HomeMy WebLinkAboutN. Orchards Economic and Fiscal Impact Analysis, dated August 8, 2025, updated November 10, 2025HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 1
SUMMARY OF RESULTS
ORCHARDS AT BISHOP RANCH ECONOMIC AND FISCAL
IMPACT ANALYSIS
AUGUST 8, 2025
UPDATED NOVEMBER 10, 2025
Attachment N
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 2
INTRODUCTION
HR&A Advisors, Inc. (HR&A) is an industry-leading real estate, economic development and public
policy consulting firm.
For nearly 50 years, HR&A has provided a full range of pre-construction real estate advisory services,
including market analysis, financial feasibility analysis, economic and fiscal impact analysis, and structuring
of public-private financing agreements for some of the most complex mixed-use, neighborhood, downtown,
campus, and regional development projects across North America and abroad. We understand the
importance of linking private investment with public resources to support investor and community
responsibilities and aspirations.
Sunset Development (“Sunset” or the “Company”) is planning Orchards at Bishop Ranch, a mixed-use
community on 92 acres (the “Project”) in the City of San Ramon (the “City” or “San Ramon”). The Project
will offer up to 2,500 residential units consisting of various for-sale and rental products, 125,000 square
feet of new retail at the base of new multifamily buildings, and open space amenities, including a 2.5-acre
park, additional pocket parks, recreational facilities and pedestrian pathways. Construction is expected
to begin in late 2026, with full build-out and stabilization by 2045.
This briefing book reports analysis prepared by HR&A Advisors, Inc. on the Project’s economic impacts in
the Contra Costa County economy and its fiscal impacts to San Ramon from 2026 to 2045, accounting for
construction, initial home sales and rentals, and stabilized operations.
WHO WE ARE
STUDY PURPOSE
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 3
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY | Through 2045, the Project will generate approximately
$2.1 billion in one-time and $358.2 million in annual economic activity to the
Contra Costa economy and contribute approximately $4.4 million in cumulative
net new revenue to San Ramon (all in 2025 $).
NET FISCAL IMPACTS FROM OPERATIONS
OVER PROJECT BUILD-OUT
$4.4 million
(2025 dollars)
Revenues to the City of San Ramon resulting from
Project operations between 2028-2045 (i.e., not
including one-time revenues).
ONE-TIME FISCAL IMPACTS
$4.8 million
(2025 dollars)
Revenues to the City of San Ramon resulting
from private construction spending.
ECONOMIC IMPACTS FISCAL IMPACTS
The Project will contribute to the Contra Costa County
economy by adding new jobs and household
spending, whose impacts will multiply throughout the
economy.
The Project will deliver important new revenue to the
City of San Ramon through 2045 from applicable
revenue sources, including transfer, property and
sales tax, franchise fees and other revenues.
RECURRING ECONOMIC IMPACTS
FROM OPERATIONS
$358.2 million
(Annually, 2025 dollars)
Economic output in Contra Costa resulting from
ongoing Project operations at full build-out in 2045.
ONE-TIME ECONOMIC IMPACTS
$2.1 billion
(2025 dollars)
Economic output to the Contra Costa County
resulting from private construction spending.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 4
ORCHARDS AT BISHOP RANCH MASTER PLAN | Sunset expects to complete the Project in phases between 2026 and 2045. For-sale residential will be completed and stabilized by 2030, mixed-use by 2034, and multifamily by 2045.
Source: Sunset Development
DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM
368
For-Sale Residential
1,465
Multifamily
619
Mixed-Use Residential
2,452
Total Residential Units
(including 386 units below-market rate affordable)
Neighborhood/For-Sale
Residential District
Multifamily
District Mixed-Use
District
Orchards Park
2.5 acres
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 5
SUMMARY OF METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH
This analysis quantifies the net economic impacts
to the County and net fiscal impacts on the City's
General Fund. Impacts from the existing commercial
uses were deducted from gross Project impacts.
Results focus on the “end state” scale of
development, with phasing occurring according to
market conditions and Sunset’s internal planning.
The analysis does not look at spillover benefits
from the Project on existing development, which
will likely see property values increase and
improved sales performance due to the Project’s new
population and amenities.
HR&A used IMPLAN for the economic impact
analysis, which is an industry-standard input-output
model used by leading public and private sector
organizations across the United States. A custom
spreadsheet model was developed to project tax
revenues specific to the City.
Economic and net fiscal results are shown in
constant 2025 dollars;fiscal results are also
shown in constant dollars (i.e., including
inflation). For economic impacts, all inputs to the
IMPLAN model were set to 2025 dollars (e.g.,
construction costs, anticipated household incomes)
and were modeled at one point in time at full build-
out. For fiscal impacts, 2025 dollars are calculated
using a discount rate of 11.4% based on the
weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for a set
of major national homebuilders.
Additional detail on the methodological approach is
provided in Appendix A of this document.
APPROACH
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 6
Assumptions were sourced primarily from Sunset
(independently reviewed by HR&A), City of San
Ramon, U.S. Census Bureau, and other third-party
data sources. Where appropriate, HR&A made
additional assumptions reflective of the market and
Project characteristics.
City service costs, tax rates, and tax formulas are
from the FY 2025-26 San Ramon budget and are
assumed to remain constant over the course of
development (but subject to inflation adjustments).
The costs of City services delivered to the Project
are conservatively based on a per-capita cost
accounting method that expresses Project residents
and employees as “resident equivalents” based on
the time they spend in the City to calculate average
per-capita General Fund operating budgets of
applicable City departments and certain other line
items whose budgets tend to be affected by the
Project’s new City population.
The analysis is consistent with the tax sharing
agreement between Contra Costa County and the
City of San Ramon that governs the distribution of
property taxes within Bishop Ranch. Accordingly,
HR&A assumes 50 percent of new sales tax revenues
from the Project’s retail operations would be debited
from the City’s expected property tax general levy.
The analysis assumes no major disruptive
economic events to the Contra Costa economy
over the course of Project development.
Following City review of the initial draft fiscal
analysis from August 2025, certain calculation
adjustments are reflected in this updated version.
Additional detail on assumptions for this analysis is
also provided in Appendix A of this document.
SUMMARY OF ASSUMPTIONS
ASSUMPTIONS
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 7
ECONOMIC IMPACTS: SUMMARY | The Project is expected to generate almost
9,000 jobs and approximately $2.1 billion in one-time economic impacts and
over 2,000 jobs and $358.2 million in ongoing economic impacts to Contra
Costa County.
ONE-TIME IMPACTS RECURRING IMPACTS
Impacts to the Contra Costa County economy
resulting from construction activities.
Revenues to the Contra Costa County economy resulting
for ongoing operations at full build-out in 2045.
SUPPORTED EMPLOYMENT
8,976 jobs
$860.4 million
(2025 dollars)
TOTAL ECONOMIC OUTPUT
$2.1 billion
(2025 dollars)
EMPLOYEE COMPENSTATION
Source: IMPLAN, HR&A
SUPPORTED EMPLOYMENT
2,032 jobs
$123.1 million
(2025 dollars)
TOTAL ECONOMIC OUTPUT
$358.2 million
(2025 dollars)
EMPLOYEE COMPENSTATION
Note: As a simplifying modeling assumption, we assumed that all new construction occurred in 2025 to report all economic impacts in
2025 dollars.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 8
Impact
Category Employment Employee
Compensation
Total Economic
Output
Direct 6,083 $642,690,000 $1,467,230,000
Indirect 1,381 $114,060,000 $314,420,000
Induced 1,512 $103,690,000 $309,120,000
Total Impact 8,976 $860,430,000 $2,090,770,000
ECONOMIC IMPACTS: ONE-TIME | Project construction will contribute
approximately $1.5 billion directly to the San Ramon economy, with a multiplier
effect leading to an additional $623.5 million to the wider Contra Costa
economy.
ONE-TIME IMPACT SUMMARYInducedIndirect
INDIRECT
INDUCED
DIRECT effects are from spending associated with
Project construction. These effects occur primarily
at the site, within the City of San Ramon.
INDIRECT effects are from spending by
businesses supplying construction-related
goods and services.
INDUCED effects from household spending
due to income received from direct and
indirect activities.
DIRECT
Source: IMPLAN, HR&A
MU
L
T
I
P
L
I
E
R
EF
F
E
C
T
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 9
ECONOMIC IMPACTS: RECURRING | At build-out, Project operations will
contribute approximately $358.2 million of economic output to the Contra
Costa economy.
Source: IMPLAN, HR&A
InducedIndirect
INDIRECT
INDUCED
DIRECT effects are from spending
immediately associated with annual retail
operations and property management.
INDIRECT effects are from spending by
businesses supplying goods and services to
building operations and retail tenants.
INDUCED effects from household spending
by direct and indirect workers and new
Project households.
DIRECT
MU
L
T
I
P
L
I
E
R
EF
F
E
C
T
Impact
Category Employment Employee
Compensation
Total Economic
Output
Direct 605 $23,300,000 $64,260,000
Indirect 100 $8,670,000 $22,330,000
Induced 1,327 $91,100,000 $271,580,000
Total Impact 2,032 $123,080,000 $358,180,000
SUMMARY OF RECURRING IMPACTS IN 2045
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 10
FISCAL IMPACTS: SUMMARY | By 2045, the Project will have generated $4.8
million in one-time revenues and $4.4 million in revenues from annual
operations to San Ramon, for a combined total of $9.2 million (all in 2025 $).
ONE-TIME IMPACTS RECURRING IMPACTS
Impacts to the City of San Ramon resulting from
construction activities.
Net revenues to the City of San Ramon resulting from
annual operations through 2045.
IMPACT THROUGH 2045
Source: HR&A
Note: 2025 dollars calculated using a discount rate of 11.4% based on the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for a set of
major national homebuilders.
IMPACT THROUGH 2045
ANNUAL IMPACT AT FULL BUILD-OUT$0.09 million
(2025 dollars, in 2045)$0.89 million
(nominal dollars, in 2045)
$4.4 million
(2025 dollars)
$14.2 million
(nominal dollars)
$4.8 million
(2025 dollars)
$9.7 million
(nominal dollars)
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 11
Category Nominal $2025 $
Construction Property Tax $1,376,000 $648,000
Construction MVLF In Lieu $319,000 $150,000
Construction Materials Sales Tax $6,917,000 $3,365,000
Documentary Transfer Tax (Initial
Sales)$1,042,000 $658,000
Net Fiscal Impact $9,654,000 $4,822,000
FISCAL IMPACTS: ONE-TIME | 70 percent of one-time fiscal revenues to San
Ramon will come from sales tax on construction materials.
Source: HR&A
DISTRIBUTION OF ONE-TIME FISCAL
REVENUES FROM CONSTRUCTION
2026-2045
GENERAL FUND FISCAL REVENUES
RE
V
E
N
U
E
S
T
H
R
O
U
G
H
2
0
4
5
Note: Construction sales tax revenues from building materials assume proper registration of the construction site with the California
Department of Tax and Fee Administration. Motor Vehicle in Lieu Fee (“MVLF”) is an additional property tax provided by the State
to communities following the elimination of local receipt of Motor Vehicle License Fees in 2005.
Property Tax
13%
MVLF
3%
Sales Tax
70%
Documentary
Transfer Tax
14%
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 12
Category Nominal $2025 $
Property Tax $41,651,000 $10,657,000
MVLF In Lieu $9,682,000 $2,477,000
Documentary Transfer Tax
(Ongoing Turnover)$2,891,000 $638,000
Franchise Tax $2,998,000 $734,000
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$31,762,000 $9,460,000
Licenses, Permits, Fees & Fines $13,155,000 $3,173,000
Total Revenues $102,139,000 $27,140,000
Less: Existing Prop. Tax & MVLF ($5,567,000)($2,010,000)
Less: City Service Costs ($66,404,000)($16,021,000)
Less: Sales Tax Reduction for
City-County Tax Sharing
Agreement ($15,881,000)($4,730,000)
Net Fiscal Impact $14,297,000 $4,378,000
FISCAL IMPACTS: RECURRING| Over the duration of Project operations (but
not including one-time revenues), property and sales taxes will combine for 74
percent of new General Fund revenues to San Ramon.
Source: HR&A
DISTRIBUTION OF CITY REVENUES
FROM OPERATIONS 2028-2045
GENERAL FUND FISCAL REVENUES
RE
V
E
N
U
E
S
T
H
R
O
U
G
H
2
0
4
5
(O
v
e
r
A
n
a
l
y
s
i
s
P
e
r
i
o
d
)
Note: Property Tax and MVLF in Lieu include property tax turnover, assuming ten percent of homes are re-sold each year, resetting
these taxes for those homes based on their resale price. One-free-standing, deed-restricted affordable housing building may be
eligible for the Welfare Exemption from ad valorem property tax, which is not reflected in this analysis, because the calculation
depends on building specifics which are not yet available.
Sales Tax
35%
Property
Tax
39%
Licenses,
Permits, Fees
& Fines
12%
MVLF In Lieu
9%
Franchise
Tax
3%
Documentary Transfer
Tax
2%
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 13
Category Nominal $2025 $
Property Tax $4,240,000 $436,000
MVLF In Lieu $985,000 $101,000
Documentary Transfer Tax
(Ongoing Turnover)$360,000 $37,000
Franchise Tax $308,000 $32,000
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$2,103,000 $216,000
Licenses, Permits, Fees & Fines $1,414,000 $145,000
Total Revenues $9,408,000 $967,000
Less: Existing Prop. Tax & MVLF ($333,000)($34,000)
Less: City Service Costs ($7,135,000)($734,000)
Less: Sales Tax Reduction for
City-County Tax Sharing
Agreement ($1,052,000)($108,000)
Net Fiscal Impact $887,000 $91,000
FISCAL IMPACTS: RECURRING| At full build-out, property and sales taxes will
combine for just over two-thirds of new General Fund revenues from Project
annual operations to San Ramon.
Source: HR&A
DISTRIBUTION OF CITY REVENUES
FROM OPERATIONS IN 2045
GENERAL FUND FISCAL REVENUES
RE
V
E
N
U
E
S
I
N
2
0
4
5
(F
u
l
l
B
u
i
l
d
-Ou
t
)
Note: Property Tax and MVLF in Lieu include property tax turnover, assuming ten percent of homes are re-sold each year, resetting
these taxes for those homes based on their resale price. One-free-standing, deed-restricted affordable housing building may be
eligible for the Welfare Exemption from ad valorem property tax, which is not reflected in this analysis, because the calculation
depends on building specifics which are not yet available.
Sales Tax
22%
Property
Tax
45%
Licenses,
Permits, Fees
& Fines15%
MVLF In Lieu
11%
Franchise
Tax
3%
Documentary Transfer
Tax
4%
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 14
GENERAL AND LIMITING CONDITIONS
1.Any person who relies on or otherwise uses this Study is required to have first read, understood and accepted the following disclosures, limitations and disclaimers, and will, by reason of such reliance or other use, be deemed to have read, understood and accepted the same.
