with Policy 9.2-I-1, the proposed project would identify and mitigate any
potential geologic or seismic hazards, including those related to fault rupture. These hazards would
be assessed during the construction phase during required geotechnical field review pursuant to
Policy 9.2-I-5.
14 Sunset Development Company. 2022. Feasibility Level Geotechnical Evaluation. Bishop Ranch: Proposed Future
Residential Development. August 16.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 95
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Therefore, development of the proposed project as part of the Orchards project site would not result
in any environmental effects that are peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The proposed
project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in
the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
ii) Ground Shaking
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The General Plan Area has been impacted by ground shaking during major earthquakes, given its
location within the seismically-active San Francisco Bay region, and has been classified as having
“violent” ground shaking potential on either side of the I-680 and “severe” in the rest of the General
Plan Area. To minimize impacts associated with life or property damage as a result of violent ground
shaking, new development would be required to comply with mandatory CBC requirements in
addition to guiding policies of the 2040 General Plan designed to address these impacts during
building operations. These include Policy 9.2-I-12 (Continued Geologic Investigation) and Policy 9.1-I-
13 (Updates to City Excavation, Grading, and Filling Requirements). Therefore, the 2040 General
Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
As noted within the Geotechnical Evaluation, the project site is located in the San Francisco Bay
Area, a seismically active region subject to very strong ground shaking in response to a major
earthquake on any one of several nearby faults. Considering the proximity of the site to active faults
capable of producing a maximum moment magnitude of 6.0 or more, the Geotechnical Evaluation
concluded that there is a high potential for strong ground shaking at the project site; however, this is
typical of all sites in the area.
As previously mentioned, the proposed project would be designed in accordance with CBC
requirements as well as recommendations outlined in the Geotechnical Evaluation prepared for the
proposed project, pursuant to General Plan Policy 9.1-I-3 (Comprehensive Geologic Studies).
Therefore, development of the proposed project would not result in any environmental effects that are
peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more
severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the General Plan EIR.
iii) Ground Failure
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
As previously mentioned, the General Plan Area contains the Calaveras Fault which extends through
the western portion of the City in a north to south direction and the Pleasanton Fault extending in a
north to south direction in the eastern portion of the City. To prevent impacts associated with ground
failure and liquefaction, the proposed project would implement mandatory CBC requirements and
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
96 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2040 General Plan policies, including Policy 9.2-I-1 (Site Risk Assessment); Policy 9.1-I-3
(Comprehensive Geologic Studies); and Policy 9.2-I-5 (Geotechnical Field Review During
Construction). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than
significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
According to the Geotechnical Evaluation, the project site is not within an area that has been cited by
the California Geologic Survey (CGS) for liquefaction potential. However, the project site has been
included in regional liquefaction studies conducted by the USGS. The soil sampling performed as part
of the Geotechnical Evaluation found that soils at the project site below a depth of 9 feet could
experience liquefication during a seismic event with a magnitude of 6.9 or greater. However, because
of the depth of the liquefiable layers, it was determined that they would not need design consideration
for the proposed project. Therefore, the proposed project would not result in any environmental
effects that are peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a
new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
iv) Landslides
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The western and eastern hillside portions of the General Plan Area are identified as having the
potential for landslide hazards. To minimize risks associated with landslides, in addition to mandatory
CBC requirements, new development would be required to comply with policies incorporated into the
2040 General Plan, including Policy 9.2-I-7 (Limit Cut-and-Fill Slopes to 33 Percent); Policy 9.2-I-8
(Blend Cut-and-Fill Slopes with Existing Contours); and Policy 9.2-I-10 (Control Erosion of Graded
Areas). Implementation of these policies would prevent impacts associated with new development
and exacerbating landslide conditions within the eastern and western portions of San Ramon.
Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site is not within an area identified as having the potential for landslide hazards, according
to Figure 3.5-5 of the 2040 General Plan FEIR. The project site is relatively flat and is not located on
or adjacent to a significant slope. Therefore, development of the site as proposed would not result in
any environmental effects that are peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The proposed project
would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the
2040 General Plan EIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 97
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
b) Erosion
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Buildout proposed within the 2040 General Plan would include construction activities such as
stockpiling, excavation, and grading, that would result in ground disturbance. Construction activities
that disturb one or more acres of land surface would be subject to the regional NPDES Permit
requiring preparation of a SWPPP which would include BMPs, including those for erosion and
sediment controls. Additionally, compliance with the provisions of Title C, Chapter IV of the San
Ramon Municipal Code for addressing erosion prevention and sediment control would apply to all
construction within the 2040 General Plan Area. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan concluded that
impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Development of the proposed project could result in soil erosion or the loss of topsoil. The proposed
project exceeds 1 acre in size and would therefore be subject to the regional NPDES Permit requiring
preparation of a SWPPP which would include erosion and sediment control BMPs during project
construction. Furthermore, similar to other developments, the proposed project would include
landscaping and would implement its own stormwater plan in order to prevent erosion resulting from
stormwater runoff during project operation. The Interim Area would include hydroseeding, which
would protect the soil from erosion while applications for development of the Interim Area are in
process.
Therefore, development of the project site as proposed would not result in any environmental effects
that are peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or
more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
c) Unstable Soils or Geologic Units
Would the project: Be located on a geologic unit or soil that is unstable, or that would
become unstable as a result of the project, and potentially result in
on- or off-site landsliding, lateral spreading, subsidence,
liquefaction, or collapse?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
As previously mentioned, the eastern and western hillside portions of the General Plan Area are
identified with the potential for landslide hazards. The General Plan Area also contains soils with the
potential for liquefaction, particularly along the I-680, in addition to expansive soils that may result in
subsidence or lateral spreading. To minimize impacts that would exacerbate conditions related to
liquefaction, lateral spreading, or subsidence, new development is required to comply with current
seismic standards, as stipulated within mandatory CBC requirements that address safe building
development, in addition to 2040 General Plan policies such as Policy 9.2-I-7 (Limit Cut-and-Fill
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
98 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Slopes to 33 Percent); Policy 9.2-I-8 (Blend Cut-and-Fill Slopes with Existing Contours); and Policy
9.2-I-10 (Control Erosion of Graded Areas). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that
impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
As discussed previously, the project site is relatively flat and is not within an area identified as having
the potential for landslide hazards. Furthermore, there are soils that could result in liquefaction, lateral
spreading, and settlement during a seismic event. However, it was determined that these soils are at
a depth for which they do not present design constraints for development at the site. Therefore, the
proposed project would not result in any environmental effects that are peculiar to the site or the
proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that
was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
d) Expansive Soils
Would the project: Be located on expansive soil, creating substantial direct or indirect
risks to life or property?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The eastern portion of the 2040 General Plan Area contains soils that are highly expansive, i.e.,
composed of compressible sediments. The 2040 General Plan EIR determined that, to minimize
impacts associated with expansive soils, including soil shrinks or swells, new development would be
required to comply with mandatory CBC requirements for testing expansive soils and design
specifications, including measures for treating expansive soil conditions through removal, proper fill
section, and compaction. Compliance with the requirements of the CBC, in addition to relevant
policies of the 2040 General Plan (Policy 9.2-I-6 [Preparation of a Soils Report as Needed]; Policy
9.2-I-12 [Continued Geologic Investigation by State Agencies]; and Policy 9.2-I-13 [Updates to City
Excavation, Grading, and Filling Requirements]), would reduce impacts related to expansive soils.
Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Soil testing conducted as part of the Geotechnical Evaluation prepared for the proposed project
indicated that the near-surface soils at the project site have expansion characteristics ranging from
low to moderate and a high expansion potential.
Per Policy 9.2-I-6 of the 2040 General Plan, the proposed project would be required to comply with
the recommendations of the Geotechnical Evaluation as well as CBC requirements for expansive
soils. These include the use of import material with low expansion potential, controlled compaction,
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 99
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
moisture conditioning to reduce the soil water absorption and volume change potentials, and/or the
use of selective lime treatment to reduce the soil’s expansion potential. The proposed project would
be required to comply with updated City Code requirements for excavation, grading, and filling
pursuant to Policy 9.2-I-13. Therefore, development of the site as proposed would not result in any
environmental effects that are peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The proposed project would
not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the General
Plan EIR.
e) Septic Tanks
Would the project: Have soils incapable of supporting the use of septic tanks or other
alternative wastewater disposal systems where sewers are not
available?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Development facilitated within the 2040 General Plan Area would occur in urbanized areas serviced
by existing wastewater infrastructure. Therefore, buildout resulting from implementation the 2040
General Plan would not include or require the use of septic tanks or alternative wastewater disposal
systems. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that there would be no impact.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed project would not include or require the use of septic tanks or alternative wastewater
disposal systems.
Therefore, development of the site as proposed would not result in any environmental effects that are
peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more
severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the General Plan EIR.
f) Destruction of Paleontological Resource or Unique Geologic Feature
Would the project: Directly or indirectly destroy a unique paleontological resource or
site or unique geologic feature?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The General Plan Area intersects with the Las Trampas Ridge, Diablo, Tassajara, Hayward, Dublin,
and Livermore USGS 7.5-minute topographic quadrangles. Within these quadrangles, seven distinct
geologic units were identified: Quaternary alluvium (Qa), Quaternary landslide deposits (Qls),
Quaternary older alluvium (Qoa); Livermore Gravel (QTlg), Orinda Formation (Tor), Briones
Sandstone (Tbr), and Monterey Formation (Tmc). Quaternary alluvium and Quaternary landslide
deposits (Qls) were identified as having low paleontological sensitivity and Quaternary older alluvium,
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
100 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Livermore Gravel, Orinda Formation, Briones Sandstone, and Monterey Formation were identified as
having high paleontological sensitivity.
To minimize construction-related impacts associated with the damage or destruction of
paleontological resources, new development would be required to implement 2040 General Plan EIR
MM GEO-1, which would require the retention of a qualified professional Paleontologist to conduct a
paleontological resource analysis prior to ground disturbance activities within areas consisting of
geologic units with high paleontological sensitivity. If the potential for impacts to paleontological
resources is found to be significant, the qualified professional Paleontologist would be required to
implement a Paleontological Resources Impact Mitigation Program (PRIMP) to reduce impacts to
paleontological resources to a level that is less than significant. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan
FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant with mitigation.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Fossils are nonrenewable resources subject to protection by federal, State, and local rules and
regulations. The Society of Vertebrate Paleontology (SVP) Standard Procedures classifies significant
paleontological resources as identifiable vertebrate fossils, or large or small, uncommon invertebrate,
plant, and trace fossils older than the middle Holocene that provides important scientific information to
various disciplines. Rock units with high paleontological potential consist of sedimentary rock units
older than the middle Holocene that are temporally or lithologically suitable for the preservation of
fossils such as fine-grained fluvial and marine sandstones, argillaceous paleosols, some volcanic
rocks like ashes or tephras, and low-grade metamorphic rocks that have yielded significant
paleontological resources within their geographical extent.15 Furthermore, areas that have previously
experienced gradual deposition such as fluvial and alluvial environments at lower elevations usually
provide a favorable environment for fossil preservation.
The University of California Museum of Paleontology (UCMP) prepared a paleontological records
search on, and within a 0.5-mile radius of the project site to identify whether any fossil localities that
have yielded significant paleontological resources currently curated at their repository institution have
been previously uncovered in the project vicinity. Although no fossil localities were identified in the
project area, the UCMP identified two locations that have yielded significant paleontological resources
approximately 2.5 miles from the project site. The first fossil locality was uncovered from the San
Ramon Creek to the north 10 feet below the surface within Quaternary rock units yielding a late-
Pleistocene bison femur underlain by grey siltstone, while the second locality is situated in the
Greenbrook neighborhood that produced over 1,200 screen-washed mammalian specimens within a
15 Society of Vertebrate Paleontology (SVP). 2010. Standard Procedures for the Assessment and Mitigation of Adverse
Impacts to Paleontological Resources.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 101
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
6 to 8-inch layer of grey green siltstone with pumice fragments associated with the Green Valley and
Tassajara Formations, undivided from the late-Pliocene.16
A Feasibility Level Geotechnical Investigation prepared for the project site by Ninyo & Moore
identified the project site, based on geologic mapping, to be underlain by older Pleistocene epoch
alluvial fan deposits that were deposited from the upper portions of the Amador and San Ramon
Valleys.17
The Feasibility Level Geotechnical Investigation identified older Pleistocene epoch alluvial fan
deposits from geologic mapping that were deposited from sediments washed from higher
elevations.18 Pleistocene alluvian fans are known to produce vertebrate fossils in multiple areas of
California. Older Pleistocene alluvial fans are equivalent to Quaternary older alluvium specified in the
2040 General Plan EIR. As such, given that the project site is located on alluvial fan deposits,
excavations from the construction of the proposed project could encounter significant paleontological
resources.
However, new significant impacts are not anticipated because the 2040 General Plan FEIR identifies
MM GEO-1 for areas with high paleontological sensitivity. MM GEO-1 requires the retention of a
qualified professional Paleontologist as defined by the SVP to conduct a paleontological resources
analysis prior to ground disturbance and to develop and implement a PRIMP as needed. With
implementation of MM GEO-1, the new information identified in the Geotechnical Investigation would
not constitute a significant impact. Therefore, development of the proposed project would not result in
any environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the General Plan
EIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
MM GEO-1 Protect Paleontological Resources
The City of San Ramon shall provide for the protection of paleontological resources.
The City shall require the following:
• A qualified professional Paleontologist (as defined by SVP14) must be retained to
conduct a paleontological resources analysis prior to the beginning of projects
involving ground disturbance in geologic units with high paleontological sensitivity
to determine whether there is a potential for significant impacts to paleontological
resources.
16 Holroyd, Patricia A. Senior Museum Scientist, University of California Museum of Paleontology. Personal communication:
email. August 21, 2025.
17 Ninyo & Moore. 2022. Feasibility Level Geotechnical Evaluation, Bishop Ranch, Proposed Future Residential
Development, 6001 Bollinger Canyon Road, San Ramon, California, August 16.
18 Ibid.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
102 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
• If potential impacts to paleontological resources are found to be significant, then a
qualified professional Paleontologist shall be retained to develop and implement a
Paleontological Resources Impact Mitigation Program to ensure that impacts to
paleontological resources are less than significant.
Conclusion
With regard to Geology and Soils, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. MM GEO-1 would be required for the proposed project’s specific impacts to be less than
significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 103
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More
Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.8 Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Would the project:
a) Generate greenhouse gas
emissions, either directly or
indirectly, that may have a
significant impact on the
environment?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
b) Conflict with any applicable
plan, policy or regulation of
an agency adopted for the
purpose of reducing the
emissions of greenhouse
gases?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
a) Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Would the project: Generate greenhouse gas emissions, either directly or indirectly, that
may have a significant impact on the environment?
The 2040 General Plan FEIR discussed emissions associated with implementation of the 2040
General Plan qualitatively and compared the 2040 General Plan to the 2022 Bay Area Air District
thresholds. Construction- and operational-related emissions were discussed separately. The 2040
General Plan FEIR found operational impacts related to generation of GHG emissions could be
potentially significant. To address the potentially significant impact, MM GHG-1 required the City to
adopt and implement a qualified CAP that would align with State GHG reduction targets, the Bay Area
Air District’s 2022 CEQA Guidelines, and would represent an update to the City’s CAP. With
implementation of MM GHG-1, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that the 2040 General Plan
would not generate indirect or direct GHG emissions that would have a significant impact on the
environment, and impacts would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
104 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The 11.3-acre Mixed-Use District would consist of residential communities with ground floor retail,
entertainment and commercial uses complementary to City Center Bishop Ranch across Bollinger
Canyon Road. The 26-acre Multi-Family District would consist of communities that may be developed
into apartments, condominiums, senior or affordable housing, offering a variety of housing options
and would include Orchards Park, a 2.5-acre park that would serve as a gathering place for residents
and visitors. The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District are expected to be developed under
separate projects over the longer-term future and would be subject to future project-level CEQA
analysis.
The Bay Area Air District’s 2022 CEQA Air Quality Guidelines provide recommended significance
thresholds for GHGs for land use development projects and plans. The thresholds state that projects
demonstrating consistency with either one of two enumerated Criterion “A” or “B” would result in a
less than significant impact related to the generation of direct and indirect GHG emissions. A project’s
consistency with Criterion A is based on incorporating specific project design elements. A project’s
consistency with Criterion B involves demonstrating consistency with a local GHG reduction strategy
that meets the criteria under CEQA Guidelines Section 15183.5(b). As stated above, the City adopted
a qualified CAP in June 2025. Individual projects developed within the Mixed-Use District or Multi-
family District would be required to demonstrate consistency with the 2025 CAP (either through
consistency with the checklist, or another method) or demonstrate that project implementation would
not result in direct or indirect GHG emissions that may have significant climate impacts. Therefore,
the Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District would not generate direct or indirect emissions of
GHGs that may have a significant impact on the environment, and impacts would be less than
significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or
more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The Bay Area Air District’s 2022 CEQA Air Quality Guidelines provide recommended significance
thresholds for GHGs for land use development projects and plans. The thresholds state that projects
demonstrating consistency with either one of two enumerated Criterion “A” or “B” would result in a
less than significant impact related to the generation of direct and indirect GHG emissions. A project’s
consistency with Criterion A is based on incorporating specific project design elements. A project’s
consistency with Criterion B involves demonstrating consistency with a local GHG reduction strategy
that meets the criteria under CEQA Guidelines Section 15183.5(b). As stated above, the City adopted
a qualified CAP in June 2025. The 2025 CAP includes a checklist for individual projects to
demonstrate their consistency with the 2025 CAP. The checklist is provided in Appendix B and
demonstrates that the Neighborhood District would be consistent with the applicable measures
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 105
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
contained within the 2025 CAP. Accordingly, the Neighborhood District would meet Criterion B of the
Bay Area Air District’s thresholds of significance, and impacts would be less than significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
b) Greenhouse Gases Emissions Reduction Plan Conflict
Would the project: Conflict with any applicable plan, policy or regulation of an agency
adopted for the purpose of reducing the emissions of greenhouse
gases?
