Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutP. Appeal supplement filed by Brian Swanson, dated February 13, 2026Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP Page 1 of 2 STATEMENT OF APPEAL AND SUPPORTING GROUNDS SUPPLEMENT #1 This supplemental submission is provided for inclusion in the administrative record as an amendment and clarification to my timely filed appeal regarding the Orchards Development Project. This supplement addresses two items that warrant explicit treatment in the record: (1) the lack of institutional impartiality and the absence of meaningful procedural guardrails in the City’s appeal process as publicly described; and (2) a discrete but important correction to California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) notice terminology in the City’s record as it relates to Assembly Bill 52 (AB 52) tribal consultation assertions. Appeal process opacity and lack of guardrails (deposit-driven process with undefined work product). The City’s published “Zoning Appeal” instructions identify a $4,500 deposit requirement for an appeal of a Planning Commission decision and describe basic intake steps and statutory timelines for scheduling and decision. However, the City’s published materials do not explain—at all—what analysis, written work product, or findings the public is paying for when required to tender a $4,500 deposit. The instructions do not state whether Community Development staff must prepare a written response that addresses each ground of appeal; whether the City’s environmental consultant (or any independent reviewer) must prepare a neutral technical memorandum evaluating the appellant’s issues; whether staff must produce findings responsive to the CEQA issues raised; or whether the City Council will be asked to decide the appeal on the basis of an undefined, staff-controlled record that simply reiterates the approval posture already advanced at the Planning Commission. In short, the City’s published appeal process reads as “pay a substantial deposit and have faith in an undefined process,” which is not a fair or transparent framework for meaningful administrative relief in a CEQA-driven discretionary approval. Institutional impartiality and fair-hearing concerns (staff positioned to defend its own prior work product). This process opacity matters because it directly implicates due process and fair-hearing expectations. Here, City staff managed the entitlement path, directed, and relied upon the City’s CEQA consultant, authored the Planning Commission staff reports, framed the findings and conditions, and advanced the City’s CEQA posture in support of approval. Absent any published separation-of-functions safeguards, the City’s structure and public instructions leave the clear impression that the same staff operation responsible for the original approval recommendation is also positioned to control the City’s appellate response and to frame the recommendation and administrative narrative presented to the City Council. That is a structural impartiality problem: it risks turning an appeal into staff’s defense of staff’s own prior work product, rather than an impartial re-evaluation of whether the City’s CEQA record and entitlement findings are complete, coherent, and legally defensible. When the City demands a substantial deposit yet does not identify the analysis standards, responsible preparers, or required written deliverables, the appeal process functions less like meaningful administrative review and more like an opaque, potentially political gatekeeping mechanism. Attachment P Orchards Development Project Appeal – Supplement #1 Brian C. Swanson, AICP Page 1 of 2 Comparable local jurisdictions demonstrate that clear guardrails are feasible and routinely articulated. Several nearby jurisdictions publish clearer appeal guardrails that reduce the appearance of prejudgment and improve public understanding of what an appeal is and is not. For example, the City of Pleasanton’s municipal code expressly provides that appeal hearings are conducted “de novo” and requires the decision-making body to make findings supporting its decision. The City of Pleasant Hill’s code requires that when an appellate body modifies or reverses an original decision, it must state specific reasons, and it sets time limits for scheduling and deciding appeals, including a rule that failure to act within prescribed time limits results in affirmation of the original decision. The City of Walnut Creek publishes detailed public-facing appeal instructions describing what must be filed, the filing deadline mechanics, and even identifies the responsible staff liaison and hearing body by appeal type. Contra Costa County publishes plain-language appeal guidance that identifies the general appeal chain and specific “grounds for appeal.” The City of Dublin’s appeals ordinance materials explicitly address the appearance of bias and clarify appeal procedures in ways that acknowledge and manage fairness concerns. These examples are not offered as perfect models, but they demonstrate that clear, codified, publicly accessible procedural guardrails are feasible and common in local practice; San Ramon’s failure to similarly articulate guardrails is therefore not inevitable, and it should be weighed as a process integrity deficiency relevant to whether meaningful administrative relief is being provided. CEQA notice terminology correction (AB 52 / tribal consultation trigger language). I also submit the following targeted terminology correction for accuracy in the record. Where my appeal references the City’s checklist statement regarding AB 52 consultation triggers, the phrase “Notice of Mitigated Negative Declaration” and “Notice of Negative Declaration” should be read and corrected as the appropriate CEQA notice terminology: Notice of Preparation (for an Environmental Impact Report), Notice of Intent to Adopt a Mitigated Negative Declaration, and Notice of Intent to Adopt a Negative Declaration. This correction does not concede the City’s substantive AB 52 posture; it simply ensures that the City’s administrative record uses the correct CEQA notice terminology when asserting why AB 52 consultation is or is not required. This supplement is submitted to ensure the record squarely addresses the institutional impartiality and due process defects inherent in a deposit-driven, undefined appeal process administered by the same staff operation responsible for the underlying approval narrative, and to ensure accuracy in CEQA notice terminology as the City frames its AB 52 assertions. I respectfully request that the City Clerk include this supplemental submission in full in the administrative record for the Orchards Development Project appeal and confirm receipt in writing. DATED: February 13, 2026 Respectfully submitted, Brian C. Swanson, AICP