2.HR&A Advisors, Inc. (HR&A) has been engaged and compensated by Sunset Development Company to prepare this Study. In preparing this Study, HR&A has used its independent professional judgment and skills in good faith, subject to the limitations, disclosures and disclaimers herein.
3.This Study is based on estimates, assumptions and other information developed by HR&A, other third-party consultants, and city officials. Every reasonable effort has been made to ensure that the data contained in this Study are accurate as of the date of this Study; however, factors exist that are outside the control of HR&A and that may affect the estimates and/or projections noted herein. HR&A neither guarantees any results nor takes responsibility for their actual achievement or continuing applicability, as actual outcomes will depend on future events and circumstances beyond HR&A’s control.
4.HR&A reviewed the information and projections provided by third parties using its independent professional judgment and skills in good faith, but assumes no liability resulting from errors, omissions or any other inaccuracies with respect to the information provided by such third parties referenced in this Study.
5.HR&A also relied on data provided by or purchased from the U.S. Census, American Community Survey, Minnesota IMPLAN Group (MIG), CoStar Group, and discussion with staff at Sunset Development Company. HR&A assumes no liability resulting from errors, omissions, or any other inaccuracies with respect to the information provided by these parties.
6.In addition to relying on data, information, projections, and forecasts of others as referred to above, HR&A has included in this Study estimates and assumptions made by HR&A that HR&A believes are appropriate, but HR&A makes no representation that there will be no variances between actual outcomes and such estimates and assumptions.
7.No summary or abstract of this Study, and no excerpts from this Study, may be made for any purpose without HR&A’s prior written consent.
8.HR&A has provided estimates of potential property tax impacts in San Ramon based on our experience and familiarity with national best practices for tax assessments of income-producing properties. HR&A is not a licensed real estate appraiser and makes no further representations regarding such estimates.
9.No opinion is intended to be expressed, and no responsibility is assumed for any matters that are legal in nature or require legal expertise or specialized knowledge beyond that of a real estate consultant.
10.Many of the figures presented in this report will be rounded. HR&A disclaims any and all liability relating to rounding errors.
11.This Study may be relied on and otherwise used only by persons who receive this Study from HR&A or with HR&A’s prior written consent and only for the purpose stated in writing in conjunction with such receipt or consent. No reliance on or other use of this Study by any person or for any purpose other than as stated in the previous sentence is permitted. HR&A disclaims all responsibility in the case of any reliance on or other use of this Study in conflict with the above portions of this paragraph.
12.If the Study is referred to or included in any offering material or prospectus, the Study shall be deemed to have been included for informational purposes only and its use shall be subject to these General and Limiting Conditions. HR&A, its directors, officers and employees have no liability to recipients of any such offering material or prospectus. HR&A disclaims any and all liability to any party.
13.This Study is qualified in its entirety by, and should be considered in light of these General and Limiting Conditions. By use of this Study, each party that uses this Study agrees to be bound by all of the General and Limiting Conditions stated herein.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 15
APPENDIX A
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 16
Appendix Guide
Appendix A is divided into two sections, one each for the Economic Impacts and Fiscal Impacts analyses. Within each section,
additional detail is provided on the approach and assumptions used for that analysis. Each section also contains tables of
supporting calculation detail for the results presented in this analysis.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 17
Economic Impacts
Methodology, Assumptions, and Summary Tables
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 18
Economic Impact Methodology
HR&A’s economic impact analysis considers the one-time impact of Project construction and the ongoing impact from Project
operations each year. Economic inputs include direct, indirect, induced, and total effects, as explained below.
Induced
Indirect
Direct Initial change in spending or employment attributable
to new investment (e.g., construction of new market rate
and affordable homes).
Change in spending or employment by businesses that
supply goods and services to the directly affected
industry (e.g., construction material suppliers).
Change in household spending of employees who are
compensated for working in the directly and indirectly
affected industry sectors (e.g., food and beverage
spending by construction workers). Also includes
household spending by households in new residential
development.
Multiplier
Impacts
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 19
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
HR&A used IMPLAN to estimate the economic impacts of the
development and operation of the Project on the local economy.
IMPLAN, created by IMPLAN Group, LLC (formerly MIG, Inc. and
the Minnesota IMPLAN Group, Inc.), is an industry standard
input-output model used to conduct economic impact analyses by
leading public and private sector organizations across the United
States. It also has been used to monitor job creation for a range
of Federal government initiatives, including the economic impacts
of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 on state
economies.
HR&A conducted its analysis using the IMPLAN input-output
model for the Contra Costa County economy. IMPLAN analysis
traces the pattern of commodity purchases and sales between
industries that are associated with each dollar’s worth of a
product or service sold to a customer, analyzing interactions
among 528 industry sectors. The model makes adjustments to
exclude spending that takes place outside of the study area. The
model relies on data about the Contra Costa County economy as
of 2023 (latest available).
In addition to overall economic output, the IMPLAN input-output
model also produces estimates of the number of jobs supported
and worker compensation. It includes wage and salary income
plus benefits and employer paid taxes, in addition to income
earned by independent proprietors. The estimates of jobs and
labor income are based on the Bureau of Labor Statistics’
Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages (QCEW), data from
the Census Bureau’s County Business Patterns data, and data from
the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis Regional Economic and
Product Accounts. A full description of IMPLAN and its data
methods and sources can be found at www.implan.com.
Economic Impact Methodology
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 20
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Economic Impact Methodology
One-Time Economic Impacts in Contra Cosa County from Construction of the Orchards at Bishop Ranch
Category Direct Indirect Induced Total
Output
1. For-Sale Residential $315,080,483 $64,584,598 $71,139,499 $450,804,580
2. Multifamily $779,627,996 $169,318,821 $161,748,518 $1,110,695,335
3. Mixed $372,521,478 $80,516,900 $76,232,268 $529,270,646
Total $1,467,229,957 $314,420,320 $309,120,285 $2,090,770,561
Employment
1. For-Sale Residential 1,451 277 348 2,076
2. Multifamily 3,138 750 791 4,679
3. Mixed 1,494 354 373 2,220
Total 6,083 1,381 1,512 8,976
Labor Income
1. For-Sale Residential $151,380,470 $22,889,435 $23,862,575 $198,132,481
2. Multifamily $333,791,739 $62,034,137 $54,256,002 $450,081,877
3. Mixed $157,514,606 $29,133,850 $25,570,888 $212,219,344
Total $642,686,816 $114,057,422 $103,689,466 $860,433,703
Source(s): Sunset Development; IMPLAN; HR&A
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 21
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Economic Impact Methodology
Ongoing Economic Impacts in Contra Cosa County from Construction of the Orchards at Bishop Ranch
Category Direct Indirect Induced Total
Output
1. For-Sale Residential --$51,696,619 $51,696,619
2. Multifamily $10,479,131 $4,690,465 $146,146,008 $161,315,604
3. Mixed $53,778,863 $17,642,956 $73,741,013 $145,162,833
Total $64,257,994 $22,333,421 $271,583,641 $358,175,056
Employment
1. For-Sale Residential --258 258
2. Multifamily 42 21 710 773
3. Mixed 563 79 359 1,001
Total 605 100 1,327 2,032
Labor Income
1. For-Sale Residential --$17,332,911 $17,332,911
2. Multifamily $3,113,276 $1,654,569 $49,042,929 $53,810,774
3. Mixed $20,190,144 $7,019,654 $24,724,253 $51,934,051
Total $23,303,420 $8,674,223 $91,100,093 $123,077,737
Source(s): Sunset Development; IMPLAN; HR&A
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 22
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Economic Impact Methodology
Construction Cost Allocation
Cost Categories Estimated Construction Cost
(2025 $)Modelable?Estimated Costs for IMPLAN IMPLAN Sector #IMPLAN Sector
Component
For-Sale Residential
Hard Costs $199,550,000 100%$199,550,000 52 Construction of new Single-Family residential structures
Soft Costs $61,516,000 100%$61,516,000 439 Architectural, engineering, and related services
Fee Costs $42,734,000 0%$0
Land Costs $193,300,000 0%$0
Demolition Costs - Infrastructure $4,522,183 100%$4,522,183 55 Maintenance and repair construction of nonresidential structures
Hard Costs - Infrastructure $46,236,228 100%$46,236,228 49 Construction of new highways and streets
Soft Costs - Infrastructure $3,256,072 100%$3,256,072 439 Architectural, engineering, and related services
Property Taxes - Infrastructure $1,139,625 0%$0
0 0 0
Multifamily (Not Mixed-Use)0 0 0
Hard Costs $549,375,000 100%$549,375,000 53 Construction of new multifamily residential structures
Soft Costs $201,975,000 100%$201,975,000 439 Architectural, engineering, and related services
Fee Costs $91,025,000 0%$0
Land Costs $134,500,000 0%$0
Demolition Costs - Infrastructure $2,367,481 100%$2,367,481 55 Maintenance and repair construction of nonresidential structures
Hard Costs - Infrastructure $24,205,876 100%$24,205,876 49 Construction of new highways and streets
Soft Costs - Infrastructure $1,704,639 100%$1,704,639 439 Architectural, engineering, and related services
Property Taxes - Infrastructure $596,624 0%$0 -
0 0 0
Mixed-Use $0 0 0
Hard Costs $263,075,000 100%$263,075,000 53 Construction of new multifamily residential structures
Soft Costs $83,565,000 100%$83,565,000 439 Architectural, engineering, and related services
Fee Costs $40,235,000 0%$0
Land Costs $61,900,000 0%$0
Tenant Improvement Costs $8,640,882 100%$8,640,882 55 Maintenance and repair construction of nonresidential structures
Demolition Costs - Infrastructure $1,443,412 100%$1,443,412 55 Maintenance and repair construction of nonresidential structures
Hard Costs - Infrastructure $14,757,897 100%$14,757,897 49 Construction of new highways and streets
Soft Costs - Infrastructure $1,039,288 100%$1,039,288 439 Architectural, engineering, and related services
Property Taxes – Infrastructure $363,751 0%$0
Total $2,033,023,958 -$1,467,229,958
Source(s): Sunset Development
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 23
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Economic Impact Methodology
Retail Program Modeling Inputs
Category Category
% of
Program Leasable SF Sales PSF Total Sales
Vacancy
Adjusted Sales
IMPLAN Sector
#IMPLAN Sector
Grocery Grocery 17%20,839 $1,000 $20,838,546 $19,129,785 381 Wholesale - Grocery and related product wholesalers
Full-Service Restaurant Food 12%14,467 $922 $13,345,114 $12,250,815 491 Full-service restaurants
Fine Fast Casual Food 8%9,645 $1,127 $10,870,492 $9,979,112 492 Limited-service restaurants
Walk-Up (coffee, juice, etc)Food 6%7,307 $986 $7,203,482 $6,612,797 493 All other food and drinking places
Health and Convenience Retail (Goods)9%10,850 $1,015 $11,007,768 $10,105,131 380 Wholesale - Drugs and druggists’ sundries
Health and Beauty Retail (Goods)5%6,028 $423 $2,547,737 $2,338,822 380 Wholesale - Drugs and druggists’ sundries
Misc Retail Retail (Goods)20%24,112 $214 $5,153,449 $4,730,867 394 Retail - General merchandise stores
Jeweler Retail (Goods)3%3,617 $1,886 $6,821,879 $6,262,485 395 Retail - Miscellaneous store retailers
Hardware Store Retail (Goods)2%2,411 $412 $992,468 $911,086 388
Retail - Building material and garden equipment and supplies
stores
Apparel Retail (Goods)3%3,200 $1,127 $3,607,718 $3,311,885 392 Retail - Clothing and clothing accessories stores
Boutique Fitness Retail (Services)8%9,645 $936 $9,031,084 $8,290,535 487 Fitness and recreational sports centers
Laundromat Retail (Services)5%6,028 $57 $341,122 $313,150 501 Dry-cleaning and laundry services
Hair Salon Retail (Services)2%2,411 $613 $1,478,194 $1,356,982 499 Personal care services
Overall 100%120,560 $773 $93,239,054 $85,593,451
Source(s): Sunset Development; Retail Maxim (2021); HR&A
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 24
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Economic Impact Methodology
Housing Program Modeling Inputs
Project Component IMPLAN Sector Inputs
For-Sale Residential 10009 - Households GT200k $121,568,146
Multifamily 10008 - Households 150-200k $212,229,921
Multifamily 10007 - Households 100-150k $9,431,468
Multifamily 10006 - Households 70-100k $9,737,398
Multifamily 10005 - Households 50-70k $6,094,667
Mixed 10008 - Households 150-200k $97,629,413
Mixed 10007 - Households 100-150k $4,352,985
Mixed 10005 - Households 50-70k $2,782,348
Total $463,826,346
Source(s): HR&A Advisors
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 25
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Economic Impact Methodology
Multifamily On-Site FTEs
Project Component IMPLAN Sector #IMPLAN Sector FTEs
Multifamily 429 Other real estate 42
Mixed-Use (Multifamily/Retail)429 Other real estate 16
Source(s): Sunset Development
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 26
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Economic Impact Methodology
Household Size to Bedroom Count Conversion
Household Size Bed Room Count
1 person Studio
2 person 1-Bed
3 person 2-Bed
4 person 3-Bed
6 person 4-Bed
Source(s): HCD
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 27
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Economic Impact Methodology
2025 Maximum Qualifying Annual Income Levels for San Ramon by Household Size (Inclusionary)
Income Category 1 Person 2 Persons 3 Persons 4 Persons 5 Persons 6 Persons 7 Persons 8 Persons
Acutely Low $16,750 $19,150 $21,550 $23,950 $25,850 $27,800 $29,700 $31,600
Extremely Low (30% AMI)$33,600 $38,400 $43,200 $47,950 $51,800 $55,650 $59,500 $63,300
Very Low Income (50% AMI)$55,950 $63,950 $71,950 $79,900 $86,300 $92,700 $99,100 $105,500
Low Income (80% AMI)$87,550 $100,050 $112,550 $125,050 $135,100 $145,100 $155,100 $165,100
Median Income $111,850 $127,850 $143,800 $159,800 $172,600 $185,350 $198,150 $210,950
Moderate Income (120% AMI)$134,250 $153,400 $172,600 $191,750 $207,100 $222,450 $237,750 $253,100
Source(s): HCD
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 28
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Economic Impact Methodology
Inclusionary Rents and Average Household Income
Category Unit Distribution Unit Mix 50% AMI Units (Half
of Units)
80% AMI Units
(Half of Units)
Max Monthly Rent
per Unit (50%
AMI)
Max Monthly Rent per
Unit (80% AMI)
Total Annual Rent
Revenue
Assumptions
Studio 10%27 13.4 13.4 $1,399 $2,189 $575,148
1 Bedroom 40%107 53.4 53.4 $1,599 $2,501 $2,629,248
2 Bedroom 40%107 53.4 53.4 $1,799 $2,814 $2,957,904
3 Bedroom 10%27 13.4 13.4 $1,998 $3,126 $821,440
Total 100%267 133.6 133.6 $6,983,740
Weighted Average Household Income $ 67,945 $ 106,300
Source: HCD
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 29
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Economic Impact Methodology
2025 MSTP Income and Rent Limits and Average Household Income (LIHTC)
Category Income Limits (60%
AMI)
Rent Limit
(60% AMI)Unit Distribution Unit Mix Total Annual Rent
Revenue
Assumptions
1 bedroom $76,740 $1,798 50%60 $1,283,772
2 bedroom $86,340 $2,158 25%30 $770,406
3 bedroom $95,880 $2,493 25%30 $890,001
Total 100%119 $2,944,179
Weighted Average Household Income $83,925
Source: HCD
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 30
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Economic Impact Methodology
Housing Income Calculation
Category Townhome Row House Detached Court Multifamily -
Market Rate
Multifamily
(Inclusionary - 80%
AMI)
Multifamily
(Inclusionary - 50%
AMI)
Multifamily
(LIHTC)Total
Total Units 138 58 130 42 1,698 133 134 119 2,452
For-Sale Only
Estimated Sales Price $1,250,000 $1,650,000 $1,900,000 $2,500,000 ----
Down Payment (20%)$250,000 $330,000 $380,000 $500,000 ----
Loan Amount $1,000,000 $1,320,000 $1,520,000 $2,000,000 ----
Interest Rate 6.6%6.6%6.6%6.6%----
Term (Years)30 30 30 30 ----
Monthly Mortgage $6,378 $6,378 $6,378 $6,378 ----
Property Tax (1.14%)$1,187 $1,187 $1,187 $1,187 ----
Homeowner's Insurance $347 $458 $527 $694 ----
Maintenance (1% of home value)$1,042 $1,042 $1,042 $1,042 ----
Household Income Estimate
Average Monthly Mortgage or Rent $8,954 $9,065 $9,134 $9,301 $4,200 $2,658 $1,699 $2,098
Average Annual Mortgage or Rent $107,445 $108,777 $109,610 $111,608 $50,398 ---
Average Annual Utility Cost $6,727 $6,727 $6,727 $6,727 $5,983 ---
Total Annual Housing Cost $114,172 $115,504 $116,337 $118,335 $56,381 $31,890 $20,384 $25,178
Housing Cost as a Share of Household Income 35.0%35.0%35.0%35.0%30.0%30.0%30.0%30.0%
Required Gross Household Income $326,206 $330,012 $332,391 $338,099 $187,935 $106,300 $67,945 $83,925
Total Project Gross Household Income $45,016,484 $19,140,703 $43,210,790 $14,200,169 $319,113,630 $14,137,900 $9,104,630 $9,987,075 $473,911,381
Estimated Vacancy Rate 0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%2.9%2.5%2.5%2.5%
Total Income from Occupied Units $45,016,484 $19,140,703 $43,210,790 $14,200,169 $309,859,334 $13,784,453 $8,877,015 $9,737,398 $463,826,346
IMPLAN Income Band
10009 -
Households
GT200k
10009 -
Households
GT200k
10009 -
Households
GT200k
10009 -
Households
GT200k
10008 -
Households
150-200k
10007 - Households
100-150k
10005 -
Households 50-70k
10006 -
Households
70-100k
Source(s): Sunset Development Company; US BLS Consumer Expenditure Survey; HCD; CoStar; HR&A Advisors
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 31
Fiscal Impacts
Methodology, Assumptions, and Summary Tables
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 32
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
To construct the fiscal impact analysis model for the Project, HR&A
used public and proprietary third-party data to estimate certain
real estate metrics, City municipal code requirements, and City
budget data to identify tax revenues and tax formulas
applicable to the Project, and industry-standard tax revenue and
municipal services cost analysis approaches. Sunset provided
HR&A with certain assumptions about the Project including the
scale of Project components, phasing, and estimates of sale
prices and rents and for each category of new housing and an
illustrative retail program and pricing for the completed
Project.