The 2040 General Plan FEIR evaluated the 2040 General Plan for consistency with the applicable
plans adopted for the purpose of reducing GHG emissions which included ARB’s Scoping Plan, the
Bay Area Air District’s 2022 CEQA Guidelines, and consistency with the 2011 San Ramon CAP. The
2040 General Plan FEIR found that the 2040 General Plan could be inconsistent with the Scoping
Plan, Bay Area Air District’s 2022 CEQA Guidelines, and the 2011 San Ramon CAP. To address the
potentially significant impact, MM GHG-1 required the City to adopt and implement a qualified CAP
that would align with State GHG reduction targets, the Bay Area Air District’s 2022 CEQA Guidelines,
and would represent an update to the City’s CAP. With implementation of MM GHG-1, the 2040
General Plan FEIR concluded that the 2040 General Plan would not conflict with an applicable plan,
policy, or regulation of an agency adopted for the purpose of reducing GHG emissions and impacts
would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The 11.3-acre Mixed-Use District would consist of residential communities with ground floor retail,
entertainment and commercial uses complementary to City Center Bishop Ranch across Bollinger
Canyon Road. The 26-acre Multi-Family District would consist of communities that may be developed
into apartments, condominiums, senior or affordable housing, offering a variety of housing options
and would include Orchards Park, a 2.5-acre park that would serve as a gathering place for residents
and visitors. The Mixed-Use District and Multi-Family District are expected to be developed under
separate projects over the longer-term future and would be subject to future project-level CEQA
analysis.
Pursuant to MM GHG-1 of the 2040 General Plan FEIR, the City adopted a qualified CAP in June
2025, which includes targets that reflect those set by California SB 32 to reduce GHG emissions by
40 percent below the 1990 levels by 2030 and AB 1279 to achieve carbon neutrality by 2045.19
19 City of San Ramon. 2025. Climate Action Plan. Website:
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
106 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
These reduction targets also align with the targets set forth in the 2022 ARB Scoping Plan. The City’s
2025 CAP includes a checklist for individual projects to demonstrate their consistency with the 2025
CAP. Individual projects developed within the Mixed-Use District or Multi-family District would be
required to demonstrate consistency with the 2025 CAP (either through the checklist, or another
method), or demonstrate that project implementation would not result in direct or indirect GHG
emissions that may have significant climate impacts. Accordingly, the Mixed-Use District and the
Multi-Family District would demonstrate consistency with the Bay Area Air District’s 2022 CEQA
Guidelines, the City’s CAP and the 2022 ARB Scoping Plan.
Therefore, implementation of the Mixed-Use District and the Multi-Family District would not conflict
with any applicable plan, policy or regulation adopted for the purpose of reducing the emissions of
greenhouse gases, and impacts would be less than significant.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or
more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Pursuant to MM GHG-1 of the 2040 General Plan FEIR, the City adopted a qualified CAP in June
2025 (2025 CAP) which includes targets that reflect those set by California SB 32 to reduce GHG
emissions by 40 percent below the 1990 levels by 2030 and AB 1279 to achieve carbon neutrality by
2045.20 These reduction targets also align with the targets set forth in the 2022 ARB Scoping Plan.
The City’s 2025 CAP includes a checklist for individual projects to demonstrate their consistency with
the 2025 CAP. The checklist is provided in Appendix B and demonstrates that the Neighborhood
District Development plus Grading of Interim Area would be consistent with the applicable measures
contained in the 2025 CAP. Therefore, the Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of
Interim Area would demonstrate consistency with the Bay Area Air District’s 2022 CEQA Guidelines,
the City’s CAP and the 2022 ARB Scoping Plan.
There are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
None.
https://sanramon.ca.gov/our_city/departments_and_divisions/community_development/planning_services/climate_action
_plan. Accessed November 7, 2025.
20 City of San Ramon. 2025. Climate Action Plan. Website:
https://sanramon.ca.gov/our_city/departments_and_divisions/community_development/planning_services/climate_action
_plan. Accessed November 7, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 107
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Conclusion
With regard to Greenhouse Gases, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site that were not analyzed as
significant effects in the 2040 General Plan FEIR have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
analyzed in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures from the 2040 General Plan FEIR would be required because the
proposed project’s specific impacts would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
108 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.9 Hazards and Hazardous Materials
Would the project:
a) Create a significant hazard
to the public or the
environment through the
routine transport, use, or
disposal of hazardous
materials?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Create a significant hazard
to the public or the
environment through
reasonably foreseeable
upset and accident
conditions involving the
release of hazardous
materials into the
environment?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
c) Emit hazardous emissions
or handle hazardous or
acutely hazardous
materials, substances, or
waste within one-quarter
mile of an existing or
proposed school?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
d) Be located on a site which
is included on a list of
hazardous materials sites
compiled pursuant to
Government Code Section
65962.5 and, as a result,
would it create a significant
hazard to the public or the
environment?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 109
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
e) For a project located within
an airport land use plan or,
where such a plan has not
been adopted, within two
miles of a public airport or
public use airport, would the
project result in a safety
hazard or excessive noise
for people residing or
working in the project area?
No impact No No No No
f) Impair implementation of or
physically interfere with an
adopted emergency
response plan or
emergency evacuation
plan?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
g) Expose people or
structures, either directly or
indirectly to a significant risk
of loss, injury or death
involving wildland fires?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
a) Routine Transport, Use, or Disposal of Hazardous Materials
Would the project: Create a significant hazard to the public or the environment through
the routine transport, use, or disposal of hazardous materials?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The I-680, running north–south through the General Plan Area, is designated as a Class A (All Non-
radioactive Hazardous Materials) route and Class B (Class 1 Explosives) route by the National
Hazardous Materials Route Registry (NHMRR). During both construction and operations, all new
development would be required to with comply with County, State, and federal standards related to
the transportation, use, and disposal of hazardous materials, including the Hazardous Materials
Transportation Act, the California Hazardous Waste Control Law, California Health and Safety Code,
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
110 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
and the Hazardous Materials Unified Program Agency (HMUPA). Compliance with these regulations
would reduce impacts associated with the transport, use, or disposal of hazardous waste, including
on the I-680 and local roads adjacent to or near open hazardous waste sites, such as Alcosta
Boulevard and Dougherty Road. Through compliance with these regulations, the 2040 General Plan
FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site lies adjacent to the I-680, a designated Class A route and Class B route by the
NHMRR. Typical of similar projects, the proposed project may utilize hazardous materials, such as
fuels or solvents, during the construction phase of the project. During the operations phase, residents
may also routinely use commonly available hazardous substances such as fuels, lubricants, and
household cleaners. As discussed above, potential hazards arising from the transport, use, and
disposal of these hazardous materials would be minimized and regulated in accordance with local,
State, and federal policies, regulations, and standards. As such, there are no environmental effects
that are peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or
more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
b) Risk of Upset
Would the project: Create a significant hazard to the public or the environment through
reasonably foreseeable upset and accident conditions involving the
release of hazardous materials into the environment?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Hazardous materials within the General Plan Area include hazardous building materials (e.g.,
asbestos, lead), hazardous substances in the physical environment (e.g., cleaning products,
herbicides, pesticides), and hazardous waste. To avoid resulting in upset or accident conditions that
would involve the release of hazardous materials into the environment, new development would be
required to abide by the California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA), the Clean
Air Act, and all applicable regional, State, and federal regulations listed during both construction and
operations. As noted in the 2040 General Plan FEIR, in the case of underground storage tanks
(USTs), all new development would be required to minimize risk according to existing standards
contained within Chapters 6.7 and 6.75 (UST Program) of the California Health and Safety Code and
all sources of contamination of groundwater sources from UST and elsewhere would require
remediation under the oversight of the San Francisco Bay RWQCB. New development would also be
required to comply with applicable 2040 General Plain policies, including Policy 5.4-I-9 (Specify
Hauling Routes for Transportation of Hazardous Materials); Policy 9.3-I-3 (Cleanup of Contaminated
Sites); and Policy 9.3-I-4 (Compliance with Contra Costa County Hazardous Waste Management
Plan) in order to minimize impacts associated with hazardous materials. The 2040 General Plan FEIR
concluded that, with compliance with these regulations, impacts would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 111
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
A Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (Phase I ESA) was prepared on July 12, 2022 and a
follow-up Phase II ESA was prepared on August 30, 2022 which identified two significant Recognized
Environmental Conditions (RECs) on the site (Appendix F). These conditions are not unique or
unusual for properties undergoing urban infill or redevelopment.
A REC refers to the presence or likely presence of any hazardous substances or petroleum products
in, on, or at a property.
According to the Phase I ESA, the RECs for the project site included:
• Historical land use as orchard farm
• A 15,000-gallon diesel underground storage tank (UST) is located within the Building J
courtyard area and was installed sometime before 1996 with no UST record of subsurface
investigation in the area
Given these RECS, the following recommendations were made:
• A Limited Phase II Subsurface Investigation to evaluate contamination from former agricultural
operations on-site and those from a 15,000-gallon diesel UST estimated to be over 25 years
old.
• A comprehensive hazardous materials survey (including asbestos and lead) prior to demolition
activities.
A Phase II ESA was prepared on October 1, 2025 by ENGEO, which included soil and groundwater
sampling, which revealed trace amounts of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), namely, benzene, in
exceedance of San Francisco Bay RWQCB Commercial/Industrial Soil Vapor Intrusion Environmental
Screening Levels (ESLs). However, the project site contains properties favorable for natural bio
attenuation.21 It was determined that benzene does not exceed the ESL when factoring in bio
attenuation.
The Phase II ESA provided the following recommendations:
• Removal of the UST in collaboration with the Contra Costa Health Services Hazardous
Materials Programs and Contra Costa County Fire Protection District.
• Preparation of a Soil Management Plan outlining protocols for handling soil, appropriate safety
procedures, monitoring, and other items to support the redevelopment.
21 Bio attenuation is the natural reduction of contaminant concentrations through biological processes, such as microbial
activity that breaks down VOCs in the presence of oxygen and other favorable conditions.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
112 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
A Soil Management Plan was prepared on October 8, 2025, by ENGEO Incorporated (Appendix F).
The Phase II ESA also recommended removal of the UST, which would be done through appropriate
permitting and coordination with the Contra Costa Health Services Hazardous Materials Programs
and Contra Costa County Fire Protection District. According to the General Plan FEIR, potential risks
associated with removal of on-site USTs prior to construction activities would be minimized through
compliance with existing standards contained in Division 20, Chapter 6.7 and 6.75 (UST Program) of
the California Health and Safety Code as enforced by the Environmental Programs Division.22 As
such, the presence of the UST, which would be removed in compliance with State law, would not
constitute a peculiar impact.
The proposed project would also be required to comply with all applicable regional, State, and federal
regulations regarding the transport, use, and disposal of hazardous materials. All contaminated waste
would be collected and disposed of at an appropriately licensed disposal or treatment facility.
The UST is not peculiar to the project or site because it reflects typical environmental conditions
found in redevelopment areas and was anticipated in the General Plan and is being managed through
well-established regulatory processes. Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to
the site or the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe
adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
c) Exposure of Schools to Hazardous Materials or Emissions
Would the project: Emit hazardous emissions or handle hazardous or acutely hazardous
materials, substances, or waste within one-quarter mile of an
existing or proposed school?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan Area contains 14 elementary schools, five middle schools, and two high
schools operated by the San Ramon Valley Unified School District (SRVUSD). Currently, there are no
open hazardous materials sites located within a 0.25-mile distance of any school within the 2040
General Plan Area; however, 11 of these schools are located near an identified hazardous materials
transportation route. As previously mentioned, the transportation of hazardous materials along the I-
680 and nearby local roads would be subject to federal, State, and local regulations, including the
Hazardous Materials Transportation Act, the California Hazardous Waste Control Law, California
Health and Safety Code, and the HMUPA. Furthermore, development facilitated by the 2040 General
Plan would be primarily residential, commercial, office, and semi-public, and would therefore not
involve substantial quantities of hazardous materials during operations. Therefore, the 2040 General
Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
22 City of San Ramon. 2023. San Ramon 2040 General Plan Draft Environmental Impact Report. August 30. Page 3.7-32.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 113
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site boundary is 0.2 mile west of the Montevideo Elementary School. The proposed
project would involve the temporary use of hazardous materials during construction such as diesel
fuel, asphalt, and concrete mixtures. However, use of construction-related hazardous materials is
typical of similar construction projects and would be temporary. The proposed project would only
result in mixed-use, park and open space, and residential development. Uses involving large
quantities of hazardous materials would not be permitted. As such, project operations may involve the
use of small quantities of household materials through the use of household cleaners or solvents.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The
proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
d) Hazardous Materials Sites
Would the project: Be located on a site which is included on a list of hazardous
materials sites compiled pursuant to Government Code Section
65962.5 and, as a result, would it create a significant hazard to the
public or the environment?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The General Plan Area contains four hazardous materials sites listed pursuant to Government Code
Section 65962.5. Two of these are open sites where remedial activities have not yet been conducted:
Former Green Valley Shopping Center, located at 12141 Alcosta Boulevard, and Shell Service Station
#16049, located at 2850 Crow Canyon Road. Given that new development would be required to
conduct remediation activities to the satisfaction of the California Department of Toxic Substances
Control (DTSC) and the RWQCB prior to construction activities, construction impacts would be
reduced through compliance with federal, State, and local regulations. These regulations would also
apply for new development facilitated on identified hazard sites, which would require site-specific
remediation and containment measures to the satisfaction of the oversight agency. Additionally, new
development would be required to comply with various measures of the 2040 General Plan to
minimize impacts related to hazardous materials, including: Policy 5.4-I-9 (Specify Hauling Routes for
Transportation of Hazardous Materials); Policy 9.3-I-3 (Cleanup of Contaminated Sites); and Policy
9.3-I-4 (Compliance with Contra Costa County Hazardous Waste Management Plan). Therefore, the
2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
According to the California State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) GeoTracker
and the DTSC Envirostor database, there are no hazardous sites within the project site, and the
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
114 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
project site is not included on the Cortese list.23,24 Furthermore, according to the regulatory database
report included in the Phase I ESA, the project site is not included in the EPA databases which list
properties that are subject to land use restrictions or Federal Superfund Liens, or any lists maintained
by DTSC. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the site or the proposed
project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
e) Airports
Would the project: For a project located within an airport land use plan or, where such a
plan has not been adopted, within two miles of a public airport or
public use airport, would the project result in a safety hazard or
excessive noise for people residing or working in the project area?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The nearest airport to the 2040 General Plan Area is the Livermore Municipal Airport, located
approximately 7 miles to the southeast. There are no flight paths, airport noise contours, or airport-
restricted development zones that overlap with San Ramon. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR
concluded that there would be no impact.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
As previously mentioned, there are no airports within the 2040 General Plan Area and there is no
overlap with flight paths, airport noise contours, or airport-restricted development zones from the
Livermore Municipal Airport. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the
proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that
was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
23 California State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board). 2025. Geotracker (Web Viewer). Website:
https://geotracker.waterboards.ca.gov/map/?CMD=runreport&myaddress=Sacramento. Accessed August 13, 2025.
24 California Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC). 2025. EnviroStor. Hazardous Waste and Substances Site
List (Cortese). Website:
https://www.envirostor.dtsc.ca.gov/public/search?cmd=search&reporttype=CORTESE&site_type=CSITES,FUDS&status
=ACT,BKLG,COM&reporttitle=HAZARDOUS+WASTE+AND+SUBSTANCES+SITE+LIST+%28CORTESE%29.
Accessed August 13, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 115
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
f) Emergency Response and Evacuation
Would the project: Impair implementation of or physically interfere with an adopted
emergency response plan or emergency evacuation plan?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Potential emergency evacuation routes within the 2040 General Plan Area include the I-680, Crow
Canyon Road, San Ramon Valley Boulevard, Dougherty Road, and Alcosta Boulevard. All new
development would be required to comply with the provisions of the Contra Costa County Emergency
Operation Plan and Contra Costa County Local Hazard Mitigation Plan (LHMP) to ensure adequate
emergency vehicle access during construction, including through the preparation of a construction
management plan during CEQA review. New development would also be required to comply with
2040 General Plan policies, including Policy 9.1-I-4 (Two Emergency Evacuation Routes for
Development within High Risk Hazard Areas) and Policy 9.5-I-1 (Site Design Features). In addition,
new development would be required to provide adequate fire truck and apparatus turning radii and
clearance for purposes of adequate emergency access and response for review by the San Ramon
Valley Fire Protection District (SRVFPD). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that
impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The intersection of I-680 and Bollinger Canyon Road is located to the northwest of the project site.
Bollinger Canyon Road provides access to the I-680 north–south evacuation route. Both the I-680
and Bollinger Canyon Road provide connections to Crow Canyon Road, located 1.35 miles to the
west, which would serve as an emergency evacuation route in the east–west direction. Bollinger
Canyon Road also provides connections to San Ramon Valley Boulevard, located directly across the
project site on the other side of the I-680, and Alcosta Boulevard located. Both Bollinger Canyon
Road and Crow Canyon Road provide direct access to Dougherty Road located 1.99 miles to the
east, past hillside development.