HR&A quantified both one-time construction-rated impacts and
recurring fiscal impacts to the General Fund for the City of San
Ramon. One-time impacts include tax revenues resulting from
property tax revenues on in-progress construction, initial real
estate transfer tax on home sales, and the City’s share of sales
tax on construction materials (assuming the construction site is
properly registered by the contractors with the State of
California for this purpose). The construction tax revenue
estimates do not include any planning fees, construction permits,
developer fees, or mitigation fee charges because these charges
are generally set at rates intended to directly offset City costs
and, therefore, do not represent net new revenues that can be
used to fund other City expenditures.
Recurring fiscal impacts refer to City revenues and costs that
occur on an annual basis as the Project is completed in phases,
leased, and stabilized. Estimated recurring Project revenues are
based on current City tax rates and tax formulas, which are
assumed to remain unchanged (except for the sales tax reversion
to 1% in 2035) over the 2026-2045 projection period (i.e.,
incremental phased completion plus two years for stabilized
operation of the last phase), and HR&A analysis.
The estimated costs to deliver City services to the Project are
based on a per-capita cost accounting method that first
expresses the total number of residents and employees working
in the City as “resident equivalents” (based on the time they
spend in the City) and then calculates average per-capita
General Fund operating expenditures for City departments and
certain other line items whose budgets are affected by new
development. The difference between total Project revenues
and estimated City services costs, less current property tax
revenues and tax sharing agreement adjustments (see pg. 34),
yields the net fiscal impact of the Project.
Results are shown in constant 2025-dollars unless otherwise
specified, using a discount rate of 11.4% which is the weighted
average cost of capital for a set of major national homebuilders.
Fiscal Impact Methodology
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 33
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
Descriptions of key revenue sources for the City of San Ramon’s
General Fund are as follows:
Sales Tax. The State Department of Tax and Fee Administration
allocates one percent of local sales tax revenue back to the City
for general purposes. Additionally, in November 2024 voters
approved Measure N, which increased the City’s sales tax rate
by one percent through 2034, unless extended by the voters,
which extension is not assumed in this analysis. HR&A’s analysis
includes sales tax generated from direct retail sales, spending by
Project households in San Ramon, and designated construction
materials.
Property Tax. The property tax applicable to the Project site
includes a one percent general levy on the assessed value of land
and buildings, which is distributed among different local taxing
entity accounts including the City. As each Project phase is
completed, assessed value is based on the weighted average
sales price for homes sold in that phase. Thereafter, assessed
value of those homes is increased by two percent annually in
accordance with Proposition 13. The analysis assumes that 3.5
percent of detached single family and 7.5 percent of attached
single family homes in each phase are re-sold each year, which
resets the property tax for those homes based on their resale
price, which in turn assumes annual appreciation above the
original sale price.
Property Tax In Lieu of Motor Vehicle License Fees. This
additional property tax revenue is provided by the State to
communities following the elimination of local receipt of Motor
Vehicle License Fees in 2005. The motor vehicle in lieu fee (MVLF)
amount is set by the State based on the total assessed value of
land and buildings in a given municipality each year. HR&A
calculates MLVF based on the ratio of MVLF in FY 2024 and
assessed value in FY 2024. This tax revenue calculation is also
derived from assessed value, and hence it is based on the same
per-phase weighted average sales price of homes sold each
year, including resales.
Documentary Transfer Tax. The City collects a transfer tax on
every real estate transaction. HR&A applies this tax to each unit
subject to initial sale and annual re-sale based on its sale price in
that year.
Franchise Tax. A franchise fee is imposed on various utilities,
which permits them to use and operate facilities within the City.
The fee is based on the gross income derived by each utility from
charges to new Project businesses and households. This tax is
applied as each building and phase is completed.
Operating Transfers In and Out. At the City’s request, HR&A
subsequently added cost factors for citywide insurance and for
infrastructure maintenance and replacement.
Fiscal Impact Methodology
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 34
10M SF
Known
Pipeline
The following methodological component warrant further
clarification:
Open Space Maintenance: Modeling assumes Sunset
Development will develop and maintain the central park and
trails system as part of the Project, avoiding increased services
costs for the City. The fiscal model, however, still accounts for
increased expenses for the Parks and Community Services
Department which might be overstated given the current plans for
maintenance.
Tax Sharing Agreement: Given the Project’s location in Bishop
Ranch, a 585-acre area annexed into the City in 1987, the
Project is subject to the Master Property Tax Exchange
Agreement for Allocation of Property Tax (Master Agreement)
between the County and City. Under the latest version of the
Master Agreement adopted on June 14, 2016, property tax
revenue allocation to the City for parcels within Bishop Ranch is
reduced by 50 percent of the total sales tax and transient
occupancy taxes collected in the Bishop Ranch area. To account
for the impact of the Master Agreement on the Project, net fiscal
impacts were reduced by 50 percent of the sales tax revenues
anticipated from ongoing operations of the retail component of
the Project.
Property Turnover: HR&A did not consider the sale or resale of
apartment buildings. Inclusion of turnover for apartment buildings
would increase the property tax projections for the multifamily
and mixed-use components of the Project.
Rental Units vs. Condominiums: Our estimate of City revenues
from multifamily residential units assumes all units will be rentals.
If some share of the units are eventually developed as
condominium units, City revenues and net fiscal impact from those
units and the Project overall would likely be greater, due to (1)
higher assessed building values and hence more local property
tax revenue; (2) higher household incomes generating more
household spending subject to local sales tax; (3) additional local
real estate transfer tax revenue from periodic condo re-sales;
and (4) no material difference in allocated City operating costs
Welfare Exemption: HR&A did not apply any welfare exemption
sometimes accorded to affordable housing complexes that are
owned by non-profits. Most below market units (15% of total) will
be built as inclusionary units within Sunset’s planned residential
developments and therefore would not be eligible for this
exemption. For the one free-standing affordable component (120
units as part of the multifamily district), the ownership structure
has yet to be determined.
Fiscal Impact Methodology
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 35
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Net Fiscal Revenue Impact Summary for the Construction and Annual Operations of the Proposed Project
Full Build-Out
(2045)
Over Analysis Period
(2026-2045)
One-Time Revenues to the City of San Ramon General Fund Nominal $2025 $1 Nominal $2025 $1
Construction Property Tax $157,880 $1,376,022 $648,067
Construction MVLF In Lieu $319,246 $150,356
Construction Materials Sales Tax $18,930 $6,917,087 $3,365,045
Documentary Transfer Tax (Initial Sale)$1,041,883 $658,335
Total One-Time Revenues to the City of San Ramon General Fund $334,689 $9,654,238 $4,821,802
Annual Revenues to the City of San Ramon General Fund
Property Tax $4,238,212 $435,832 $41,651,473 $10,655,780
MVLF In Lieu $984,642 $101,255 $9,682,108 $2,477,435
Documentary Transfer Tax (Ongoing Turnover)$359,715 $36,991 $2,829,116 $639,752
Franchise Tax $307,886 $31,661 $2,997,620 $734,413
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$2,103,142 $216,275 $31,762,051 $9,460,036
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $1,413,873 $145,394 $13,155,210 $3,173,108
Total Annual Recurring Revenues to City's General Fund $9,407,470 $967,408 $102,077,579 $27,140,524
Total General Fund Revenue (One-Time + Annual Recurring)$9,407,470 $967,408 $111,731,817 $31,962,326
Less: Property Tax and MVLF Revenue from Existing Site ($333,156)($34,260)($5,556,533)($2,010,021)
Less: City Service Costs ($7,134,853)($733,706)($66,403,758)($16,021,374)
Less: Sales Tax Reduction for City-County Tax Sharing Agreement ($1,051,571)($108,137)($15,881,025)($4,730,018)
Net Fiscal Impact to City’s General Fund $887,889 $91,305 $23,890,502 $9,200,914
1 Discount rate of 11.4% based on the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for major national homebuilders, sourced from GuruFocus.
Prepared by: HR&A Advisors, Inc.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 36
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Net Fiscal and Other Revenue Impacts from Annual Operations to the City of San Ramon – Year 2045 (Complete Build-Out) – Nominal
Year 2045 (Complete Build Out) - Nominal
Annual Revenues to the City of San Ramon General Fund Total For-Sale Residential Multifamily (Single-Use)Multifamily (Mixed-Use)Other¹
Property Tax $4,238,212 $2,611,660 $1,153,588 $472,963 $0
MVLF In Lieu $984,642 $605,923 $268,988 $109,731 $0
Documentary Transfer Tax $359,715 $359,715 $0 $0 $0
Franchise Tax $307,886 $38,711 $154,108 $115,067 $0
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$2,103,142 $247,887 $566,510 $1,288,745 $0
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $1,413,873 $210,703 $820,327 $382,844 $0
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $9,407,470 $4,074,599 $2,963,521 $2,369,350 $0
Less: Property Tax and MVLF Revenue from Existing Site ($333,156)
Less: City Service Costs ($7,134,853)($1,019,721)($4,169,105)($1,946,027)$0
Less: Sales Tax Reduction for City-County Tax Sharing Agreement ($1,051,571)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund $887,889 $3,054,877 ($1,205,585)$423,324 $0
1Other category includes any horizontal infrastructure not easily assigned to a vertical project component (i.e., demolition/abatement of current office complex, parks and open space).
Prepared by: HR&A Advisors, Inc.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 37
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Net Fiscal and Other Revenue Impacts from Annual Operations to the City of San Ramon -- Year 2045 (Complete Build-Out) – NPV
Year 2045 (Complete Build Out) – NPV
Annual Revenues to the City of San Ramon General Fund Total For-Sale Residential Multifamily (Single-Use)Multifamily (Mixed-Use)Other¹
Property Tax $435,832 $268,568 $118,628 $48,637 $0
MVLF In Lieu $101,255 $62,310 $27,661 $11,284 $0
Documentary Transfer Tax (Ongoing Turnover)$36,991 $36,991 $0 $0 $0
Franchise Tax $31,661 $3,981 $15,848 $11,833 $0
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$216,275 $25,491 $58,256 $132,527 $0
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $145,394 $21,667 $84,357 $39,369 $0
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $967,408 $419,007 $304,751 $243,650 $0
Less: Property Tax and MVLF Revenue from Existing Site ($34,260)
Less: City Service Costs ($733,706)($104,862)($428,726)($200,118)$0
Less: Sales Tax Reduction for City-County Tax Sharing Agreement ($108,137)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund $91,305 $314,145 ($123,975)$43,532 $0
1Other category includes any horizontal infrastructure not easily assigned to a vertical project component (i.e., demolition/abatement of current office complex, parks and open space).
Prepared by: HR&A Advisors, Inc.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 38
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Net Fiscal and Other Revenue Impacts from Annual Operations to the City of San Ramon – Total 2026-2045 Projection Period – Nominal
Total 2026-2045 Projection Period – Nominal
Total For-Sale Residential Multifamily (Single-Use)Multifamily (Mixed-Use)Other¹
One-Time Revenues to the City of San Ramon General Fund
Construction Property Tax $1,376,022 $272,184 $786,521 $317,317 $0
Construction MVLF $319,246 $63,148 $182,478 $73,620 $0
Documentary Transfer Tax (Initial Sale)$1,041,883 $1,041,883 $0 $0 $0
Construction Materials Sales Tax $6,917,087 $1,303,081 $3,846,315 $1,551,769 $215,922
Total One-Time Revenues to the City of San Ramon General
Fund $9,654,238 $2,680,296 $4,815,314 $1,942,706 $215,922
Annual Revenues to the City of San Ramon General Fund
Property Tax $41,651,473 $25,670,292 $9,326,010 $6,655,171 $0
MVLF In Lieu $9,682,108 $5,955,684 $2,182,379 $1,544,045 $0
Documentary Transfer Tax (Ongoing Turnover)$2,829,116 $2,829,116 $0 $0 $0
Franchise Tax $2,997,620 $525,512 $1,054,415 $1,417,694 $0
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$31,762,051 $4,328,356 $3,996,726 $23,436,969 $0
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $13,155,210 $2,860,377 $5,600,389 $4,694,444 $0
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $102,077,579 $42,169,337 $22,159,919 $37,748,323 $0
Total General Fund Revenue $111,731,817 $44,849,633 $26,975,233 $39,691,029 $215,922
Less: Property Tax and MVLF Revenue from Existing Site ($5,556,533)
Less: City Service Costs ($66,403,758)($14,078,960)($28,462,580)($23,862,217)$0
Less: Sales Tax Reduction for City-County Tax Sharing Agreement ($15,881,025)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund $23,890,502 $30,770,673 ($1,487,347)$15,828,812 $215,922
1Other category includes any horizontal infrastructure not easily assigned to a vertical project component (i.e., demolition/abatement of current office complex, parks and open space).
Prepared by: HR&A Advisors, Inc.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 39
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Net Fiscal and Other Revenue Impacts from Annual Operations to the City of San Ramon – Total 2026-2045 Projection Period – NPV
Total 2026-2045 Projection Period - NPV
Total For-Sale Residential Multifamily (Single-Use)Multifamily (Mixed-Use)Other¹
One-Time Revenues to the City of San Ramon General Fund
Construction Property Tax $648,067 $182,641 $261,151 $204,275 $0
Construction MVLF $150,356 $42,374 $60,589 $47,393 $0
Documentary Transfer Tax (Initial Sale)$658,335 $658,335 $0 $0 $0
Construction Materials Sales Tax $3,365,045 $949,821 $1,277,102 $998,965 $139,157
Total One-Time Revenues to the City of San Ramon General
Fund $4,821,802 $1,833,171 $1,598,841 $1,250,634 $139,157
Annual Revenues to the City of San Ramon General Fund
Property Tax $10,655,780 $6,746,786 $1,984,485 $1,924,509 $0
MVLF In Lieu $2,477,435 $1,565,301 $465,635 $446,499 $0
Documentary Transfer Tax (Ongoing Turnover)$639,752 $639,752 $0 $0 $0
Franchise Tax $734,413 $152,113 $212,621 $369,678 $0
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$9,460,036 $1,448,027 $840,070 $7,171,939 $0
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $3,173,108 $827,974 $1,127,775 $1,217,359 $0
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $27,140,524 $11,379,952 $4,630,586 $11,129,985 $0
Total General Fund Revenue $31,962,326 $13,213,123 $6,229,427 $12,380,619 $139,157
Less: Property Tax and MVLF Revenue from Existing Site ($2,010,021)
Less: City Service Costs ($16,021,374)($4,101,809)($5,731,635)($6,187,929)$0
Less: Sales Tax Reduction for City-County Tax Sharing Agreement ($4,730,018)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund $9,200,914 $9,111,314 $497,792 $6,192,689 $139,157
1Other category includes any horizontal infrastructure not easily assigned to a vertical project component (i.e., demolition/abatement of current office complex, parks and open space).
Prepared by: HR&A Advisors, Inc.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 40
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Development Program¹
Product Total Residential Market Rate 80% AMI2 60% AMI2 50% AMI2 Retail
For-Sale Residential 368 Units 368 Units ----
Townhomes 138 Units 138 Units
Row House 58 Units 58 Units
Detached Single Family 130 Units 130 Units
Court 42 Units 42 Units
Multifamily 1,465 Units 1,163 Units 91 Units 119 Units 92 Units -
Multifamily (Single Use)1,345 Units 1,162 Units 91 Units 92 Units
Affordable (LIHTC)120 Units 1 Units 119 Units
Mixed-Use 619 Units 535 Units 42 Units -42 Units 120,560 SF
Multifamily (Mixed Use)619 Units 535 Units 42 Units 42 Units
Retail 120,560 SF
Total 2,452 Units 2,066 Units 133 Units 119 Units 134 Units 120,560 SF
¹ Sunset Development
² Area Median Income (AMI) for Contra Costa County was $143,800 for a 3-person household. HCD, 2025 Income Limits.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 41
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Phasing¹
Development 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035
Townhomes
Units Under Construction 69 69
Units Delivered 138
Units Absorbed 69 69
Row House
Units Under Construction 29 29
Units Delivered 58
Units Absorbed 29 29
Detached Single Family
Units Under Construction 65 65
Units Delivered 130
Units Absorbed 65 65
Court
Units Under Construction 21 21
Units Delivered 42
Units Absorbed 21 21
Affordable Development
Units Under Construction 120
Units Delivered 120
Units Absorbed 120
Multifamily (Single Use)
Units Under Construction 169 169 114 114 70
Units Delivered 337 227
Units Absorbed 169 169 114
Multifamily (Mixed Use)
Units Under Construction 133 133 99 99 79 79
Units Delivered 265 197 157
Units Absorbed 133 133 99 99 79 79
Retail
SF Under Construction 32,328 32,328 13,988 13,988 13,965 13,965
SF Delivered 64,655 27,975 27,930
SF Absorbed 32,328 32,328 13,988 13,988 13,965 13,965
Total Units Constructed --69 184 115 120 169 169 114 114 70
Total Units Absorbed ---69 184 115 120 -169 169 114
¹ Sunset Development
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 42
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Phasing¹
Development 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045
Townhomes
Units Under Construction
Units Delivered
Units Absorbed
Row House
Units Under Construction
Units Delivered
Units Absorbed
Detached Single Family
Units Under Construction
Units Delivered
Units Absorbed
Court
Units Under Construction
Units Delivered
Units Absorbed
Affordable Development
Units Under Construction
Units Delivered
Units Absorbed
Multifamily (Single Use)
Units Under Construction 70 31 31 100 100 190 190
Units Delivered 140 61 200 380
Units Absorbed 114 70 70 31 31 100 100 190 190
Multifamily (Mixed Use)
Units Under Construction
Units Delivered
Units Absorbed
Retail
SF Under Construction
SF Delivered
SF Absorbed
Total Units Constructed 70 31 31 100 100 -190 190 --
Total Units Absorbed 114 70 70 31 31 100 100 -190 190
¹ Sunset Development
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 43
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Construction Hard Costs (2025$)¹
Category Vertical Costs Horizontal Costs Total
For-Sale Residential $199,550,000 $39,996,909 $239,546,909
Townhomes $62,100,000 $12,447,046 $74,547,046
Row House $29,000,000 $5,812,630 $34,812,630
Detached Single Family $78,000,000 $15,633,971 $93,633,971
Court $30,450,000 $6,103,262 $36,553,262
Multifamily $549,375,000 $11,519,598 $560,894,598
Multifamily (Single-Use)$504,375,000 $10,576,013 $514,951,013
Affordable (LITHC)$45,000,000 $943,585 $45,943,585
Mixed-Use $271,715,882 $3,683,493 $275,399,375
Multifamily (Mixed-Use)$263,075,000 $3,683,493 $266,758,493
Retail (Tenant Improvements) $8,640,882 $8,640,882
Demolition/Abatement $8,333,076 $8,333,076
Parks and Open Spaces $30,000,000 $30,000,000
Total $1,020,640,882 $93,533,076 $1,114,173,958
¹Sunset Development
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 44
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Home Values¹
Category Average Sales Price
Townhomes $1,250,000
Row House $1,650,000
Detached Single Family $1,900,000
Court $2,500,000
¹Sunset Development
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 45
Fiscal Impact Methodology
For-Sale Mortgage Assumptions
Category Value
Downpayment¹20%
Interest Rate (30-year fixed rate mortgage)²6.6%
Mortgage Term¹30
Property Tax (% of home value)³1.14%
Homeowners Insurance (% of home value)⁴0.33%
Maintenance (% of home value)¹1.00%
¹ HR&A Advisors, Inc.
² Freddie Mac - Primary Mortgage Market Survey
³ Contra Costa County, Annual Comprehensive Financial Report FY23-24⁴ MoneyGeek - Average Cost of Homeowners Insurance in CA (2025)
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 46
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Operating Assumptions – Apartments
Category Apartment (Market-Rate)Apartment (80% AMI)Apartment (60% AMI)Apartment (50% AMI)
Monthly Rent per Unit1 $4,200 $2,658 $2,098 $1,699
Vacancy Rate1 2 2.9%2.5%2.5%2.5%
OpEx2 30%30%30%30%
Cost of Sale2 3%3%3%3%
¹ CoStar
2 HR&A Advisors, Inc.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 47
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Operating Assumptions – Retail
Use Monthly Rent per SF1
Monthly Rent per Unit1 $2.74
Vacancy Rate1 8.2%
OpEx2 10%
Cost of Sale2 3%
Building Efficiency³86%
Sales PSF² ⁴$773
Taxable Sales 85%
¹ CoStar
2 HR&A Advisors, Inc.
³ Sunset Development⁴ Retail Maxim 2021
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 48
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Financing and Tax Assumptions
Land Use Factors
Apartment Cap Rate1 6.7%
Retail Cap Rate1 7.6%
Discount Rate for 2025 NPV2 11.4%
Annual Inflation Rate³2.9%
Annual Inflation Rate (Property Tax and MVLF In Lieu)2.0%
Housing Appreciation Rate ⁴
Detached Single Family 7.0%
Condo/Townhomes 9.0%
Unit Re-Sale Turnover 4, 5
Detached Single Family 3.5%
Condo/Townhomes 7.5%
1 RERC, 2Q2025
2 Weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for major national homebuilders.
³ Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, 2015-2025 YTD⁴ The Real Estate Market Trends Report - Contra Costa County 2024⁵ American Community Survey 2023 (5-Year Estimate)
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 49
Fiscal Impact Methodology
City Tax Rates
General Fund Factors
General Levy (x Assessed Value)1.0%
City Share of General Levy1 10.2%
2024 City Assessed Value2 $27,430,272,867
2024 City MVLF in Lieu2 $6,506,788
MVLF In Lieu Percentage (x Assessed Value)0.024%
Documentary Transfer Tax3 $1.10/$1,000
Sales and Use Tax3 2.0%
Tax Sharing Agreement Sales Tax Discount on PropertyTax4
Construction 0.00%
Operations 50.00%
Franchise Tax (Internet and Cable)3 5.0%
1 Contra Costa County Assessor
2 FY 2025-26 Adopted Budget, City of San Ramon
3 City of San Ramon Municipal Code; per Measure N (sunset date in
2034), this analysis assumes that the City sales tax rate will revert to
1% in 2035
4 3rd Amendment to the City-County Tax Sharing Agreement
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 50
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Resident Estimates
Category Factors
Avg Future Owner HH Size¹2.90
Avg Future Renter HH Size
Multifamily (Market)¹2.90
Inclusionary Housing ²2.50
Affordable (LIHTC)²2.75
Estimated Residents 6,990
Townhomes 402
Row House 169
Detached Single Family 378
Court 122
Multifamily (Single Use)3,827
Affordable (LIHTC)330
Multifamily (Mixed Use)1,762
¹ Sunset Development
² HCD. Household Size to Bedroom County Conversion
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 51
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Worker and Business Estimates
Category Factors
Retail
Average Units/SF per Establishment 2,565
Number of Establishments / Buildings¹47
Workers (FTE)²596
FTE per Establishment 12.7
Apartment
Workers (FTE)³58
FTE per Unit 0.027831094
1 HR&A assumption based on Sunset Development program.
2 IMPLAN
3 Sunset Development
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 52
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Household Spending – Housing Costs¹
Category Annual Utilities1 Housing Cost2
For-Sale Housing $6,727 35%
Apartment (Market-Rate)$5,983 30%
Apartment (80% AMI)Part of rent allowance 30%
Apartment (60% AMI)Part of rent allowance 30%
Apartment (50% AMI)Part of rent allowance 30%
¹ Consumer Expenditure Survey, 2023
2 HR&A Advisors, Inc.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 53
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Household Spending Categories
Annual Consumer Expenditures1 Percent Taxable2
Adjustment for Shopping @
Project2
Food at Home 25%-10%
Food Away from Home 100%-5%
Alcoholic Beverages 100%0%
Housekeeping Supplies 100%0%
Household Furnishings & Equipment 100%-5%
Apparel & Services 100%0%
Transportation 100%0%
Entertainment (less Fees & Admissions)100%-5%
Personal Care Products & Services 100%-10%
Reading 100%0%
Tobacco Products 100%-5%
Miscellaneous 100%0%
Housing Costs 0%0%
Health Care 0%-2%
Entertainment - Fees & Admissions 0%0%
Education 0%0%
Cash Contributions 0%0%
Personal Insurance and Pensions 0%0%
¹ Consumer Expenditure Survey, 2023
2 HR&A Advisors, Inc.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 54
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Property Taxes (Construction)
Stabilized Valuation Factors Values4
For-Sale Residential $239,546,909
Townhomes $74,547,046
Row House $34,812,630
Detached Single Family $93,633,971
Court $36,553,262
Multifamily $560,894,597.71
Multifamily (Single-Use)$514,951,013
Affordable (LIHTC)$45,943,585
Mixed-Use $275,399,375
Mixed-Use $266,758,493
Retail $8,640,882
Total Assessed Value $1,075,840,882
Property Tax General Levy Factors Values
General Levy (x Assessed Value)3 1.0%$10,758,409
For-Sale Residential $2,395,469
Townhome $745,470
Row House $348,126
Detached Single Family $936,340
Court $365,533
Multifamily $5,608,946
Multifamily (Single-Use)$5,149,510
Affordable (LIHTC)$459,436
Mixed-Use $2,753,994
Mixed-Use $2,667,585
Retail $86,409
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 55
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Property Taxes (Construction) – continued