Construction or operation of the proposed project would not be expected to significantly impede the
use of these evacuation routes, as it would connect to the existing circulation system. The proposed
project’s internal street network would be designed to accommodate the turning radius of emergency
vehicles, such as large fire trucks, and the proposed project would undergo review by the SRVFPD to
ensure adequate emergency access.
The proposed project would undergo review by the SRVFPD to ensure adequate emergency access.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The
proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
116 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
g) Wildland Fires
Would the project: Expose people or structures, either directly or indirectly to a
significant risk of loss, injury or death involving wildland fires?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
At the time of its publication, the 2040 General Plan Area was not located within a designated Very
High Fire Hazard Severity Zone (VHFHSZ). However, the northwesternmost portion of the 2040
General Plan Area is located within a VHFHSZ within a Local Responsibility Area. New development
facilitated by the 2040 General Plan would be subject to the requirements of the California Fire Code
and the CBC, as stipulated within the 2040 General Plan, including: Policy 9.5-I-1 (Site Design
Features) and Policy 9.5-I-4 (Sprinklers in New Homes). Additionally, new development would be
required to meet minimum standards for emergency access, fuel modification, setback, signage, and
water supply, as set forth in California Code of Regulations Title 14, and all new development within a
High FHSZ would be required to implement MM HAZ-1 (Conduct Project Landscape and Slope
Design Wildfire Risk Reduction). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts
would be less than significant with mitigation.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
As noted by the latest California Department of Fire (CAL FIRE) Fire Hazard Severity Zone (FHSZ)
maps, the project site is not located within a designated FHSZ. The nearest Medium FHSZ is located
approximately 0.17 mile west of the project site directly across the I-680, and the closest High FHSZ
is located 0.21 mile east if the project site. The closest VHFHSZ is located approximately 3.84 miles
northeast of the project site.25 The proposed project would not include any uses that would
exacerbate fire risk.
The proposed project would be required to comply with applicable goals and policies from the 2040
General Plan, including Policy 9.5-I-1 (Site Design Features) to ensure the use of fire retardant
building materials and other measures to reduce the risk of fire on-site. This would also include
General Plan 2050 Policy 9.5-I-4 (Sprinklers in New Homes) through the installation of sprinklers in all
new residential units. The proposed project would be subject to the requirements of the California Fire
Code (CFC) and the CBC, as well as minimum standards set forth by California Code of Regulations
Title 14 regarding emergency access, fuel modification, setback, signage, and water supply.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The
proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
25 California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE). 2025. Fire Hazard Severity Zone Viewer (Map
Viewer). Website: https://fire-hazard-severity-zones-rollout-calfire-forestry.hub.arcgis.com/pages/access-map. Accessed
August 13, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 117
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
None.
Conclusion
With regard to Hazards and Hazardous Materials, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
118 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.10 Hydrology and Water Quality
Would the project:
a) Violate any water quality
standards or waste
discharge requirements or
otherwise substantially
degrade surface or
groundwater quality?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Substantially decrease
groundwater supplies or
interfere substantially with
groundwater recharge such
that the project may impede
sustainable groundwater
management of the basin?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
c) Substantially alter the
existing drainage pattern of
the site or area, including
through the alteration of the
course of a stream or river
or through the addition of
impervious surfaces, in a
manner which would:
(i) result in substantial
erosion or siltation on-
or off-site;
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
(ii) substantially increase
the rate or amount of
surface runoff in a
manner which would
result in flooding on- or
off-site;
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 119
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
(iii) create or contribute
runoff water which
would exceed the
capacity of existing or
planned stormwater
drainage systems or
provide substantial
additional sources of
polluted runoff; or
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
(iv) impede or redirect flood
flows?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
d) In flood hazard, tsunami, or
seiche zones, risk release
of pollutants due to project
inundation?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
e) Conflict with or obstruct
implementation of a water
quality control plan or
sustainable groundwater
management plan?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
a) Water Quality
Would the project: Violate any water quality standards or waste discharge requirements
or otherwise substantially degrade surface or groundwater quality?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan Area is located within the Suisun Basin under the jurisdiction of the San
Fransico Bay RWQCB, which manages strategies for achieving water quality objectives in
accordance with the Water Quality Control Plan (Basin Plan) for the San Francisco Bay Basin. During
construction, new development would be required to mitigate impacts to water quality through
compliance with the provisions of the NPDES Construction General Permit and San Ramon Municipal
Code requirements, which include implementation of site-specific BMPs to reduce impacts. New
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
120 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
development would also be required to prepare a SWPPP in accordance with the City’s NPDES
permit, which would require use of Low Impact Development (LID) treatment measures such as
bioretention systems, swales, green roofs, infiltration systems, and permeable pavers per the
requirements of the CCCWP Stormwater C.3 Guidebook, as stipulated in Section B6-3644 of the San
Ramon Municipal Code and 2040 General Plan Policy 8.3-I-11 (Participation in Contra Costa Clean
Water Program). During operations, new development would be required to continue compliance with
City-specific components of the CCCWP, including implementation of stormwater control measures to
minimize or avoid potential water quality impacts. These would be complemented by adherence to
relevant 2040 General Plan Policies, including Policy 8.3-I-3 (Explore Opportunities for Preservation
of Open Space) and Policy 8.6-I-6 (Continued Implementation of City Stormwater Management
Program). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than
significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
Designation of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts does not include any construction. However,
future development under the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts may impact water quality due to
changes in stormwater patterns. During construction of future projects under the Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family Districts, projects would be required to comply with the NPDES Permit, meaning they
would follow the required SWPPP, which includes BMPs to prevent erosion and siltation during
project construction. The proposed project would comply with Section B6-364 of the San Ramon
Municipal Code and the latest CCCWP recommendations.
Furthermore, future development projects would be required to use LID treatment measures as part
of the project design, including an optimized site layout featuring open space and landscaped areas
in addition to on-site treatment systems for managing stormwater runoff. These features are outlined
in the Stormwater Control Plan.26 Furthermore, as noted in the Stormwater Control Plan, the Mixed-
Use and Multi-Family Districts would involve the use of permanent source control BMPs such as
minimizing pesticide and fertilizer use during landscaping and maintenance activities and operational
source control BMPs such as providing information on integrated pest management to new site
owners. This would prevent polluted runoff from impacting water quality. Therefore, there are no
environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The
proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or more severe
adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Demolition and grading activities for the Neighborhood and Interim Area would be compliant with the
NPDES Permit, meaning they would follow the required SWPPP, which includes BMPs to prevent
26 Sunset Development. January. Stormwater Control Plan for Orchards Subdivision 9693. January.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 121
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
erosion and siltation during project construction. The proposed project would comply with Section B6-
364 of the San Ramon Municipal Code and the latest CCCWP recommendations.
The proposed project would include demolition, tree removal, and grading of the Interim Area. This
would expose soils and could create sedimented stormwater runoff, which could negatively impact
water quality. However, the proposed Interim Area includes hydroseeding. Hydroseeding is the
process of spraying a watery mixture of seed, mulch, fertilizer and binder on the ground to promote
fast-growing turf in order to control erosion. During demolition and grading activities for the Interim
Area, hydroseeding specifically would be utilized to minimize erosion and surface runoff throughout
construction, reducing potential impacts on surface or groundwater quality.
In compliance with 2040 General Plan Policy 8.3-I-11, the Neighborhood District would include LID
treatment measures as explained in the Stormwater Control Plan.27 For example, it would include
bioretention basins on-site to treat 100 percent of on-site runoff. Furthermore, as noted in the
Stormwater Control Plan, the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would involve the use of
permanent source control BMPs such as minimizing pesticide and fertilizer use during landscaping
and maintenance activities and operational source control BMPs such as providing information on
integrated pest management to new site owners. This would prevent polluted runoff from impacting
water quality. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed
Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading
of Interim Area would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
b) Groundwater
Would the project: Substantially decrease groundwater supplies or interfere
substantially with groundwater recharge such that the project may
impede sustainable groundwater management of the basin?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan Area overlies the San Ramon Valley Groundwater Basin and the Livermore
Valley Groundwater Basin. Water supply for new development would be provided either via the
EBMUD, which covers the San Ramon Valley Groundwater Basin and does not produce groundwater,
or the Dublin San Ramon Services District (DSRSD), which covers the Livermore Valley Groundwater
Basin and produces a limited amount of groundwater supply under the jurisdiction of the Zone 7
Water Agency, a California Department of Water Resources (DWR)-approved Groundwater
Sustainability Agency. As noted within the 2040 General Plan FEIR, new development would be
required to development project-specific SWPPPs for the implementation BMPs to comply with the
CWA and the CCCWP during construction. Furthermore, during operations, new development would
be required to maintain or increase pervious surfaces aimed at maximizing stormwater retention and
infiltration, per the requirements of the San Ramon Municipal Code, the CCCWP, and 2040 General
27 Sunset Development. January. Stormwater Control Plan for Orchards Subdivision 9693. January.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
122 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Plan Policy 5.6-I-18 (Compatible Land Uses to Minimize Unnecessary Pavement). Therefore, the
2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed project would not result in direct groundwater consumption. The project site is already
developed and already has a limited area of impervious surfaces where groundwater recharge may
occur. The proposed project would include bioretention areas and landscaped areas that would allow
for groundwater recharge. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the
proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that
was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
c) Drainage
Would the project: Substantially alter the existing drainage pattern of the site or area,
including through the alteration of the course of a stream or river or
through the addition of impervious surfaces, in a manner which
would:
i) result in substantial erosion or siltation on- or off-site;
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
As noted within the 2040 General Plan FEIR, new development facilitated by the 2040 General Plan
would be primarily infill development and would therefore not alter the course of any stream or river.
However, new development would still be required to comply with the provisions of the 2040 General
Plan to minimize impacts, including those related to erosion or siltation, including Policy 9.2-I-109
(Control Erosion of Graded Areas) in addition to the City’s NPDES requirements, Municipal Code, and
CCCWP Stormwater C.3 requirements for implementation of BMPs to minimize or avoid the potential
of erosion or siltation during construction. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that
impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
No specific development is proposed within the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. As such,
determining specific erosion of siltation impacts is too speculative at this time. Future development of
the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would be required to prepare a project-specific SWPPP
incorporating construction-related BMPs for erosion and sediment controls in accordance with 2040
General Plan Policy 9.2-I-19 (Control Erosion of Graded Areas), the City’s NPDES requirements, the
City’s Municipal Code, and CCCWP Stormwater C.3 requirements. Therefore, there are no
environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 123
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or more severe
adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Demolition and grading activities for the Neighborhood District and Interim Area would be compliant
with the NPDES Permit, meaning they would follow the required SWPPP, which includes BMPs to
prevent erosion and siltation during project construction. The proposed project would comply with
Section B6-364 of the San Ramon Municipal Code and the latest CCCWP recommendations.
The proposed Interim Area would include demolition, tree removal, and grading of the area. This
would expose soils which could create impacts related to erosion or siltation. However, the proposed
Interim Area includes hydroseeding, which would prevent erosion and siltation in the area while
applications for development of the Interim Area are in process.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District
plus Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would
not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040
General Plan FEIR.
(ii) substantially increase the rate or amount of surface runoff in a manner which
would result in flooding on- or off-site;
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan FEIR refers to Section B6-364 the San Ramon Municipal Code, per the most
recent version of the CCCWP, for the implementation of LID treatment measures during construction,
including the use of infiltration ponds and other design measures, which would be used to minimize
runoff. As previously mentioned, these measures would be required to be addressed by new
development through development of a site-specific SWPPP per the requirements of the City’s
NPDES permit. During operations, all new developments would be required to conform to the
regulations of the County Flood Control and Water Conservation District’s 50-Year Plan. Therefore,
the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
As previously mentioned, development of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would be required
to comply with Section B6-364 of the San Ramon Municipal Code and latest CCCWP
recommendations for construction-related LID treatment measures for managing surface runoff
through a project-specific SWPPP.
As noted in the program-level Stormwater Control Plan, the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts
would incorporate an on-site treatment system designed in accordance with CCCWP Provision C.3
requirements for managing stormwater flow during operations in addition to the installation of
landscape and open space areas. The Preliminary Stormwater Control Plan prepared for the project
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
124 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
accounts for an increase in impervious surface area, and outlines a stormwater plan such that
development of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would not result in an exceedance
stormwater runoff flow from pre-development conditions. Therefore, there are no environmental
effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-
Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact
that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Demolition and grading activities for the Neighborhood and Interim Area would be compliant with the
NPDES Permit, meaning they would follow the required SWPPP, which includes BMPs to prevent
surface runoff during project construction. The proposed project would comply with Section B6-364 of
the San Ramon Municipal Code and the latest CCCWP recommendations.
The proposed Interim Area would include demolition and grading of the area, which would impact
stormwater flow. However, the proposed Interim Area includes hydroseeding, which, by spraying a
mixture of seed, mulch, fertilizer, and water would promote soil stabilization and vegetative growth,
thus increasing water absorption and preventing surface runoff.
As noted in the Preliminary Stormwater Control Plan, the Neighborhood District would include
bioretention basins located in a few areas around the project site perimeter in open space areas. The
bioretention areas would treat stormwater flows during operations, which are designed to have
capacity for 100 percent of anticipated stormwater runoff. Therefore, there are no environmental
effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim
Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not result in a new or
more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
(iii) create or contribute runoff water which would exceed the capacity of existing or
planned stormwater drainage systems or provide substantial additional sources
of polluted runoff;
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
As noted within the 2040 General Plan FEIR, new development facilitated by the 2040 General Plan
would be concentrated as infill development. Therefore, new development would be unlikely to
contribute to alterations in existing drainage patterns that would result in exceedances of the storm
drain system. As previously mentioned, new development would be required to implement LID
treatment measures to minimize surface runoff during construction per the San Ramon Municipal
Code and the CCCWP. During operations, new development would be required to comply with 2040
General Plan Policies for minimizing potential impacts associated with stormwater drainage and
capacity of the storm drain system, including Policy 9.4-I-3 (Preparation of Hydrologic Studies); Policy
9.4-I-4 (Maintenance of Drainage Facilities); and Policy 9.4-I-5 (Landscape and Maintenance
Guidelines for Detention Basins). Therefore, development of the project site as proposed would not
result in any environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 125
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the
2040 General Plan FEIR.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
Development of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts does not include construction. However,
future development under the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts may impact storm drain capacity
through increased impervious surfaces, creating changes in runoff or additional sources of polluted
runoff.
Future development projects would be required to use on-site treatment systems designed in
accordance with Provision C.3 requirements. As explained in the Preliminary Stormwater
Management Plan, the proposed project includes a bioretention system designed to treat 100 percent
of anticipated stormwater runoff. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the
proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District
designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Demolition and grading activities for the Neighborhood and Interim Area would be compliant with the
NPDES Permit, meaning they would follow the required SWPPP, which includes BMPs to prevent
polluted runoff during project construction. The proposed project would comply with Section B6-364 of
the San Ramon Municipal Code and the latest CCCWP recommendations.
The proposed Interim Area would include demolition, tree removal, and grading of the area. It would
also include hydroseeding of the area in order to increase absorption and reduce stormwater runoff.
During operations, the Neighborhood Development District would utilize proposed bioretention basins
to manage stormwater runoff. As explained in the Preliminary Stormwater Management Plan, the
proposed bioretention system would have capacity to treat 100 percent of anticipated stormwater
runoff. As such, it is not anticipated that the Neighborhood District would result in new sources of
polluted runoff. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed
Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading
of Interim Area would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
(iv) impede or redirect flood flows?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan FEIR identifies Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)-designated
Flood Zones within the 2040 General Plan Area, where 100-year floodplains are found along San
Ramon Creek, South San Ramon Creek, West Branch Alamo Creek, and Alamo Creek. Portions of
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
126 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
the 500-year floodplain are along South San Ramon Creek, which is entirely modified for flood control
purposes. New development associated with the 2040 General Plan would be concentrated as infill
development and would be required to comply with all regulations applicable to the presence of
designated Flood Hazard Areas, including those for appropriately sized and designed drainage
facilities that would not result in increased runoff or flooding. These compliance measures would
support 2040 General Plan policies designed to minimize or avoid impacts related to flood flows,
specifically Guiding Policy 9.4-G-1 (Protect Risks to Lives and Property). Therefore, the 2040 General
Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The project site is not located within a FEMA-designated Flood Zone. The closest FEMA-designated
Flood Zone is Coyote Creek, a 100-year floodplain (FEMA Zone AE) located approximately 0.63 mile
southeast of the proposed Districts.28 Thus, future development of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
Districts would not impede or redirect flood flows within a FEMA-designated Flood Zone.
Furthermore, as explained in the Preliminary Stormwater Management Plan, future development of
the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would not result in an exceedance in pre-
stormwater runoff during operations. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to
the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
District designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The closest FEMA-designated Flood Hazard Area is located along Coyote Creek. It is a 100-year
floodplain (FEMA Zone AE) located approximately 0.4 mile southeast of the proposed Neighborhood
District across intervening development.29
The proposed Interim Area would include demolition and grading of the area. It would also include
hydroseeding of the area in order to increase absorption and prevent additional runoff.
As noted in the project-specific Preliminary Stormwater Management Plan, the proposed bioretention
system would have capacity to treat 100 percent of anticipated stormwater at the project site.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District
plus Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would
not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040
General Plan FEIR.
28 Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). 2025. National Flood Hazard Layer (Web Viewer). Website:
https://www.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=8b0adb51996444d4879338b5529aa9cd. Accessed
September 3, 2025.