City Share of General Levy3 10.2%$1,099,977
For-Sale Residential $244,921
Townhome $76,220
Row House $35,594
Detached Single Family $95,735
Court $37,373
Multifamily $573,478.3
Multifamily (Single-Use)$526,504
Affordable (LIHTC)$46,974
Mixed-Use $281,578
Mixed-Use $272,743
Retail $8,835
MVLF In Lieu (x Assessed Value)3 0.0237%$255,202
For-Sale Residential $56,823
Townhome $17,683.45
Row House $8,257.97
Detached Single Family $22,211.10
Court $8,670.87
Multifamily $133,051
Multifamily (Single-Use)$122,152.52
Affordable (LIHTC)$10,898.37
Mixed-Use $65,328
Mixed-Use $63,278.30
Retail $2,049.72
1 Sunset Development. Includes both market-rate and affordable units.
2 Allocation based on total program units by product type.
3 See Appendix A - Table 2: Land Use Assumptions
4 Based on the total hard costs of construction.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 56
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Onsite Construction Sales + Use Tax
Land Use
Total Allocated Hard
Costs (2025 $)1 % Building Materials Taxable Sales
% Sales
Occurring in
San Ramon
Taxable Sales in San
Ramon
City's Sales
Tax Rate2
Total Construction
Sales (2019 $)3
Townhomes $74,547,046 50%$37,273,523 50%$18,636,762 2.0%$372,735.23
Row House $34,812,630 50%$17,406,315 50%$8,703,158 2.0%$174,063.15
Detached Single Family $93,633,971 50%$46,816,985 50%$23,408,493 2.0%$468,169.85
Court $36,553,262 50%$18,276,631 50%$9,138,315 2.0%$182,766.31
Multifamily (Single-Use)$514,951,013 50%$257,475,506 50%$128,737,753 2.0%$2,574,755.06
Affordable (LIHTC)$45,943,585 50%$22,971,792 50%$11,485,896 2.0%$229,717.92
Multifamily (Mixed-Use)$266,758,493 50%$133,379,247 50%$66,689,623 2.0%$1,333,792.47
Retail $8,640,882 50%$4,320,441 50%$2,160,220 2.0%$43,204.41
Demolition/Abatement $8,333,076 50%$4,166,538 50%$2,083,269 2.0%$41,665.38
Parks and Open Spaces $30,000,000 50%$15,000,000 50%$7,500,000 2.0%$150,000.00
Total $1,067,200,000 $5,336,000
1 See Appendix A - Table 3: Estimated Property Taxes (Construction)
2 Assumes 2.0% sales tax rate remains in effect through 2034, then reverts to 1.0% in 2035 through the remainder of the projection period.
3 Assumes the City will work with the contractors to ensure the point of sale of all materials occurs at the worksite (i.e. within City limits).
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 57
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Property Taxes
Stabilized Valuation Factors Values5
For-Sale Residential (Townhomes)
Average Price per Unit1 $1,250,000
Total Units1 138
Gross Sales $172,500,000
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 3%-$5,175,000
Net Value = Assessed Value $167,325,000
For-Sale Residential (Row House)
Average Price per Unit1 $1,650,000
Total Units1 58
Gross Sales $95,700,000
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 3%-$2,871,000
Net Value = Assessed Value $92,829,000
For-Sale Residential (Detached Single Family)
Average Price per Unit1 $1,900,000
Total Units1 130
Gross Sales $247,000,000
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 3%-$7,410,000
Net Value = Assessed Value $239,590,000
For-Sale Residential (Court)
Average Price per Unit1 $2,500,000
Total Units1 42
Gross Sales $105,000,000
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 3%-$3,150,000
Net Value = Assessed Value $101,850,000
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 58
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Property Taxes – continued
Multifamily (Single-Use) Rental Total
Average Annual Rent1 $47,094
Total Apartments1 1,345
Occupancy3 97%
Effective Gross Income $61,539,625
Less: OpEx @ 30% 3 -$18,461,888
NOI $43,077,738
Cap Rate4 6.7%
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 -$1,292,332
Net Value = Assessed Value $642,951,307
Multifamily (Single-Use): Market Rate
Average Annual Rent1 $50,400
Total Apartments1 1,162
Occupancy3 97%
Effective Gross Income $56,866,421
Less: OpEx @ 30% 3 -$17,059,926
NOI 39,806,495
Cap Rate4 6.7%
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 -$1,194,195
Net Value = Assessed Value $594,126,784
Multifamily (Single-Use): 80% AMI
Average Annual Rent1 $31,890
Total Apartments1 91
Occupancy3 98%
Effective Gross Income $2,829,440
Less: OpEx @ 30% 3 -$848,832
NOI 1,980,608
Cap Rate4 6.7%
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 $59,418
Net Value = Assessed Value $29,561,316
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 59
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Property Taxes – continued
Multifamily (Single-Use): 50% AMI
Average Annual Rent1 $20,384
Total Apartments1 92
Occupancy3 98%
Effective Gross Income $1,828,400
Less: OpEx @ 30% 3 -$548,520
NOI $1,279,880
Cap Rate4 6.7%
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 -$38,396
Net Value = Assessed Value $19,102,686.04
Affordable (60% AMI)
Average Annual Rent1 $25,178
Total Apartments1 119
Occupancy3 98%
Effective Gross Income $2,921,219.44
Less: OpEx @ 30% 3 -876,366
NOI 2,044,854
Cap Rate4 6.7%
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 -$61,346
Net Value = Assessed Value $30,520,203
Multifamily (Mixed-Use) Rental Total
Average Annual Rent1 $47,107
Total Apartments1 619
Occupancy3 97%
Effective Gross Income $28,313,862
Less: OpEx @ 30% 3 -$8,494,159
NOI $19,819,703
Cap Rate4 6.7%
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 -$594,591
Net Value = Assessed Value $295,816,467
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 60
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Property Taxes – continued
Multifamily (Mixed-Use): Market Rate
Average Annual Rent1 $50,400
Total Apartments1 535
Occupancy3 97%
Effective Gross Income $26,182,044
Less: OpEx @ 30% 3 -$7,854,613
NOI 18,327,431
Cap Rate4 6.7%
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 -$549,823
Net Value = Assessed Value $273,543,743
Multifamily (Mixed-Use): 80% AMI
Average Annual Rent1 $31,890
Total Apartments1 42
Occupancy3 97%
Effective Gross Income $1,300,538
Less: OpEx @ 30% 3 -$390,161
NOI 910,377
Cap Rate4 6.7%
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 -$27,311
Net Value = Assessed Value $13,587,710
Multifamily (Mixed-Use): 50% AMI
Average Annual Rent1 $20,384
Total Apartments1 42
Occupancy3 97%
Effective Gross Income $831,280
Less: OpEx @ 30% 3 -$249,384
NOI 581,896
Cap Rate4 6.7%
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 -$17,457
Net Value = Assessed Value $8,685,014
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 61
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Property Taxes – continued
Retail
Average Annual Rent per SF1 $2.74
Gross SF1 120,560
Leasable SF @ 86% Efficiency 103,960
Occupancy2 92%
Effective Gross Income @ 59% Occupied1 $261,494
Less: OpEx @ 10%3 -$26,149
NOI $235,344
Cap Rate4 7.6%
Less: Cost of Sale @ 3%2 -$92,899
Net Value = Assessed Value $3,003,739
For-Sale Residential $601,594,000
Townhome $167,325,000
Row House $92,829,000
Detached Single Family $239,590,000
Court $101,850,000
Multifamily $673,310,990
Multifamily (Single-Use)$642,790,787
Affordable (LIHTC)$30,520,203
Mixed-Use $298,820,206
Mixed-Use $295,816,467
Retail $3,003,739
Total Assessed Value $1,573,725,196
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 62
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Property Taxes – continued
Property Tax Factors Values
General Levy (x Assessed Value)4 1.0%$15,737,252
For-Sale Residential $6,015,940
Townhome $1,673,250
Row House $928,290
Detached Single Family $2,395,900
Court $1,018,500
Multifamily $6,733,110
Multifamily (Single-Use)$6,427,908
Affordable (LIHTC)$305,202
Mixed-Use $2,988,202
Mixed-Use $2,958,165
Retail $30,037
City Share of General Levy4 10.2%$1,609,032
For-Sale Residential $615,091
Townhome $171,079
Row House $94,912
Detached Single Family $244,965
Court $104,135
Multifamily $688,417
Multifamily (Single-Use)$657,212
Affordable (LIHTC)$31,205
Mixed-Use $305,524
Mixed-Use $302,453
Retail $3,071
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 63
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Property Taxes – continued
MVLF In Lieu (x Assessed Value)4 0.0237%$373,306
For-Sale Residential $142,705
Townhome $39,691
Row House $22,020
Detached Single Family $56,834
Court $24,160
Multifamily $159,717
Multifamily (Single-Use)$152,478
Affordable (LIHTC)$7,240
Mixed-Use $70,884
Mixed-Use $70,171
Retail $713
1 Sunset Development. Includes both market-rate and affordable units.
2 HR&A Advisors. Includes management fee, a replacement reserve, and all other operating expenses.
3 HR&A Advisors, Inc.
4 See Appendix A - Table 2: Land Use Assumptions
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 64
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Sales + Use Tax
Tenant Type Leasable SF Sales Per SF¹
Annual Gross
Sales
Vacancy
Rate
Adjusted Annual
Gross Sales Taxable %²
Annual Taxable
Retail Sales
Retail 120,560 $773 $93,239,054 8%$85,593,451 85%$72,754,434
Total 120,560 $93,239,054 $85,593,451 $72,754,434
City's Sales Tax Rate3 2.00%
Annual Sales Tax Revenue (2025 $)$1,455,089
1 Retail Sales per SF Standards (Retail Maxim).
² HR&A assumption based on retail mix from Sunset Development.
3 Assumes 2.0% sales tax rate remains in effect through 2034, then reverts to 1.0% in 2035 through the remainder of the projection period.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 65
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Household Retail Spending in San Ramon
Categories Values
Total Retail Spending in San Ramon1 $1,188,522,887
Number of Workers Living Outside San Ramon2 28,704
Annual Spending Per Worker3 $7,998
Total Worker Spending3 $229,568,633
Total Resident Spending in San Ramon $958,954,254
Total Spending Potential of San Ramon Residents $1,876,592,299
Percent Resident Spending in San Ramon 51%
1CA Department of Tax and Fee Administration, Taxable Sales (2024)
2LEHD. Excludes workers earning less than $3,333 per month ($40,000 per year).
3International Council of Shopping Centers, Office Worker Retail Spending in a Digital Age, p. 32, Urban Spending, 2011
4ESRI Business Analyst - Retail Demand by Industry (2022-23)
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 66
Fiscal Impact Methodology
For-Sale Residential (Townhomes) Household Sales Tax Revenue
Household Income Per Unit Spending Category Amount Percent
Percent
Taxable2
Taxable
Amount
% of Project
Household
Taxable
Purchases San
Ramon
Adjustment
for
Shopping
@ Project2
Off-site
Taxable
Purchases
Average Purchase Price1 $1,250,000 Hhld. Income Before Taxes9 $335,248 100%52%
Down Payment2 20%Average CES Household Size 3.2
Mortgage Principal $1,000,000 Average Expected Household Size 2.9
Term (Years)2 30 Household Size Adjustment Factor 0.9
Rate (APR)3 6.6%
Average Monthly Mortgage Payment $6,378 Annual Consumer Expenditures10 $232,828 100.00%12.9%12.6%
Monthly Utility Cost4 $561 Food at Home $8,792 3.78%30%$2,638 $1,372 -10%$1,234
Annual Property Tax Rate⁵1.139%Food Away from Home $7,997 3.43%100%$7,997 $4,158 -5%$3,950
Annual Property Tax Payment $14,241 Alcoholic Beverages $1,420 0.61%100%$1,420 $738 0%$738
Annual Insurance Cost⁶$4,163 Housekeeping Supplies $1,224 0.53%100%$1,224 $637 0%$637
Annual Maintenance $12,500 Household Furnishings & Equipment $5,111 2.20%100%$5,111 $2,658 -5%$2,525
Total Annual Housing Cost $114,172 Apparel & Services $4,233 1.82%100%$4,233 $2,201 0%$2,201
Housing Allocation2 35%Transportation $25,654 11.02%100%$25,654 $13,340 0%$13,340
Estimated Gross Hhld. Income $326,206 Entertainment (less Fees & Admissions)$5,401 2.32%100%$5,401 $2,809 -5%$2,668
Personal Care Products & Services $1,726 0.74%100%$1,726 $898 -10%$808
Project Annual Sales Tax Reading $219 0.09%100%$219 $114 0%$114
Total Units⁷138 Tobacco Products $200 0.09%100%$200 $104 -5%$99
Total Project Gross Hhld. Income $45,016,484 Miscellaneous $2,152 0.92%100%$2,152 $1,119 0%$1,119
Annual Hhld. Spending/Total Hhld. Income 69%Housing Costs2 $114,172 49.04%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Spending $31,263,777 Health Care $9,707 4.17%0%$0 $0 -2%$0
Adjustment for Taxable Spending 12.6%Entertainment-Fees & Admissions $3,232 1.39%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Taxable Spending After Adjustment $3,952,430 Education $6,166 2.65%0%$0 $0 0%$0
City Sales Tax Rate8 2.00%Cash Contributions $5,855 2.51%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Sales Tax Revenue (2025$)$79,049 Personal Insurance and Pensions $29,565 12.70%0%$0 $0 0%$0
1 Sunset Development.
2 HR&A Advisors assumption.
3 Freddie Mac - Primary Mortgage Market Survey
4 U.S. Energy Information Administration and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
5 Contra Costa County, Annual Comprehensive Financial Report FY23-24
6 MoneyGeek - Average Cost of Homeowners Insurance in CA (2025)
7 See Appendix A - Table 2: Land Use Assumptions.
8 Assumes 2.0% sales tax rate remains in effect through 2034, then reverts to 1.0% in 2035 through the remainder of the projection period.
9 Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey 2023 mean income before taxes for households earning over $200,000 annually.
10 Average consumer spending in total and by category correspond to the 2023 Consumer Expenditure Survey for households earning over $200,000 annually, adjusted for household size.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 67
Fiscal Impact Methodology
For-Sale Residential (Row Homes) Household Sales Tax Revenue
Household Income Per Unit Spending Category Amount Percent
Percent
Taxable2
Taxable
Amount
% of Project
Household
Taxable
Purchases San
Ramon
Adjustment
for Shopping
@ Project2
Off-site
Taxable
Purchases
Average Purchase Price1 $1,650,000 Hhld. Income Before Taxes9 $335,248 100%52%
Down Payment2 20%Average CES Household Size 3.2
Mortgage Principal $1,320,000 Average Expected Household Size 2.9
Term (Years)2 30 Household Size Adjustment Factor 0.9
Rate (APR)3 6.6%
Average Monthly Mortgage Payment $8,420 Annual Consumer Expenditures10 $267,211 114.77%11.3%11.0%
Monthly Utility Cost4 $561 Food at Home $8,792 3.78%30%$2,638 $1,372 -10%$1,234
Annual Property Tax Rate⁵1.139%Food Away from Home $7,997 3.43%100%$7,997 $4,158 -5%$3,950
Annual Property Tax Payment $18,798 Alcoholic Beverages $1,420 0.61%100%$1,420 $738 0%$738
Annual Insurance Cost⁶$5,495 Housekeeping Supplies $1,224 0.53%100%$1,224 $637 0%$637
Annual Maintenance $16,500 Household Furnishings & Equipment $5,111 2.20%100%$5,111 $2,658 -5%$2,525
Total Annual Housing Cost $148,555 Apparel & Services $4,233 1.82%100%$4,233 $2,201 0%$2,201
Housing Allocation2 35%Transportation $25,654 11.02%100%$25,654 $13,340 0%$13,340
Estimated Gross Hhld. Income $424,442 Entertainment (less Fees & Admissions)$5,401 2.32%100%$5,401 $2,809 -5%$2,668
Personal Care Products & Services $1,726 0.74%100%$1,726 $898 -10%$808
Project Annual Sales Tax Reading $219 0.09%100%$219 $114 0%$114
Total Units⁷58 Tobacco Products $200 0.09%100%$200 $104 -5%$99
Total Project Gross Hhld. Income $24,617,639 Miscellaneous $2,152 0.92%100%$2,152 $1,119 0%$1,119
Annual Hhld. Spending/Total Hhld. Income 80%Housing Costs2 $148,555 63.80%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Spending $19,621,601 Health Care $9,707 4.17%0%$0 $0 -2%$0
Adjustment for Taxable Spending 11.0%Entertainment-Fees & Admissions $3,232 1.39%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Taxable Spending After Adjustment $2,161,419 Education $6,166 2.65%0%$0 $0 0%$0
City Sales Tax Rate8 2.00%Cash Contributions $5,855 2.51%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Sales Tax Revenue (2025$)$43,228 Personal Insurance and Pensions $29,565 12.70%0%$0 $0 0%$0
1 Sunset Development.
2 HR&A Advisors assumption.
3 Freddie Mac - Primary Mortgage Market Survey
4 U.S. Energy Information Administration and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
5 Contra Costa County, Annual Comprehensive Financial Report FY23-24
6 MoneyGeek - Average Cost of Homeowners Insurance in CA (2025)
7 See Appendix A - Table 2: Land Use Assumptions.
8 Assumes 2.0% sales tax rate remains in effect through 2034, then reverts to 1.0% in 2035 through the remainder of the projection period.
9 Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey 2023 mean income before taxes for households earning over $200,000 annually.
10 Average consumer spending in total and by category correspond to the 2023 Consumer Expenditure Survey for households earning over $200,000 annually, adjusted for household size.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 68
Fiscal Impact Methodology
For-Sale Residential (Detached Single-Family) Household Tax Revenue
Household Income Per Unit Spending Category Amount Percent
Percent
Taxable2
Taxable
Amount
% of Project
Household
Taxable Purchases
San Ramon
Adjustment for
Shopping @
Project2
Off-site
Taxable
Purchases
Average Purchase Price1 $1,900,000 Hhld. Income Before Taxes9 $335,248 100%52%
Down Payment2 20%Average CES Household Size 3.2
Mortgage Principal $1,520,000 Average Expected Household Size 2.9
Term (Years)2 30 Household Size Adjustment Factor 0.9
Rate (APR)3 6.6%
Average Monthly Mortgage Payment $9,695 Annual Consumer Expenditures10 $288,700 124.00%10.4%10.2%
Monthly Utility Cost4 $561 Food at Home $8,792 3.78%30%$2,638 $1,372 -10%$1,234
Annual Property Tax Rate⁵1.139%Food Away from Home $7,997 3.43%100%$7,997 $4,158 -5%$3,950
Annual Property Tax Payment $21,647 Alcoholic Beverages $1,420 0.61%100%$1,420 $738 0%$738
Annual Insurance Cost⁶$6,327 Housekeeping Supplies $1,224 0.53%100%$1,224 $637 0%$637
Annual Maintenance $19,000 Household Furnishings & Equipment $5,111 2.20%100%$5,111 $2,658 -5%$2,525
Total Annual Housing Cost $170,044 Apparel & Services $4,233 1.82%100%$4,233 $2,201 0%$2,201
Housing Allocation2 35%Transportation $25,654 11.02%100%$25,654 $13,340 0%$13,340
Estimated Gross Hhld. Income $485,839 Entertainment (less Fees & Admissions)$5,401 2.32%100%$5,401 $2,809 -5%$2,668
Personal Care Products & Services $1,726 0.74%100%$1,726 $898 -10%$808
Project Annual Sales Tax Reading $219 0.09%100%$219 $114 0%$114
Total Units⁷130 Tobacco Products $200 0.09%100%$200 $104 -5%$99
Total Project Gross Hhld. Income $63,159,114 Miscellaneous $2,152 0.92%100%$2,152 $1,119 0%$1,119
Annual Hhld. Spending/Total Hhld. Income 86%Housing Costs2 $170,044 73.03%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Spending $54,389,692 Health Care $9,707 4.17%0%$0 $0 -2%$0
Adjustment for Taxable Spending 10.2%Entertainment-Fees & Admissions $3,232 1.39%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Taxable Spending After Adjustment $5,545,346 Education $6,166 2.65%0%$0 $0 0%$0
City Sales Tax Rate8 2.00%Cash Contributions $5,855 2.51%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Sales Tax Revenue (2025$)$110,907 Personal Insurance and Pensions $29,565 12.70%0%$0 $0 0%$0
1 Sunset Development.
2 HR&A Advisors assumption.
3 Freddie Mac - Primary Mortgage Market Survey
4 U.S. Energy Information Administration and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
5 Contra Costa County, Annual Comprehensive Financial Report FY23-24
6 MoneyGeek - Average Cost of Homeowners Insurance in CA (2025)
7 See Appendix A - Table 2: Land Use Assumptions.
8 Assumes 2.0% sales tax rate remains in effect through 2034, then reverts to 1.0% in 2035 through the remainder of the projection period.
9 Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey 2023 mean income before taxes for households earning over $200,000 annually.
10 Average consumer spending in total and by category correspond to the 2023 Consumer Expenditure Survey for households earning over $200,000 annually, adjusted for household size.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 69
Fiscal Impact Methodology
For-Sale Residential (Court) Household Sales Tax Revenue
Household Income Per Unit Spending Category Amount Percent
Percent
Taxable2
Taxable
Amount
% of Project
Household
Taxable
Purchases San
Ramon
Adjustment for
Shopping @
Project2
Off-site
Taxable
Purchases
Average Purchase Price1 $2,500,000 Hhld. Income Before Taxes $335,248 100%52%
Down Payment2 20%Average CES Household Size9 3.2
Mortgage Principal $2,000,000 Average Expected Household Size 2.9
Term (Years)2 30 Household Size Adjustment Factor 0.9
Rate (APR)3 6.6%
Average Monthly Mortgage Payment $12,757 Annual Consumer Expenditures10 $340,274 146.15%8.9%8.7%
Monthly Utility Cost4 $561 Food at Home $8,792 3.78%30%$2,638 $1,372 -10%$1,234
Annual Property Tax Rate⁵1.139%Food Away from Home $7,997 3.43%100%$7,997 $4,158 -5%$3,950
Annual Property Tax Payment $28,483 Alcoholic Beverages $1,420 0.61%100%$1,420 $738 0%$738
Annual Insurance Cost⁶$8,325 Housekeeping Supplies $1,224 0.53%100%$1,224 $637 0%$637
Annual Maintenance $25,000 Household Furnishings & Equipment $5,111 2.20%100%$5,111 $2,658 -5%$2,525
Total Annual Housing Cost $221,617 Apparel & Services $4,233 1.82%100%$4,233 $2,201 0%$2,201
Housing Allocation2 35%Transportation $25,654 11.02%100%$25,654 $13,340 0%$13,340
Estimated Gross Hhld. Income $633,193 Entertainment (less Fees & Admissions)$5,401 2.32%100%$5,401 $2,809 -5%$2,668
Personal Care Products & Services $1,726 0.74%100%$1,726 $898 -10%$808
Project Annual Sales Tax Reading $219 0.09%100%$219 $114 0%$114
Total Units⁷42 Tobacco Products $200 0.09%100%$200 $104 -5%$99
Total Project Gross Hhld. Income $26,594,098 Miscellaneous $2,152 0.92%100%$2,152 $1,119 0%$1,119
Annual Hhld. Spending/Total Hhld. Income 101%Housing Costs2 $221,617 95.18%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Spending $26,992,770 Health Care $9,707 4.17%0%$0 $0 -2%$0
Adjustment for Taxable Spending 8.7%Entertainment-Fees & Admissions $3,232 1.39%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Taxable Spending After Adjustment $2,334,952 Education $6,166 2.65%0%$0 $0 0%$0
City Sales Tax Rate⁸2.00%Cash Contributions $5,855 2.51%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Sales Tax Revenue (2025$)$46,699 Personal Insurance and Pensions $29,565 12.70%0%$0 $0 0%$0
1 Sunset Development.
2 HR&A Advisors assumption.
3 Freddie Mac - Primary Mortgage Market Survey
4 U.S. Energy Information Administration and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
5 Contra Costa County, Annual Comprehensive Financial Report FY23-24
6 MoneyGeek - Average Cost of Homeowners Insurance in CA (2025)
7 See Appendix A - Table 2: Land Use Assumptions.
8 Assumes 2.0% sales tax rate remains in effect through 2034, then reverts to 1.0% in 2035 through the remainder of the projection period.
9 Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey 2023 mean income before taxes for households earning over $200,000 annually.
10 Average consumer spending in total and by category correspond to the 2023 Consumer Expenditure Survey for households earning over $200,000 annually, adjusted for household size.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 70
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Multifamily (Market-Rate)
Household Income Per Unit Spending Category Amount Percent
Percent
Taxable
2
Taxable
Amount
% of Project
Household
Taxable
Purchases San
Ramon
Adjustment
for
Shopping
@ Project2
Off-site
Taxable
Purchases
Average Monthly Rent¹$4,200 Hhld. Income Before Taxes⁵$171,339 100%52%
Average Annual Rent $50,400 Average CES Household Size 3.2
Annual Utility Cost2 $5,983 Average Expected Household Size 2.9
Total Annual Housing Cost $56,383 Household Size Adjustment Factor 0.9
Housing Allocation2 30%
Estimated Gross Hhld. Income $187,943 Annual Consumer Expenditures⁶$135,612 58.25%16.5%16.1%
Food at Home $7,814 3.36%30%$2,344 $1,219 -10%$1,097
Food Away from Home $6,020 2.59%100%$6,020 $3,131 -5%$2,974
Alcoholic Beverages $1,150 0.49%100%$1,150 $598 0%$598
Housekeeping Supplies $1,046 0.45%100%$1,046 $544 0%$544
Household Furnishings & Equipment $3,544 1.52%100%$3,544 $1,843 -5%$1,751
Apparel & Services $2,731 1.17%100%$2,731 $1,420 0%$1,420
Transportation $19,155 8.23%100%$19,155 $9,961 0%$9,961
Entertainment (less Fees & Admissions)$3,765 1.62%100%$3,765 $1,958 -5%$1,860
Personal Care Products & Services $1,277 0.55%100%$1,277 $664 -10%$598
Project Annual Sales Tax Reading $157 0.07%100%$157 $82 0%$82
Total Units³1,698 Tobacco Products $294 0.13%100%$294 $153 -5%$145
Total Project Gross Hhld. Income 319,127,780 Miscellaneous $1,593 0.68%100%$1,593 $828 0%$828
Annual Hhld. Spending/Total Hhld. Income 79%Housing Costs2 $56,383 24.22%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Spending 252,584,214 Health Care $7,305 3.14%0%$0 $0 -2%$0
Adjustment for Taxable Spending 16.1%Entertainment-Fees & Admissions $1,562 0.67%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Taxable Spending After
Adjustment 40,711,103 Education $1,911 0.82%0%$0 $0 0%$0
City Sales Tax Rate⁴2.00%Cash Contributions $2,907 1.25%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Sales Tax Revenue (2025$)$814,222 Personal Insurance and Pensions $16,996 7.30%0%$0 $0 0%$0
1 CoStar
2 HR&A Advisors assumption.
3 See Appendix A - Table 2: Land Use Assumptions.
4 Assumes 2.0% sales tax rate remains in effect through 2034, then reverts to 1.0% in 2035 through the remainder of the projection period.
5 Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey 2023 mean income before taxes for households earning between $150,000 and $199,999 annually.
6 Average consumer spending in total and by category correspond to the 2023 Consumer Expenditure Survey for households earning between $150,000 and $199,999 annually, adjusted for household size.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 71
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Multifamily (80% AMI)
Household Income Per Unit Spending Category Amount Percent
Percent
Taxable
2
Taxable
Amount
% of Project
Household
Taxable
Purchases San
Ramon
Adjustment
for
Shopping
@ Project2
Off-site
Taxable
Purchases
Average Monthly Rent¹$2,658 Hhld. Income Before Taxes⁵$121,816 100%52%
Average Annual Rent $31,890 Average CES Household Size 3.2
Annual Utility Cost2 $0 Average Expected Household Size 2.9
Total Annual Housing Cost $31,890 Household Size Adjustment Factor 0.9
Housing Allocation2 30%
Estimated Gross Hhld. Income $106,300 Annual Consumer Expenditures⁶$111,119 47.73%20.2%19.7%
Food at Home $7,814 3.36%30%$2,344 $1,219 -10%$1,097
Food Away from Home $6,020 2.59%100%$6,020 $3,131 -5%$2,974
Alcoholic Beverages $1,150 0.49%100%$1,150 $598 0%$598
Housekeeping Supplies $1,046 0.45%100%$1,046 $544 0%$544
Household Furnishings & Equipment $3,544 1.52%100%$3,544 $1,843 -5%$1,751
Apparel & Services $2,731 1.17%100%$2,731 $1,420 0%$1,420
Transportation $19,155 8.23%100%$19,155 $9,961 0%$9,961
Entertainment (less Fees & Admissions)$3,765 1.62%100%$3,765 $1,958 -5%$1,860
Personal Care Products & Services $1,277 0.55%100%$1,277 $664 -10%$598
Project Annual Sales Tax Reading $157 0.07%100%$157 $82 0%$82
Total Units³133 Tobacco Products $294 0.13%100%$294 $153 -5%$145
Total Project Gross Hhld. Income $14,137,900 Miscellaneous $1,593 0.68%100%$1,593 $828 0%$828
Annual Hhld. Spending/Total Hhld. Income 91%Housing Costs2 $31,890 13.70%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Spending $12,896,401 Health Care $7,305 3.14%0%$0 $0 -2%$0
Adjustment for Taxable Spending 19.7%Entertainment-Fees & Admissions $1,562 0.67%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Taxable Spending After
Adjustment $2,536,793 Education $1,911 0.82%0%$0 $0 0%$0
City Sales Tax Rate⁴2.00%Cash Contributions $2,907 1.25%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Sales Tax Revenue (2025$)$50,736 Personal Insurance and Pensions $16,996 7.30%0%$0 $0 0%$0
1 CoStar
2 HR&A Advisors assumption.
3 See Appendix A - Table 2: Land Use Assumptions.
4 Assumes 2.0% sales tax rate remains in effect through 2034, then reverts to 1.0% in 2035 through the remainder of the projection period.