29 Ibid.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 127
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
d) Risk of Pollutant Release Due to Inundation
Would the project: In flood hazard, tsunami, or seiche zones, risk release of pollutants
due to project inundation?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The City is not within a tsunami hazard zone; a coastal zone; or a large body of water where there
would be a risk of seiche. As previously mentioned, new development would be required to comply
with the provisions of the CWA and the CCCWP through implementation of a SWPPP to reduce
impacts related to pollutant release. As previously mentioned, implementation of BMPs would be site-
specific and would therefore mitigate impacts related to pollutant release to a level that is less than
significant regardless of location within a flood hazard zone. Furthermore, new development would be
required to comply with 2040 General Plan Policy 9.4-I-8 (Not Increase Runoff to 100-Year Peak
Flow) and Policy 9.4-I-9 (Locate Buildings Above 100-Year Floodplain). Therefore, the 2040 General
Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site is located 13.4 miles east of the nearest coastline; thus, the proposed project is not
located within the coastal zone, nor is at risk for tsunami inundation. The project site is not near a
large body of water where there would be the risk of a seiche. Therefore, development of the project
site as proposed would not result in any environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed
project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
e) Water Quality Control or Sustainable Groundwater Management Plans Consistency
Would the project: Conflict with or obstruct implementation of a water quality control
plan or sustainable groundwater management plan?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
As previously mentioned, all new development would be required to comply with all applicable
regional and local requirements to conform with water quality objectives under the Basin Plan,
including the preparation of a project-specific SWPPP and compliance with all relevant 2040 General
Plan Policies mentioned under Impact 4.10(a).
The 2040 General Plan Area overlies the Sam Ramon Valley Groundwater Basin, which has been
designated by the DWR as Very Low Priority and therefore not required to be managed by a
Groundwater Sustainability Plan (GSP). The 2040 General Plan Area also overlies the Livermore
Valley Groundwater Basin, which is designated as Medium Priority and is regulated by the Zone 7
Water Agency as the exclusive GSP for compliance with the Sustainable Groundwater Management
Act within the 2040 General Plan Area. As previously mentioned, new development would be required
to implement project-specific SWPPPs during construction which would minimize or avoid conflict or
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
128 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
obstruction of implementation of a water quality control plan or sustainable groundwater management
plan. During operations, no groundwater supply would be sourced for new development serviced by
the EBMUD and groundwater used by new development serviced by the DSRSD would be regulated
under the GSP for the Basin. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would
be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use, Multi-Family District, and Neighborhood
Districts plus Grading of Interim Area)
Designation of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts does not include any construction. The
project site is within the Livermore Valley Groundwater Basin, which is regulated by a GSP.
Demolition and grading activities for the Neighborhood District and Interim Area would be compliant
with the NPDES Permit, meaning they would follow the required SWPPP, which includes BMPs to
prevent impacts to water quality during project construction. The proposed project does not include
direct groundwater consumption during construction or operation. The potential for impacts
associated with groundwater and water quality are typical of urban development and are adequately
covered by existing regulatory frameworks. Therefore, no additional site-specific or project-specific
impacts are anticipated.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed
project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in
the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
None.
Conclusion
With regard to Hydrology and Water Quality, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 129
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.11 Land Use and Planning
Would the project:
a) Physically divide an
established community?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Cause a significant
environmental impact due
to a conflict with any land
use plan, policy, or
regulation adopted for the
purpose of avoiding or
mitigating an environmental
effect?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
a) Division of an Established Community
Would the project: Physically divide an established community?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan Area is comprised of 20.09 square miles (approximately 12,861 acres) of land
within the San Ramon Planning Area. Vacant/undeveloped lands comprise approximately 1.5 percent
of all land within the 2040 General Plan Area. The majority of new development facilitated by the
2040 General Plan Area would involve infill development, and would be conducted in accordance with
net new residential and nonresidential development assumptions for all land within the 2040 General
Plan Area by 2040. To ensure that existing communities within the 2040 General Plan Area are
maintained, and that existing communities would not be divided, all new development would be
required to comply with applicable 2040 General Plan policies, including: Policy 4.6-I-10 (Provide a
Wide Range of Housing Opportunities); Policy 4.8-I-5 (Encourage Neighborhood Linkage and
Integration through Pedestrian and Bicycle Connections); Policy IP 11.5.1-6 (Maintain a Variety of
Housing Types for Jobs-to-Housing Ratio); and Policy IP 11.5.2-6 (Preservation of Affordable Housing
Units). These policies would be designed to promote orderly development while enhancing the City’s
multimodal circulation system, maximizing connections, and minimizing barriers to connectivity.
Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that the 2040 General Plan would not physically
divide a community and that impacts would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
130 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
Future development under the designated Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts includes the
construction of up to 2,084 residential units on an infill site, and would therefore not result in the
division of an established community. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar
to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
District designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Development of the proposed Neighborhood District would involve construction of up to 368
residential units and 58 ADUs at a vacant office building site. Development of the proposed
Neighborhood District would involve the construction of a proposed greenway and multiuse path
along the Neighborhood District’s outer boundaries, providing direct connections to adjacent office
park land uses to the east and indirect connections to commercial land uses to the north and
residential land uses to the south. Therefore, development of the proposed Neighborhood District
would not divide an established community. Furthermore, a multiuse path along the District’s outer
boundaries provides connections to Bollinger Canyon Road and the nearby Iron Horse Trail.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District
plus Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would
not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040
General Plan FEIR.
b) Conflict with Applicable Land Use Plans, Policies, or Regulations
Would the project: Cause a significant environmental impact due to a conflict with any
land use plan, policy, or regulation adopted for the purpose of
avoiding or mitigating an environmental effect?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan requires compliance with Association of Bay Area Governments/Metropolitan
Transportation Commission (ABAG/MTC) Plan Bay Area 2050 in promoting healthy, safe, and
equitable communities through enforcement of 2040 General Plan Policies, including: Policy IP
11.5.1-5 (Compliance with City Inclusionary Housing Ordinance); Policy IP 11.5.2-6 (Preservation of
Affordable Housing Units); Policy IP 11.5.1-6 (Maintain a Variety of Housing Types for Jobs-to-
Housing Ratio); and Policy IP 11.5.1-7 (Diversity of Unity Size and Bedroom Numbers for Multi-family
Housing); Policy IP 11.5.3-4 (Variety of Housing Types for Housing Mobility); and Policy 3.1-I-3
(Diverse Housing Options for Local Employment Base).
Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that the 2040 General Plan would not physically
divide a community and that impacts would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 131
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The project site has a land use and zoning designation of DMU-S. The purpose of the DMU-S land
use is to encourage a mixed-use neighborhood, extending the activity of City Center across Bollinger
Canyon Road with shops, offices, and a diversity of housing opportunities with walkable streets, parks
and trails. Designation of the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would be in
conformance with land use and zoning designations of the project site.
Future development under the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would include the
construction of up to 2,084 residential units on 37.3 acres, at a density of 55.87. As the DMU-S
designation allows for a density of up to 60 du/ac, future development of the 2,084 residential units
would be within what is permitted for DMU-S. Specifically, the Mixed-Use District would include up to
125,000 square feet of ground floor retail. Development of these Districts would also include bicycle
and pedestrian improvements, including those providing accessibility to the nearby Iron Horse Trail.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-
Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a
new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed Neighborhood District is located in the DMU-S land use designation. Development
under the DMU-S land use designation includes a permitted density range of between 20 to 60
du/acre; a minimum FAR of 1.25; a maximum height of 85 feet; and a minimum front setback distance
of 10 feet.
The proposed Neighborhood District, in combination with the anticipated development Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family Districts, would have a sitewide density of 47.2 du/acre. The Neighborhood District
would also have a FAR of 0.41 and building heights ranging from 26 to 34 feet tall and a minimum
front setback distance of 10 feet. Although the FAR of the Neighborhood District would be less than
the standard expressed in the General Plan, the proposed project would be eligible for a FAR waiver
under the State Density Bonus Law. As explained in CEQA Guidelines Section 15183(j)(2), “For
purposes of this section, ‘consistent’ means that the density of the proposed project is the same or
less than the standard expressed for the involved parcel in the general plan, community plan or
zoning action for which an EIR has been certified, and that the project complies with the density-
related standards contained in that plan or zoning.”
Furthermore, in accordance with the objectives of the DMU-S land use designation to encourage a
diversity of housing types and multimodal connections, development of the proposed Neighborhood
District would result in the construction of 368 residential units comprised of single-family homes,
townhomes, and vertical mixed-use units, in addition to 58 ADUs along with bicycle and pedestrian
connections to Bollinger Canyon Road and the nearby Iron Horse Trail. Therefore, there are no
environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
132 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not result in a new or
more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
None.
Conclusion
With regard to Land Use and Planning, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 133
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.12 Mineral Resources
Would the project:
a) Result in the loss of
availability of a known
mineral resource that would
be of value to the region
and the residents of the
State?
No impact No No No No
b) Result in the loss of
availability of a locally
important mineral resource
recovery site delineated on
a local general plan,
specific plan or other land
use plan?
No impact No No No No
a, b) Loss of Minerals Resources of Statewide or Local Importance
Would the project: a) Result in the loss of availability of a known mineral resource that
would be of value to the region and the residents of the State?
b) Result in the loss of availability of a locally important mineral
resource recovery site delineated on a local general plan, specific
plan or other land use plan?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
There are no significant mineral deposits or active mining operations within or in the vicinity of the
2040 General Plan Area. In addition, implementation of the proposed plan would not affect a locally
important mineral resource recovery site delineated by an applicable land use plan. Therefore, the
2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that there would be no impact.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
134 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The project site does not contain significant mineral resources and would not result in the loss of
availability of a locally important mineral resource recovery site.
Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed
project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact than what was previously identified
in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
None.
Conclusion
With regard to Minerals and Mineral Resources, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project would have no
impact with respect to mineral resources.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 135
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More
Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.13 Noise
Would the project:
a) Generation of a substantial
temporary or permanent
increase in ambient noise
levels in the vicinity of the
project in excess of
standards established in the
local general plan or noise
ordinance, or applicable
standards of other agencies?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
b) Generation of excessive
groundborne vibration or
groundborne noise levels?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
c) For a project located within
the vicinity of a private
airstrip or an airport land use
plan or, where such a plan
has not been adopted, within
two miles of a public airport
or public use airport, would
the project expose people
residing or working in the
project area to excessive
noise levels?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
Characteristics of Noise and Vibration
Noise is defined as unwanted sound. Sound levels are usually measured and expressed in decibels
(dB), with 0 dB corresponding roughly to the threshold of hearing. Most of the sounds that we hear in
the environment do not consist of a single frequency, but rather a broad band of frequencies, with
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
136 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
each frequency differing in sound level. The intensities of each frequency add together to generate a
sound. Noise is typically generated by transportation, specific land uses, and ongoing human activity.
The standard unit of measurement of the loudness of sound is the dB. The 0 point on the dB scale is
based on the lowest sound level that the healthy, unimpaired human ear can detect. Changes of 3 dB
or less are only perceptible in laboratory environments. A change of 3 dB is the lowest change that
can be perceptible to the human ear in outdoor environments. While a change of 5 A-weighted
decibel (dBA) is considered to be the minimum readily perceptible change to the human ear in
outdoor environments.
Since the human ear is not equally sensitive to sound at all frequencies, the dBA scale was derived to
relate noise to the sensitivity of humans. It gives greater weight to the frequencies of sound to which
the human ear is most sensitive. The A-weighted sound level is the basis for a number of various
sound level metrics, including the day/night sound level (Ldn) and the Community Noise Equivalent
Level (CNEL), both of which represent how humans are more sensitive to sound at night. In addition,
the equivalent continuous sound level (Leq) is the average sound energy of time-varying noise over a
sample period and the Lmax is the maximum instantaneous noise level occurring over a sample
period.
Groundborne vibration consists of rapidly fluctuating motion through a solid medium, specifically the
ground, which has an average motion of zero and in which the motion’s amplitude can be described
in terms of displacement, velocity, or acceleration. The effects of groundborne vibration typically only
cause a nuisance to people, but in extreme cases, excessive groundborne vibration has the potential
to cause structural damage to buildings. Although groundborne vibration can be felt outdoors, it is
typically only an annoyance to people indoors where the associated effects of the shaking of a
building can be notable. Groundborne noise is an effect of groundborne vibration and only exists
indoors, since it is produced from noise radiated from the motion of the walls and floors of a room,
and may also consist of the rattling of windows or dishes on shelves.
Several different methods are used to quantify vibration amplitude such as the maximum
instantaneous peak in the vibrations velocity, which is known as the peak particle velocity (PPV) or
the root mean square (rms) amplitude of the vibration velocity.
Existing Noise Environment
An ambient noise monitoring effort was conducted to document daytime ambient noise levels on the
project site. Short-term noise monitoring was conducted by FCS on October 31, 2025, between 11:16
and 11:56 a.m. Dominant noise sources in the vicinity included freeway traffic from I-680, as well as
pedestrian activity and parking lot noise located near the site. The documented daytime average
noise levels range from 43.1 dBA to 67.6 dBA Leq on the project site. The noise monitoring data
sheets are included in Appendix H.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 137
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
a) Noise Levels in Excess of Adopted Standards
Would the project result in: Generation of a substantial temporary or permanent
increase in ambient noise levels in the vicinity of the project
in excess of standards established in the local general plan
or noise ordinance, or applicable standards of other
agencies?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The City identified potential significant construction noise impacts that could occur with
implementation of the General Plan. To reduce these potential impacts, the City stated that new
development would be expected to comply with 2040 General Plan policies for reducing construction
noise impacts, including Policy 10.1-I-14 requiring implementation of all best management practice
noise attenuation measures for limiting adverse impacts. In addition, the City identified that MM NOI-1
was required to ensure construction noise impacts would be reduced to less than significant. This
mitigation measure requires implementation of best management noise reduction measures and use
of temporary sound barriers, if needed, to ensure construction noise for development projects within
the City would be reduced to below the significance threshold. Thus, impacts would be less than
significant with mitigation.
The City also identified potential traffic noise increase impacts that could occur with implementation of
the General Plan. The analysis identified multiple City policies that would help reduce traffic noise
impacts. Although compliance with these policies would reduce roadway noise, the City found that
impacts resulting from roadway vehicle noise would remain potentially significant. Therefore, new
development would be required to implement MM NOI-2, implementation of operational roadway
vehicle noise reduction measures, in order to reduce impacts. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR
concluded that impacts would be less than significant with mitigation. In addition, the City identified
potential stationary noise impacts from sources such as HVAC systems, loading docks, maintenance
activities, and other intermittent or continuous noise-generating uses associated with residential,
commercial, and public facilities. The analysis noted that the proposed Noise Element includes
guiding and implementing policies requiring noise analyses for projects exceeding normally
acceptable levels, attenuation measures, and protection of sensitive receptors. Implementation of
these policies would ensure that stationary noise impacts are minimized and mitigated to acceptable
levels. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that stationary operational noise impacts
would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
Construction Noise Impacts
A significant impact would occur if project construction activities would generate a substantial
temporary substantial increase in ambient noise levels as measured at sensitive receptors in excess
of established standards. According to the policies of the General Plan, construction activities should
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
138 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
be commissioned to occur during normal work hours of the day to provide relative quiet during the
more sensitive evening and early morning periods.
In compliance with the methodology of the 2040 General Plan EIR, this analysis uses the noise limits
established by the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) to determine the potential construction noise
impacts. The FTA identifies construction noise limits in the Transit Noise and Vibration Impact
Assessment Manual. During daytime hours, a significant temporary increase would be an increase in
excess of the average daily noise level of 80 dBA Leq(8-hr) as measured at a receiving residential land
use.
Although there are no site-specific development plans, construction activities associated with future
development could result in the potential for construction noise to reach a relatively high single event
resulting in temporary substantial increase in ambient noise levels in the vicinity of the proposed
project in excess of established standards, potentially resulting in an intermittent noise nuisance that
could result in annoyance or sleep disturbances at nearby sensitive receptors. Therefore, to ensure
compliance with City standards, Mitigation Measure NOI-1 must be implemented. This measure
requires the use of BMPs, compliance with restricted construction hours, and installation of temporary
sound barriers, as needed, to ensure that construction noise would not exceed the FTA’s construction
noise thresholds of 80 dBA Leq(8-hr) as measured at a receiving residential land use. In addition, the
City’s General Plan EIR mandates implementation of General Plan Policy 10.1-I-14, which requires all
feasible noise attenuation measures to be applied.
With implementation of MM NOI-1 and adherence to applicable General Plan policies, construction
noise impacts would be reduced to less than significant.
Operational/Stationary Source Noise Impacts
A significant impact would occur if operational noise levels generated by stationary noise sources at
the project site would result in a substantial permanent increase in ambient noise levels in excess of
normally acceptable thresholds for receiving land uses.
Although specific operational details are not yet available, implementation of future development
could introduce new stationary and mobile noise sources, such as HVAC systems, mechanical
equipment, and increased vehicle traffic. To ensure compliance with City standards and reduce
potential impacts, new development would be required to implement Mitigation Measure NOI-2, which
includes operational roadway vehicle noise reduction strategies.
Additionally, the City’s General Plan EIR identifies policies designed to minimize operational noise
impacts, including requirements for noise analysis, acoustical studies, noise attenuation measures,
and disclosure of potential significant noise impacts. These policies are mandatory and would apply
to all future development within the Future Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts.
With implementation of MM NOI-2 and adherence to applicable General Plan policies, operational
noise impacts would be reduced to less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 139
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-
Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a
new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Construction Noise Impacts
A significant impact would occur if project construction activities would generate a substantial
temporary substantial increase in ambient noise levels as measured at sensitive receptors in excess
of established standards. According to the policies of the General Plan, construction activities should
be commissioned to occur during normal work hours of the day to provide relative quiet during the
more sensitive evening and early morning periods.
In compliance with the methodology of the 2040 General Plan EIR, this analysis uses the noise limits
established by the FTA to determine the potential construction noise impacts. As such, during daytime
hours, a significant temporary increase would be an increase in excess of the average daily noise
level of 80 dBA Leq(8-hr) as measured at a receiving residential land use.
Construction is completed in discrete steps, each of which has its own mix of equipment and,
consequently, its own noise characteristics. These various sequential phases would change the
character of the noise generated on the site and, therefore, the noise levels surrounding the site as
construction progresses. Despite the variety in the type and size of construction equipment,
similarities in the dominant noise sources and patterns of operation allow construction-related noise
ranges to be categorized by work phase. Typical operating cycles for these types of construction
equipment may involve 1 or 2 minutes of full power operation followed by 3 or 4 minutes at lower
power settings. Impact equipment such as pile drivers are not proposed for construction of this
project.
The site preparation phase, which includes excavation and grading of the site, tends to generate the
highest noise levels because the noisiest construction equipment is earthmoving equipment.
Earthmoving equipment expected to be used includes excavators, bulldozers, backhoes, front
loaders, and graders.
The closest noise-sensitive receptor to the project site is a single-family residence located south of
the project site. This closest noise-sensitive receptor would be located approximately 50 feet from the
closest footprint of construction activity where heavy construction equipment would potentially
operate at the project site. To calculate the reasonable worst-case hourly and 8-hour average
construction noise levels, the modeling assumed the loudest piece of equipment operating at the
point of the closest footprint with the next four loudest pieces of equipment operating at the nearest
safe distance from that closest piece of equipment. Based on these assumptions, reasonable worst-
case maximum hourly average construction noise levels would attenuate to below 82 dBA Leq at the
closest residential receptor. The reasonable worst-case calculated 8-hour noise level would be 75
dBA Leq(8-hr), as measured at this nearest sensitive receptor. The calculation spreadsheet with the
detailed modeling assumptions is included in Appendix H.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
140 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
The calculated worst-case construction noise levels do not exceed the FTA’s 80 dBA Leq(8-hr) threshold
as measured at the nearest residential receptors. Therefore, temporary or periodic noise impacts
from construction activities associated with implementation of the proposed project would be less
than significant.
This analysis demonstrates that the proposed project complies with the requirements of the 2040
General Plan Policy 10.1-I-14 requiring measures for limiting adverse construction noise impacts and
meets the requirements of General Plan EIR MM NOI-1 since project construction noise would not
exceed the significance threshold of 80 dBA Leq (8-hr) during the daytime at residential uses and other
sensitive receptors in all cases.
Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed
project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact than what was previously identified
in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
Operational Stationary Source Noise Impacts
A significant impact would occur if operational noise levels generated by stationary noise sources at
the project site would result in a substantial permanent increase in ambient noise levels in excess of
normally acceptable thresholds for receiving land uses. The General Plan Noise Element established
the following thresholds for stationary noise sources.
• The ambient noise level is less than 60 dB Ldn and the project increases noise levels by 5 dB or
more.
• The ambient noise level is 60-65 dB Ldn and the project increases noise levels by 3 dB or more.
• The ambient noise level is greater than 65 dB Ldn and the project increases noise levels by 1.5
dB or more.
The primary stationary noise source associated with implementation of the proposed project would be
new mechanical ventilation system operations.
Mechanical Equipment Operations
Typical residential-grade mechanical ventilation equipment systems range up to approximately 70
dBA Leq at a distance of 3 feet. Proposed mechanical ventilation systems would be located adjacent
to each proposed residential unit.
The nearest sensitive receptor to potential mechanical ventilation system locations is a single-family
residence located south of the project site. The façade of this receptor could be located approximately
120 feet from the nearest proposed mechanical ventilation system. At this distance, noise generated
by proposed mechanical ventilation equipment would attenuate to 24 dBA Leq. The calculation
spreadsheet is included in Appendix H.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 141
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
These projected noise levels are well below the documented existing ambient noise levels, which
range from 43.1 dBA Leq to 67.6 dBA Leq. The noise monitoring data is included in Appendix H.
Therefore, noise levels from proposed mechanical ventilation equipment operations would not result
in a substantial permanent increase in ambient noise levels in the project vicinity and the impact of
noise produced by project-related mechanical ventilation equipment operations to off-site sensitive
receptors would be less than significant.
Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed
project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact than what was previously identified
in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
Operational Mobile Source Noise Impacts
Mobile Source Noise Impacts
A significant impact would occur if implementation of the proposed project would result in a
substantial increase in traffic noise levels compared with traffic noise levels existing without the
proposed project. The General Plan Noise Element established the following thresholds for mobile
noise sources:
• The ambient noise level is less than 60 dB Ldn and the project increases noise levels by 5 dB or
more.
• The ambient noise level is 60-65 dB Ldn and the project increases noise levels by 3 dB or more.
• The ambient noise level is greater than 65 dB Ldn and the project increases noise levels by 1.5
dB or more.
Based on the traffic analysis prepared for this project, the proposed project would generate
approximately 2,442 net new average daily trips. Based on the traffic analysis prepared for this
project, Bolinger Canyon Road, where 100 percent of the project trips would occur as they access the
project site, currently experiences 3,998 AM peak-hour trips and 4,228 PM peak-hour trips, which
conservatively represents a minimum of 42,200 average daily trips under existing conditions.
Therefore, project trips would clearly not double existing traffic volumes on roadway segments
accessing the project site. Therefore, the project Average Daily Traffic (ADT) of 2,442 would not result
in even a 1 dBA increase in traffic noise levels along this, or any other, roadway segment in the
project vicinity. Therefore, project-related traffic would result in a less than significant permanent
increase in traffic noise levels.
Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
142 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
b) Groundborne Vibration
Would the project result in: Generation of excessive groundborne vibration or
groundborne noise levels?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The City identified that new development generated from buildout of the 2040 General Plan Area
would result in intermittent groundborne vibration during construction. The analysis identified that all
new development would be required to comply with 2040 General Plan Policy 10.1-I-18 (Mitigate
Below Federal Transit Administration-Recommend Criteria) and would be required to implement MM
NOI-3, requiring preparation of a noise and vibration analysis and implementation of construction
vibration controls and setbacks, to reduce impacts. Therefore, construction-related groundborne
vibration impacts would be less than significant with mitigation.
The analysis also identified that no operational groundborne vibration impacts would occur from the
development that could occur under the General Plan; thus, operational groundborne vibration
impacts were determined to be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
Construction Vibration Impacts
A significant impact would occur if the proposed project would generate groundborne vibration or
groundborne noise levels in excess of established standards. As required by Policy 10.1-I-18 of the
City’s 2040 General Plan, all new development must mitigate vibration levels below FTA
recommended criteria. Therefore, the FTA vibration impact thresholds are applied in this analysis.
These guidelines are published in its Transit Noise and Vibration Impact Assessment Manual.30
Although there are no site-specific development plans proposed at this time for this portion of the
project site, construction activities associated with future development in the proposed Future Mixed-
Use and Multi-Family Districts could potentially result in construction vibration levels that could
exceed the FTA’s damage threshold criteria for receiving structures. As a result, mitigation would be
required to reduce this potential impact. Therefore, consistent with the 2040 General Plan FEIR,
future development would be required to implement General Plan EIR MM NOI-3, which mandates
preparation of a noise and vibration analysis and implementation of construction vibration controls
and setbacks. These measures would ensure that vibration impacts generated by future development
projects would be reduced to a less than significant impact at residential uses and other sensitive
receptors in all cases.
Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-
Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District Designations would not result in a
30 Federal Transit Administration (FTA). 2018. Transit Noise and Vibration Impact Assessment Manual. September.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 143
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
new or more severe adverse impact than what was previously identified in the 2040 General Plan
EIR.
Operational Vibration Impacts
Implementation of the proposed project would not include any permanent sources that would expose
persons in the project vicinity to groundborne vibration levels that could be perceptible without
instruments at any receiving property line. Therefore, project operational groundborne vibration level
impacts would be less than significant.
Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-
Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District Designations would not result in a
new or more severe adverse impact than what was previously identified in the 2040 General Plan
EIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Construction Vibration Impacts
A significant impact would occur if the proposed project would generate groundborne vibration or
groundborne noise levels in excess of established standards. As required by Policy 10.1-I-18 of the
City’s 2040 General Plan, all new development must mitigate vibration levels below FTA
recommended criteria. Therefore, the FTA vibration impact thresholds are applied in this analysis.
These guidelines are published in its Transit Noise and Vibration Impact Assessment Manual.
Of the variety of equipment that would be used during construction, a large vibratory roller would
produce the greatest groundborne vibration levels nearest the project boundaries. A large vibratory
roller can produce groundborne vibration levels ranging up to 0.210 inch per second (in/sec) PPV at
25 feet from the operating equipment. Impact equipment such as pile drivers is not expected to be
used during construction of this project.
The closest structure to the project site would be a pool located approximately 130 feet south from
the nearest construction footprint where a large vibratory roller would potentially operate. At this
distance, groundborne vibration levels would range up to 0.017 in/sec PPV from operation of a large
vibratory roller. This is well below the FTA’s Construction Vibration Impact Criteria of 0.5 in/sec PPV
for this type of structure, which is a structure constructed of reinforced concrete. In addition, the
closest that other heavy equipment such as a large bulldozer would operate would be 50 feet from
the pool, and at this distance vibration levels would attenuate to approximately 0.031 in/sec PPV,
which is still below the FTA’s threshold of 0.5 in/sec PPV for this type of structure. Accordingly,
construction activities would not adversely impact this structure.
The nearest off-site residential structure would be a located approximately 160 feet south from the
nearest construction footprint where a large vibratory roller would potentially operate. At this distance,
groundborne vibration levels would range up to 0.012 in/sec PPV from operation of a large vibratory
roller. This is well below the FTA’s Construction Vibration Impact Criteria of 0.5 in/sec PPV for this
type of structure, which is a building of nonengineered timber and masonry construction. Other heavy
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
144 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
equipment such as a large bulldozer could operate as close as 50 feet from the residential structure,
and at this distance vibration levels would be approximately 0.031 in/sec PPV, which is still below the
applicable threshold of 0.20 in/sec PPV for this type of structure. As a result, construction of the
proposed project would not expose nearby buildings to groundborne vibration levels in excess of their
applicable FTA damage criteria and this impact would be less than significant.
This analysis demonstrates that the proposed project complies with the requirements of the 2040
General Plan Policy 10.1-I-18, which calls for mitigating construction vibration impacts below the FTA
recommended criteria. The analysis also demonstrates that the project meets the criteria of General
Plan EIR MM NOI-3. Therefore, MM NOI-3 does not apply to this project-level portion, and project
construction vibration would not exceed the significance threshold at residential uses and other
sensitive receptors in all cases.
Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
Operational Vibration Impacts
The City does not have adopted operational vibration impact criteria; therefore, consistent with the
General Plan EIR, operational vibration impacts are evaluated qualitatively. Implementation of the
proposed project would not include any permanent sources that would expose persons in the project
vicinity to groundborne vibration levels that could be perceptible without instruments at any receiving
property line. In addition, there are no existing significant permanent sources of groundborne vibration
in the project vicinity to which the proposed project would be exposed. Therefore, project operational
groundborne vibration level impacts would be less than significant.
Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
c) Airport or Private Airstrip Noise
Would the project result in: For a project located within the vicinity of a private
airstrip or an airport land use plan or, where such a plan
has not been adopted, within two miles of a public
airport or public use airport, would the project expose
people residing or working in the project area to
excessive noise levels?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
As noted in the 2040 General Plan FEIR, impacts related to airport or private airstrip noise would be
limited to operational impacts. The nearest airport to San Ramon is the Livermore Municipal Airport,
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 145
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
which is located approximately 4.7 miles southeast of the City boundary. The 2040 General Plan Area
does not fall within the 60 dBA CNEL noise contours of the Livermore Municipal Airport. The
Livermore Municipal Airport does not offer commercial airline service and therefore would not be
impacted by buildout of the 2040 General Plan Area. As such, there would be no exposure of
residents or workers to excessive noise. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that
impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The entire project site is not located within 2 miles of a public airport or private airstrip or within an
airport land use plan. The nearest airport facility is the Livermore Municipal Airport, approximately 8.1
miles southeast of the project site. While aircraft noise is occasionally audible at the project site, due
to the distance from the airport and the orientation of runways and flight patterns, the project site does
not lie within 60 dBA CNEL noise contours of Livermore Municipal Airport. Therefore, implementation
of the proposed project would not expose persons residing or working in the project vicinity to noise
levels from airport activity that would exceed normally acceptable standards for the proposed land
use development, and no impact would occur.
Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed
project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact than what was previously identified
in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
MM NOI-1 Include and Implement Construction Noise Reduction Measures
To minimize noise during construction, construction contractors shall implement the
following measures for construction activities conducted within San Ramon.
Construction plans submitted to the City shall include construction noise analysis and
identify these measures on demolition, grading, and construction plans submitted to
the City. The City of San Ramon Building Division and/or Public Works Department
shall verify that grading, demolition, and/or construction plans submitted to the City
include these notations prior to issuance of demolition, grading and/or building
permits.
• Mufflers. During excavation and grading construction phases, all construction
equipment, fixed or mobile, shall be operated with closed engine doors and shall
be equipped with properly operating and maintained mufflers consistent with
manufacturers’ standards.
• Stationary Equipment. All stationary construction equipment shall be placed so
that emitted noise is directed away from the nearest sensitive receivers.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
146 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
• Equipment Staging Areas. Equipment staging shall be located in areas that will
create the greatest distance feasible between construction-related noise sources
and noise-sensitive receivers.
• Smart Backup Alarms. Mobile construction equipment shall have smart backup
alarms that automatically adjust the sound level of the alarm in response to
ambient noise levels. Alternatively, backup alarms shall be disabled and replaced
with human spotters to ensure safety when mobile construction equipment is
moving in the reverse direction in compliance with applicable safety laws and
regulations.
• Electrically-Powered Tools and Facilities. Electrical power shall be used to run
air compressors and similar power tools and to power any temporary structures,
such as construction trailers or caretaker facilities, where feasible.
• Noise Disturbance Coordinator. The project applicant shall designate a “noise
disturbance coordinator” responsible for responding to any local complaints about
construction noise. The disturbance coordinator shall determine the cause of any
noise complaint and shall require that reasonable measures be implemented to
correct the problem. A telephone number for the disturbance coordinator and the
City shall be posted at the construction site.
• Temporary Noise Barriers. Erect temporary noise barriers, where feasible, when
construction noise is predicted to exceed the acceptable standards (e.g., 80 dBA
Leq at residential receivers, schools or other sensitive receptors during the daytime)
and when the anticipated construction duration is greater than is typical (e.g., two
years or greater). Temporary noise barriers shall be constructed with solid
materials (e.g., wood) with a density of at least 1.5 pounds per square foot with no
gaps from the ground to the top of the barrier. If a sound blanket is used, barriers
shall be constructed with solid material with a density of at least 1 pound per
square foot with no gaps from the ground to the top of the barrier and be lined on
the construction side with acoustical blanket, curtain or equivalent absorptive
material rated Sound Transmission Class (STC) 32 or higher.
MM NOI-3 Prepare a Noise and Vibration Analysis and Implement Construction Vibration
Control Measures and Screening Distances
Prior to issuance of a building permit for a project requiring pile driving during
construction (a) within 135 feet of fragile structures (historical resources, 100 feet of
nonengineered timber and masonry buildings [e.g., most residential buildings], or
within 75 feet of engineered concrete and masonry (no plaster); (b) a vibratory roller
within 40 feet of fragile historical resources or 25 feet of any other structure; and/or d)
a dozer or other large earthmoving equipment within 20 feet for a fragile historical
structure and/or (c) 15 feet of any other structure, the project applicant shall prepare
a groundborne noise and vibration analysis to assess and mitigate potential noise
and vibration impacts related to these construction activities. This noise and vibration
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 147
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
analysis shall be conducted by a qualified and experienced acoustical consultant or
engineer. The vibration levels shall not exceed FTA architectural damage thresholds
(e.g., 0.12 in/sec PPV for fragile or historical resources, 0.2 in/sec PPV for
nonengineered timber and masonry buildings, and 0.3 in/sec PPV for engineered
concrete and masonry). If vibration levels would exceed this threshold, alternative
uses such as drilling piles as opposed to pile driving, static rollers as opposed to
vibratory rollers, and lower horsepower earthmoving equipment shall be used. If
necessary, construction vibration monitoring shall be conducted to ensure FTA
vibration thresholds are not exceeded.
Conclusion
With regard to Noise, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
148 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.14 Population and Housing
Would the project:
a) Induce substantial
unplanned population
growth in an area, either
directly (for example, by
proposing new homes and
businesses) or indirectly
(for example, through
extension of roads or other
infrastructure)?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Displace substantial
numbers of existing people
or housing, necessitating
the construction of
replacement housing
elsewhere?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
a) Growth Inducement
Would the project: Induce substantial population growth in an area, either directly (for
example, by proposing new homes and businesses) or indirectly (for
example, through extension of roads or other infrastructure)?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The ABAG projections for the 2040 General Plan Area suggest that the City’s population would grow
by approximately 0.4 percent (approximately 345 new residents); the number of dwelling units are
expected to increase by 5 percent (approximately 1,460 new dwelling units) and the number of jobs
would increase by 32.9 percent (approximately 17,775 new jobs) between 2022 and 2040. New
development facilitated by the 2040 General Plan is expected to result in approximately 30,874 new
residents and 11,812 net new residential units, resulting in more than a 35 percent increase in total
population projections over that assumed by ABAG. However, growth anticipated by ABAG is based
on existing land use assumptions, and growth anticipated by the 2040 General Plan would meet
regional housing needs over the long-term through the facilitation of affordable housing and
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 149
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
increasing the jobs-to-household ratio. These aims would be met through implementation of relevant
2040 General Plan policies, including Policy IP 11.5.4-1 (Diverse Housing Options for Infill
Development), in addition to the 2040 General Plan’s prioritization of infill development during Plan
buildout. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than
significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
While no development is currently proposed in the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts, it is
anticipated that the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District would generate 2,084 residential units. The
Neighborhood District proposes 368 units, including 58 ADUs, resulting in a total unit count of 426
residential units. The Department of Finance (DOF) estimates that the average household size in the
City is 2.86.31 As such, the 2,048 residential units anticipated for the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
Districts is expected to generate approximately 5,960 persons.32 The Neighborhood District is
expected to generate approximately 1,218 persons.33 In total, the proposed project would construct a
maximum of 2,510 units and is estimated to result in 7,179 residents.