5 Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey 2023 mean income before taxes for households earning between $100,000 and $149,999 annually.
6 Average consumer spending in total and by category correspond to the 2023 Consumer Expenditure Survey for households earning between $100,000 and $149,999 annually, adjusted for household size.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 72
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Multifamily (50% AMI)
Household Income Per Unit Spending Category Amount Percent
Percent
Taxable
2
Taxable
Amount
% of Project
Household
Taxable
Purchases San
Ramon
Adjustment
for
Shopping
@ Project2
Off-site
Taxable
Purchases
Average Monthly Rent¹$1,699 Hhld. Income Before Taxes⁵$59,346 100%52%
Average Annual Rent $20,384 Average CES Household Size 3.2
Annual Utility Cost2 $0 Average Expected Household Size 2.9
Total Annual Housing Cost $20,384 Household Size Adjustment Factor 0.9
Housing Allocation2 30%
Estimated Gross Hhld. Income $67,945 Annual Consumer Expenditures⁶$99,612 42.78%22.5%21.9%
Food at Home $7,814 3.36%30%$2,344 $1,219 -10%$1,097
Food Away from Home $6,020 2.59%100%$6,020 $3,131 -5%$2,974
Alcoholic Beverages $1,150 0.49%100%$1,150 $598 0%$598
Housekeeping Supplies $1,046 0.45%100%$1,046 $544 0%$544
Household Furnishings & Equipment $3,544 1.52%100%$3,544 $1,843 -5%$1,751
Apparel & Services $2,731 1.17%100%$2,731 $1,420 0%$1,420
Transportation $19,155 8.23%100%$19,155 $9,961 0%$9,961
Entertainment (less Fees & Admissions)$3,765 1.62%100%$3,765 $1,958 -5%$1,860
Personal Care Products & Services $1,277 0.55%100%$1,277 $664 -10%$598
Project Annual Sales Tax Reading $157 0.07%100%$157 $82 0%$82
Total Units³134 Tobacco Products $294 0.13%100%$294 $153 -5%$145
Total Project Gross Hhld. Income $9,104,630 Miscellaneous $1,593 0.68%100%$1,593 $828 0%$828
Annual Hhld. Spending/Total Hhld. Income 168%Housing Costs2 $20,384 8.75%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Spending $15,282,144 Health Care $7,305 3.14%0%$0 $0 -2%$0
Adjustment for Taxable Spending 21.94%Entertainment-Fees & Admissions $1,562 0.67%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Taxable Spending After
Adjustment $3,353,323 Education $1,911 0.82%0%$0 $0 0%$0
City Sales Tax Rate⁴2.00%Cash Contributions $2,907 1.25%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Sales Tax Revenue (2025$)$67,066 Personal Insurance and Pensions $16,996 7.30%0%$0 $0 0%$0
1 CoStar
2 HR&A Advisors assumption.
3 See Appendix A - Table 2: Land Use Assumptions.
4 Assumes 2.0% sales tax rate remains in effect through 2034, then reverts to 1.0% in 2035 through the remainder of the projection period.
5 Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey 2023 mean income before taxes for households earning between $50,000 and $69,999 annually.
6 Average consumer spending in total and by category correspond to the 2023 Consumer Expenditure Survey for households earning between $50,000 and $69,999 annually, adjusted for household size.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 73
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Multifamily (60% AMI)
Household Income Per Unit Spending Category Amount Percent
Percent
Taxable
2
Taxable
Amount
% of Project
Household
Taxable
Purchases San
Ramon
Adjustment
for
Shopping
@ Project2
Off-site
Taxable
Purchases
Average Monthly Rent¹$2,098 Hhld. Income Before Taxes⁵$83,578 100%52%
Average Annual Rent $25,178 Average CES Household Size 2.6
Annual Utility Cost2 $0 Average Expected Household Size 2.8
Total Annual Housing Cost $25,178 Household Size Adjustment Factor 1.1
Housing Allocation2 30%
Estimated Gross Hhld. Income $83,925 Annual Consumer Expenditures⁶$71,280 30.61%19.3%18.8%
Food at Home $5,510 2.37%30%$1,653 $860 -10%$774
Food Away from Home $3,284 1.41%100%$3,284 $1,708 -5%$1,622
Alcoholic Beverages $464 0.20%100%$464 $241 0%$241
Housekeeping Supplies $734 0.32%100%$734 $382 0%$382
Household Furnishings & Equipment $2,346 1.01%100%$2,346 $1,220 -5%$1,159
Apparel & Services $1,913 0.82%100%$1,913 $995 0%$995
Transportation $11,450 4.92%100%$11,450 $5,954 0%$5,954
Entertainment (less Fees & Admissions)$2,216 0.95%100%$2,216 $1,152 -5%$1,095
Personal Care Products & Services $924 0.40%100%$924 $481 -10%$433
Project Annual Sales Tax Reading $85 0.04%100%$85 $44 0%$44
Total Units³119 Tobacco Products $392 0.17%100%$392 $204 -5%$193
Total Project Gross Hhld. Income $9,987,075 Miscellaneous $978 0.42%100%$978 $508 0%$508
Annual Hhld. Spending/Total Hhld. Income 85%Housing Costs2 $25,178 10.81%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Spending $8,517,567 Health Care $5,463 2.35%0%$0 $0 -2%$0
Adjustment for Taxable Spending 18.8%Entertainment-Fees & Admissions $654 0.28%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Hhld. Taxable Spending After
Adjustment $1,601,225 Education $1,002 0.43%0%$0 $0 0%$0
City Sales Tax Rate⁴2.00%Cash Contributions $1,760 0.76%0%$0 $0 0%$0
Annual Sales Tax Revenue (2025$)$32,025 Personal Insurance and Pensions $6,927 2.98%0%$0 $0 0%$0
1 CoStar
2 HR&A Advisors assumption.
3 See Appendix A - Table 2: Land Use Assumptions.
4 Assumes 2.0% sales tax rate remains in effect through 2034, then reverts to 1.0% in 2035 through the remainder of the projection period.
5 Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey 2023 mean income before taxes for households earning between $70,000 and $99,999 annually.
6 Average consumer spending in total and by category correspond to the 2023 Consumer Expenditure Survey for households earning between $70,000 and $99,999 annually, adjusted for household size.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 74
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Franchise Tax
Tenant Type Units/Establishments1 Net SF Cost per HH2
Cost per SF or Unit
with Vacancy
Allowance Franchise Tax Rate3 Total Franchise Tax
For-Sale Residential
Internet 368 $696 $661 5.0%$12,166
Cable 368 $936 $889 5.0%$16,361
$28,527
Multifamily (Single-Use)
Internet 1,345 $696 $661 5.0%$44,466
Cable 1,345 $936 $889 5.0%$59,799
Multifamily (Mixed-Use)
Internet 619 $696 $661 5.0%$20,464.14
Cable 619 $936 $889 5.0%$27,520.74
$47,984.88
Affordable (LIHTC)
Internet 120 $696 $661 5.0%$3,967.20
Cable 120 $936 $889 5.0%$5,335.20
$9,302.40
Annual Residential Franchise Tax Revenue (2025$)$145,613
Internet2 47 120,560 $12,000 5.0%$28,200
$28,200
Annual Franchise Tax Revenue (2025$)$173,813
1 Sunset Development. Includes both for-sale and rental units.
2 U.S. Energy Information Administration, various cable and internet providers.
3 City of San Ramon. Assumes tax rates effective 1/1/2025 remain in effect without change over the projection period.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 75
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated Other Taxes
% of Day in City1 Resident-Equivalents
Residential
Resident Population 6,990 89%6,223
Residential Workers 58 27%16
Retail/Restaurant Workers2 596 27%160
Total Resident-Equivalents 6,398
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Other Fines
FY 2024-25 Revenues3 $10,633,185
Total Resident-Equivalents1 85,237
Per Resident-Equivalent $125
Annual Revenues (2025$)$798,184
1 See Resident-Equivalent calculation, Appendix A - Table 9: Resident-Equivalents.
2 Estimate based on IMPLAN outputs.
3
City of San Ramon. Revenues include general government service charge, city ordinance violation, application/filing fee, dog license, building permits, and miscellaneous permits
per San Ramon's FY 2024-25 revised budget.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 76
Fiscal Impact Methodology
City Resident-Equivalents
Number % of Week in City4 Resident-Equivalents
City of San Ramon Population1
Out-Commuting Resident Workers2 35,110 73%25,706
Remaining Residential Population 50,624 100%50,624
Subtotal 85,734 76,330
Weighted Average Percent 89%
Non-Resident Daytime Employment Population3 33,256 27%8,908
Subtotal 33,256 8,908
Grand Total 118,990 85,237
1 2023 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimate.
2 Out-commuting resident workers per Longitudinal Employment Housing Data, 2022, U.S. Census Bureau.
3 In-commuting resident workers per Longitudinal Employment Housing Data, 2022, U.S. Census Bureau.
4 Calculated per an assumed percentage the individual is actually within the City. For example, non-resident daytime employees are assumed to be in the City 9
hours per day, 5 days per week for a total of 45 hours per week out of a total of 168 hours, this equates to 27% of the week within the City.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 77
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Estimated City Service Costs
City Departments FY 2025-26 Adopted Budget¹Adjustment Factor2
Total Resident- Equivalent
Population3 Cost Per Resident-Equivalent
General Government⁴$9,674,173 25%85,237 $28
Finance $2,213,756 10%85,237 $3
Community Development $6,622,082 25%85,237 $19
Public Works $19,890,877 90%85,237 $210
Police Services $23,106,728 90%85,237 $244
Parks & Community Services $10,346,598 90%85,237 $109
Non-Departmental $50,000 10%85,237 $0
Infrastructure Maintenance – Transfers-In/Out $631,000 100%85,237 $7
Citywide Insurance – Transfers-In/Out $1,100,000 100%85,237 $13
$73,635,214 $634
Number % of Day Resident-Equivalents
Total Resident-Equivalents
Resident Population⁵6,990 89%6,223
Residential Workers⁶58 27%16
Retail/Restaurant Workers⁷596 27%160
Total Resident-Equivalents 6,398
Total Cost of City Services (2025 $)$4,056,571
1 FY 2025-26 Adopted Budget, City of San Ramon; includes departmental budget appropriations (salary, expenses, and other direct costs) as well as certain related/indirect variable costs.
2 Adjustment factors based on HR&A precedent assumptions regarding the variable share of departmental budgets.
3 See Resident-Equivalent calculation, Appendix A - Table 10: City Resident-Equivalents.
4 General Government includes the expenditures of the City Council, City Manager, City Attorney, City Clerk, Human Resources, and Information Technology.
5 Estimate based on the product of residential units of market-rate versus affordable and their respective average household size.
6 Sunset Development.
7 Estimate based on IMPLAN outputs.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 78
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Existing Property Tax
Category Factor2 Total
Assessed Value1 $177,990,000
General Levy (x Assessed Value)1.0%$1,779,900
City Share of General Levy 10.2%$181,983
MVLF In Lieu (x Assessed Value)0.024%$42,221
San Ramon Property Tax Revenue (2025 $)$224,205
1 2024 assessed value for parcel 213-120-008-7 from the Contra Costa County Assessors and includes both land and improvement value.
2 City of San Ramon Municipal Code; 3rd Amendment of City-County Tax Sharing Agreement
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 79
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Tax Revenue Cash Flow – With Annual Inflation – Total Development Project
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035
Percent Program Constructed 0%6%32%74%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Delivered 0%0%0%38%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Absorbed 0%0%0%19%69%100%100%100%100%100%100%
General Fund Revenues 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035
Property Tax (Construction)$0 $1,659 $60,964 $152,245 $239,200 $157,526 $110,905 $118,668 $50,219 $53,012 $32,795
MVLF In Lieu (Construction)$0 $385 $14,144 $35,322 $55,496 $36,547 $25,731 $27,532 $11,651 $12,299 $7,609
Documentary Transfer Tax (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $129,852 $508,751 $403,280 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Sales Tax (Construction)$0 $115,027 $608,370 $881,955 $630,068 $943,396 $542,358 $580,322 $245,587 $259,245 $160,375
Property Tax (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $263,568 $743,541 $1,296,794 $1,333,261 $1,672,509 $1,729,640 $1,938,776 $2,016,676
MVLF In Lieu (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $61,150 $172,526 $301,866 $310,347 $389,075 $402,351 $450,893 $468,988
Documentary Transfer Tax (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $0 $10,923 $46,220 $75,892 $84,783 $94,722 $105,831 $118,249
Franchise Tax $0 $0 $0 $4,465 $34,144 $60,814 $81,866 $95,382 $120,691 $147,388 $160,633
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $108,243 $772,787 $1,412,477 $1,745,227 $2,045,354 $2,456,683 $2,844,309 $1,497,491
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $0 $0 $0 $24,323 $144,784 $246,457 $337,074 $387,812 $500,370 $619,129 $684,966
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $0 $117,071 $683,477 $1,661,121 $3,312,221 $4,905,377 $4,562,661 $5,401,437 $5,611,914 $6,430,883 $5,147,783
Less: Property Tax and MVLF Revenue from Existing Site ($224,205)($228,689)($233,262)($237,928)($242,686)($247,540)($252,491)($257,541)($262,691)($267,945)($273,304)
Less: City Service Costs $0 $0 $0 ($123,615)($732,698)($1,244,060)($1,702,330)($1,957,861)($2,527,501)($3,128,593)($3,460,614)
Less: City-County Tax Sharing Agreement for Sales Tax $0 $0 $0 ($54,121)($386,393)($706,238)($872,613)($1,022,677)($1,228,342)($1,422,155)($748,746)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund ($224,205)($111,618)$450,215 $1,299,579 $2,336,837 $3,413,777 $2,607,840 $3,186,035 $2,821,722 $3,034,344 $1,413,865
Appreciation
Annual Inflation Rate 2.9%
Annual Inflation Rate (Property Tax and MVLF In Lieu)2.0%
Discount Rate1 11.4%
1Discount rate of 11.4% based on the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for major national homebuilders.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 80
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Tax Revenue Cash Flow – With Annual Inflation – Total Development Project – continued
2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045
Percent Program Constructed 100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Delivered 100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Absorbed 100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
General Fund Revenues 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045
Property Tax (Construction)$34,362 $15,130 $17,709 $52,525 $54,048 $4,431 $108,734 $111,888 $0 $0
MVLF In Lieu (Construction)$7,972 $3,510 $4,109 $12,186 $12,540 $1,028 $25,227 $25,959 $0 $0
Documentary Transfer Tax (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Sales Tax (Construction)$168,042 $73,990 $86,604 $256,863 $264,312 $21,671 $531,742 $547,162 $0 $0
Property Tax (Ongoing)$2,198,610 $2,300,120 $2,457,455 $2,586,354 $2,880,727 $3,045,133 $3,228,548 $3,743,691 $3,977,857 $4,238,212
MVLF In Lieu (Ongoing)$511,220 $534,794 $571,320 $601,248 $669,569 $707,737 $750,315 $869,857 $924,211 $984,642
Documentary Transfer Tax (Ongoing)$132,133 $147,654 $165,008 $184,411 $206,107 $230,367 $257,497 $287,836 $321,767 $359,715
Franchise Tax $174,523 $185,442 $196,848 $205,259 $213,993 $229,581 $245,894 $253,025 $279,786 $307,886
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$1,576,001 $1,643,969 $1,714,555 $1,774,548 $1,836,580 $1,925,500 $2,018,033 $2,076,556 $2,210,596 $2,103,142
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $754,100 $807,237 $862,822 $902,269 $943,279 $1,020,714 $1,101,847 $1,133,801 $1,270,354 $1,413,873
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $5,556,963 $5,711,846 $6,076,428 $6,575,664 $7,081,155 $7,186,164 $8,267,837 $9,049,775 $8,984,571 $9,407,470
Less: Property Tax and MVLF Revenue from Existing Site ($278,770)($284,346)($290,033)($295,833)($301,750)($307,785)($313,941)($320,219)($326,624)($333,156)
Less: City Service Costs ($3,809,320)($4,076,648)($4,356,336)($4,553,930)($4,759,379)($5,149,866)($5,559,058)($5,718,215)($6,408,880)($7,134,853)
Less: City-County Tax Sharing Agreement for Sales Tax ($788,001)($821,985)($857,277)($887,274)($918,290)($962,750)($1,009,017)($1,038,278)($1,105,298)($1,051,571)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund $1,468,873 $1,350,853 $1,430,060 $1,725,902 $2,020,025 $1,728,513 $2,394,839 $3,011,340 $2,249,068 $1,939,460
Appreciation
Annual Inflation Rate 2.9%
Annual Inflation Rate (Property Tax and MVLF In Lieu)2.0%
Discount Rate1 11.4%
1Discount rate of 11.4% based on the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for major national homebuilders.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 81
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Tax Revenue Cash Flow – With Annual Inflation – Total For-Sale Residential
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035
Percent Program Constructed 0%6%32%74%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Delivered 0%0%0%38%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Absorbed 0%0%0%19%69%100%100%100%100%100%100%
General Fund Revenues 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035
Property Tax (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $83,045 $189,139 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
MVLF In Lieu (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $19,267 $43,882 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Documentary Transfer Tax (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $129,852 $508,751 $403,280 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Sales Tax (Construction)$0 $64,040 $310,240 $543,548 $385,253 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Property Tax (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $120,696 $596,907 $988,330 $1,018,628 $1,055,856 $1,100,654 $1,153,745 $1,215,945
MVLF In Lieu (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $28,002 $138,486 $229,299 $236,329 $244,966 $255,359 $267,677 $282,108
Documentary Transfer Tax (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $0 $10,923 $46,220 $75,892 $84,783 $94,722 $105,831 $118,249
Franchise Tax $0 $0 $0 $4,465 $16,845 $25,212 $25,943 $26,695 $27,470 $28,266 $29,086
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $43,064 $201,207 $322,889 $332,253 $341,888 $351,803 $362,005 $186,252
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $0 $0 $0 $24,323 $91,708 $137,227 $141,206 $145,301 $149,515 $153,851 $158,313
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $0 $64,040 $310,240 $996,261 $2,183,101 $2,152,457 $1,830,251 $1,899,491 $1,979,523 $2,071,375 $1,989,952
Less: City Service Costs $0 $0 $0 ($123,615)($462,910)($688,837)($706,758)($725,199)($744,175)($763,701)($783,794)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund $0 $64,040 $310,240 $872,646 $1,720,191 $1,463,620 $1,123,493 $1,174,292 $1,235,348 $1,307,673 $1,206,159
Annual Inflation Rate 2.9%
Annual Inflation Rate (Property Tax and MVLF In Lieu)2.0%
Housing Appreciation Rate 9.0%
Discount Rate1 11.4%
1Discount rate of 11.4% based on the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for major national homebuilders.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 82
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Tax Revenue Cash Flow – With Annual Inflation – Total For-Sale Residential – continued
2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045
Percent Program Constructed 100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Delivered 100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Absorbed 100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
General Fund Revenues 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045
Property Tax (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
MVLF In Lieu (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Documentary Transfer Tax (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Sales Tax (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Property Tax (Ongoing)$1,288,176 $1,371,478 $1,467,017 $1,576,108 $1,700,223 $1,841,019 $2,000,351 $2,180,300 $2,383,199 $2,611,660
MVLF In Lieu (Ongoing)$298,866 $318,192 $340,358 $365,668 $394,463 $427,129 $464,095 $505,845 $552,919 $605,923
Documentary Transfer Tax (Ongoing)$132,133 $147,654 $165,008 $184,411 $206,107 $230,367 $257,497 $287,836 $321,767 $359,715
Franchise Tax $29,929 $30,797 $31,690 $32,609 $33,555 $34,528 $35,530 $36,560 $37,620 $38,711
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$191,653 $197,211 $202,930 $208,815 $214,871 $221,102 $227,514 $234,112 $240,901 $247,887
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $162,904 $167,628 $172,489 $177,491 $182,639 $187,935 $193,385 $198,994 $204,764 $210,703
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $2,103,661 $2,232,961 $2,379,493 $2,545,102 $2,731,858 $2,942,081 $3,178,372 $3,443,646 $3,741,170 $4,074,599
Less: City Service Costs ($804,469)($825,743)($847,635)($870,161)($893,341)($917,193)($941,737)($966,992)($992,980)($1,019,721)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund $1,299,193 $1,407,217 $1,531,858 $1,674,941 $1,838,517 $2,024,888 $2,236,635 $2,476,655 $2,748,190 $3,054,877
Annual Inflation Rate 2.9%
Annual Inflation Rate (Property Tax and MVLF In Lieu)2.0%
Housing Appreciation Rate 9.0%
Discount Rate1 11.4%
1Discount rate of 11.4% based on the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for major national homebuilders.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 83
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Tax Revenue Cash Flow – With Annual Inflation – Total Multifamily (Single-Use)
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035
Percent Program Constructed 0%0%0%0%0%16%26%37%44%51%55%
Percent Program Delivered 0%0%0%0%0%0%8%31%31%46%46%
Percent Program Absorbed 0%0%0%0%0%0%8%8%19%31%39%
General Fund Revenues 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035
Property Tax (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $0 $2,075 $104,680 $70,412 $74,500 $50,219 $53,012 $32,795
MVLF In Lieu (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $0 $481 $24,287 $16,336 $17,285 $11,651 $12,299 $7,609
Sales Tax (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $0 $10,146 $511,917 $344,333 $364,327 $245,587 $259,245 $160,375
Property Tax (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $0 $905 $47,949 $48,908 $251,037 $256,057 $404,644 $412,737
MVLF In Lieu (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $0 $229 $12,126 $12,368 $59,284 $60,470 $94,964 $96,863
Documentary Transfer Tax
Franchise Tax $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $8,460 $8,705 $21,535 $35,102 $45,091
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $38,586 $39,705 $136,461 $238,796 $156,955
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $43,661 $44,927 $113,364 $185,733 $239,000
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $0 $0 $0 $0 $13,835 $700,959 $583,064 $859,770 $895,345 $1,283,795 $1,151,425
Less: City Service Costs $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 ($221,897)($228,332)($576,145)($943,939)($1,214,660)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund $0 $0 $0 $0 $13,835 $700,959 $361,166 $631,438 $319,200 $339,856 ($63,235)
Annual Inflation Rate 2.9%
Annual Inflation Rate (Property Tax and MVLF In Lieu)2.0%
Discount Rate1 11.4%
1Discount rate of 11.4% based on the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for major national homebuilders.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 84
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Tax Revenue Cash Flow – With Annual Inflation – Total Multifamily (Single-Use) – continued
2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045
Percent Program Constructed 60%62%64%70%76%77%88%100%100%100%
Percent Program Delivered 56%56%60%60%74%74%74%100%100%100%
Percent Program Absorbed 46%51%56%58%60%67%74%74%87%100%
General Fund Revenues 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045
Property Tax (Construction)$34,362 $15,130 $17,709 $52,525 $54,048 $4,431 $108,734 $111,888 $0 $0
MVLF In Lieu (Construction)$7,972 $3,510 $4,109 $12,186 $12,540 $1,028 $25,227 $25,959 $0 $0
Sales Tax (Construction)$168,042 $73,990 $86,604 $256,863 $264,312 $21,671 $531,742 $547,162 $0 $0
Property Tax (Ongoing)$514,679 $524,972 $578,695 $590,269 $752,127 $767,169 $782,513 $1,108,793 $1,130,969 $1,153,588
MVLF In Lieu (Ongoing)$120,537 $122,947 $135,434 $138,143 $175,719 $179,233 $182,818 $258,543 $263,714 $268,988
Documentary Transfer Tax
Franchise Tax $55,630 $63,101 $70,959 $75,720 $80,696 $92,419 $104,754 $107,792 $130,342 $154,108
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$196,589 $224,554 $253,977 $271,614 $290,060 $334,131 $380,514 $391,549 $476,724 $566,510
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $295,202 $335,031 $376,921 $402,278 $428,788 $491,303 $557,083 $573,238 $693,535 $820,327
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $1,393,012 $1,363,235 $1,524,408 $1,799,596 $2,058,289 $1,891,386 $2,673,385 $3,124,924 $2,695,283 $2,963,521
Less: City Service Costs ($1,500,288)($1,702,709)($1,915,608)($2,044,476)($2,179,206)($2,496,923)($2,831,234)($2,913,340)($3,524,717)($4,169,105)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund ($107,276)($339,474)($391,201)($244,879)($120,917)($605,536)($157,848)$211,584 ($829,435)($1,205,585)
Annual Inflation Rate 2.9%
Annual Inflation Rate (Property Tax and MVLF In Lieu)2.0%
Discount Rate1 11.4%
1Discount rate of 11.4% based on the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for major national homebuilders.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 85
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Tax Revenue Cash Flow – With Annual Inflation – Total Multifamily (Mixed-Use)
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035
Percent Program Constructed 0%1%21%44%59%75%87%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Delivered 0%0%0%43%43%75%75%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Absorbed 0%0%0%0%22%43%59%75%87%100%100%
General Fund Revenues 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035
Property Tax (Construction)$0 $1,659 $60,964 $69,200 $47,987 $52,846 $40,494 $44,168 $0 $0 $0
MVLF In Lieu (Construction)$0 $385 $14,144 $16,055 $11,133 $12,261 $9,395 $10,247 $0 $0 $0
Sales Tax (Construction)$0 $8,113 $298,130 $338,407 $234,670 $258,430 $198,025 $215,995 $0 $0 $0
Property Tax (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $142,873 $145,730 $260,515 $265,725 $365,616 $372,928 $380,387 $387,995
MVLF In Lieu (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $33,147 $33,810 $60,441 $61,650 $84,825 $86,522 $88,252 $90,017
Documentary Transfer Tax
Franchise Tax $0 $0 $0 $0 $17,300 $35,602 $47,463 $59,981 $71,686 $84,020 $86,456
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$0 $0 $0 $65,179 $571,580 $1,089,588 $1,374,388 $1,663,760 $1,968,419 $2,243,508 $1,154,285
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $0 $0 $0 $0 $53,076 $109,230 $152,206 $197,583 $237,490 $279,546 $287,653
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $0 $10,157 $373,238 $664,860 $1,115,285 $1,878,912 $2,149,346 $2,642,176 $2,737,046 $3,075,713 $2,006,406
Less: City Service Costs $0 $0 $0 $0 ($269,788)($555,224)($773,675)($1,004,329)($1,207,181)($1,420,953)($1,462,160)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund $0 $10,157 $373,238 $664,860 $845,497 $1,323,688 $1,375,671 $1,637,847 $1,529,865 $1,654,760 $544,246
Annual Inflation Rate 2.9%
Annual Inflation Rate (Property Tax and MVLF In Lieu)2.0%
Discount Rate1 11.4%
1Discount rate of 11.4% based on the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for major national homebuilders.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Orchards at Bishop Ranch Economic and Fiscal Analysis | 86
Fiscal Impact Methodology
Tax Revenue Cash Flow – With Annual Inflation – Total Multifamily (Mixed-Use)
2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045
Percent Program Constructed 100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Delivered 100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Percent Program Absorbed 100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
General Fund Revenues 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045
Property Tax (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
MVLF In Lieu (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Sales Tax (Construction)$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Property Tax (Ongoing)$395,755 $403,670 $411,743 $419,978 $428,378 $436,945 $445,684 $454,598 $463,690 $472,963
MVLF In Lieu (Ongoing)$91,818 $93,654 $95,527 $97,438 $99,387 $101,374 $103,402 $105,470 $107,579 $109,731
Documentary Transfer Tax
Franchise Tax $88,964 $91,544 $94,198 $96,930 $99,741 $102,634 $105,610 $108,673 $111,824 $115,067
Sales Tax (Ongoing)$1,187,759 $1,222,204 $1,257,648 $1,294,120 $1,331,649 $1,370,267 $1,410,005 $1,450,895 $1,492,971 $1,288,745
Licenses, Permits, Fees and Fines $295,995 $304,578 $313,411 $322,500 $331,853 $341,476 $351,379 $361,569 $372,055 $382,844
Total Annual Revenues to City's General Fund $2,060,290 $2,115,650 $2,172,528 $2,230,966 $2,291,007 $2,352,696 $2,416,080 $2,481,204 $2,548,118 $2,369,350
Less: City Service Costs ($1,504,563)($1,548,195)($1,593,093)($1,639,293)($1,686,832)($1,735,750)($1,786,087)($1,837,884)($1,891,182)($1,946,027)
Net Fiscal Impact to City's General Fund $555,727 $567,454 $579,435 $591,673 $604,175 $616,946 $629,992 $643,320 $656,936 $423,324
Annual Inflation Rate 2.9%
Annual Inflation Rate (Property Tax and MVLF In Lieu)2.0%
Discount Rate1 11.4%
1Discount rate of 11.4% based on the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for major national homebuilders.