The DMU-S land use designation allows for a density of 20 to 60 du/acre, meaning a maximum of
5,490 residential units is permitted at the project site.34 As such the proposed project would be within
the envelope of residents anticipated in the General Plan. As such, the anticipated population
increase from future development under the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would be
considered planned growth consistent with the City’s projections. Therefore, there are no
environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project would not result
in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan
FEIR.
b) Displacement of Persons or Housing
Would the project: Displace substantial numbers of existing people or housing,
necessitating the construction of replacement housing elsewhere?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan proposes approximately 11,812 new housing units by 2040 across a variety
of housing types to accommodate new development. The 2040 General Plan also does not propose
the demolition of existing residences. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan would not result in substantial
31 Department of Finance (DOF). E-5 Population and Housing Estimates for Cities, Counties, and the State, 2020-2025.
Website: https://dof.ca.gov/forecasting/demographics/estimates/e-5-population-and-housing-estimates-for-cities-
counties-and-the-state-2020-2025/. Accessed September 22, 2025.
32 (2.86 persons/household) * (2,084 households) = 5,960 persons.
33 (2.86 persons/household)*(426 households) = 1,218 persons.
34 (60 du/acre) * (91.5 acres) = 5,490 du.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
150 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
numbers of displacement necessitating the construction of replacement housing elsewhere. Thus, the
2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed project would result in the demolition of a vacant office park and parking area. It would
not displace any people or housing and would not necessitate any replacement housing. Therefore,
there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project
would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the
2040 General Plan FEIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
None.
Conclusion
With regard to Population and Housing, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 151
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More
Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.15 Public Services
Would the project result in substantial adverse physical impacts associated with the provision of new
or physically altered governmental facilities, need for new or physically altered governmental
facilities, the construction of which could cause significant environmental impacts, in order to
maintain acceptable service ratios, response times or other performance objectives for any of the
public services:
a) Fire protection? Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Police protection? Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
c) Schools? Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
d) Parks? Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
e) Other public facilities? Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
a) Fire Protection
Would the project: Result in substantial adverse physical impacts associated with the
provision of new or physically altered governmental facilities, need
for new or physically altered governmental facilities, the
construction of which could cause significant environmental
impacts, in order to maintain acceptable service ratios, response
times or other performance objectives for any of the public services:
Fire protection?
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
152 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The SRVFPD provides fire protection services within the 2040 General Plan Area and operates nine
fire stations with 14 fire companies and approximately 45 full-time staff members. SRVFPD response
times for first unit response are approximately seven minutes and 33 seconds in urban areas; and
eight minutes in suburban areas. Medical responses are approximately 10 minutes in urban and
suburban areas. Buildout of the 2040 General Plan would result in a net increase of approximately
11,812 residential units and the addition of 30,874 net new residents. To accommodate the
anticipated demand for new facilities, the SRVFPD would review all development plans to ensure
consistency with all federal, State, and local regulations, including the requirements of the 2022 CFC
for building construction standards, road widths and configurations to allow for fire truck and engine
circulation, requirements for sprinkler systems, and minimum flow rates for water mains. New
development would be required to comply with applicable 2040 General Plan Policies, including
Policy 3.3-I-4 (Review of Impacts Public Services); Policy 7-6-I-2 (Coordination with SRVFPD); and
Policy 7.6-I-2 (Input from SRVFPD during the Review Process). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan
FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The designation of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts does not include any proposed
construction. However, as explained under Impact 4.15(a), future development of the Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family Districts could eventually result in a population growth of up to 5,960 persons.35
However, the maximum density that would be permitted under the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
Districts is consistent with the General Plan. As such, while the increase in population could
eventually result in an increase in demand for fire protection, this increased demand would not be
beyond what is already anticipated by the General Plan. Future development of these Districts would
be subject to review by the SRVFPD for consistency with the 2022 CFC building construction
standards and inclusion of fire protection measures. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
District designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are
peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
As explained under Impact 4.15(a), development of the Neighborhood District would result in a
population increase of up to 1,218 new residents; however, this population growth is anticipated in the
General Plan, which also accounts for the corresponding increase in demand for fire protection
services. Furthermore, the SRVFPD has reviewed the proposed project and provided standard
conditions of approval.36 Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the
proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District
35 (2.86 persons/household) * (2,084 households) = 5,960 persons.
36 Letter from the San Ramon Valley Fire Protection District (SRVFPD), Community Risk Reduction Division. July 15, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 153
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
plus Grading of Interim Area would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
b) Police Protection
Would the project: Result in substantial adverse physical impacts associated with the
provision of new or physically altered governmental facilities, need
for new or physically altered governmental facilities, the
construction of which could cause significant environmental
impacts, in order to maintain acceptable service ratios, response
times or other performance objectives for any of the public services:
Police protection?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Law enforcement services within San Ramon city limits are provided by the San Ramon Police
Department (SRPD), which consists of 70 sworn officers, 19 civilian staff, and 40 volunteers. Law
enforcement services in the General Plan Area outside of San Ramon city limits are provided by the
Contra Costa County Office of the Sheriff, which consists of approximately 723 sworn officers and
377 professional employees and operates six stations and administrative offices. As previously
mentioned, the 2040 General Plan would result in a net increase of approximately 11,812 residential
units and the addition of 30,874 net new residents. Buildout from the 2040 General Plan would be
concentrated as infill development and would therefore likely occur on previously disturbed or
developed areas; therefore, adverse impacts resulting from the construction of new police facilities
would be considered less than significant. Furthermore, deployment of applicable 2040 General Plan
policies, including Policy 78.7-I-1 (Participation in the Crime Prevention Through Environmental
Design program [CPTED]); Policy 7.7-I-2 (Monitoring of New Development in Unincorporated Areas);
and Policy 7.7.-I-3 (Funding Mechanism to Support Police Services), would ensure that new
development would not exceed the service capacity of the SRVFPD and that adequate staffing levels
would be provided through year 2040. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that
impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The designation of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts does not include any proposed
construction. However, as explained under Impact 4.15(a), future development of the Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family Districts could eventually result in a population growth of up to 5,960 persons. This is
within the maximum density that would be permitted under the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts
and is consistent with the General Plan. As such, while the increase in population could eventually
result in an increase in demand for police protection services, this increased demand would not
exceed what is already anticipated by the General Plan. Therefore, there are no environmental effects
that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was
not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
154 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area)
As previously mentioned under Impact 4.15(a), development of the Neighborhood District would
result in an increase of up to 1,218 persons37 which would result in an increase in demand on police
protection services. As such, while the increase in population could eventually result in an increase in
demand for police protection services, this increased demand would not be beyond what is already
anticipated by the General Plan. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the
proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District
plus Grading of Interim Area would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
c) Schools
Would the project: Result in substantial adverse physical impacts associated with the
provision of new or physically altered governmental facilities, need
for new or physically altered governmental facilities, the
construction of which could cause significant environmental
impacts, in order to maintain acceptable service ratios, response
times or other performance objectives for any of the public services:
Schools?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The SRVUSD serves the 2040 General Plan Area and contains 14 elementary schools; five middle
schools; and three high schools. The 2040 General Plan would result in a net increase of
approximately 11,812residential units and the addition of 30,874 net new residents, including
approximately 6,835 students to the SRVUSD by 2040 based on the proportion of the projected
number of detached single-family housing within 2040 General Plan buildout.38 As previously
mentioned, the 2040 General Plan would prioritize infill development so construction impacts related
to the construction of new school facilities would be less than significant. To ensure that operational
impacts of the school would not exceed SRVUSD capacity due to increased enrollment, the City
would implement 2040 General Plan Policies involving collaboration with the SRVUSD on meeting
enrollment needs, including Policy 7.2-I-1 (Development of Public “School Parks”) and Policy 7.2-I-4
(Student Generation Rates). Additionally, new development facilitated by the 2040 General Plan
would be required to pay SRVUSD school impact fees pursuant to Section 65995(3)(h) of the
California Government Code. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would
be less than significant.
37 (2.86 persons/household)*(426 households) = 1,218 persons.
38 City of San Ramon. 2021. General Plan Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR). Page 3.11-22.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 155
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The designation of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts does not include any proposed
construction. However, as explained under Impact 4.15(a), future development of the Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family Districts could eventually result in a population growth of up to 5,960 persons. The
maximum density that would be permitted under the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts is
consistent with the General Plan. As such, while this increase in population would result in increased
demand on schools, this increased demand would not exceed what is already anticipated by the
General Plan. Future development of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would still be required
to pay school impact fees. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the
proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District
designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area)
Development of the Neighborhood District would result in the development of 368 single-family
detached dwelling units, which would result in an increase in school enrollment. Based on the City’s
student generation rates, this would result in 96 K-5 students, 67 Grade 6-8 students, and 118 Grade
9-12 students, for a total of 281 new students within the SRVUSD.39,40,41 Because the residential
density of the Neighborhood District and the proposed project as a whole is within what was
anticipated for the site by the 2040 General Plan, this increase in students was already accounted for
by the 2040 General Plan FEIR. The payment of school impact fees would be required. Therefore,
there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
39 0.25 K-5 students/single-family detached unit * 368 single-family detached units = 96 K-5 students
40 0.18 Grade 6-8 students/single-family detached unit * 368 single-family detached units = 67 Grade 6-8 students
41 0.32 Grade 9-12 students/ single-family detached unit * 368 single-family detached units = 118 Grade 9-12 students
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
156 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
d, e) Parks and Other Public Services?
Would the project: Result in substantial adverse physical impacts associated with the
provision of new or physically altered governmental facilities, need
for new or physically altered governmental facilities, the
construction of which could cause significant environmental
impacts, in order to maintain acceptable service ratios, response
times or other performance objectives for any of the public services:
Parks? Other public services?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Parkland within the 2040 General Plan Area totals approximately 395 acres and is managed by the
San Ramon Parks and Community Services Department (SRPCSD). This includes approximately 140
acres of neighborhood parks, 78 acres of school parks, 108 acres of community parks, 78 acres of
specialized recreation areas, and 22 acres of public spaces. The Iron Horse Trail, a regional multiuse
trail, runs north–south through the City along the I-680. To maintain the City’s parkland ratio of 6.5
acres per 1,000 residents, implementation of applicable 2040 General Plan policies would ensure the
availability of parkland and recreational facilities to meet City needs, including Policy 4.6-I-14
(Clustered Development for Four or More Units); Policy 4.8-I-6 (Maximize Public Access to the Iron
Horse Trail); Policy 4.8-I-19 (Well-Designed Parks and Recreational Amenities); Policy 5.7-I-4
(Connection Points and Adjacent Amenities Along the Iron Horse Trail); Policy 6.5-I-5 (Dedications for
Land, Improvements, and/or In Lieu Fees); Policy 6.5-I-8 (Completion of Parkland Dedication
Requirements Prior to Final Occupancy); Policy 6.5-I-9 (Development of Landscaped and Dedicated
Public Spaces); and Policy 6.5-I-18 (Provision of Public Spaces for Active or Passive Use). Therefore,
the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts to parks would be less than significant.
The Contra Costa County Library System operates two Library Locations in the General Plan Area:
the San Ramon Library is located at 100 Montgomery Street, and the Dougherty Station Library is
located at 17017 Bollinger Canyon Road. To enhance library services in response to increased
community need throughout buildout of the 2040 General Plan, the City would implement Policy 7.1-I-
1 (Confer with Contra Costa County Library) and similar policies to maintain services.
Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts to other public facilities would be less
than significant.
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
No construction is proposed as part of the designation of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts.
Future development under the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts could result in up to
5,960 new residents. This addition of residents would require up to an additional 38.7 acres of
parkland to maintain the City’s ratio of 6.5 acres per 1,000 residents.42
42 6.5 acres * (5,960) residents/1000 residents) = 38.7 acres
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 157
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
It is anticipated that future development of the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would partially
offset this requirement by constructing approximately 246,578 square feet, or 5.66 acres of parkland
space, including a 2.5-acre park as well as the construction of a greenway and multiuse path along
the project’s perimeter.43 The project applicant would also be required to pay parkland impact fees
equivalent to the park acreage that would not be included as part of the proposed Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family Districts.
The closest library to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts, the San Ramon Library, is
located approximately 0.31 mile east of the project site. Development of the proposed Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family Districts would result in an increase of up to 5,960 residents, which may result in an
increase in demand for library services. However, per the 2040 General Plan FEIR, implementation of
the 2040 General Plan would ensure the enhancement of City facilities, including library facilities, to
meet public needs.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-
Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a
new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
Development of the Neighborhood District would result in up to 1,218 new residents. As such, the
proposed project would require up to 7.91 acres of parkland to maintain the City’s ratio of 6.5 acres
per 1,000 residents.44 The Neighborhood District proposes three publicly accessible parks and open
space amenities and two pocket parks totaling up to 397,184 square feet, or 9.12 acres of parkland,
exceeding the required parkland acreage to meet the City’s ratio. Development of this District would
also include connections, through sidewalk installation and a proposed greenway and multiuse trail
located along the perimeter of the site, to the Iron Horse Trail, located approximately 0.23 mile
northeast of the District. No specific development is currently proposed for the Interim Area.
Furthermore, the project applicant would be required to pay a park impact fee for the required park
acreage not covered by the proposed facilities in the Neighborhood District.
The closest library to the proposed Neighborhood District, the San Ramon Library, is located
approximately 0.23 mile northeast of the project site. Although the Neighborhood District would result
in up to 1,218 new residents, which may increase demand for library services, this is considered
planned growth under the General Plan. Implementation of the 2040 General Plan would ensure the
enhancement of City facilities, including library facilities, to meet public needs.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District
plus Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would
not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040
General Plan FEIR.
43 (246,578 sq ft) x (1 acre/43,4560 sq ft) = 5.66 acres
44 6.5 acres * (1,218 residents/1000 residents) = 7.91 acres
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
158 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
None.
Conclusion
With regard to Public Services, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 159
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.16 Recreation
Would the project:
a) Would the project increase
the use of existing
neighborhood and regional
parks or other recreational
facilities such that
substantial physical
deterioration of the facility
would occur or be
accelerated?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
b) Does the project include
recreational facilities or
require the construction or
expansion of recreational
facilities, which might have
an adverse physical effect
on the environment?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
a, b) Existing Neighborhood and Regional Parks and Recreational Facilities
Would the project: a) increase the use of existing neighborhood and regional parks
or other recreational facilities such that substantial physical
deterioration of the facility would occur or be accelerated; or
Does the project: b) include recreational facilities or require the construction or
expansion of recreational facilities, which might have an
adverse physical effect on the environment?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Parkland within the 2040 General Plan Area totals approximately 395 acres and is managed by the
SRPCSD. This includes approximately 140 acres of neighborhood parks, 78 acres of school parks,
108 acres of community parks, 78 acres of specialized recreation areas, and 22 acres of public
spaces. The Iron Horse Trail, a regional multiuse trail, runs north–south through the City along the I-
680. To maintain the City’s parkland ratio of 6.5 acres per 1,000 residents, the SRPCSD would need
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
160 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
to incrementally increase their parks and recreational services through year 2040. To minimize or
avoid impacts that would result in substantial physical deterioration of existing parks during 2040
General Plan buildout or environmental impacts to existing recreational facilities, the City would
require new development to conform with applicable 2040 General Plan policies. These include
Policy 4.8-I-19 (Well-Designed Parks and Recreational Amenities); Policy 5.7-I-4 (Connection Points
and Adjacent Amenities Along the Iron Horse Trail); Policy 6.5-I-5 (Dedications for Land,
Improvements, and/or In Lieu Fees); Policy 6.5-I-9 (Development of Landscaped and Dedicated
Public Spaces in New Development); and Policy 6.5-I-18 (Provision of Public Spaces for Active or
Passive Use for Parkland Dedication Credit). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that
impacts to parks would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
As explained under Impact 4.16(d), development of the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family
Districts could result in up to 5,960 new residents, which would therefore require the provision of an
additional 38.7 acres of parkland to meet public need. It is anticipated that future development of
these Districts would partially offset this requirement through the provision of 5.66 acres of open
space, including a 2.5-acre park. Development of these Districts would also include the construction
of a proposed greenway and multiuse path along the District perimeters, which alongside off-site
improvements on Bollinger Canyon Road, would enhance accessibility to the Iron Horse Trail. The
project applicant would also be required to pay parkland impact fees equivalent to the park acreage
that would not be included as part of the proposed project. Therefore, there are no environmental
effects that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-
Use and Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact
that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
As mentioned previously under Impact 4.16(d), development of the Neighborhood District would
result in up to 1,218 new residents. As such, the proposed project would require the provision of up to
7.91 acres of parkland to maintain the City’s ratio of 6.5 acres per 1,000 residents. However, as
previously explained under Impact 4.16(d), the proposed Neighborhood District would exceed these
requirements through the provision of 9.64 acres of parkland, encompassing three publicly accessible
parks and open space amenities and two pocket parks. Development of this District would also
include connections, through sidewalk installation and a proposed greenway and multiuse trail
located along the perimeter of the site, to the Iron Horse Trail, located approximately 0.23 mile
northeast of the District. The project applicant would also be required to pay parkland impact fees
equivalent to the park acreage that would not be included as part of the proposed project. Therefore,
there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed Neighborhood District plus
Grading of Interim Area. The proposed Neighborhood District plus Grading of Interim Area would not
result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General
Plan FEIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 161
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
None.
Conclusion
With regard to Recreation, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
162 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.17 Transportation
Would the project:
a) Conflict with a
program plan,
ordinance or policy of
the circulation system,
including transit,
roadway, bicycle and
pedestrian facilities?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
b) Would the project
conflict or be
inconsistent with
CEQA Guidelines
Section 15064.3,
subdivision (b)?
Significant and
unavoidable
impact
No No No No
c) Substantially increase
hazards due to a
geometric design
feature (e.g., sharp
curves or dangerous
intersections) or
incompatible uses
(e.g., farm
equipment)?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
d) Result in inadequate
emergency access?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 163
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
a) Conflict with a Circulation System Policy
Would the project: Conflict with a program plan, ordinance or policy of the circulation
system, including transit, roadway, bicycle and pedestrian facilities?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan Area contains a regional highway, the I-680; arterials; collectors; and local
streets, as shown in Figure 3.12-1 of the 2040 General Plan FEIR. The 2040 General Plan Area also
contains bicycle and pedestrian facilities, including the Iron Horse Trail, a multiuse trail running north–
south through the City just east of the I-680. Additionally, multiple Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART)
lines provide local and regional connections. The General Plan FEIR identifies potential construction
impacts associated with encroachment into lane, bicycle path, or sidewalk closures that would impact
bicycle, pedestrian, or roadway/transit connections. The 2040 General Plan FEIR requires
implementation of MM TRA-1, where all new development must prepare a Construction Traffic
Management Plan for projects that require off-site staging, lane closures, or substantial hauling of cut
and fill on a local street. Furthermore, new development would be expected to comply with various
2040 General Plan policies to reduce these impacts, including: Policy 5.2-I-5 (TDM and Trip
Reduction Strategies); Policy 5.6-I-7 (Mix of Uses and Complete Streets Concepts to Reduce VMT);
Policy 5.7-I-4 (Connection Points to Iron Horse Trail); and Policy 5.7-I-5 (Bicycle Parking, Storage,
and Support Facilities). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less
than significant with mitigation.
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would include their own circulation network with
sidewalks throughout, in compliance with Policy 5.2-I-5. Furthermore, the project site is walking
distance from two bus stops. The Bishop Ranch 1 bus stop is located less than 0.25 mile from the
project site and is on the County Connection 92X, 96X, and 97X bus lines, which arrive to the
Dublin/Pleasanton BART station. The Bollinger Canyon Road and Bishop Ranch 1 bus stop is also
located less than 0.25 mile from the project site and is on the County Connection 35 and 335 bus
lines. The 35 and 335 also arrive at the Dublin/Pleasanton BART station via a different route. Future
development under the Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts would provide adequate bicycle facilities
and parking in compliance with Policy 5.7-I-5. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are
peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-
Family District designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Project-Level Analysis (Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed Neighborhood District would include its own circulation network with sidewalks
throughout, in compliance with Policy 5.2-I-5. The proposed multiuse greenway trail would allow for
additional bicycle and pedestrian circulation and connect the project site to the Iron Horse Trail and
City’s Walking District in compliance with Policy 5.7-I-4. As the Neighborhood District would consist of
primarily single-family homes with garages, bicycle parking would be adequate in compliance with
Policy 5.7-I-5. As described above, the project site is walking distance from multiple County
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
164 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Connection lines that lead to Dublin/Pleasanton BART. Therefore, there are no environmental effects
that are peculiar to the proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and
Multi-Family District designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was
not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
b) Inconsistent with CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.3
Would the project: Would the project conflict or be inconsistent with CEQA Guidelines
Section 15064.3, subdivision (b)
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
According to the Governor’s Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation (LCI) guidance on the
application of SB 743, a Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) impact is significant if VMT per capita or
employee remains above 15 percent below the existing baseline. At the time the General Plan EIR
was prepared, the City’s Home-Based VMT per Resident was 20.4 and the Home-Work VMT per
Employee was 15.0. To achieve a 15 percent reduction, the 2040 General Plan would have needed to
reduce Home-Based VMT per Resident to 17.3 and the Home-Work VMT per Employee to 12.8. The
General Plan EIR determined that Home-Based VMT per Resident would be reduced to 18.6 and the
Home-Work VMT per Employee would be reduced to 14.9 under the 2040 General Plan. As such, it
was determined that the 2040 General Plan would have a potentially significant impact related to
VMT. The 2040 General Plan FEIR included MM TRA-2, which requires development projects to
either modify project characteristics to reduce VMT or implement a Transportation Demand
Management (TDM) program. Examples of TDM Measures include T-7 (Commute Trip Reduction
Marketing), T-9 (Subsidized or Discounted Transit Program), T-10 (End-of-Trip Bicycle Facilities), and
T-18 (Pedestrian Network Improvements). MM TRA-2 also provides the option for the City to
participate in a Contra Costa Transportation Authority (CCTA)-approved VMT impact fee program
and/or VMT mitigation exchange/banking program, once it is completed by the CCTA. Although these
measures would likely reduce project-level VMT impacts, impacts of project-level mitigation on 2040
General Plan Area VMT remain uncertain pending buildout through 2040. Therefore, the 2040
General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be significant and unavoidable.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use, Multi-Family, and Neighborhood Districts
plus Grading of Interim Area)
A VMT analysis was prepared by Fehr & Peers for the proposed project on November 10, 2025
(Appendix I).45 The analysis evaluated whether the proposed project would generate Home-Based
VMT per resident and Home-Work VMT per service population higher than 85 percent of the Home-
Based VMT per resident in the City or higher than 85 percent of the existing countywide average VMT
per service population.
45 Fehr & Peers. 2025. Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis. November 10.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 165
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
The City’s average Home-Based VMT per resident is 18.7, meaning a significant impact would occur
if the proposed project would generate VMT per resident greater than 15.9.46 The proposed project is
expected to generate 16.7 Home-Based VMT per resident, meaning impacts would be potentially
significant.
The County’s Home-Work VMT per service population is 16.8, meaning a significant impact would
occur if the proposed project would generate VMT per service population greater than 14.3. The
proposed project is expected to generate 3.7 Home-Work VMT per service population, which would
not create a significant impact.
Because Home-Based VMT per resident would create a potentially significant impact, the proposed
project is required to implement General Plan MM TRA-2 via TDM strategies, including integration of
affordable and below market rate housing and community-based travel planning. The proposed
project would be required to mitigate just over 5 percent of its Home-Based VMT to result in a less
than significant impact. It is expected that these measures would reduce the proposed project’s
Home-Based VMT by 6.1 percent, meaning impacts would be less than significant with mitigation
incorporated. Because the 2040 General Plan EIR concluded that VMT impacts would be significant
and unavoidable, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The
proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
c) Roadway Safety Hazards
Would the project: Substantially increase hazards due to a geometric design feature
(e.g., sharp curves or dangerous intersections) or incompatible uses
(e.g., farm equipment)?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Construction during buildout of the 2040 General Plan Area would utilize vacant areas for staging and
designated travel routes for the transport of materials to reduce impacts. New development that
would add traffic to streets not designed to current standards would be required to provide mitigation
to minimize or eliminate traffic hazards or to fund related improvements where needed, including the
installation of shoulder widening, signalized intersections, or the addition of sidewalks or cross walks.
Additionally, new development would be required to comply with federal, State, and local design
standards as well as applicable 2040 General Plan Policies: Policy 5.1-I-3 (Traffic Impact Studies for
50 or More New Net Peak-Hour Trips and VMT Assessment) and Policy 5.1-I-4 (Identify Mitigation
Measures). Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than
significant.
46 18.7 * 0.85=15.9
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
166 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use, Multi-Family, and Neighborhood Districts
plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed project would include its own circulation network in compliance with Policy 5.1-I-4. The
proposed circulation network would be evaluated by the Public Works department to ensure
compliance with all City policies. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the
proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts. The proposed Mixed-Use and Multi-Family District
designations would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
d) Emergency Access
Would the project: Result in inadequate emergency access?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Construction during buildout of the 2040 General Plan would utilize multiple access routes and
provide detour signs. Development facilitated by the 2040 General Plan would be required to provide
adequate fire access to structure frontages, multiple access points to development, as well as
adequate width, height, and turning radius of roadways and access points, pursuant to CBC
requirements. This would include compliance with requirements of the CFC, including the provision of
at least two separated and approved fire apparatus access roads that have a minimum width of 20
feet with turning radii of 25 feet inside and 45 feet outside. Additionally, new development would be
required to comply with applicable 2040 General Plan policies, including Policy 5.1-I-3 (Traffic Impact
Studies for 50 or More New Net Peak-Hour Trips and VMT Assessment) and Policy 5.1-I-4 (Identify
Mitigation Measures) to ensure adequate emergency access. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR
concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use, Multi-Family, and Neighborhood Districts
plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed project’s internal street network would be designed to accommodate the turning radius
of emergency vehicles, such as large fire trucks, and the proposed project would undergo review by
the SRVFPD to ensure adequate emergency access.
The SRVFPD reviewed the proposed project to ensure adequate emergency access and provided
standard conditions of approval.47 Lastly, while it is not anticipated, it is possible that construction of
the proposed project could result in lane closures. As such, implementation of 2040 General Plan EIR
MM TRA-1 is required. With implementation of MM TRA-1, impacts would be less than significant.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the site or the proposed project. The
47 Letter from the San Ramon Valley Fire Protection District, Community Risk Reduction Division. July 15, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 167
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
MM TRA-1 Prepare and Implement Construction Traffic Management Plans
Prior to issuance of building permits, the contractor for an individual development
project that requires off-site staging, lane closures, or substantial hauling of cut and
fill on a local street (i.e., not under Caltrans’ jurisdiction) shall prepare a Construction
Traffic Management Plan that includes measures such as, but not limited to, the
following as deemed necessary by the City. The approved Construction Traffic
Management Plan shall be implemented during construction.
• Provide a temporary traffic signal, if necessary
• Project Staging Plan to maximize on-site storage of materials and equipment
• A set of comprehensive traffic control measures, including scheduling of major
truck trips and deliveries to avoid peak-hours; lane closure proceedings; signs,
cones, and other warning devices for drivers; and designation of construction
access routes
• Permitted construction hours
• Location of construction staging
• Identification of parking areas for construction employees, site visitors, and
inspectors, including on-site locations
• Provisions for street sweeping to remove construction-related debris on public
streets
MM TRA-2 Prepare and Implement VMT Reduction Measures
The CCTA’s VMT Analysis for Land Use Projects in Contra Costa, which is found in
Appendix A in CCTA’s Final Technical Procedures (November 2022) describes
options for mitigation of VMT impacts. The first two options below apply to
development projects and plans, and the third applies at a General Plan area-wide
scale.
1. A project applicant shall modify a project’s characteristics to reduce VMT
generated by such project prior to issuance of an occupancy permit. This might
involve changing the density or mixture of land uses on a project site, or
changing a project’s location to one that is more accessible by transit or other
travel modes.
2. A project applicant shall implement Transportation Demand Management (TDM)
or physical design measures to reduce VMT generated by a project prior to
issuance of an occupancy permit.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
168 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
3. The City shall participate in a CCTA-approved VMT impact fee program and/or
VMT mitigation exchange/banking program, once it is completed and published
by CCTA. (Note that CCTA is developing such a program for Contra Costa
County.)
When option 2 (TDM plan) is applied for future land use development projects
facilitated by the 2040 General Plan that do not meet CCTA screening criteria and
thresholds, the City shall require preparation and implementation of a project-level
TDM plan with the [TDM measures outlined under Table 3.12-4 in the General Plan
FEIR.]
Feasible options listed under General Plan FEIR Table 3.12-4 to reduce VMT below CCTA thresholds
shall be implemented for individual projects facilitated by the 2040 General Plan. VMT reduction
measures shall be included at project design review and be reviewed and approved by the City prior
to issuance of construction permits.
Table 7 lists the measures applicable to the proposed project.
Table 7: Transportation Demand Management Measures
CAPCOA Handbook Measure Description
T-4: Integrate Affordable and
Below Market Rate Housing
This measure requires Below Market Rate (BMR) housing. BMR housing
provides greater opportunity for lower income families to live closer to job
centers and achieve a jobs/housing match near transit. It is also an
important strategy to address the limited availability of affordable housing
that might force residents to live far away from jobs or school, requiring
longer commutes.
T-23: Community-Based Travel
Planning
This measure will target residences in the plan/community with
Community-Based Travel Plan (CBTP). CBTP is a residential-based
approach to outreach that provides households with customized
information, incentives, and support to encourage the use of transportation
alternatives in place of single occupancy vehicles, thereby reducing
household Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) and associated greenhouse gas
(GHG) emissions.
Notes:
CAPCOA = California Air Pollution Control Officers Association
Source: Fehr & Peers. 2025. Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis. September 3.
Conclusion
With regard to Transportation, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 169
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. MM TRA-2 would be required for impacts to be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
170 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.18 Utilities and Service Systems
Would the project:
a) Require or result in the
relocation or
construction of new or
expanded water,
wastewater treatment
or stormwater
drainage, electric
power, natural gas, or
telecommunications
facilities, the
construction or
relocation of which
could cause significant
environmental effects?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
b) Have sufficient water
supplies available to
serve the project and
reasonably
foreseeable future
development during
normal, dry and
multiple dry years?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
c) Result in a
determination by the
wastewater treatment
provider which serves
or may serve the
project that it has
adequate capacity to
serve the project’s
projected demand in
addition to the
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 171
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
provider’s existing
commitments?
d) Generate solid waste
in excess of State or
local standards, or in
excess of the capacity
of local infrastructure,
or otherwise impair the
attainment of solid
waste reduction
goals?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
e) Comply with federal,
state, and local
management and
reduction statutes and
regulations related to
solid waste?
Less than
significant
impact
No No No No
Setting
Water supply providers within the 2040 General Plan Area include EBMUD and DSRSD. Wastewater
collected in the northern portion of the City, in the Dougherty Valley area, is collected and diverted to
the l Central San wastewater treatment plant. Wastewater collected in the southern portion of the City
is collected and diverted to the DSRSD wastewater treatment plant. Stormwater is collected by a
system of storm drains, inlets, curbside gutters, catch basins, drainage ditches, and man-made
channels managed by the Contral Costa County Public Works. Electricity would be provided by MCE
via existing PG&E power lines unless individual residents have chosen to opt in to PG&E.
Telecommunications service is provided by Xfinity and AT&T.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
172 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
a) Water, Wastewater, and Stormwater Facilities
Would the project: Require or result in the relocation or construction of new or
expanded water, wastewater treatment or stormwater drainage,
electric power, natural gas, or telecommunications facilities, the
construction or relocation of which could cause significant
environmental effects?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
All new development would be required to comply with all applicable federal, State, and local
regulations governing the provision of utility infrastructure and utilities, which would reduce the
potential for adverse construction impacts associated with construction of new or expanded utility and
infrastructure and facilities associated with implementation of the 2040 General Plan. To mitigate
impacts during operations, the 2040 General Plan FEIR included MM UTL-1 (Measures to Provide
Adequate Water Supply) and MM UTL-2 (Measures to Provide Adequate Wastewater Infrastructure
and Treatment), both which contain service requirements for new development. New development
would also be required to include site-specific BMPs for LID treatment and would be required to
comply with applicable 2040 General Plan policies, including Policy 9.4-I-4 (Maintenance of Drainage
Facilities) and Policy 9.4-I-8 (Not Increase Runoff to 100-Year Peak Flow). New development would
also be required to comply with 2040 General Plan Policy 7.4-I-8 (Technological Support for
Telecommunications Services) to reduce impacts to telecommunications services. Therefore, the
2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant with mitigation.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed project represents typical development anticipated in the General Plan. Development
of the proposed project would involve the routine construction of new utility lines throughout the
project site, consistent with standard infrastructure improvements commonly associated with similar
projects. The proposed wastewater system would connect to an existing sanitary sewer line at the
southern border of the project site. The proposed potable water system would connect to an existing
water line in Bollinger Canyon Road. The proposed storm drain and bioretention system would
connect to existing stormwater lines at the southeast corner of the project site and at two locations on
the eastern border of the project site, as well as in Bollinger Canyon Road. Given the Districts’
location within an urbanized area of the City, development of the Districts would not involve the
construction or expansion of new telecommunications infrastructure.
Impacts resulting from the construction of these on-site utility features and off-site connections are
included in the evaluation of the proposed project throughout this document.
Therefore, development of the project site as proposed would not result in any environmental effects
that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more
severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 173
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
b) Water Supply
Would the project: Have sufficient water supplies available to serve the project and
reasonably foreseeable future development during normal, dry and
multiple dry years?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan EIR concluded that, according to the Urban Water Management Plan
(UWMPs) for both EBMUD and DSRSD, there would be sufficient water supplies for normal and dry
years, but the EBMUD UWMP determined that there may be supply shortfalls after three consecutive
dry years at buildout of the 2040 General Plan. All new development within EBMUD’s jurisdiction
would be subject to the same drought restrictions as for all EBMUD customers stipulated within its
Water Shortage Contingency Plan and Drought Management Plan, which the agency concluded
would be sufficient to address projected supply deficits during multiple dry years. By imposing water
restrictions in the first dry year of potential drought periods, EBMUD attempts to minimize water use
restrictions in subsequent years if a drought persists.
Additionally, all new development would be required to comply with applicable 2040 General Plan
policies, including Policy 8.6-I-1 (Outdoor Water Conservation and Demand Management); Policy 8.6-
I-3 (Accommodations for Nonpotable Water Service); and Policy 8.6-I-4 (Compliance with the State
Model Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance [MWELO]). Furthermore, the General Plan EIR
recognizes that under SB 610 requirements, when an EIR, negative declaration or Mitigated Negative
Declaration is required for new development of a certain size, a water supply assessment may be
required.48 Therefore, the 2040 General Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than
significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
As explained in Section 4.11, Land Use and Planning, and Section 4.14, Population and Housing,
future development under the proposed project would have a maximum density that is consistent with
the DMU-S land use designation and is considered planned growth. Development of the proposed
Neighborhood District would involve construction of up to 368 residential units and 58 ADUs. The City
will comply with SB 610 and the requirements of the California Water Code for any additional future
development beyond the proposed Neighborhood District. Additional future development is
anticipated and is reviewed with regard to water supply at a programmatic level. Because the amount
48 Section 10910 of the California Water Code does not specify exemptions as requiring Water Supply Assessments
(WSAs). Additionally, SB 610 does not apply to program-level environmental analyses, such as those conducted for
general plans, specific plans, or other broad planning documents. These program-level reviews typically evaluate policies
or land use designations over a large geographic area and do not authorize specific development projects. Because SB
610 is intended to assess water supply adequacy for discrete, project-level proposals, its requirements are triggered
only when a qualifying project is proposed for approval.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
174 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
of residential and commercial development permitted by the proposed project is consistent with what
was anticipated in the 2040 General Plan, it is assumed that the water demand resulting from the
proposed project has already been anticipated by the 2040 General Plan, and that there would be
sufficient water supply for the proposed project. The proposed project would be required to comply
with all indoor water conservation and demand management measures, consistent with building code
standards and CAP policies as well as to comply with the State MWELO. Therefore, there are no
environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project would not result
in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan
FEIR.
c) Wastewater Treatment Capacity
Would the project: Result in a determination by the wastewater treatment provider
which serves or may serve the project that it has adequate capacity
to serve the project’s projected demand in addition to the provider’s
existing commitments?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan FEIR determined that the majority of wastewater collected within the 2040
General Plan Area is serviced by Central San. According to the 2040 General Plan FEIR, Central San
would have sufficient treatment capacity to accommodate wastewater generated at buildout of the
2040 General Plan. Furthermore, Central San is expected to enact its 10-year Capital Improvement
Program (CIP) to expand, upgrade, and replace its collection system to maintain or improve service.
Therefore, the 2040 General Plan concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
As explained in Section 4.11, Land Use and Planning, and Section 4.14, Population and Housing,
future development under the proposed project would have a maximum density that is consistent with
the DMU-S land use designation and is considered planned growth. Because the amount of
residential and commercial development permitted by the proposed project is consistent with what
was anticipated in the 2040 General Plan, it is assumed that the wastewater generation resulting from
the proposed project was already anticipated in the 2040 General Plan, and there would be sufficient
wastewater capacity to serve the proposed project. Therefore, there are no environmental effects that
are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe
adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 175
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
d, e) Solid Waste Reduction Goals Consistency and Solid Waste Regulations
Consistency
Would the project: Generate solid waste in excess of State or local standards, or in
excess of the capacity of local infrastructure, or otherwise impair the
attainment of solid waste reduction goals?
Would the project: Comply with federal, State, and local management and reduction
statutes and regulations related to solid waste?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Solid waste is collected by Alameda County Industries within the 2040 General Plan Area. All new
development within the 2040 General Plan Area would be subject to federal, State, and local
regulations and would be required to pay solid waste service fees. The 2040 General Plan EIR
determined that the 2040 General Plan would yield an annual solid waste generation of approximately
53,923 pounds per day, which would account for approximately 1 percent of the throughput of the
Vasco Road Landfill. In addition to the Vasco Road Landfill, solid waste could also be transferred to
the Altamont Landfill, which has a maximum throughput of roughly 11,150 tons per day and an
anticipated closure date of December 1, 2070. Altamont Landfill has a remaining capacity of
approximately 65,400,000 cubic yards and could also divert a portion of the solid waste from the
General Plan Area. During construction, all new development would be subject to 2040 General Plan
Policy 7.5-I-9 (Compliance with Municipal Code’s Construction and Demolition Debris Diversion
Requirements) to ensure that construction-generated solid waste would not be in excess of State or
local standards or impair solid waste reduction goals. During operations, the 2040 General Plan FEIR
found that local solid waste infrastructure would provide sufficient capacity for new development.
Additionally, new development would be subject to applicable policies of the 2040 General Plan,
including Policy 7.5-I-4 (Convenient Recyclable Material Storage Locations); Policy 7.5-I-5
(Compliance with State Requirements for Proper Handling and Storage of Solid Waste); and Policy
7.5-I-7 (Options for Safe Disposal of Hazardous Waste and Materials). Therefore, the 2040 General
Plan FEIR concluded that impacts would be less than significant.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusion
Program-level Analysis (Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Districts)
The proposed project would be subject to Policy 7.5-I-9 (Compliance with Municipal Code’s
Construction and Demolition Debris Diversion Requirements) ensuring that construction-generated
solid waste would not be in excess of State or local standards or impair solid waste reduction goals.
As explained in Section 4.11, Land Use and Planning, and Section 4.14, Population and Housing,
future development under the proposed project would have a maximum density that is consistent with
the DMU-S land use designation and is considered planned growth. Because the amount of
residential and commercial development permitted by the proposed project is consistent with what
was anticipated in the 2040 General Plan, it is assumed that the waste generation resulting from the
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
176 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
proposed project was already anticipated in the 2040 General Plan, and there would be sufficient
landfill capacity to serve the proposed project.
Additionally, the proposed project would be required to comply with all federal, State, and local
management and reduction statutes and regulations related to solid waste. Therefore, there are no
environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed project would not result
in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in the 2040 General Plan
FEIR.
Conclusion
With regard to Utilities and Service Systems, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FIER.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 177
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.19 Wildfire
If located in or near State Responsibility Areas or lands classified as Very High Fire Hazard Severity
Zones, would the project:
a) Substantially impair an
adopted emergency
response plan or
emergency evacuation
plan?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
b) Due to slope,
prevailing winds, and
other factors,
exacerbate wildfire
risks, and thereby
expose project
occupants to, pollutant
concentrations from a
wildfire or the
uncontrolled spread of
a wildfire?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
c) Require the installation
or maintenance of
associated
infrastructure (such as
roads, fuel breaks,
emergency water
sources, power lines
or other utilities) that
may exacerbate fire
risk or that may result
in temporary or
ongoing impacts to the
environment?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
178 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
d) Expose people or
structures to
significant risks,
including downslope or
downstream flooding
or landslides, as a
result of runoff, post-
fire slope instability, or
drainage changes?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
a) Emergency Response/Evacuation Plan Consistency
Would the project: If located in or near State Responsibility Areas or lands classified as
Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones, substantially impair an
adopted emergency response plan or emergency evacuation plan?
b) Expose Project Occupants to Pollutant Concentrations from Wildfire
Would the project: If located in or near State Responsibility Areas or lands classified as
Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones, due to slope, prevailing winds,
and other factors, exacerbate wildfire risks, and thereby expose
project occupants to, pollutant concentrations from a wildfire or the
uncontrolled spread of a wildfire?
c) Infrastructure that Exacerbates Fire Risk
Would the project: If located in or near State Responsibility Areas or lands classified as
Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones, require the installation or
maintenance of associated infrastructure (such as roads, fuel
breaks, emergency water sources, power lines or other utilities) that
may exacerbate fire risk or that may result in temporary or ongoing
impacts to the environment?
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 179
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
d) Flooding and Landslide Hazards Due To Post-fire Slope Instability/Drainage
Changes
Would the project: If located in or near State Responsibility Areas or lands classified as
Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones, expose people or structures to
significant risks, including downslope or downstream flooding or
landslides, as a result of runoff, post-fire slope instability, or
drainage changes?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
Although the City is not located within a VHFHSZ or a State Responsibility Area (SRA), the
northwestern portion of the 2040 General Plan Area is located in a VHFHSZ in an SRA. There is also
a High FHSZ within an SRA located within the southwestern and eastern portions within the City and
in areas east of city limits. New development would be expected to conform with existing local and
State regulations, including California Code of Regulations Title 14, which sets forth the minimum
standards for emergency access, fuel modification, setback, signage, and water supply. Compliance
with these guidelines would reduce the potential for any wildfire risk associated with new
development or the installation or maintenance of project infrastructure that may exacerbate fire risk.
New development would also be reviewed for compliance with CFC design standards for residential
development. These include the use of non-combustible or ignition-resistant building materials and
fire flow requirements for buildings, fire hydrant location, and distribution criteria (which are also
specified in 2040 General Plan Policy 9.5-I-1 (Site Design Features), Policy 9.5-I-4 (Sprinklers in New
Homes), and Policy 9.5-I-5 (Sprinklers in Mixed-Use Development)). All new development would be
required to comply with 2040 General Plan Policy 9.5-I-2 (Fire Protection Plan) to evaluate
appropriate mitigation measures and all development within or adjacent to High FHSZs would be
required to implement MM HAZ-1. Implementation of MM HAZ-1 would require review of project
landscape plans, including slope design, as well as geotechnical if the project site is within a known
landslide area, and would minimize or avoid impacts related to wildfire spread, pollutant exposure,
and post-fire instability. Therefore, the 2040 General Plan concluded that impacts would be less than
significant with mitigation incorporated.
Orchards Project Analysis and Conclusions
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The latest CAL FIRE FHSZ maps show that the project site is not located within a designated FHSZ
and is not within or adjacent to a designated High FHSZ.49 The project site is typical of sites evaluated
for development in the 2040 General Plan.
49 California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE). 2025. Fire Hazard Severity Zone Viewer (Map
Viewer). Website: https://fire-hazard-severity-zones-rollout-calfire-forestry.hub.arcgis.com/pages/access-map. Accessed
August 13, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
180 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
As explained in Section 4.9, Hazards and Hazardous Materials and Section 4.17, Transportation, the
proposed project would provide adequate access for emergency vehicles. The project site provides
direct connections to all of the City’s potential evacuation routes and the proposed project would
comply with the Contra Costa County Emergency Operation Plan and the Contra Costa County
LHMP during and would not obstruct either Plan during operations. Additionally, the SRVFPD has
reviewed the proposed project to ensure adequate fire truck and apparatus turning radii and
clearance for purposes of adequate emergency access and response and provided standard
conditions of approval.50The project site is surrounded by intervening development, meaning there is
not very much fuel for wildfire in the immediate vicinity of the project site. Furthermore, as described
in Section 4.7 Geology and Soils, the project site is not at risk of landslides, meaning wildfires would
not exacerbate any landslide or downslope flooding risks. As described in Section 4.10, Hydrology
and Water Quality, the proposed project would not substantially alter the existing drainage pattern of
the site or area.
Finally, the proposed project would comply with applicable 2040 General Plan policies, including
Policy 9.5-I-1 (Site Design Features) to ensure the use of fire retardant building materials and other
measures to reduce the risk of fire on-site and Policy 9.5-I-4 (Sprinklers in New Homes) through the
installation of sprinklers in all new residential units. The proposed project would also be subject to the
requirements of the CFC and the CBC as well as minimum standards set forth by California Code of
Regulations Title 14 regarding emergency access, fuel modification, setback, signage, and water
supply, avoiding the use of infrastructure that would exacerbate fire risk.
Therefore, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The proposed
project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact that was not previously identified in
the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
Conclusion
With regard to Wildfire, the Consistency Checklist demonstrates that:
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FIER.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
50 Letter from the San Ramon Valley Fire Protection District, Community Risk Reduction Division. July 15, 2025.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 181
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
4.20 Mandatory Findings of Significance
a) Does the project have
the potential to
substantially degrade
the quality of the
environment,
substantially reduce the
habitat of a fish or
wildlife species, cause
a fish or wildlife
population to drop
below self-sustaining
levels, threaten to
eliminate a plant or
animal community,
substantially reduce the
number or restrict the
range of a rare or
endangered plant or
animal, or eliminate
important examples of
the major periods of
California history or
prehistory?
Less than
significant
impact with
mitigation
incorporated
No No No No
b) Does the project have
impacts that are
individually limited, but
cumulatively
considerable?
(“Cumulatively
considerable” means
that the incremental
effects of a project are
considerable when
viewed in connection
Significant and
unavoidable
impact
No No No No
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
182 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Environmental Issues
Prior FEIR
Determination
CEQA Section 15183(b) Criteria
Effect
Peculiar to
Project or
Site?
New
Significant
Effect?
New
Significant
Off-site,
Cumulative
Impact?
New
Information,
More Severe
Adverse
Impact?
with the effects of past
projects, the effects of
other current projects,
and the effects of
probable future
projects)?
c) Does the project have
environmental effects,
which will cause
substantial adverse
effects on human
beings, either directly or
indirectly?
Significant and
unavoidable
impact
No No No No
a) Potential Degradation to Environment and Examples of California History or
Prehistory
Does the project: Have the potential to substantially degrade the quality of the
environment, substantially reduce the habitat of a fish or wildlife
species, cause a fish or wildlife population to drop below self-
sustaining levels, threaten to eliminate a plant or animal community,
substantially reduce the number or restrict the range of a rare or
endangered plant or animal, or eliminate important examples of the
major periods of California history or prehistory?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan EIR found that the 2040 General Plan would not eliminate or threaten wildlife
habitats or eliminate important examples of California history or prehistory with incorporation of
mitigation with incorporation of mitigation.
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed project would not eliminate or threaten wildlife habitats or eliminate important examples
of California history or prehistory with incorporation of General Plan MM BIO-1, MM BIO-2, CR-2, CR-
3, and CR-4. Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project. The
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
FCS 183
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact than what was previously
identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
b) Cumulatively Considerable Impacts
Does the project: Have impacts that are individually limited, but cumulatively
considerable? (“Cumulatively considerable” means that the
incremental effects of a project are considerable when viewed in
connection with the effects of past projects, the effects of other
current projects, and the effects of probable future projects)?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan EIR found that, while the 2040 General Plan includes policies that encourage
the reduction of VMT, GHG emissions, solid waste generation, as well as energy, fuel, and water
usage, there would still be significant and unavoidable impacts related to VMT and cumulative VMT
impacts. Impacts were determined to be significant and unavoidable.
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed project would have a less than significant VMT impact with incorporation of General
Plan MM TRA-2. Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project.
The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact than what was
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
c) Adverse Effects on Human Beings?
Does the project: Have environmental effects, which will cause substantial adverse
effects on human beings, either directly or indirectly?
Summary of 2040 General Plan EIR
The 2040 General Plan EIR found that, while the 2040 General Plan would result in a significant and
unavoidable impact related to transportation that could, in turn, affect human beings. It was
determined that impacts would be significant and unavoidable.
Program-level and Project-level Analysis (Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and
Neighborhood District Development plus Grading of Interim Area)
The proposed project would have a less than significant VMT impact with incorporation of General
Plan MM TRA-2. Thus, there are no environmental effects that are peculiar to the proposed project.
The proposed project would not result in a new or more severe adverse impact than what was
previously identified in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
2040 General Plan FEIR Mitigation Measures
General Plan MM BIO-1, MM BIO-2, CR-2, CR-3, CR-4, and TRA-2.
ORCHARDS PROJECT
CEQA GUIDELINES SECTION 15183 CONSISTENCY CHECKLIST
184 FCS
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
Conclusion
1. No peculiar impacts related to the proposed project or its site have been identified.
2. There are no potentially significant off-site and/or cumulative impacts which were not
discussed by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
3. No substantial new information has been identified which results in an impact which is more
severe than anticipated by the 2040 General Plan FEIR.
4. No mitigation measures would be required because the proposed project’s specific impacts
would be less than significant.
Orchards Project
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist
FCS 185
Https://adecinnovations.sharepoint.com/sites/PublicationsSite/Shared Documents/Publications/Client (PN-JN)/2491/24910040/Consistency Checklist/24910040 Orchards Project Consistency Checklist CY
Screencheck Draft.docx
5 - LIST OF PREPARERS
FirstCarbon Solutions
2999 Oak Road, Suite 250
Walnut Creek, CA 94597
Phone: 925.357.2562
Project Director ........................................................................................................................ Mary Bean
Project Manager ................................................................................................................. Maddie Dolan
Legal Counsel ................................................................................................................. Megan Starr, JD
Director of Cultural Resources ....................................................................... Dana DePietro, PhD, RPA
Senior Archaeologist ......................................................................................... Stefanie Griffin, MA, RPA
Archaeologist and Field Supervisor ................................................................................... Natalie Adame
Director of Noise and Air Quality ............................................................................. Phil Ault, LEED® AP
Senior Air Quality Scientist ................................................................................................. Jackie Winkel
Senior Biologist ................................................................................................................... Robert Carroll
Biologist ................................................................................................................................. Kelly Evans
Environmental Services Analyst .......................................................................................... Heather Carr
Senior Managing Editor ........................................................................................................ Susie Harris
Publications Manager ............................................................................................................. Alec Harris
Technical Editor ...................................................................................................................... Sarah Vine
Technical Document Manager ....................................................................................... Melissa Ramirez
GIS/Graphics .............................................................................................................. Karlee McCracken
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK