HomeMy WebLinkAboutQ. Appellant’s Appeal Exhibits A through H, submitted March 30, 2026 revised April 2, 2026Orchards Appellant’s Appeal Exhibit Index A through H, submitted March 30, 2026,
revised April 2, 2026:
Exhibit A: Filed Appeal Package (Appeal + Supplement(s) + filed cover materials);
Exhibit B: May 8, 2025 ARB Public Comment (Orchards);
Exhibit C: Lucy Beyhan (Confederated Villages of Lisjan Nation) Public Comment,
February 3, 2026;
Exhibit D: Email Chain re: process clarification/procedures for this appeal hearing;
Exhibit E: November 12, 2024 City Council action dissolving advisory committees
(including TDM);
Exhibit F: Fehr & Peers VMT memorandum;
Exhibit G: Excerpts of GP2040 EIR SOC pages re: VMT; and
Exhibit H: Caltrans comment letter (October 13, 2023).
Attachment Q
Brian C. Swanson, Rrcp
69 Ayamonte Court
San Ramon, California 94583
Telephone: (925) 785-4013
Email: briancswanson@qmail com
Mobile Telephone: (925) 785-4013
February 12,2026
City Clerk
City of San Ramon
EEerrvsr
FtB I 2 ?a?5t.?{.,Y',-
CIl }'Ci-ERK
l. iir ,:i \.11: i(,1)trr1:.1_
), i.'. "
AlJ i t i:
<via hand delivery>
7000 Bollinger Canyon Road
San Ramon, California 94583
Re: Timely Zoning Appeal - Orchards Development project
(Planning Commission Agenda ltem 8.1; February 3, 2026) and
Planning Commission Resolution No. 02-26; Project at
6001 Bollinger Canyon Road (APN 213-120-008)
Dear City Clerk:
Please accept this timely appeal, filed pursuant to Title D (Zoning), Division D7, Chapter
ll (Appeals and calls for Review) of the San Ramon Municipal code. This appeal
challenges the Planning Commission's February 3,2026 approval of the
Orchards Development Project, including the Master Plan and the Neighborhood District
approvals memorialized in Planning Commission Resolution No. 02-26.
(February 3,2026 Planning commission Agenda Packet, staff Report, packet p. 7.)
This appeal also challenges the City's related California Environmental Quality Act
(CEOA) determination to treat the Orchards Development Project as exempt from further
CEQA review based on CEQA Guidelines section 15183, as reflected in the City's
Notice of Exemption (NoE) filed February 6,2026. (Notice of Exemption for the
Orchards Development Project, filed February 6,2020, pp. 1-2)
Under san Ramon Municipal code section D7-9, an appeal may be initiated by "the
applicant or any interested person," and must be initiated within 10 calendar days of the
date of the decision. (san Ramon Municipal code, Title D, Division D7, chapter ll,
sections D7-9 and D7-10.)
Enclosed are: ('1) the $4,500 Appeal Fee Deposit, (2) the city's Appeat tnitiation Form,
(3) a detailed Statement of Appeal and Supporting Grounds with Exhibits.
Please confirm receipt and completeness in writing, and schedule the appeal hearing
consistent with San Ramon Municipal Code section D7-12. Please also note that a
timely appeal stays the effective date of the action or decision being appealed until a
Exhibit A
Orchards Development Project Appeal
Brian C. Swanson, RtcP
Page 2 of 2
final decision has been rendered by the appropriate appellate body.
(San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter ll,
section D7-11.C.)
Respectfully submitted,
F.u;* Swan*rt
Brian C. Swanson, ntcp
Enclosures: $4,500 Appeal Fee Deposit (Check #104, Payable to the
City of San Ramon)
Completed Appeal lnitiation Forms (2 pages)
Statement of Appeal and Supporting Grounds including Exhibits
APPELLANT -
;\PPIiAL INSTRUCTIONS
(zoNrNG)
Pttrstruttt to Division D7, Chirptcr II "Appciils ancl (--lJis firr I{cvicu"'of thc Srin Ranrrru
i\'ltrtricipul Codc. thc lirllouing infirrrnritiorr is rcquirctl to hc suhrrritterl iri orr.lcr-to lllc an
rppcll t,ith thc Cit_r, of San ltanron:
It Thc tpprr:al ntusl [:re ii]ccl with thc Citv Cicrk's olficc *,irhin l[) cllcnclrrr tlrrrs crf the-
i.littc o1'thc r-lccisirln. The- lppclri rnust bc Iilccl unLl rccc'ivctl in grcrron trl h-r'nxril rtitlr
the Citv CIc:lk's ol'ficc ut thc clorc ol'trt-tsittcss at illL'r'r)rl ot' l{) criicnciill'rli.r\\.
luccorulrtrticd hy the: ftu'rilcntilrr,-ri in th,,'( ir1"s Fcc ScitciJulr-:
2t The nalnr'arlcl adclress ot'thc pro.jt'ct tliat vou t'ish to rrltpcll:.l) Your Ilatrc. lc5idclttilil atldle-ss. cr.rtail irddrcss urrrl rlrrvtirnc tclr'phorrc rturnbt-r.
.1) A statt'nrcrrt outlining thr' -sptcif'ic rL.usorls tiir thc upl)cxl'
.i.t Payrrrcnt ol'f,.'cs its \!:t l'orth trt'thc Cit_r's Fcc Sr. lrr:dulc.
Llpon rcccipt of'all ittnrs listtd rtbovt. thc Citv Clcrk uill rccr:pt thc rr1:,pr'ul lnrl vt'ril'r thr:
cot'ttplctctlcss ol'thc irtt'orn]lttion. A lcttcr uill thcn bc:cnt to the'ir1:pclliln{ acklto\\'lcrlsins
rcccipt ot thc appcul and vclil',r,ing courpliancc rvitlr tlrr:sc instnrcrirrns.
!qr Sc_ctiorr D7- 12.
fltc appl'al rlill bc sclicdttlr.:tl lirr'a hr'ar^ing lrclirrr-'thi'itl)pL'llittr'hoclr'.,rirhin 60 clrltrrdlrr da_rs
ttf thc Citv's rccc:i1:t of thc rppc-lrl unlcss hoth thc applictnt arrcl thc appcllliur c()usr-nt Io a lrrcr
date. A laler dute lbr thc pr:lrlic helrrins \\,ill hc lrken into c()rrsiLl!:ritli\)tr bt thc. Citt Clr.rk il
[roth thc appr:llant ancl t]tt applicant suhnrit;r stipulution in u'ritinr. ,,\]l partir-s uill irrr ath'iscd
irl tltc datc. tirnc and pl;tcr-'til'thc rcsclrctlirlcd lrc;irirr.u br rnrril. A dceisrrrrr hv tltc l1:lpellatt-
trod1, s'i11 bc rcrtclcrtd u'ithin 30 talcnr.lar ck1's ot thc closc of tlr* hclrring. Thc troticc sirall bt
rurilccl uithin tiyc u,orking rirtl,s irlir"r thc dutc o1'tlrt riccision lo rhc lrlrltliclrnt. thc appcliant.
Irrrtl utr.r (ltl)tr Iurt) l'trluc\tin!.: trotirc.
P*c'r St'ctir,rlr L)7- l_l:
,{ tlccisitrrt bv thc Planrrirrg Crrnrrlrirsion shirll lrt'cornc final l0 calcntlar dir_r: al'tcr tlrr
r"'ficctivc drltc oi'thi: dccisiort. .\ dccisiou h_v thc Citi'CoLrncil sitall bL.('cllltc frrrul ou rhcr
u'tl ccti r. r' LlirtL- (rl l ltr' dci. i siorr.
Cq1 {i1"c;t...J11 l-L11 } ril.t i !)lt ;
Christina l;rrrnct>
ClitY Ckrk
(L.trii L)7 1_)i()J
! I I ililt'(liri \;1111 iii:1ilil.r.';i.:li j\
San, Ramon
.,\ ppellant I rrtilrnration
,\ppellant Name (First and [-ast):
(lounsel Rcpre^srntiug Appellaut:
Residerrtial,,\ddress:
E-mail ,\ddrcss:
Dal tirne Plrouc:
I'rqject Nartrc:
Project Address:
APPEAL INITIATION
FORVI
Brian C. Swanson, AICP
cu rre ntly self-represented
69 Ayamonte Court
San Ramon, California 94583
bnancswanson@g mail. com
(925) 785-4013
Orchards Development Project
6001 Bollinger Canyon Road
(APN-21 3-120-008)
Plt'rrsc [)11)v'iclt'tht rtasoil lirr thr'aplrr-:al stating spccil'iculll'tlrt'lrr]lor|ing tnli>r.llriltiorr:
l. Thc \pt'Lrfir'r-lctclrttrrt.rti,.rrt ol ir)tclirrt'tlrtion tliat ir cliiirncil t() i)c ll()t in crrniplilrrict-
u'ittr thc Ilurl)ose s til'tl.rc Zoning Ordinunc..:
2. Thc spccilic iitcts thlit arc claiurt:rl to lre in crr'or ()r'lrr rt.usc- of rlircrctiorr:
.1. Tlrc spu'cit'ic luclr ot'tlrc rccord u'hich arc cl;rirncd to hc irrirccurrtc: or
:1. Thc sptcit'ic tlccisiort tltat is clltirncri to tt,-'unsuppor.tr'tl llv thc r,.:cortl.
Plcrisc itttach [)lgL'i irs r)L'cl;ssiif v.
'l'ltis fonn rtrust he accoutpatried bl'the tee pur-nrent identitied in the Citr''s Iee schedule
and rcceived in person ur bv nrail hv the flitt,fllcrk.
Cin,Clcrk Stafl:
[)utr' Ilt'ccir r'tl.
--N()tcs:
Dcposit Paitl:
CITY OF SAN RAMON
City Clerk's Office
Received
Purpose:
RECENED BY
l2--
DATETOTAL AMOUNT RECEIVED:
L
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 1 of 2 STATEMENT OF APPEAL AND SUPPORTING GROUNDS SUPPLEMENT #1 This supplemental submission is provided for inclusion in the administrative record as an amendment and clarification to my timely filed appeal regarding the Orchards Development Project. This supplement addresses two items that warrant explicit treatment in the record: (1) the lack of institutional impartiality and the absence of meaningful procedural guardrails in the City’s appeal process as publicly described; and (2) a discrete but important correction to California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) notice terminology in the City’s record as it relates to Assembly Bill 52 (AB 52) tribal consultation assertions. Appeal process opacity and lack of guardrails (deposit-driven process with undefined work product). The City’s published “Zoning Appeal” instructions identify a $4,500 deposit requirement for an appeal of a Planning Commission decision and describe basic intake steps and statutory timelines for scheduling and decision.
However, the City’s published materials do not explain—at all—what analysis, written work product, or findings the public is paying for when required to tender a $4,500 deposit. The instructions do not state whether Community Development staff must prepare a written response that addresses each ground of appeal; whether the City’s environmental consultant (or any independent reviewer) must prepare a neutral technical memorandum evaluating the appellant’s issues; whether staff must produce findings responsive to the CEQA issues raised; or whether the City Council will be asked to decide the appeal on the basis of an undefined, staff-controlled record that simply reiterates the approval posture already advanced at the Planning Commission. In short, the City’s published appeal process reads as “pay a substantial deposit and have faith in an undefined process,” which is not a fair or transparent framework for meaningful
administrative relief in a CEQA-driven discretionary approval. Institutional impartiality and fair-hearing concerns (staff positioned to defend its own prior work product). This process opacity matters because it directly implicates due process and fair-hearing expectations. Here, City staff managed the entitlement path, directed, and relied upon the City’s CEQA consultant, authored the
Planning Commission staff reports, framed the findings and conditions, and advanced the City’s CEQA posture in support of approval. Absent any published separation-of-functions safeguards, the City’s structure and public instructions leave the clear impression that the same staff operation responsible for the original approval recommendation is also positioned to control the City’s appellate response and to frame the recommendation and administrative narrative presented to the City Council. That is a structural impartiality problem: it risks turning an appeal into staff’s defense of staff’s own prior work product, rather than an impartial re-evaluation of whether the City’s CEQA record and entitlement findings are complete, coherent, and legally defensible. When the City demands a substantial deposit yet does not identify the analysis standards, responsible preparers, or required written deliverables, the appeal process
functions less like meaningful administrative review and more like an opaque, potentially political gatekeeping mechanism.
Orchards Development Project Appeal – Supplement #1 Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 1 of 2
Comparable local jurisdictions demonstrate that clear guardrails are feasible and routinely articulated. Several nearby jurisdictions publish clearer appeal guardrails that reduce the appearance of prejudgment and improve public understanding of what an appeal is and is not. For example, the City of Pleasanton’s municipal code expressly provides that appeal hearings are conducted “de novo” and requires the decision-making body to make findings supporting its decision. The City of Pleasant Hill’s code requires that when an appellate body modifies or reverses an original decision, it must state specific reasons, and it sets time limits for scheduling and deciding appeals, including a rule that failure to act within prescribed time limits results in affirmation of the original decision. The City of Walnut Creek publishes detailed public-facing appeal instructions describing what must be filed, the filing deadline mechanics, and even identifies the responsible staff liaison and hearing body by appeal type. Contra Costa County publishes plain-language appeal guidance that identifies the general appeal chain and specific “grounds for appeal.” The City of Dublin’s appeals ordinance materials explicitly
address the appearance of bias and clarify appeal procedures in ways that acknowledge and manage fairness concerns. These examples are not offered as perfect models, but they demonstrate that clear, codified, publicly accessible procedural guardrails are
feasible and common in local practice; San Ramon’s failure to similarly articulate guardrails is therefore not inevitable, and it should be weighed as a process integrity deficiency relevant to whether meaningful administrative relief is being provided. CEQA notice terminology correction (AB 52 / tribal consultation trigger language). I also submit the following targeted terminology correction for accuracy in the record. Where my appeal references the City’s checklist statement regarding AB 52 consultation triggers, the phrase “Notice of Mitigated Negative Declaration” and “Notice of Negative Declaration” should be read and corrected as the appropriate CEQA notice terminology: Notice of Preparation (for an Environmental Impact Report), Notice of Intent to Adopt a Mitigated Negative Declaration, and
Notice of Intent to Adopt a Negative Declaration. This correction does not concede the City’s substantive AB 52 posture; it simply ensures that the City’s administrative record uses the correct CEQA notice terminology when asserting why AB 52 consultation is or
is not required. This supplement is submitted to ensure the record squarely addresses the institutional
impartiality and due process defects inherent in a deposit-driven, undefined appeal process administered by the same staff operation responsible for the underlying approval narrative, and to ensure accuracy in CEQA notice terminology as the City frames its AB 52 assertions. I respectfully request that the City Clerk include this supplemental submission in full in the administrative record for the Orchards Development Project appeal and confirm receipt in writing. DATED: February 13, 2026
Respectfully submitted,
Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Brian C. Swanson, AICP 69 Ayamonte Court
San Ramon, California 94583 Telephone: (925) 785-4013 Email: briancswanson@gmail.com
Mobile Telephone: (925) 785-4013 February 12, 2026 City Clerk City of San Ramon <via hand delivery> 7000 Bollinger Canyon Road San Ramon, California 94583 Re: Timely Zoning Appeal – Orchards Development Project (Planning Commission Agenda Item 8.1; February 3, 2026) and Planning Commission Resolution No. 02-26; Project at 6001 Bollinger Canyon Road (APN 213-120-008)
Dear City Clerk:
Please accept this timely appeal, filed pursuant to Title D (Zoning), Division D7, Chapter II (Appeals and Calls for Review) of the San Ramon Municipal Code. This appeal challenges the Planning Commission’s February 3, 2026 approval of the Orchards Development Project, including the Master Plan and the Neighborhood District approvals memorialized in Planning Commission Resolution No. 02-26. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report, Packet p. 7.) This appeal also challenges the City’s related California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) determination to treat the Orchards Development Project as exempt from further CEQA review based on CEQA Guidelines section 15183, as reflected in the City’s Notice of Exemption (NOE) filed February 6, 2026. (Notice of Exemption for the Orchards Development Project, filed February 6, 2026, pp. 1–2.) Under San Ramon Municipal Code section D7-9, an appeal may be initiated by “the
applicant or any interested person,” and must be initiated within 10 calendar days of the date of the decision. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, sections D7-9 and D7-10.)
Enclosed are: (1) the $4,500 Appeal Fee Deposit, (2) the City’s Appeal Initiation Form, (3) a detailed Statement of Appeal and Supporting Grounds with Exhibits. Please confirm receipt and completeness in writing, and schedule the appeal hearing consistent with San Ramon Municipal Code section D7-12. Please also note that a timely appeal stays the effective date of the action or decision being appealed until a
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 2 of 2
final decision has been rendered by the appropriate appellate body. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-11.C.) Respectfully submitted, Brian C. Swanson, AICP Enclosures: $4,500 Appeal Fee Deposit (Check #104, Payable to the City of San Ramon) Completed Appeal Initiation Forms (2 pages)
Statement of Appeal and Supporting Grounds including Exhibits
Brian C. Swanson, AICP
currently self-represented
69 Ayamonte Court
San Ramon, California 94583
briancswanson@gmail.com
(925) 785-4013
Orchards Development Project
6001 Bollinger Canyon Road
(APN-213-120-008)
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 1 of 12 STATEMENT OF APPEAL AND SUPPORTING GROUNDS 1. Appealed Decision and Project Summary This appeal is directed to the City Council as the appellate body for Planning Commission decisions. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-8.A.2.) The decision being appealed is the Planning Commission’s February 3, 2026 approval of the Orchards Development Project (Planning Commission Agenda Item 8.1), including approval of the Master Plan and the Neighborhood District (the Project) development approvals, as memorialized in Planning Commission Resolution No. 02-26. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report, Packet p. 7; February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26,
Packet pp. 12–26.) As described in Agenda Item 8.1 staff report, the Project includes demolition of
approximately 1.3 million square feet of office buildings (formerly the Chevron Office Park), subdivision of an approximately 92-acre site into three districts and 191 lots, and approvals for up to 2,510 residential units, including approval of two development plans for the Master Plan and the Neighborhood District (230 single-family homes, 138 multi-family townhomes, and 58 optional accessory dwelling units). (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report, Packet p. 7.) The City’s approval record further states that the proposed Master Plan is anticipated to be developed over approximately 20 years and includes: (1) up to 619 dwelling units within a Mixed Use District with 125,000 square feet of ground-floor retail/entertainment/commercial uses; (2) 1,465 dwelling units within a Multi-Family
District; and (3) a lower-density Neighborhood District with 368 single-family townhomes and detached homes plus 58 optional accessory dwelling units. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26, Packet p. 15.)
2. Jurisdiction, Standing, Timeliness, and Stay Standing. This appeal is initiated by Brian C. Swanson, AICP, an interested person, as expressly authorized by San Ramon Municipal Code section D7-9. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-9.). Appellant
is also an individual resident of the City of San Ramon and Contra Costa County, California, and a certified planner, specializing in transportation impact analysis, who lives, works, travels, and recreates in and around the Orchards Development Project. Appellant submitted verbal and written comments during the City’s public processes concerning the Orchards Development Project and during the Planning Commission’s hearing process, on December 16, 2025, January 20, 2026, and February 3, 2026
(Exhibits 3-6). Timeliness. San Ramon Municipal Code section D7-10 requires that an appeal be initiated within 10 calendar days of the date of the decision. This appeal is filed to meet that requirement. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-10.)
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 2 of 12 Stay. A timely appeal stays the effective date of the decision being appealed until a final decision has been rendered by the appellate body. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-11.C.) De novo hearing and new evidence. The Municipal Code provides that an appeal hearing is conducted “de novo,” and the City Council may consider new materials and testimony in addition to the materials that were the subject of the original decision. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-12.C.1.) 3. Related CEQA Determination and Notice of Exemption In connection with the Project approvals, the City has asserted that the Project qualifies for streamlined review under CEQA Guidelines section 15183 (Projects Consistent with a Community Plan or General Plan), and that impacts analyzed in the
2040 General Plan Update (2040 GPU) Environmental Impact Report (EIR) remain valid and do not require further project-level CEQA review absent “peculiar” impacts. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report,
Packet pp. 8-9.) The City filed a Notice of Exemption for the Project on February 6, 2026, citing CEQA Guidelines section 15183 and describing the Project as consistent with the 2040 GPU EIR (State Clearinghouse No. 2022060549). (Notice of Exemption for the Orchards Development Project, filed February 6, 2026, pp. 1–2.) This appeal challenges that CEQA posture, including the sufficiency, procedural soundness, and legal defensibility of the City’s reliance on CEQA Guidelines section 15183 for what the City itself describes as a 20-year phased Master Plan and the first Neighborhood District approvals. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda
Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26, Packet p. 15; January 20, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Orchards Phasing Scenario slide, Packet p. 47.) 4. Grounds for Appeal This appeal is based on the following grounds, which are stated with specificity
consistent with San Ramon Municipal Code section D7-11.A. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-11.A.) 4.1. CEQA Guidelines section 15183 is being treated as long-term “environmental clearance” for a 20-year phased master plan, contrary to CEQA’s intent and the City’s own record. The City’s record frames CEQA Guidelines section 15183 as a basis to conclude that “impacts that were analyzed in the 2040 GPU EIR are not peculiar to the Project or its site and do not require further review.” (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report, Packet pp. 8-9.)
However, the City’s approvals are not limited to a single, near-term construction permit. They approve a long-range master plan that the City states is anticipated to be
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 3 of 12
developed over approximately 20 years. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26, Packet p. 15.) The applicant’s own presentation depicts phasing in multi-year increments, including delivery of the “Orchards Neighborhood” in Year 7 and additional districts extending through Year 20. (January 20, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Orchards Phasing Scenario slide, Packet p. 47.) The applicant’s traffic consultant (Fehr & Peers) expressly recognizes the implications of phasing and changing conditions over time. In the Traffic Operations Report conclusion, Fehr & Peers states: “We recommend that the need for mitigation measures is re-assessed after occupation of each phase of development.” (Fehr & Peers, Bishop Ranch Orchards Traffic Operations Report, November 10, 2025, p. 18.)
That admission is fundamentally inconsistent with a blanket “no further review” posture for a 20-year phased master plan. If mitigation needs must be reassessed after each phase, then by definition the Project’s impacts, assumptions, and/or effectiveness of
mitigation are expected to change over time. A CEQA approach that treats a December 2023 program-level EIR and a December 2025 consistency checklist as sufficient for the full 20-year buildout is not procedurally sound without enforceable, phase-based triggers for further environmental review when conditions materially change. Accordingly, the City must establish (in the approval record itself, not informally) clear, realistic, enforceable expectations for when additional environmental review will occur as the master plan is phased, districts are entitled, and conditions change—especially for transportation, air quality, greenhouse gas emissions, and noise impacts that are directly tied to travel behavior and cumulative development over time.
4.2. The City’s reliance on the 2040 General Plan Update Environmental Impact Report does not account for post-2023 regulatory baseline changes and more detailed post-certification entitlements affecting cumulative conditions.
The City’s CEQA record emphasizes that the Project is consistent with the development density of the Downtown Mixed Use – South (DMU-S) land use designation and therefore consistent with impacts evaluated in the 2040 GPU EIR. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26, Packet p. 15; Notice of Exemption for the Orchards Development Project, filed February 6, 2026, p. 2.) But the City’s own record also demonstrates that the regulatory baseline and operative development framework have evolved materially since the 2040 GPU EIR was certified on December 14, 2023. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26, Packet p. 15; City Council Agenda Packet, October 14, 2025, Ordinance 534 Staff Report, Packet p. 14.)
For example, the City Council adopted Ordinance 529 on May 13, 2025, reducing the Downtown Mixed Use – Neighborhood (DMU-N) minimum sitewide floor area ratio from
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 4 of 12
1.25 to 0.5. (City Council Agenda Packet, May 13, 2025, Ordinance 529 Staff Report, Packet p. 105.) The City Council also adopted Ordinance 534 on October 14, 2025, amending Title D (Zoning) of the San Ramon Municipal Code, including amendments to parking standards as reflected in the redlined parking requirement tables for residential uses. (City Council Agenda Packet, October 14, 2025, Ordinance 534, Exhibit A-2 (Division D3 Redlines), Table 3-8 – Parking Requirements by Land Use, Packet pp. 90-94.) The Orchards Development Project itself has also relied on concessions, waivers, and alternative standards that change development intensity and operational characteristics in ways that matter for CEQA analysis. For example, the City’s December 16, 2025 record lists applicant requests to reduce the minimum sitewide floor area ratio from
1.25 to 0.79, to use Orchards Design Guidelines in lieu of the City’s Objective Design and Development Standards, and to obtain multiple waivers from landscaping and parking/circulation standards. (December 16, 2025 Planning Commission
Agenda Packet, Applicant Requests slide, Packet p. 90.) The Notice of Exemption further acknowledges that the Neighborhood District is requesting a waiver from the minimum floor area ratio requirement under the State Density Bonus Law, and asserts that CEQA Guidelines section 15183 consistency is based on density rather than floor area ratio. (Notice of Exemption for the Orchards Development Project, filed February 6, 2026, p. 2.) Even if the City elects to define “consistency” for purposes of CEQA Guidelines section 15183 primarily through residential density, floor area ratio, parking supply, and objective standards waivers are not irrelevant to environmental impacts—especially
transportation behavior, greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, noise, and cumulative effects across a multi-district, multi-decade buildout.
In addition, since certification of the 2040 GPU EIR, the City has made a series of discretionary approvals in “the downtown area core” that add substantial, project-level detail and change the cumulative development picture, including but not limited to
approvals involving Bishop Ranch 1A, Bishop Ranch 3A, Bishop Ranch 7 (Bartlett – KB Home South Bay, Inc.), Bishop Ranch 8 (Canopy), Bishop Ranch 11 (Trumark Homes), Bishop Ranch 12 (Annabel), and Bishop Ranch Affordable Housing (Bishop Ranch Service Center). To the extent the City has relied on the 2040 GPU EIR and/or the City Walk Master Plan EIR (including for Bishop Ranch 1A and Bishop Ranch 3A) for tiering and streamlining determinations, that post-certification, project-level detail cannot be ignored when assessing current cumulative conditions for this 20-year master plan approval. These references are provided solely for regulatory-baseline and cumulative-setting context relevant to the Orchards Development Project, and are not asserted as a separate, independent appeal or challenge to any other approval.
The City has also adopted updated San Ramon Climate Action Plan (CAP) and the CEQA Greenhouse Gas Emissions Thresholds and Guidance Report (June 10, 2025)
post-dating certification of the 2040 GPU EIR, which should not be ignored in CEQA
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 5 of 12
tiering decisions for any major discretionary approvals issued years after the December 2023 certification of the 2040 GPU EIR. Given this additional information obtained from each project’s development agreement and entitlement record, together with these regulatory and cumulative-setting changes, it is not credible to treat the December 2023 program-level EIR as a static “all-purpose clearance” for major, phased approvals issued years later—particularly where traffic patterns change over time and post-certification actions and ordinance amendments affect development intensity assumptions and cumulative impacts relevant to Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT), air quality, greenhouse gas emissions, and noise, among others. 4.3. Transportation and Vehicle Miles Traveled: the record acknowledges uncertain thresholds, potentially significant impacts, and mitigation that is not shown to be fully enforceable or effective, especially for a phased, long-term buildout.
The December 16, 2025 Planning Commission staff report states that “no project-level VMT analysis is required due to the Project relying on the 15183 exemption,” but also acknowledges that a project-level analysis was prepared “for use in case there is a ‘peculiar characteristic’ of the project which means it does not generally fit within the 2040 GPU EIR analysis.” (December 16, 2025 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report discussion of Vehicle Miles Traveled, Packet p. 70.) Fehr & Peers’ Vehicle Miles Traveled memorandum further states that, at the time of preparation, “the City of San Ramon has not yet formally adopted its own VMT criteria, standards, or thresholds,” and therefore the assessment follows current Governor’s Office of Planning and Research guidance and
Contra Costa Transportation Authority guidance, not local or project-based thresholds. (Fehr & Peers, Bishop Ranch Orchards Vehicle Miles Traveled Analysis, November 10, 2025, p. 2.)
The City’s CEQA Guidelines section 15183 consistency checklist acknowledges that the 2040 GPU EIR identified Vehicle Miles Traveled impacts as potentially significant, and
that the 2040 GPU EIR concluded that Vehicle Miles Traveled impacts would remain significant and unavoidable, with the effectiveness of citywide Transportation Demand Management programs characterized as uncertain pending buildout and future behavior changes. (FirstCarbon Solutions, Orchards Project CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist, December 2025, pp. 164–165.) Despite that context, the checklist concludes that there are “no environmental effects peculiar to the proposed project,” while relying on Transportation Demand Management measures to reduce home-based Vehicle Miles Traveled by “just over” five percent and asserting an expected reduction of 6.1 percent. (FirstCarbon Solutions, Orchards Project CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist, December 2025, p. 165;
December 16, 2025 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report discussion of Vehicle Miles Traveled, Packet p. 70.)
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 6 of 12
This reasoning is not legally defensible as presented. Where the program-level Environmental Impact Report concluded that Vehicle Miles Traveled impacts would be significant and unavoidable because mitigation effectiveness is uncertain, the City cannot credibly treat a marginal, model-based percentage reduction (6.1 percent versus a “just over” five percent target) as a settled basis for a “no further review” conclusion—especially for a project that the City itself describes as a 20-year phased master plan. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26, Packet p. 15; January 20, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Orchards Phasing Scenario slide, Packet p. 47.) Moreover, the Project’s own Traffic Operations Report explicitly recommends reassessing the need for mitigation measures after occupation of each phase of development. (Fehr & Peers, Bishop Ranch Orchards Traffic Operations Report, November 10, 2025, p. 18.)
Mitigation measures under CEQA must be feasible, effective, and fully enforceable by the lead agency throughout the life of the approval. Here, the adopted
Conditions of Approval include broad Transportation Demand Management requirements (e.g., implement a Community-Based Travel Plan prior to occupancy and distribute Transportation Demand Management information), but the record does not demonstrate how those measures will be monitored, enforced over time, and adaptively strengthened if Vehicle Miles Traveled reductions do not materialize. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Resolution No. 02-26, Neighborhood District Conditions of Approval, Condition 115, Packet p. 57; February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Resolution No. 02-26, Master Plan Conditions of Approval, Condition 99, Packet p. 41.) Because Vehicle Miles Traveled directly drives related impact areas—traffic operations,
air quality, greenhouse gas emissions, and noise—the deficiencies in the Vehicle Miles Traveled analysis and mitigation framework create cascading CEQA problems that cannot be dismissed by conclusory statements of “not peculiar” impacts.
4.4. Reliance on applicant-prepared technical studies without demonstrated independent verification undermines impartiality and the City’s duty of independent judgment. The City’s staff report states that the City’s consultant (FirstCarbon Solutions) prepared the CEQA Guidelines section 15183 checklist, but the checklist’s transportation conclusions rely on the applicant’s Fehr & Peers Traffic Operations Report and Vehicle Miles Traveled analysis. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report, Packet pp. 8-9; December 16, 2025 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report discussion of Vehicle Miles Traveled, Packet p. 70.) The December 16, 2025 staff report further states that the City Traffic Engineer reviewed and “agrees with the methodology and conclusions” of the applicant’s Traffic Operations
Report and Vehicle Miles Traveled analysis. (December 16, 2025 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report discussion of Vehicle Miles Traveled, Packet p. 70.)
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 7 of 12
CEQA permits the use of applicant-prepared studies, but the lead agency and its environmental consultant must exercise independent judgment. For a project of this magnitude and duration—particularly one relying on a streamlined CEQA pathway and making close calls on Vehicle Miles Traveled significance and mitigation—the City must demonstrate, in the record, how independent verification occurred (e.g., peer review, replication checks, sensitivity testing, or other objective validation), rather than solely accepting the applicant’s preferred assumptions and conclusions. The presence of the repeated “Note to Reviewer” in the Fehr & Peers Vehicle Miles Traveled memorandum—stating that the project-level Vehicle Miles Traveled assessment was prepared only “in case” the project does not fit within the General Plan Environmental Impact Report analysis—underscores that even the applicant’s consultant recognized the legal and technical sensitivity of relying on CEQA Guidelines section 15183 alone. (Fehr & Peers,
Bishop Ranch Orchards Vehicle Miles Traveled Analysis, November 10, 2025, pp. 1, 3, and 5.) 4.5. Tribal cultural resources and Assembly Bill 52: the record contains indicators of tribal cultural resource sensitivity that are not resolved by a blanket “not required” conclusion. The CEQA Guidelines section 15183 checklist states that Assembly Bill 52 (AB 52) consultation is “not required” because no Notice of Preparation, Notice of Mitigated Negative Declaration, or Notice of Negative Declaration is being issued for a CEQA Guidelines section 15183 checklist. (FirstCarbon Solutions, Orchards Project CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist, December 2025, p. 79.) At the same time, the checklist acknowledges: (1) a response from the
Confederated Villages of Lisjan Nation recommending caution with exempting the project due to proximity to historic creek systems; and (2) a positive Native American Heritage Commission Sacred Lands File result indicating potential tribal
cultural resources within the project boundaries. (FirstCarbon Solutions, Orchards Project CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist, December 2025, p. 79.)
Those indicators are not resolved by simply reciting that AB 52 consultation is “not required.” For a project involving substantial grading and ground disturbance across a large site, tribal cultural resource protection requires clear, enforceable conditions, culturally appropriate protocols, and transparent documentation of how tribal concerns were addressed in the record. 4.6. Process integrity, transparency, and meaningful public participation: statutory streamlining cannot substitute for a complete, coherent, and legally defensible record.
The City has processed Orchards Development Project under Senate Bill 330 (SB 330) as a Preliminary Housing Development application with a maximum of five public meetings. (December 16, 2025 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report,
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 8 of 12
Packet p. 54; February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26, “WHEREAS” recital, Packet p. 16.) The City’s approval record confirms that the February 3, 2026 hearing was the third of that maximum five-meeting allotment. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26, “WHEREAS” recital, Packet p. 16.) SB 330 is not a license to curtail transparency, compress environmental review, or convert a meeting cap into a mandate to approve an incomplete or internally inconsistent record. If the City elects to pursue streamlining pathways, it must do so with heightened—not diminished—discipline in record clarity and defensibility. Appeal process clarity. The City’s published appeal instructions provide only a minimal checklist of required items and do not clearly explain (among other things): how
the City defines the administrative record for purposes of appeal; where the public can access that record in a stable, centralized format; and how CEQA determinations embedded in project approvals are expected to be presented and reviewed on appeal.
(City of San Ramon, Appeal Instructions (Zoning), downloaded February 9, 2026, p. 1.) Appeal fee deposit, scope of review, and lack of guardrails. The City’s adopted Master Fee Schedule establishes that an appeal from a Planning Commission decision—whether characterized as residential or non-residential—requires a $4,500 deposit under San Ramon Municipal Code section D7-8. (City of San Ramon Resolution No. 2025-036, Exhibit 1: Master Fee Schedule FY 2025/26, “Planning,” “Appeals,” p. 6.) The Master Fee Schedule further explains that these deposits are time-and-materials charges billed at an hourly rate of $330.00 per City employee; that deposit amounts are based on an assumed average cost; and that once 80 percent of a deposit is drawn down, the City will require an additional deposit of 25 percent to 50 percent of the
original deposit “to continue processing,” with applications potentially deemed withdrawn if account deficits exist. (Id., p. 10, Planning Services Division footnotes 1-3.)
Yet the City’s appeal instructions do not explain what analysis will be performed in exchange for that deposit (or any supplemental deposits), what written staff evaluation (if any) will be prepared, whether staff will issue a written findings memorandum
responding to each ground of appeal, or what objective criteria and procedural safeguards ensure the appeal right functions as meaningful administrative review rather than a pay-to-participate act of faith. (City of San Ramon, Appeal Instructions (Zoning), downloaded February 9, 2026, p. 1.) The Municipal Code provides that the City Council conducts appeals de novo and may consider new materials and testimony. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-12.C.1.) It also provides that failure to act within the stated time limits is deemed an affirmation of the original decision. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-12.F.) Political “call for review” structure. The Municipal Code separately provides for “calls for review” that must be initiated by a member of the Planning Commission or City Council. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II,
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 9 of 12
section D7-11.B.) That structural reality further underscores why the City should take care not to treat appeal rights as dependent on political sponsorship or informal gatekeeping. Meaningful relief and fair hearing concerns. During the November 25, 2025 City Council discussion on appeal fees, the Mayor stated (at approximately 3:25:37 of the meeting video): “If a resident cannot obtain a Councilmember to bring an issue forward, then probably the odds of a successful appeal are not going to be great anyway.” Similar themes were reiterated during the City Council Special Workshop on January 31, 2026 (Agenda Item 2.1, Continued Discussion of the City’s Appeal Fee Structure), where the City Manager (approximately 9:37 a.m.), the Mayor (approximately 10:09 a.m.), and Councilmember Jweinat (approximately 10:38 a.m.) made comments that, in the appellant’s view, suggested the unlikelihood of successful appeals. The January 31, 2026 workshop recording is not posted on the City’s website; the times cited
above are from my in-person attendance notes. These statements raise due process and fair hearing concerns, particularly when paired
with a Municipal Code structure in which failure to act is deemed an affirmation. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-12.F.) This appeal is submitted to ensure that the City Council treats the appeal right as meaningful, non-political, and consistent with basic principles of due process, including a fair hearing based on the weight of the evidence and the standards in the Municipal Code. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-12.E.2.) These concerns are also inconsistent with the basic ethical obligations of public planning practice, including the American Institute of Certified Planners Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct, which emphasizes serving the public interest through transparent, fair, and integrity-driven decision-making.
Administrative record access. Finally, because the City is the custodian of the administrative record for this matter, the City should not expect residents to recreate or
reassemble the record as a condition of obtaining meaningful review. If public comments are to remain embedded in agenda packets for each meeting, the City’s Orchards Development Project webpage should clearly and plainly state where the
public can find existing public comments in the administrative record, including prior written comments and attachments, and should provide a stable, comprehensive document index identifying all relied-upon technical studies and CEQA documents, rather than forcing residents to hunt through multiple meeting packets. 5. Requested Relief For the reasons stated above, I respectfully request that the City Council: 1. Grant this appeal and reverse, or at minimum remand, the Planning Commission’s February 3, 2026 approvals for the
Orchards Development Project (Resolution No. 02-26) until the CEQA record and supporting technical analyses are corrected and brought into a legally defensible posture.
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 10 of 12
2. Direct staff to prepare additional environmental review, as needed to address the defects identified in this appeal, including (without limitation) updated and/or project-level analysis based on post-2023 project entitlements and development agreements in the vicinity (including but not limited to approvals involving Bishop Ranch 1A, Bishop Ranch 3A, Bishop Ranch 7 (Bartlett), Bishop Ranch 8 (Canopy), Bishop Ranch 11 (Trumark Homes), Bishop Ranch 12 (Annabel), and Bishop Ranch Affordable Housing (Bishop Ranch Service Center)), the City’s reliance on tiering from the 2040 GPU EIR and, where applicable, the City Walk Master Plan EIR, changed regulatory baseline conditions (including the June 10, 2025 San Ramon Climate Action Plan (CAP) and the CEQA Greenhouse Gas Emissions Thresholds and Guidance Report), changed cumulative conditions, transportation and Vehicle Miles Traveled impacts and mitigation enforceability, and tribal cultural resource protections for a phased, long-term buildout.
3. Require that any mitigation measures relied upon for CEQA compliance be feasible, fully enforceable by the City, and demonstrably effective—including
enforceable monitoring and adaptive management commitments where the record itself anticipates phase-by-phase reassessment. (Fehr & Peers, Bishop Ranch Orchards Traffic Operations Report, November 10, 2025, p. 18.) 4. Direct staff to develop and publicly adopt clear, realistic City-based and/or project-based CEQA guidelines, including thresholds of significance (including for Vehicle Miles Traveled and greenhouse gas emissions) so that CEQA determinations are transparent, consistent, and not dependent on ad hoc interpretations or shifting consultant guidance. 5. Require a coherent, publicly accessible administrative record for
Orchards Development Project, including a comprehensive document index on the City’s Orchards project webpage that identifies where public comments and all relied-upon technical documents may be found.
6. Direct the City Clerk and staff to provide clear, written appeal procedures and due process guardrails for this matter, including (without limitation): (1) a description of what analysis will be performed and what staff work product(s) will be produced for the required appeal fee deposit; (2) advance public disclosure of any staff memoranda, consultant reviews, or other materials the City intends to rely upon at the appeal hearing; and (3) a written decision document that states the City Council’s rationale and is supported by the weight of the evidence
presented at the hearing. (San Ramon Municipal Code, Title D, Division D7, Chapter II, section D7-12.E.2.) Reservation of Rights; No Prejudice to Other Matters This appeal is filed to pursue available administrative remedies concerning the
Orchards Development Project approvals and related CEQA determinations. Nothing in this appeal should be construed as a waiver of any rights, remedies, claims, or defenses
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 11 of 12
the appellant may have in any other matter, including pending litigation or future proceedings. The appellant expressly reserves all such rights. Appellant further notes that the CEQA tiering, baseline, and cumulative-impact deficiencies described in this appeal reflect recurring issues in the City’s processing of other major discretionary approvals in the Bishop Ranch and City Center area, including (without limitation) matters in which the City has relied on the 2040 GPU EIR and/or the City Walk Master Plan EIR (including Bishop Ranch 1A and Bishop Ranch 3A). References in this appeal to other approvals are made solely to demonstrate the post-December 2023 evolution of the regulatory baseline and cumulative setting relevant to the Orchards Development Project, and are not intended to reopen, revive, or collaterally attack any other approval for which administrative, judicial, or statutory deadlines may have run.
Appellant is separately pursuing challenges to certain related approvals and Citywide policy actions, including (among others) Bishop Ranch 7 (Bartlett - KB Home South Bay, Inc.), Bishop Ranch 11 (Trumark Homes), and the June 10, 2025
Climate Action Plan Update and CEQA Greenhouse Gas Emissions Thresholds and Guidance Report. Appellant’s decision to file this appeal in the Orchards Development Project matter shall not be used by the City to argue, in any other matter, that the City’s appeal process and fee structure provide a clear, affordable, or meaningful administrative remedy, nor shall it prejudice appellant’s ability to assert (where applicable) that exhaustion is excused, impracticable, cost-prohibitive, futile, or otherwise satisfied based on the City’s own record and the circumstances of each matter. Respectfully submitted,
Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Attachments: Exhibit List
Exhibits 1-9
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Page 12 of 12 EXHIBIT LIST Exhibit 1 – Notice of Exemption for the Orchards Development Project, filed February 6, 2026 (CEQA Guidelines section 15183). Exhibit 2 – February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Agenda Item 8.1 (Orchards Development Project), including Staff Report and Draft Resolution No. 02-26. (see pages 1-4, 7-87 at: https://sanramonca.iqm2.com/Citizens/FileOpen.aspx?Type=1&ID=3971&Inline=True) Exhibit 3 – Appellant’s verbal public comment script on the Orchards Development Project (February 3, 2026).
Exhibit 4 – Appellant’s written public comments on the Orchards Development Project (February 3, 2026). Exhibit 5 – Appellant’s written public comments on the Orchards Development Project (January 20, 2026). Exhibit 6 – Appellant’s written public comments on the Orchards Development Project (December 16, 2025). Exhibit 7 – Appellant’s prior public comments on the City’s appeal fee structure - January 31, 2026 (for context regarding appeal process concerns). Exhibit 8 – Appellant’s prior public comments on the City’s appeal fee structure -
November 25, 2025(for context regarding appeal process concerns).
Exhibit 9 – Appellant’s Prior public comments on the City’s appeal fee structure –
April 22, 2025 (for context regarding appeal process concerns).
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Exhibit 1
Notice of Exemption for the
Orchards Development Project,
filed February 6, 2026
(CEQA Guidelines section 15183).
.. NOTICE OF EXEMPTION . '
TO:
FROM:
County Clerk's Office
Contra Costa County
555 Escobar Street
Martinez, CA 94553-1105
Office of Planning and Research
P.O. Box 3044, Room 113
Sacramento, CA 95812-3044
City of San Ramon (Lead Agency)
Planning Services Division
7000 Bollinger Canyon Rd
San Ramon, CA 94583
(925) 973-2560
2026-00046
FILED
February 6, 2026
KRISTIN D CONNT:T.LY
CIJ•.l{K-Rl:C()ltlJER
By ~'/,,,1..o-..p,v,
L. Glasper
l>cpllly Clerk
PROJECT TITLE: Orchards Development Project (MJ 2024-0004, DP 2024-0006, DP
2024-0008, AR 2024-0013, TRP 2024-0009, and ENVR 2025-0003)
PROJECT LOCATION: 600 I Bollinger Canyon Road, San Ramon, CA 94583
Contra Costa County (APN: 213-120-008)
PROJECT APPLICANT: BR6001, LLC (c/o Sunset Development Company)
2600 Camino Ramon, Suite 20 I, San Ramon, CA 94583
Phone: (925) 380-9511
Email: shill@bishopranch.com
PROPERTY OWNER: BR6001, LLC (c/o Sunset Development Co.)
LEAD AGENCY: City of San Ramon
PROJECT DESCRIPTION: The proposed Project consists of demolition of 1.3m sq. ft. office buildings
(formerly Chevron Office Park), subdivision of the existing 92-acre site into three Districts and 191 lots for up
to 2,510 residential units, and approval of two development plans for the development of the Orchards
Development Master Plan, and the Neighborhood District consisting of 230 single-family homes, 138 multi-
family townhomes, and 58 optional accessory dwelling units (ADUs), along with associated site and landscape
improvements within this District. The Project consists of an overall density of 46.3 dwelling units per net acre.
EXEMPT STATUS: (check one)
□ Ministerial (Sec. 21080(b )( 1 ); I 5268);
□ Declared Emergency (Sec. 21080(b)(3); 15269(a));
□ Emergency Project (Sec. 21080(b)(4); 15269(b)(c));
□ Categorical Exemption:
X Statutory Exemptions: Projects Consistent with the General Plan -15183
□ Common Sense Exemption (Sec. 1506l(b)(3))
REASONS WHY PROJECT IS EXEMPT:
The proposed Project is consistent with the City of San Ramon 2040 General Plan and Zoning designation of
Downtown Mixed Use -South (DMU-S). The Project does not propose an increase in density over the existing
land use designation and is consistent with the impacts evaluated in the 2040 General Plan Update (GPU) EIR.
As required by CEQA, the City prepared a Final EIR, which analyzed the environmental impacts of the GPU
(SCH No. 2022060549). On December 13, 2023, the City Council certified an EIR for the 2040 GPU. The
Project would not result in any impacts unique to the site or that were not evaluated in the 2040 GPU EIR.
LEAD AGENCY CONT ACT: Cindy Yee, Division Manager at (925) 973-2562 or cyee@sanramon.ca.gov
Signature: ~
Authority Cited Sectio:::::i 111 O, Public Resources Code.
Reference: Sections 21108, 21152, and 21152.1, Public Resources Code.
Date: February 6, 2026
•• • FCS
City of San Ramon An ADEC Innovation
7000 BOLLINGER CANYON RD.
SAN RAMON, CALIFORNIA 94583
PMONE: (925) 973-2500
WEB SITE· WWW,S.,,NRAMQN.Q.,GQY
CEQA Guidelines §15183 -Statement of Exemption and Findings of Consistency
Orchards Project -City of San Ramon
State Clearinghouse No. 2022060549
The City of San Ramon, acting as Lead Agency under the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA"), has
reviewed the proposed Orchards Project located at 6001 Bollinger Canyon Road in San Ramon, Contra
Costa County, California. Consistent with CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 (Projects Consistent with a
Community Plan or Zoning), the City makes the following findings based on the Orchards Project CEQA
Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist and the previously certified San Ramon General Plan
2040 Final EIR (SCH No. 2022060549):
1. The Project is consistent with the development density
established by the existing zoning, community plan, or
general plan for which an EIR was certified.
The Orchards Project site is designated Downtown Mixed-Use South (DMU-S) in both the City's General
Plan and Zoning Code. The DMU-S designation permits a density range of 20-60 dwelling units per acre.
The combined Mixed-Use District, Multi-Family District, and Neighborhood District would result in a
sitewide density of 47.2 dwelling units per acre, which is within the range analyzed in the certified 2040
General Plan EIR.
Although the Neighborhood District seeks a waiver from the minimum FAR requirement under the State
Density Bonus Law, CEQA Guidelines §15183CT)(2) clarifies that consistency is based on density, not FAR.
The Project remains fully consistent with the development density evaluated in the certified EIR.
Finding: Satisfied.
C11y Council 973-2530
City Manager: 973-2530
City Attorney: 973-2549
City Clerk: 973-2539
Employee Services: 973-2503
Finance Department: 973-2609
Parks & Community Services: 973-3200
Police Services: 973-2700
Economic Development: 973-2554
Planning Department: 973-2560
Public Services: 973-2800
Engineering Services: 973-2670
2. There are no project-specific effects that are peculiar to the
project or its site.
The Consistency Checklist demonstrates that the site is already fully developed with the former Chevron
Park campus and contains no unique or sensitive environmental conditions that were not addressed in the
2040 General Plan EIR.
Across all topical areas (aesthetics, air quality, biological resources, cultural resources, geology/soils,
hazards, hydrology, noise, population/housing, public services, recreation, transportation, utilities, and
wildfire), the analysis found no environmental effects that are peculiar to the project or its site.
Where applicable (e.g., nesting birds, roosting bats, paleontological resources), the Project is subject to
General Plan EIR mitigation measures already adopted by the City, and no additional project-specific
mitigation is required.
Finding: Satisfied.
3. There are no project-specific impacts that the prior EIR failed
to analyze as significant effects.
The 2040 General Plan EIR analyzed environmental impacts associated with buildout of the General Plan,
including the DMU-S designation that governs this site.
The Consistency Checklist confirms that all impacts associated with the Orchards Project fall within the
scope of impacts already evaluated in the 2040 General Plan EIR. No impact category revealed a new or
elevated significant effect. All expected construction and operational impacts-such as air emissions, noise,
site preparation, grading, or public service demands-were anticipated and analyzed by the certified
General Plan EIR.
Finding: Satisfied.
4. There are no potentially significant off-site or cumulative
impacts which were not discussed in the prior EIR.
The certified 2040 General Plan EIR includes a comprehensive cumulative analysis for citywide and regional
environmental conditions.
Page 2 of3
The Consistency Checklist found that the Orchards Project would not create any new off-site or
cumulative impacts beyond those considered in the 2040 Generar Plan EIR. Project-generated traffic, a·r
emissions, greenhouse gases, noise, stormwater, and public seNice demands were all found to be
consistent w ith the cumulative development envelope evaluated by the prior EIR.
Finding: Satisfied.
5. There is no substantial new information that would result in
more severe environmental impacts than those anticipated in
the prior El R.
The consistency analysis 'dentified no substantial new information, which was not known at the time the
2040 General Plan EIR was certified, ind'cating:
• New s1gnif1cant impacts,
• Increased severity of previously identifed impacts, or
• New feasible mitigation measures or alternatives that the prior EIR fa iled to analyze.
Any new technical information (e.g., updated b1ologica1 surveys, updated geotechnical data, stormwater
design, ESA findings) did not alter the impact conclusions and remains within the scope of the
assumptions and analyses in the 2040 General Plan EIR.
Finding: Satisfied.
Conclusion and Exemption Determination
Based on the Consistency Checklist and the certified San Ramon General Plan 2040 Final EIR, the City of
San Ramon finds that the Orchards Project meets all requirements of CEQA Guidelines §15183.
Accordingly, the City finds that the Orchards Project is exempt from additional CEQA review pursuant to
CEQA Guidelines §15183. No further environmental analysis is required.
Page 1 of1
. Slate of caJlfomla -Department of Fish and WIidiife · :
2026 ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENT FILING FEE CASH RECEIP~
DFW 753.6a (REV. 01101/26) Previously ,DFG 753.5a
SEE INSTRUCTIONS ON REVERIE. 1YPE OR PRINT CLEARLY.
LEAD AGENCY I LEADAGENCY EMAIL
CITY-OF SAN RAMON
COUNTY/STA'Tl; AGENCY OF FILING
. CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
PROJECTTITLE
.11 ·•:•_i,·~~~-. •·1 ,. If'.:~ Sa~e•_~.'• I
RECEIPT NUPIBER:
07-02/06/2028-048
STATE CLEARINGHOUSE.NUMBER (N epplJceble)
DATE
02/0812028
DOCUMENT NU~ER
2026-00048
ORCHARDS DEVELOPMENT PR(;>JECT (MJ 2024-0004, DP 2024,0008, DP 2024-0008, AR 2024-0013, TRP 2024-0009, AND ENVR 2025-0003)
PROJECT APPLICANT NME PROJECT APPLICANT EMAIL PHONE NUMBER
BR6001, LLC (C/0 SUNSET DEVELOPMENT COMPANY)
PROJECT APPLICANT ADDRESS
2800 CAMINO RAMON, SUITE 201
PROJECT APPLICANT (Check ~le box)
• D Local Public Agency D School Dlatrlc:t
CHECK APPLICABLE FEES:
[J Environmental Impact Report (EIR)
C ~ated/Negative Decla1alion (MND)(IIID)
SHILLGBISHOPRANCH.COM
CllY STATE
SAN RAMON CA .
(925) 380-9511
ZIP CODE
94583
0 other Special Dlatrlct D State Agency Im .Private Erttty
S 4,227.50 s _______ _
C Certllled Regulatory Prog1&m (CRP) dOCIJl!lenl -payment due dlrectly to COfW
$ 3,043.75 $ ----.-------
$ 1,437.25 . S ---------
Iii Elcemptfram fee
Iii Notice ofEJllllmption (attach)
□ CDFW No Brect Determination (attach)
□ Fee previously paid (attach previously lasued cash receipt copy)
□ Wat.er Right App11cat1on or Plltltlon Fee (State Water Resourcee Control Boafli only)
II County docunentary handling fee
s 850.00 $ ----------,-
$ 50.00 S _______ :;:50:.:;.0~0
a other
P.AYMENT METHOD:
a cash a Credtt l!!I Check a Other 521
SIGNATURE
ORIGINAL•PRO.EC'l' APFUCANT COPV-CDFWIASD
$ _________ _
TOTAL.RECEIVED $ ________ s_o_.o __ o
GENCY OF FlUNG PRINTED NAME AND TITLE
Liu Glaeper Deputy Clerk
COPY· LEAD AGENCY COP'f. COUNTY a.ERK' DFW763.511 \RM'· 01012028)
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Exhibit 3
Appellant’s verbal public comment script on the
Orchards Development Project
(February 3, 2026).
Page 1 of 3
Agenda Item 8.1 - Orchards Development Project
Good evening, Commissioners. My name is Brian Swanson, and I am a certified planner and a resident of Twin Creeks South.
This is my oral summary of the extensive written public comment I
submitted for the record on Agenda Item 8.1, which I ask be incorporated in
full.
(brief pause)
What is before you tonight is not a single short-term project.
It is a 20-year Orchards Master Plan, together with approval of the
Neighborhood District as the first implementing phase.
Staff's California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) position is that neither
the Master Plan nor the Neighborhood District is peculiar to the site, and
that the environmental impacts disclosed in the December 2023-certified 2040 General Plan Update Environmental Impact Report remain valid and applicable—such that no additional CEQA review is required beyond a section 15183 consistency checklist. That conclusion is not supported by the record.
(pause)
CEQA is not a one-time environmental clearance that can be stretched across decades. The applicant's own phasing shows that major components are not delivered until Year 7, Year 12, and Year 20, with the full buildout extending to approximately 2045.
Page 2 of 3
Tiering does not eliminate the obligation to confront changed baseline conditions, substantial new information, and project-specific impacts as they arise.
Most importantly, the applicant's own traffic consultant explicitly states that mitigation must be reassessed after the occupation of each phase,
because conditions are uncertain and will change.
That is not my characterization.
That is their written conclusion. Reassessment after each phase is an admission that impacts may differ materially over time. (pause)
That directly contradicts the City's frequent "no further review" posture for
any project, especially a 20-year master plan.
The Vehicle Miles Traveled analysis reinforces this problem. The project does not screen out.
At the time of analysis, the City had no adopted VMT thresholds.
The project exceeds the screening threshold absent mitigation.
The proposed reductions are described as "expected," not enforceable or guaranteed, while the 2040 General Plan Update Environmental Impact Report found that VMT impacts were significant and unavoidable due to uncertainty.
Add to this the post-2023 regulatory and analytical baseline changes,
including Ordinances 529 and 534, the City’s June 2025 adoption of the
updated San Ramon Climate Action Plan and the CEQA Greenhouse Gas
Emissions Thresholds and Guidance Report, and a wave of more detailed
Page 3 of 3
Bishop Ranch approvals, and it is no longer credible to claim that a 2023 program-level Environmental Impact Report fully captures today’s cumulative conditions for what you are being asked to approve.
In closing, I need to address process integrity. (slow down here)
The City has repeatedly framed planning matters as:
"We only have X number of meetings, therefore we must approve it as
presented." That framing is inconsistent with due process and with the American Institute of Certified Planners Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct, which requires planners and planning bodies to exercise independent judgment, base decisions on adequate and accurate information, and ensure meaningful public participation in discretionary land-use decisions.
When statutory constraints are used to pressure acceptance of an
incomplete or internally inconsistent record, the process shifts from
deliberative review to manufactured urgency and procedural coercion.
If the City Council's stated norm is "Be prepared—do your homework," that obligation applies first to the City. Senate Bill 330 does not compel approval of a deficient CEQA record.
Streamlining is not a substitute for due process.
I respectfully urge the Commission to continue this item, require correction
of the CEQA record, and establish clear, realistic, city-based and project-
based CEQA thresholds of significance, together with feasible, fully enforceable mitigation measures and enforceable expectations governing when and how environmental review will occur as programs, plans, and projects are approved, including this 20-year master plan and the Neighborhood District.
Thank you.
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Exhibit 4
Appellant’s written public comments on the
Orchards Development Project
(February 3, 2026).
plain-language statement on the Orchards project webpage identifying exactly where the public can find existing
public comments (e.g., "Public comments are included within each Planning Commission agenda packet under'
Communications.' See the agenda packets dated [list] at [link]."). This must be placed in a clear, dedicated
location on the project webpage—not buried in meeting materials.
4. Searchable PDFs. All posted documents should be text-searchable. This includes scanned letters, appendices,
presentations, and technical reports.
5. Administrative record completeness. If staff intends to file a Notice of Exemption, the City must ensure that the
administrative record clearly contains the factual basis and substantial evidence for every prerequisite conclusion
on which the exemption claim is based. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report,
"Next Steps," Packet p. 10.)
II. The City's Current CEQA Posture Is Overbroad and Unsupported by a Long-Term Phasing Record
Staff asserts that the Project qualifies for CEQA Guidelines section 15183 because it is consistent with the Downtown
Mixed Use–South (DMU-S) land use designation and does not exceed the maximum density (60 units per net acre),
proposing approximately 46.3 dwelling units per net acre without ADUs. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda
Packet, Staff Report, Packet p. 7–8.)
Staff further states, categorically, that:
"Impacts that were analyzed in the 2040 General Plan Update (GPU) Environmental Impact Report (EIR) are not
peculiar to the Project or its site and do not require further review."
(February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report, Packet p. 8.)
That statement reads as a conclusion first, analysis second.
A. CEQA is an informational disclosure statute, not a long-term "environmental clearance" blanket
The City's own record confirms the Orchards Master Plan is anticipated to be developed over 20 years. (February 3, 2026
Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26, "WHEREAS" recital, Packet p. 14–15.)
And the applicant's own phasing presentation shows a buildout trajectory extending to Year 20, with the Neighborhood
District not delivered until Year 7. (January 20, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, "Orchards Phasing Scenario"
slide, Packet p. 47.)
CEQA's intent is to ensure that decision-makers and the public are informed at the time decisions are made—not to
provide a convenient "clearance" posture that can be stretched across decades of changing baseline conditions, changed
regulations, and changed cumulative development. Tiering and streamlining tools exist to avoid redundant re-analysis,
but they do not authorize agencies to disregard substantial changes in circumstances or substantial new information that
materially affects impact analysis.
B. The City's own transportation documents undermine the "no further review" posture
Most importantly, the applicant's traffic consultant expressly acknowledges that mitigation may need to be revisited and
adjusted as each phase is built and occupied:
"It is recommended that the City monitor the Bollinger Canyon Road and Sunset Drive intersection operations
and reassess the need for the proposed mitigation measures after the occupation of each phase of development,
because there is a potential that the mitigation measures may need to be adjusted based on the actual traffic
conditions…there is a large level of uncertainty…due to potential changes in travel patterns, construction of other
projects in the vicinity, and changes to transportation infrastructure."
(Fehr & Peers, "Orchards Traffic Operations Report," November 10, 2025, p. 37.)
This statement is devastating to the City's current posture.
If the applicant's own traffic consultant is putting in writing that mitigation must be reassessed after each phase, the City
cannot credibly maintain that a December 2023 program-level EIR and a December 2025 consistency checklist provide
sufficient environmental review for a 20-year phased buildout with changing baseline conditions.
Reassessment after each phase is—plainly—an admission that conditions will change and impacts may differ materially
over time. That is the opposite of a defensible "no further review" posture.
2/11/26, 3:55 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 8.1 – Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project - City of San Ramon Planning Commis…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r8112098300693036183%7Cmsg-a:r-125425428849386400…2/8
III. The "Shelf-Life" Problem: Tiering Limitations for a 20-Year, Multi-Phase Redevelopment
The phasing slide is not a footnote; it is the backbone of the CEQA problem here.
The applicant's phasing timeline shows:
Year 0–2: Building demolition;
Year 7: Neighborhood District + affordable community + perimeter greenway;
Year 12: Mixed-use district (housing plus 125,000 square feet);
Year 15 and Year 20: Additional multi-family districts. (January 20, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet,
"Orchards Phasing Scenario" slide, Packet p. 47.)
Meanwhile, staff's fiscal analysis frames anticipated full buildout from 2026 to 2045. (February 3, 2026 Planning
Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report, Fiscal Analysis, Packet p. 10.)
If the City is going to approve a master plan today but acknowledge the Project's buildout horizon extends to
approximately 2045, then the City must establish—up front and in the administrative record—clear expectations for when
new CEQA analysis will be required during the life of the master plan and each district's buildout. That is not optional; it is
how CEQA remains meaningful.
This is especially true given that the 2040 GPU EIR itself acknowledges that future project-level conditions and the
effectiveness of VMT-reduction measures are uncertain. The City's 2040 GPU EIR findings state that the General Plan's
VMT impact remains significant and unavoidable, in part due to unknown future conditions and uncertainty regarding the
effectiveness of reduction measures. (City of San Ramon, "2040 General Plan EIR Combined," Statement of Overriding
Considerations and Findings, Impact TRA-2 discussion, p. SOC-16.)
That is the City's own CEQA record, which admits uncertainty and the need for future project-level rigor.
IV. Regulatory Baseline Changes and "Substantial New Information" Since the December 2023 2040
General Plan Update EIR
A. Adopted ordinances materially alter the regulatory context and intensity assumptions
Since the 2040 General Plan Update EIR was certified, the City has adopted ordinances that materially alter land use
expectations and development standards in the broader area—changes that must be evaluated as part of the "substantial
new information" and "changed circumstances" inquiry.
Ordinance 529 (DMU-N FAR reduction) reduced the minimum sitewide Floor Area Ratio (FAR) in the Downtown Mixed
Use–North (DMU-N) zoning district from 1.25 to 0.5. (May 13, 2025 City Council Agenda Packet, Ordinance 529, Exhibit
A, Table 2-7, Packet p. 109.) The City's Ordinance 529 findings also acknowledge that residential development plan
applications in DMU-N (including Bishop Ranch 7 and Bishop Ranch 11) were not meeting the required minimum FAR,
driving the policy change. (May 13, 2025 City Council Agenda Packet, Ordinance 529, Resolution No. 2025-048,
Packet p. 113.)
Ordinance 534 (zoning text amendments including multi-family parking requirements) reflects additional changes to
parking standards and procedures for reductions and shared/collective parking, and includes revised multi-family parking
tables and guest parking standards. (October 14, 2025 City Council Agenda Packet, Ordinance 534, Exhibit A-2, Table 3-
8 (Multi-Family Dwellings), Packet p. 90–91.)
These changes are not merely internal zoning housekeeping—they influence development intensity, trip generation
profiles, parking supply, and travel behavior patterns. In a post–Senate Bill 743 (SB 743) CEQA framework, such
changes directly affect VMT, greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, and noise.
B. Post–2040 General Plan Update EIR approvals provide far more detailed project-level information
Since the December 2023 certification of the 2040 General Plan Update EIR, the City has advanced and approved major
entitlement packages and plans in the vicinity that provide substantially more detailed, revised, or changed information
than what was available during the program 2040 General Plan Update EIR preparation, including but not limited to:
Bishop Ranch 1A;
Bishop Ranch 3A;
Bishop Ranch 7 (Bartlett);
2/11/26, 3:55 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 8.1 – Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project - City of San Ramon Planning Commis…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r8112098300693036183%7Cmsg-a:r-125425428849386400…3/8
Bishop Ranch 8 (Canopy);
Bishop Ranch 11 (Trumark Homes);
Bishop Ranch 12 (Annabel); and
Bishop Ranch Affordable Housing (Bishop Ranch Service Center).
Additionally, the City has adopted climate framework documents post-dating the 2040 General Plan EIR, including the
Climate Action Plan and related CEQA Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Emissions Thresholds and Guidance Report (approved in
June 2025, per staff actions described in City materials).
Program-level EIRs are inherently broad; when numerous subsequent approvals add detail (and sometimes revise
assumptions), CEQA requires that new information be meaningfully considered when relying on tiering or streamlining.
C. Physical changes reinforce that baseline conditions are evolving
Beyond paper approvals, physical and operational changes in the area further demonstrate that baseline conditions are
not static, including:
shifts in the axis of development intensity toward Bollinger Canyon Road;
roadway widening on Bollinger Canyon Road and Crow Canyon Road; and
the opening of the Bollinger Canyon Road Iron Horse Trail overcrossing.
These are exactly the types of real-world changes that undermine a simplistic "no further review" stance.
V. The City Cannot Ignore VMT Reality While Claiming a CEQA Streamlining "Exemption”
A. The applicant's VMT memorandum confirms a significance issue under commonly used guidance
The VMT memo states, three separate times, a "Note to Reviewer" emphasizing that no project-level VMT analysis is
required if reliance on section 15183 is correct, but that the analysis was prepared in case there is a "peculiar
characteristic," and the project does not generally fit within the General Plan EIR analysis. (Fehr & Peers, "Bishop Ranch
Orchards VMT Analysis," November 10, 2025, pp. 3, 5, and 7.)
The same memo also acknowledges that:
"As the City of San Ramon has not yet formally adopted its own VMT criteria, standards, or thresholds … this
assessment follows current Office of Planning and Research (OPR) and Contra Costa Transportation Authority
(CCTA) guidance related to VMT."
(Fehr & Peers, "Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis," November 10, 2025, p. 7.)
Under that guidance approach, the memo finds that the Project would have a potentially significant VMT impact without
mitigation: the home-based VMT per capita estimate is 16.7, exceeding the 15.9 threshold. (Fehr & Peers, "Bishop Ranch
Orchards VMT Analysis," November 10, 2025, p. 13.)
B. The proposed VMT "mitigation" is stated as "expected," not demonstrated as effective and enforceable
Fehr & Peers then proposes mitigation combining:
Affordable/below-market-rate integration (expected to reduce VMT by 3.9%); and
Community-based travel planning (expected to reduce VMT by 2.3%), for a combined "expected" reduction of
6.1%. (Fehr & Peers, "Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis," November 10, 2025, pp. 15–17.)
Those measures are framed as expected reductions—not guaranteed outcomes. This is particularly problematic because
the City's General Plan Update EIR already acknowledges that the effectiveness of VMT reduction at the program level is
uncertain and that future conditions are unknown. (City of San Ramon, "2040 General Plan EIR Combined,"
Findings/Overriding Considerations, Impact TRA-2, p. SOC-16.)
C. The "Note to Reviewer" repetition should be treated as a warning light, not ignored
The "Note to Reviewer" appears three times. That repetition reads as an intentional professional disclaimer: Fehr &
Peers is documenting that their VMT analysis is being submitted as a contingency—because they recognize that the
City's reliance on section 15183 could be questioned if peculiar characteristics exist or if the Project does not fit neatly
within the program-level assumptions.
2/11/26, 3:55 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 8.1 – Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project - City of San Ramon Planning Commis…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r8112098300693036183%7Cmsg-a:r-125425428849386400…4/8
I am not going to speculate on internal viewpoints, but I will state this clearly: the memo itself signals that reliance on
section 15183 is not a foregone conclusion, and that a project-specific VMT concern is plausible enough that the applicant
commissioned and repeatedly caveated a project-level VMT significance review. (Fehr & Peers, "Bishop Ranch Orchards
VMT Analysis," November 10, 2025, pp. 3, 5, 7.)
D. The checklist's "no further review" conclusion is not supported by this VMT record
FirstCarbon's checklist summary concludes: "no further CEQA review is required." (FirstCarbon Solutions, "Orchards
Project Consistency Checklist," December 6, 2025, p. 3.)
But the VMT memo identifies a potentially significant impact absent mitigation under prevailing guidance, and the General
Plan EIR findings acknowledge uncertainty in VMT effectiveness and unknown future conditions. (Fehr & Peers, "Bishop
Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis," November 10, 2025, p. 13; City of San Ramon, "2040 General Plan EIR Combined," p.
SOC-16.)
At minimum, this record demands something more than the conclusory staff statement that impacts analyzed in the
General Plan EIR are "not peculiar" and require no further review. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda
Packet, Staff Report, Packet p. 8.)
VI. Traffic Operations: The City Cannot Adopt a "No Further Review" Posture While the Traffic Report
Calls for Phase-by-Phase Reassessment
The Traffic Operations Report makes multiple statements that should give the Planning Commission serious pause:
1. The proposed mitigation at Bollinger Canyon Road/Sunset Drive is described as having marginal benefit and may
simply shift queues downstream. (Fehr & Peers, "Orchards Traffic Operations Report," November 10, 2025, p. 37.)
2. The report explicitly recommends monitoring and reassessing mitigation after each phase, given uncertainty and
changing conditions. (Fehr & Peers, "Orchards Traffic Operations Report," November 10, 2025, p. 37.)
3. The report includes a safety-forward set of potential pedestrian improvements and concedes that some were not
modeled, and that implementing them could increase vehicle delay while improving pedestrian safety and
potentially reducing congestion over time. (Fehr & Peers, "Orchards Traffic Operations Report," November 10,
2025, p. 28.)
This is not a record supporting "no further review." It is a record supporting phased accountability, measurable triggers,
and enforceable commitments to reassess impacts and mitigation as conditions change.
VII. Mitigation Measures Must Be Feasible, Fully Enforceable, and Effective
The Planning Commission should not accept mitigation that is aspirational, vague, or unenforceable. CEQA requires that
mitigation measures be:
Feasible (capable of being accomplished in a successful manner);
Fully enforceable through permit conditions, agreements, or other legally binding means; and
Effective in reducing impacts to less than significant where feasible.
This matters acutely for VMT and transportation-related impacts—where "expected" reductions, programmatic measures,
and future-dependent actions are routinely overstated unless tied to clear performance standards, monitoring, reporting,
and enforceable adaptive management.
The Traffic Operations Report itself essentially recommends an adaptive management approach: monitor and reassess
after each phase. (Fehr & Peers, "Orchards Traffic Operations Report," November 10, 2025, p. 37.)
That logic should be reflected in the City's CEQA posture and mitigation framework, not ignored.
VIII. Applicant-Submitted Technical Studies Require Independent Judgment and Verification
FirstCarbon's consistency checklist and conclusions rely on applicant-submitted technical studies (including the VMT
analysis and the Traffic Operations Report).
(February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26, "WHEREAS" recitals noting
applicant resubmittals of VMT and Traffic Operations Report, Packet p. 14.)
2/11/26, 3:55 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 8.1 – Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project - City of San Ramon Planning Commis…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r8112098300693036183%7Cmsg-a:r-125425428849386400…5/8
CEQA does not prohibit applicant-prepared technical work. However, the City must demonstrate independent judgment
and must not simply "rubber stamp” applicant analyses—particularly where the record includes repeated disclaimers (as
in the VMT memo) and admissions of uncertainty (as in the Traffic Operations Report).
If the City's CEQA posture depends on these studies to justify a Notice of Exemption and a "no further review" conclusion,
then the City must be prepared to show, in writing and in the administrative record, that:
the assumptions were verified;
the methodology is appropriate for the City's adopted policy context (including any updated climate and
transportation frameworks);
the mitigation is enforceable and monitored; and
the conclusions reflect independent judgment, not applicant advocacy.
IX. AB 52/Tribal Cultural Resources: Issues Persist, and the Checklist Contains Internal Red Flags
A. The checklist's "AB 52 not required" statement does not resolve tribal cultural resource risk
FirstCarbon states AB 52 consultation "is not required" because a Notice of Preparation, Notice of Intent to Adopt a
Negative Declaration, or Mitigated Negative Declaration is not required for a section 15183 checklist. (FirstCarbon
Solutions, "Orchards Project Consistency Checklist," December 6, 2025, p. 87.)
However, the same checklist documents that FirstCarbon sent letters to tribal representatives, and that the Confederated
Villages of Lisjan Nation responded with a cautionary statement:
"As the project involves major ground disturbance, caution should be taken with exempting this project … in close
proximity to a historic creek and trail …"
(FirstCarbon Solutions, "Orchards Project Consistency Checklist," December 6, 2025, p. 87.)
Separately, the City's General Plan Update EIR states that consultation is still ongoing with Wilton Rancheria and the
Confederated Villages of Lisjan Nation, and that even for future projects not subject to AB 52, the City should adhere to
General Plan policies concerning consultation, tribal monitoring where requested, and compliance with tribal cultural
resource protections. (City of San Ramon, "2040 General Plan EIR Combined," p. 3.4-10.)
Given the scale of demolition and grading, these issues remain relevant and should be addressed with seriousness rather
than dismissed via a procedural statement about AB 52 triggers.
B. The checklist contains conflicting statements regarding the Native American Heritage Commission Sacred
Lands File
The checklist states that the Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC) Sacred Lands File search yielded no results.
(FirstCarbon Solutions, "Orchards Project Consistency Checklist," December 6, 2025, p. 4.)
But later, the checklist states:
"the NAHC SLF search results were positive for TCRs within the project boundaries."
(FirstCarbon Solutions, "Orchards Project Consistency Checklist," December 6, 2025, p. 87.)
That internal inconsistency is not a minor typo; it goes directly to the integrity of the record and the defensibility of a "no
peculiar impacts" conclusion, particularly for a project involving major ground disturbance.
X. Development Standard Waivers and Project Consistency: The Record Reflects Deviations That
Require Careful CEQA Consideration
The record reflects that the applicant identified the need for multiple waivers, including:
waiver from the 1.25 minimum sitewide Floor Area Ratio (FAR) to 0.79;
waiver to use the Orchards Design Guidelines in lieu of the City's Objective Design and Development Standards;
waivers from Landscaping standards (trees and shrubs); and
waivers from Parking and Circulation standards (D3-37-B.1 and D3-37-B.6).
(December 16, 2025 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report excerpt on waivers, Packet p. 59; February 3,
2/11/26, 3:55 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 8.1 – Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project - City of San Ramon Planning Commis…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r8112098300693036183%7Cmsg-a:r-125425428849386400…6/8
2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Draft Resolution No. 02-26 recitals, Packet p. 14.)
While the State Density Bonus Law (and related housing laws) may limit the City's ability to deny waivers, the CEQA issue
remains: these deviations can affect the environmental footprint (site design, circulation, parking supply, travel
behavior, landscaping/heat island, and more). A section 15183 approach must still be grounded in substantial evidence
that the Project will not result in new, more severe, or peculiar significant impacts beyond what was analyzed at the
program level.
XI. Requested Planning Commission Action
For all the reasons stated above, I respectfully request that the Planning Commission not adopt Resolution No. 02-26 at
this time. (February 3, 2026 Planning Commission Agenda Packet, Staff Report, Packet p. 7.)
At a minimum, the Commission should continue this item and direct staff to:
1. Revise and correct the section 15183 Consistency Checklist to eliminate internal conflicts and provide a substantial
evidence-based analysis of changed circumstances, substantial new information, and peculiar project/site effects—
especially for VMT and tribal cultural resources.
2. Reassess VMT and cumulative impacts in light of changes to ordinances, post–2040 General Plan Update EIR
approvals, development agreements, physical infrastructure changes, and updated climate/transportation
frameworks.
3. Require enforceable, measurable, monitored mitigation (not "expected" reductions) and establish clear, written,
enforceable triggers for when additional CEQA review will occur as each phase is proposed and occupied—
consistent with the Traffic Operations Report's explicit recommendation to reassess mitigation after each phase.
(Fehr & Peers, "Orchards Traffic Operations Report," November 10, 2025, p. 37.)
4. Demonstrate independent judgment regarding all applicant-prepared technical studies and ensure the
administrative record reflects verification and City-controlled conclusions.
In closing, I want to address a broader procedural concern that the Planning Commission cannot ignore. The City has
repeatedly framed reductions in public participation as a matter of State-mandated streamlining and "consistency," and
then invoked the five-meeting limit as a dispositive constraint, effectively asserting that the Project must be approved as
presented because time is running out. That framing is inconsistent with the requirements of a fair and deliberative public
hearing.
If the City Council's recently stated norms include "Be prepared—do your homework," then that obligation applies most
directly to the City itself. Due process in land-use decision-making requires that discretionary approvals be based on a
complete, coherent, and accurate administrative record, and that decision-makers be afforded a meaningful opportunity to
evaluate and, where necessary, require correction of deficiencies identified through public review. Statutory timelines do
not excuse incomplete analysis, internal inconsistencies, or reliance on assumptions the City's own record acknowledges
may change over time.
When statutory constraints are used to suggest that unresolved flaws must be accepted rather than corrected, the
process shifts from deliberative review to manufactured urgency and procedural coercion. That approach undermines
meaningful public participation and compromises the Planning Commission's quasi-judicial role.
The Planning Commission should reject that framing. Senate Bill 330 does not compel approval of a deficient record, nor
does it displace the City's obligation to ensure that CEQA compliance is procedurally sound and legally defensible.
Streamlining is not a substitute for due process, and consistency is not a waiver of evidentiary rigor, particularly where the
record itself documents the need for phase-by-phase reassessment and acknowledges uncertainty in future conditions.
Finally, I state this plainly for the record: if the City proceeds on an inadequate CEQA record that fails to account for
regulatory baseline changes, changes in cumulative conditions, Vehicle Miles Traveled impacts, mitigation enforceability,
and Tribal Cultural Resource protections, I am prepared to pursue all available administrative and legal remedies.
Respectfully submitted,
Brian C. Swanson, AICP
San Ramon Voter, Taxpayer, and Resident
2/11/26, 3:55 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 8.1 – Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project - City of San Ramon Planning Commis…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r8112098300693036183%7Cmsg-a:r-125425428849386400…7/8
On Fri, Jan 30, 2026 at 2:27 PM City of San Ramon <casramon@service.govdelivery.com> wrote:
The agenda packet for the upcoming Planning Commission meeting on Tuesday, February 3, 2026 at 6:00PM, is now
posted on the City's website.
Update your subscriptions, modify your password or email address, or stop subscriptions at any time on
your Subscriber Preferences Page. You will need to use your email address to log in.
This service includes a Public Alert System for San Ramon. Subscribers will receive real-time Public Safety and
Emergency Alerts both via email and wirelessly. In order to receive these time-sensitive emergency notifications,
you MUST subscribe to the service. To subscribe, please click here. For wireless alerts, text message and data rates
may apply. This service is provided to you at no charge by City of San Ramon.
City of San Ramon | 7000 Bollinger Canyon Road, San Ramon, CA 94583 | (925) 973 2500 | www sanramon ca gov
2 attachments
12.16.2025 - BSwanson_Public Comment-Agenda Item 9.2 - Public Hearing_ Orchards Development Project
- Planning Commission Meeting.pdf
466K
01.20.2026 - BSwanson_PublicComment-AgendaItem 8.1 - Public Hearing_ Orchards Development Project -
Planning Commission Meeting.pdf
360K
2/11/26, 3:55 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 8.1 – Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project - City of San Ramon Planning Commis…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r8112098300693036183%7Cmsg-a:r-125425428849386400…8/8
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Exhibit 5
Appellant’s prior written public comments on the
Orchards Development Project
(January 20, 2026).
The corridor from Alcosta Boulevard to San Ramon Valley Boulevard presents a significant
public safety and public health concern for any development adjacent to it, including
Orchards, City Center Bishop Ranch, City Hall, and the City Library.
B. Removal of BCR From Project Overview Plans
At the May 1 and May 8 Architectural Review Board (ARB) meetings, I requested that BCR
be depicted prominently on every overview plan for Orchards to ensure decision-makers
are continuously aware of the adjacent high-speed corridor.
Since those meetings, Sunset, with City staff's acquiescence, has removed or minimized
references to BCR in its overview plans, often relegating it to a small corner of the page.
This recent reorientation of plans also now prevents plan reviewers from visually layering
information, similar to a Geographic Information System (GIS) workflow, "if nothing more
than in their mind's eye mental map," to identify conflicts, hazards, and circulation risks.
This omission materially impairs stakeholders, including Planning Staff, the Planning
Commission, and eventually the City Council's ability to evaluate the actual risks posed by
BCR to future residents, visitors, and the broader downtown environment.
III. Historical Pattern of Ignoring Context and Induced Demand
The City widened BCR using Dougherty Valley Settlement Agreement funds because the
project was "on the grandfathered list," without meaningful review of existing conditions or
induced demand.
Concurrently, the City prepared its first Bicycle Master Plan, advanced the BCR Iron Horse Trail
Overcrossing, and applied for over $2 million in grants to coordinate signals along BCR to
increase speeds and throughput.
These actions are contradictory: a Bicycle Master Plan and pedestrian/bicycle overcrossing are
incompatible with policies designed to accelerate vehicle speeds through the same corridor.
This pattern of presenting projects in isolation—rather than as part of a coherent
transportation/mobility strategy—continues with the Orchards development.
IV. Public Safety Consequences of Failing to Calm BCR
Approving Orchards without dramatic traffic calming on BCR knowingly places future residents
at risk.
The City's experience with frequently travelled corridors, including the tragic death of NFL
coach Gregg Knapp on Dougherty Road, demonstrates the foreseeable consequences of
failing to address speed and context.
The administrative record will show that these risks were raised, documented, and ignored.
V. Internal Circulation Deficiencies Within Orchards
The project's heavy reliance on sharrows is inadequate and inappropriate for a new
development of this scale.
Sharrows are not active transportation infrastructure; they are paint-based placeholders that fail
to provide safety or comfort for users of all ages and abilities.
The limited inclusion of bike lanes on only a few prescribed routes demonstrates a
misunderstanding of how active transportation users navigate.
2/2/26, 12:53 PM Gmail - Public Comment - Agenda Item 8.1 - Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project - Planning Commission Meeting - Janu…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r-6519132595515510374&simpl=msg-a:r-65191325955155…2/4
People walking and biking choose routes based on comfort, safety, and sometimes directness,
but sometimes meandering or exploratory. A single prescribed path suppresses demand and
undermines the City's stated Walking District goals.
VI. Required Connectivity for a Functional Downtown Extension
If Orchards is intended to function as an extension of downtown, the project must provide
multiple, redundant, intuitive connections to at least the following:
1. Bollinger Canyon Road
2. The Iron Horse Trail Overcrossing
3. City Center Bishop Ranch
4. The City's Walking District
5. City Hall
6. The City Library
7. The Community Center
8. Central Park
9. Iron Horse Middle School
10. The Marketplace
11. Sports Basement (as a community biking program provider)
Current weekend observations indicate families struggling to navigate the disconnected,
high-stress network around Orchards, City Center, City Hall, Central Park, and the Iron Horse
Trail (including the BCR Overcrossing).
An "all-of-the-above" approach is required—not to identify a route, but to provide many safe,
intuitive routes for all ages and abilities.
VII. Required Conditions Before Approval
Dramatic traffic calming on Bollinger Canyon Road.
Accurate, context-rich overview plans that prominently depict BCR on every sheet.
A comprehensive, multi-directional active transportation network.
Elimination of sharrows as a primary design tool.
Transparent, accessible, and permanent posting of all public materials.
VIII. Conclusion
The Orchards development cannot be responsibly approved without addressing the
contextual, safety, and transparency issues outlined above. Sunset has plainly ignored my
previous verbal comments made at the May 1 and 8th ARB meetings. The City has an
opportunity to correct longstanding patterns of ignoring induced demand, active transportation
2/2/26, 12:53 PM Gmail - Public Comment - Agenda Item 8.1 - Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project - Planning Commission Meeting - Janu…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r-6519132595515510374&simpl=msg-a:r-65191325955155…3/4
conflicts, and corridor context. Approving the project without these corrections would repeat
the same mistakes—this time with far more people living, walking, and biking directly adjacent
to a high-speed corridor.
Respectfully submitted,
Brian C. Swanson, AICP
San Ramon Voter, Taxpayer, and Resident
On Fri, Jan 16, 2026 at 1:17 PM City of San Ramon <casramon@service.govdelivery.com> wrote:
The agenda packet for the upcoming Planning Commission meeting on Tuesday, January 20, 2026 at 6:00PM, is now
posted on the City's website.
Update your subscriptions, modify your password or email address, or stop subscriptions at any time on
your Subscriber Preferences Page. You will need to use your email address to log in.
This service includes a Public Alert System for San Ramon. Subscribers will receive real-time Public Safety and
Emergency Alerts both via email and wirelessly. In order to receive these time-sensitive emergency notifications,
you MUST subscribe to the service. To subscribe, please click here. For wireless alerts, text message and data rates
may apply. This service is provided to you at no charge by City of San Ramon.
City of San Ramon | 7000 Bollinger Canyon Road, San Ramon, CA 94583 | (925) 973 2500 | www sanramon ca gov
2/2/26, 12:53 PM Gmail - Public Comment - Agenda Item 8.1 - Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project - Planning Commission Meeting - Janu…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r-6519132595515510374&simpl=msg-a:r-65191325955155…4/4
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Exhibit 6
Appellant’s prior written public comments on the
Orchards Development Project
(December 16, 2025).
A direct link to the agenda item page where the full administrative record will be posted and maintained.
A clear statement of the public review period for posted technical materials and the deadline for submitting
written comments.
Notices that omit this information materially impair the public's ability to plan participation and meaningfully review
materials. Notices must be distributed with sufficient lead time to enable informed public engagement.
Notice Timing and Scheduling Concerns
Scheduling a follow‑up hearing on December 16, 2025, immediately before year‑end holidays and during a period when
many residents are occupied with family and travel further constrains public review and comment. The prior Planning
Commission meeting on this project was held on July 15, 2025, during the summer holiday period. These timing choices
cumulatively reduce the likelihood of robust public engagement and raise procedural fairness concerns. Notices must be
timed to avoid predictable low participation windows and must provide adequate review time for newly posted materials.
Cumulative Approvals and Volume of Materials
The volume of technical materials recently posted for the Orchards Development Project creates an unreasonable review
burden for stakeholders, especially given concurrent planning activity across the City. Since the adoption of the General
Plan 2040, approvals and ordinance amendments have proceeded rapidly and in a siloed or piecemealed fashion without
adequate cumulative analysis. This pattern undermines the public's ability to evaluate citywide impacts.
Relevant ordinance activity and project approvals to be considered together with the Orchards Project include, but are not
limited to: Ordinances 522; 526; 529; 531; 532; 534, and projects BR 1A, BR 3A, BR 7, BR 8, BR 11, BR 12, and the
Bishop Ranch Affordable Housing Site.
It should be noted that while the City's online Zoning Ordinance (https://online.encodeplus.com/regs/sanramon-ca/doc-
viewer.aspx#secid-3764) indicates it has been updated as of November 12, 2025, the broader online Municipal Code
(https://online.encodeplus.com/regs/sanramon-ca/doc-viewer.aspx#secid-5) Supplement History Table has its most recent
"included" entry as Ordinance 490 on June 25, 2019. The Supplement History Table also does not justify why an
ordinance was marked as included or omitted.
As justification for this volume and intensity, I am incorporating by reference my recent public comments on planning
issues, development projects, advisory committees, fee schedules, and City budgets, which include, but are not limited to,
the following submissions:
1. Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.2 Discussion of the City’s Appeal Fee Structure City Council Meeting November
25, 2025
2. Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.2 Public Hearing Canopy Bishop Ranch 8 Residential Development Planning
Commission Meeting November 18, 2025
3. Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.1 Public Hearing Annabel BR 12 Residential Development Planning Commission
Meeting November 18, 2025
4. Public Comment: Agenda Item 4 Public Comments or Written Communication Planning Commission Meeting
November 4, 2025
5. Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.1 Revisions to Bartlett BR 7 Residential Project Planning Commission Meeting
November 4, 2025
6. Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.2 Revisions to Avalon Bay Bishop Ranch 3A Apartment Project Planning
Commission Meeting October 21, 2025
7. Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.1 Revisions to Bishop Ranch 11 BR 11 Residential Development Planning
Commission Meeting October 21, 2025
8. Public Comment: Remove Agenda Item 5.3 Ordinance 534 from Consent Calendar City Council Meeting October
14, 2025 (with attachment)
9. Public Comment: Agenda Item 5.1 Draft Bicycle Master Plan Update - Transportation Advisory Committee Meeting
- September 18, 2025
10. Public Comment: Agenda Item 5.13 Ordinances 531 and 532 City Council Meeting September 9, 2025
11. Public Comment and Request to Pull Agenda Item 6.2 Resolution No. 11 25 Recommending Approval of Zoning
Ordinance Text Amendment TA 2024 0005 Planning Commission Meeting August 19, 2025
12. Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.4 Ordinances CityWalk Development Agreement Amendments Bishop Ranch 1A
and 3A City Council Meeting August 12, 2025
13. Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.1 Updated Climate Action Plan and CEQA GHG Thresholds City Council Meeting
June 10, 2025 (with attachments)
14. Public Comment: San Ramon Climate Action Plan Public Review Draft April 2025 (May 19, 2015) (with attachment)
15. Public Comment: Item 8.1 Uphold DMU N FAR Standards Do Not Approve Sunset Request to Reduce City Council
Meeting May 13, 2025
2/2/26, 12:55 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.2 - Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project (MJ 2024-0004, DP 2024-0006, DP 202…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r-5611839686648265784&simpl=msg-a:r-561183968664826…2/5
16. Public Questions and Comments: Formal Public Comment Processes, ADA Compliance Meeting Action Minutes,
Orchards Project - ARB Meeting May 8, 2025
17. Public Comment: Agenda Item 8.2 Introduction of Ordinance Amending Title D Mixed Use Standards City Council
Meeting April 22, 2025
18. Public Comment: Agenda Item 8.1 Adopting Master Fee Schedule FY 2025/26 City Council Meeting April 22, 2025
19. Public Comment: Item 9.4 City Council Budget Workshops FY 2025/26 City Council Meeting April 8, 2025
20. Public Comment: Item 9.2 Planning Commission Approval of Sunset's Reduction of Sitewide FAR for DMU N City
Council Meeting April 8, 2025
21. Public Comment: Item 5.3 Minute Order No. 2025 002 2024 General Plan Annual Report and Item 9.1 Innovate
680 Bollinger Canyon Road Share Mobility Hub Presentation City Council Meeting March 25, 2025
22. City Council Meeting - February 11, 2025 Item 11 Closed Session Sale or Exchange of the San Ramon Transit
Center
23. City Council Meeting - November 12, 2024 Agenda Item 8.1 - Transportation Demand Management Advisory
Committee dissolution discussion
24. City Council Meeting - September 24, 2024 Comment on Item 5.2 Resolution No. 2024 Transportation Demand
Management Programs
Fiscal Risk and Housing as a Municipal Loss Leader
Similar to all previous staff reports on the various separate major planning actions and development projects, the Agenda
Item 9.2 staff report contains no programmatic or comprehensive fiscal analysis quantifying the City's net fiscal exposure
from the concentrated wave of downtown approvals. Housing developments typically incur near term net fiscal costs for
cities when capital, operating, maintenance, and service obligations are included. By prioritizing RHNA unit counts
without a transparent, citywide fiscal strategy, the City risks materially impairing long‑term fiscal flexibility, diluting
bargaining leverage with major landowners, and prematurely locking in obligations that could have been mitigated through
phased conditions or financing mechanisms.
Before any final discretionary action, the Planning Commission and City Council must require the following analyses:
1. A downtown programmatic fiscal analysis that quantifies capital, operating, maintenance, service, and revenue
projections for all entitlements and pending approvals.
2. An absorption and market feasibility schedule with realistic phasing, anticipated completion dates, and
occupancy timelines tied to financing assumptions.
3. Sensitivity testing quantifying fiscal outcomes under weaker market scenarios (for example, slower absorption,
increased reliance on tax‑credit affordable projects, or stalled construction).
Builder's Remedy
The so‑called Builder's Remedy risk should not be used to justify accelerating approvals in Bishop Ranch. Where Sunset
and other large landowners control downtown parcels, the practical risk that a builder's remedy would undermine the
City's negotiating leverage is limited. The Commission must not forfeit fiscal protections or bargaining power based on an
uncertain legal contingency.
Operative Baseline and CEQA Tiering Obligation
Staff proposes to tier off the certified General Plan 2040 EIR (December 12, 2023). Tiering requires a clear
demonstration that the project falls within the scope of the program EIR and that no new or substantially more severe
impacts will occur under the current regulatory baseline.
Two material baseline changes adopted after certification and directly relevant to tiering must be treated as operative
baseline conditions for any project‑level analysis:
The DMU‑N sitewide FAR minimum reduction (Ordinance No. 529) was adopted in May 2025.
Ordinance No. 534, adopted October 14, 2025, revises multi family parking minimums and establishes guest
parking requirements.
Any tiered CEQA analysis must use these post‑certification standards as the operative baseline. If the project's impacts
differ materially under the updated baseline, the City must disclose those differences and prepare the appropriate CEQA
documentation rather than relying on an outdated baseline that understates impacts or mitigation needs.
Requested Actions and Remedies
2/2/26, 12:55 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.2 - Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project (MJ 2024-0004, DP 2024-0006, DP 202…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r-5611839686648265784&simpl=msg-a:r-561183968664826…3/5
To restore public confidence and ensure legally defensible, transparent decision‑making, I respectfully request that the
Planning Commission and staff take the following actions:
Post the full administrative record for Agenda Items (staff report, all attachments, and all submitted public
comments) directly adjacent to the agenda item on the meeting webpage in both HTML and searchable PDF
formats within 24 hours of the original notice of public hearing and maintain link integrity for the life of the
entitlement.
Provide explicit notice content for all future project notices as described above, including the expected approval
process and anticipated number of public hearings/meetings.
Extend the public review period for the Orchards Development Project technical materials by at least 60 days from
the date the full administrative record is posted to allow meaningful public review, given the volume of materials
and concurrent City projects.
Defer any final discretionary approvals until the requested downtown programmatic fiscal analysis, absorption
schedule, and sensitivity testing are completed, publicly released, and subject to public comment (suggested
timeline: programmatic fiscal analysis draft within 90 days, final within 120 days).
Confirm the operative regulatory baseline for CEQA tiering and, prepare supplemental environmental analysis that
accounts for post‑certification changes to the regulatory baseline (including Ordinances 529 and 534), new
additional development project details and planning “frameworks” or documents (including the Update Climate
Action Plan and CEQA GHG Thresholds and Guidance Report) that are now available that have been initiated by
the City itself, the updated and still evolving entitlement processes and subsequent development project permit
revisions, and an updated cumulative impact analysis to account for the changes in the regulatory baseline and the
new additional updated information.
Improve notice practices so that project‑specific hearing notices are included in subject lines and distributed with
sufficient lead time to allow meaningful public participation.
Provide written confirmation on the record that this comment and the requested remedies will be posted adjacent
to the agenda item and that staff will provide a timeline for the requested analyses.
Conclusion
The Orchards Development Project is a significant and dramatic proposed transformation of the City's downtown. It
represents a "shape, intensity, and activity-shift" from a major corporation's headquarters office complex to
primarily residential, with only 230 single-family homes, 138 attached multi-family townhomes, and 58 accessory dwelling
units (ADUs), currently being proposed in the vesting tentative map. The public deserves a transparent, accessible, and
deliberative process that fully accounts for cumulative impacts, fiscal consequences, and the updated regulatory
baseline. I strongly urge the Commission to require the analyses and procedural corrections above before taking any
further discretionary action.
Respectfully submitted,
Brian C. Swanson, AICP
San Ramon Voter, Taxpayer, and Resident
On Fri, Dec 12, 2025 at 4:43 PM City of San Ramon <casramon@service.govdelivery.com> wrote:
The Planning Commission meeting will begin at 6:00 p.m. on Tuesday, December 16, 2025.
The meeting agenda is now available.
2/2/26, 12:55 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.2 - Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project (MJ 2024-0004, DP 2024-0006, DP 202…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r-5611839686648265784&simpl=msg-a:r-561183968664826…4/5
Update your subscriptions, modify your password or email address, or stop subscriptions at any time on
your Subscriber Preferences Page. You will need to use your email address to log in.
If you have questions or problems with the subscription service, please contact webmanager@sanramon.ca.gov or visit
subscriberhelp.govdelivery.com.
This service includes a Public Alert System for San Ramon. Subscribers will receive real-time Public Safety and
Emergency Alerts both via email and wirelessly. In order to receive these time-sensitive emergency notifications,
you MUST subscribe to the service. To subscribe, please click here. For wireless alerts, text message and data rates
may apply. This service is provided to you at no charge by City of San Ramon.
City of San Ramon | 7000 Bollinger Canyon Road, San Ramon, CA 94583 | (925) 973-2500 | www.sanramon.ca.gov
2/2/26, 12:55 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.2 - Public Hearing: Orchards Development Project (MJ 2024-0004, DP 2024-0006, DP 202…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r-5611839686648265784&simpl=msg-a:r-561183968664826…5/5
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Exhibit 7
Appellant’s prior public comments on the City’s
appeal fee structure - January 31, 2026
(for context regarding appeal process concerns).
But the timing is only one part of the problem. The agenda suffers from multiple Brown Act
deficiencies.
1. The agenda fails to identify what fees are being discussed.
The description—“Continued Discussion of the City’s Appeal Fee Structure”—does not
inform the public that the City intends to discuss:
· Planning Division appeals.
· Appeals of development applications.
· Appeals of discretionary land‑use decisions.
· CEQA‑related appeals.
· Zoning Administrator appeals.
· Development Agreement appeals.
A member of the public reading this agenda would have no way to know that the City is
revisiting the same controversial Planning Division appeal fees debated on
April 22, 2025 and November 25, 2025.
2. The agenda provides no staff report, no background, and no reference to prior
Council actions.
A “continued discussion” cannot be lawfully noticed without identifying:
· What discussion is being continued.
· What materials were previously considered.
· What direction the Council previously gave.
· What the public should expect to be discussed now.
The agenda provides none of this.
There is no mention of:
· The April 22, 2025 Master Fee Schedule hearing.
· The November 25, 2025 appeal fee discussion.
· The Matrix Consulting Group materials.
· The extensive public comments submitted.
· The concerns raised about methodology, equity, or developer influence.
This omission deprives the public of essential context and frustrates the purpose of the
Brown Act.
3. The description is materially narrower than the scope of the discussion.
The Brown Act requires that the agenda description be sufficiently clear to allow the
public to determine whether to participate. Here, the description conceals the actual
subject matter.
4. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) contradiction compounds the notice
failure.
2/9/26, 12:22 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 2.1: Continued Discussion of the City's Appeal Fee Structure and Agenda Item 2.2: Develop…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r7081846805226159900&simpl=msg-a:r7081846805226159…2/9
The agenda states that ADA accommodation requests must be made 48 hours in
advance, yet the City provided less than 48 hours’ notice of the meeting.
The agenda also repeats the City’s standard aspirational statement:
“The City of San Ramon celebrates the diversity of our community, and we strive to be a
welcoming and open community for all.”
This rhetoric is reckless and harmful when placed on an agenda that provides less than
48 hours’ notice while simultaneously requiring that ADA accommodation requests be
submitted at least 48 hours in advance. A City cannot claim to be “welcoming and open
to all” while structuring its meetings in a way that makes it humanly impossible for
residents with disabilities to request accommodations in time to participate.
A meeting that is inadequately noticed, inadequately described, and inaccessible to
residents requiring ADA accommodations cannot be considered compliant with the
Brown Act’s requirement that meetings be “open and public.”
Agenda Item 2.1 — Continued Discussion of the City’s Appeal Fee Structure
The City’s appeal fee structure remains:
· Astronomically high.
· Cost‑prohibitive.
· Opaque.
· Selectively justified.
· Procedurally vulnerable.
These deficiencies were documented extensively in my April 22, 2025 and November 25, 2025
public comments, which I am attaching to this comment for the administrative record.
A. Methodological Failures and Withheld Information
The City continues to rely on selective excerpts from the Matrix Consulting Group study
while withholding:
· The full report.
· Raw data.
· Spreadsheets.
· Allocation assumptions.
· Comparable selection criteria.
· Staff‑time calculations.
Without this information, the fee is not legally defensible.
B. Comparative Analysis Shows San Ramon Is an Outlier
· Danville charges approximately $311 for a similar appeal.
· Pleasanton uses a dual‑rate system, charging developers more and residents less.
· Citizens Against Marketplace Apartment Development (CAMPAD) paid $2,500 in
2023—already excessive—and the City has since increased the fee by another
$2,000 without justification.
2/9/26, 12:22 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 2.1: Continued Discussion of the City's Appeal Fee Structure and Agenda Item 2.2: Develop…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r7081846805226159900&simpl=msg-a:r7081846805226159…3/9
San Ramon’s fees are not competitive, not equitable, and not grounded in transparent
analysis.
C. Developer Influence and Structural Bias
My November 25 comment documented the pervasive influence of
Sunset Development Company (Sunset):
· Sunset functions as de facto staff. Even documented making direct changes and
edits to Zoning Ordinances being amended without any documented staff approval
and included in Agenda Item Staff Reports.
· Sunset functions as de facto Planning Commission.
· Sunset functions as de facto City Council.
· Appeal fees function as a financial moat protecting Sunset’s projects.
These concerns remain unaddressed and continue to undermine public trust.
D. Delay Is Not Neutral — It Is Harmful
Deferring fee reform until the FY 26/27 Master Fee Schedule:
· Protects ongoing approvals from scrutiny.
· Preserves Sunset’s advantage.
· Reduces the public’s ability to challenge decisions.
· Magnifies fiscal and civic risk.
Delay is not administrative convenience—it is procedural harm.
E. The Mayor’s November 25, 2025 Remarks Demonstrate the Appeal Process Is
Politically Driven and Functionally Futile
The City’s own record confirms that the appeal process is not designed to provide
meaningful relief. During the November 25, 2025 City Council discussion on appeal
fees, the Mayor stated—beginning at approximately 3:25:37 of the meeting video—that:
“If a resident cannot obtain a councilmember to bring an issue forward, then probably
the odds of a successful appeal are not going to be great anyway.”
This statement is extraordinary. It reveals that:
· The City’s appeal process is politically contingent.
· Success depends not on the merits of the appeal but on whether a resident
can secure political sponsorship.
· The City does not expect appeals to succeed without prior political
alignment.
· The high appeal fees operate within a system that is already structurally
stacked against residents.
When the presiding officer of the City Council openly states that appeals are unlikely to
succeed unless a councilmember is already aligned with the appellant, the City has
effectively admitted that:
2/9/26, 12:22 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 2.1: Continued Discussion of the City's Appeal Fee Structure and Agenda Item 2.2: Develop…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r7081846805226159900&simpl=msg-a:r7081846805226159…4/9
· The appeal process is not impartial.
· The appeal process is not independent.
· The appeal process is not merit‑based.
· The appeal process is not a meaningful check on staff or commission
decisions.
Combined with the City’s astronomically high fees, this creates a system that is:
· Politically driven.
· Economically prohibitive.
· Functionally incapable of providing meaningful relief.
A fee cannot be defended as “cost recovery” for a process that the City’s own Mayor
has publicly characterized as largely futile unless a resident already has political
support. This is not a legitimate appeal system—it is a barrier to due process.
Required Structural Reforms to Any New Appeal Fee Framework
Any new or revised appeal fee structure must include the following.
1. A clear, plain‑language explanation of the detailed appeal process.
This explanation must appear:
· In the Municipal Code/Zoning Ordinance.
· On the City’s website.
· On the appeal instructions or forms themselves.
Residents must be able to understand:
· What is appealable.
· How to file an appeal.
· What materials are required.
· What standards apply.
· What the timeline is.
2. Break down appeal fees by specific planning and zoning action.
“Planning Division appeals for development applications” is far too broad. The City must
establish separate fees for:
· CEQA determinations.
· Development Agreements.
· Zoning Administrator decisions.
· Design Review decisions.
· Use Permit decisions.
· Subdivision decisions.
· General Plan consistency determinations.
· Specific Plan amendments.
· Variances.
· Planned Development modifications.
2/9/26, 12:22 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 2.1: Continued Discussion of the City's Appeal Fee Structure and Agenda Item 2.2: Develop…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r7081846805226159900&simpl=msg-a:r7081846805226159…5/9
· Tree removal decisions.
· Historic resource determinations.
Each category requires its own cost‑basis analysis.
“Planning Division appeals for development applications” is far too broad. The City must
establish separate fees for:
· CEQA determinations.
· Development Agreements.
· Zoning Administrator decisions.
· Design Review decisions.
· Use Permit decisions.
· Subdivision decisions.
· General Plan consistency determinations.
· Specific Plan amendments.
· Variances.
· Planned Development modifications.
· Tree removal decisions.
· Historic resource determinations.
Each category requires its own cost‑basis analysis.
3. Publish the cost basis for each category.
For each appeal type, the City must publish:
· The staff positions involved.
· The number of hours allocated.
· The hourly rates used.
· The overhead assumptions.
· The legal review assumptions.
· The total cost basis.
4. Provide examples and scenarios.
To ensure accessibility and transparency, the City must provide:
· Examples of appealable actions.
· Examples of non‑appealable actions.
· Sample timelines.
· Sample appeal statements.
5. Ensure the appeal process is not a barrier to due process.
A fee structure that is unclear, unsupported, or inaccessible is a barrier to due process
and exposes the City to legal challenge.
Agenda Item 2.2 — Development of Goals for Fiscal Year 2026/2027
2/9/26, 12:22 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 2.1: Continued Discussion of the City's Appeal Fee Structure and Agenda Item 2.2: Develop…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r7081846805226159900&simpl=msg-a:r7081846805226159…6/9
The agenda description for Agenda Item 2.2 does not even identify who is developing the goals for
Fiscal Year 2026/2027. The item is not attributed to the City Council, the City Manager, or any
department. This omission is not a clerical oversight — it is consistent with the City’s long-standing
pattern of avoiding clear responsibility for policy direction, management, and operational priorities.
When the City chooses to discuss “Citywide goals” without identifying:
· who is proposing them,
· who is responsible for drafting them,
· who is accountable for implementing them, and
· who will be evaluated against them,
the result is a goal setting process with no ownership, no accountability, and no transparency.
This is especially troubling because Citywide goals are, by definition, policy direction. They shape:
· budget priorities,
· staffing allocations,
· operational focus,
· service delivery,
· and the City’s long term strategic posture.
Yet the agenda frames this as a generic “development of goals” exercise, detached from the
governing body that is legally and ethically responsible for setting policy.
This lack of attribution:
· obscures who is driving the process.
· shields the City Council from accountability for the goals that will ultimately guide City
operations.
· allows staff to shape policy direction without transparent Council deliberation.
· prevents the public from understanding who to hold responsible for outcomes.
A credible goal setting process requires:
· clear authorship,
· clear responsibility,
· clear accountability, and
· clear public visibility into who is making decisions.
Instead, the City has presented a goal setting item with no identified sponsor, no staff report, no
background, no proposed goals, and no indication of how public input will be incorporated.
A goal-setting process that begins with inadequate notice, anonymity and ends with no
accountability cannot credibly claim to reflect community priorities or lawful governance.
Conclusion
The City’s decision to provide only 24 hours’ notice, with no staff report, no background, no
reference to prior actions, and an agenda description that conceals the actual subject matter, is
unacceptable and in direct contradiction to the City’s often repeated but always hollow mission and
values. The contradictions between the City’s rhetoric and its accessibility practices must be
addressed immediately.
2/9/26, 12:22 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 2.1: Continued Discussion of the City's Appeal Fee Structure and Agenda Item 2.2: Develop…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r7081846805226159900&simpl=msg-a:r7081846805226159…7/9
The public deserves a transparent, accountable, and inclusive process, not last minute meetings
that limit participation and undermine trust.
Respectfully submitted,
Brian C. Swanson, AICP
San Ramon Voter, Taxpayer, and Resident
On Thu, Jan 29, 2026 at 5:59 PM City of San Ramon <casramon@service.govdelivery.com> wrote:
The City Council will hold a Special Workshop at 9:00 a.m. on Saturday, January 31, 2026.
The agenda is now available at, https://cityofsanramon.info/4kbpSqq
HOW TO VIEW OR PARTICIAPTE IN THE MEETING;
The public is invited to participate in the meeting using any of the following methods:
IN PERSON
Members of the public can provide in person comments at the meeting. To make a request for disability related
accommodation to participate in the meeting, please contact the City Clerk’s Office 48 hours in advance of the meeting.
WRITTEN COMMUNICATION BY EMAIL
Public comments may be submitted via e mail to cityclerk@sanramon.ca.gov. Any public comments received up until
two (2) hours prior to the scheduled start time of the meeting will be distributed to the City Council via e mail, provided
at the meeting in the red binder, and posted online at www.sanramon.ca.gov/public_comment.
Written comments received after the cut off time will be provided to the City Council the day following the meeting.
Please include “Public Comment” in the subject line. In the body of the email please include your name and the item you
wish to comment on. Written public comment will not be read aloud during the meeting.
ATTENDEE CONDUCT
There will be zero tolerance for any person addressing the Council making profane, offensive and disruptive remarks, or
engaging in loud, boisterous, or other disorderly conduct, that disrupts the orderly conduct of the public meeting.
Specifically, it is important for all speakers to adhere to the following guidelines for participation in this meeting:
No profanity or obscenity.
Refrain from personal threats or attacks.
Refrain from hateful epithets and demeaning language based on any person’s race, religion, sexual orientation,
ethnicity, gender, or disability.
Respect all people that are present or watching.
At the discretion of the Mayor, a speaker may forfeit speaking time for any of the following reasons:
Exceeding the allotted time to speak;
2/9/26, 12:22 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 2.1: Continued Discussion of the City's Appeal Fee Structure and Agenda Item 2.2: Develop…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r7081846805226159900&simpl=msg-a:r7081846805226159…8/9
Yelling, screaming, or other behavior that renders this Council unable to continue the meeting;
Excessive profanity or slander;
Specific threats or “fighting words” that incite violence; or
Speech that is outside the subject matter jurisdiction of the Council or the specific agenda item in which you are
speaking.
While the City of San Ramon ensures the First Amendment rights of its citizens, we do not accept nor
endorse any offensive or hateful comments made during our meetings. The City of San Ramon
celebrates the diversity of our community, and we strive to be a welcoming and open community for
all.
H
Update your subscriptions, modify your password or email address, or stop subscriptions at any time on
your Subscriber Preferences Page. You will need to use your email address to log in.
If you have questions or problems with the subscription service, please contact webmanager@sanramon.ca.gov or visit
subscriberhelp.govdelivery.com.
This service includes a Public Alert System for San Ramon. Subscribers will receive real-time Public Safety and
Emergency Alerts both via email and wirelessly. In order to receive these time-sensitive emergency notifications,
you MUST subscribe to the service. To subscribe, please click here. For wireless alerts, text message and data rates
may apply. This service is provided to you at no charge by City of San Ramon.
City of San Ramon | 7000 Bollinger Canyon Road, San Ramon, CA 94583 | (925) 973 2500 | www sanramon ca gov
2 attachments
04.22.2025 - BSwanson_PublicComment_AgendaItem8.1–AdoptingtheMasterFeeSchedulefo
rVariousMunicipalServicesforFYear2025_26-City Council Meeting.pdf
366K
11.25.2025 - BSwanson_PublicComment_ AgendaItem9.2-DiscussionoftheCity’sAppealFeeStructure-
CityCouncilMeeting.pdf
468K
2/9/26, 12:22 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 2.1: Continued Discussion of the City's Appeal Fee Structure and Agenda Item 2.2: Develop…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-a:r7081846805226159900&simpl=msg-a:r7081846805226159…9/9
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Exhibit 8
Appellant’s prior public comments on the City’s
appeal fee structure - November 25, 2025
(for context regarding appeal process concerns).
Selective extraction from Matrix. Staff has presented only the slices of the Matrix study
that support higher fees while withholding the full report, raw data, and spreadsheets that
would reveal allocation choices and assumptions.
Methodology hidden. Comparable selection criteria, cost allocation assumptions, and the
exact spreadsheets used to calculate proposed fees are not disclosed. This opacity prevents
independent verification and invites the reasonable conclusion that numbers were
engineered to justify a predetermined policy that benefits Sunset.
Context stripped away. The report fails to show how San Ramon’s market structure,
planning staff capacity, or developer concentration compares to the jurisdictions used as
comparables. Without that context, benchmarking is meaningless. Fremont’s development
is incredibly diverse. Its revenue position and budget are in significantly better shape than
San Ramon’s and it has a substantial and rather capable planning staff.
Equity and ethics omitted. There is no analysis of how high fees disproportionately burden
individual residents and community groups while leaving well‑capitalized developers like
Sunset effectively unimpeded. Consideration of the equity and fairness discussion in
American Institute of Certified Planners (AICP) Code of Ethics and Professional Standards is
entirely absent.
Timing used as a shield. The staff timeline — “provide direction to staff” and defer fee
schedule work to the development of the FY 26–27 Master Fee Schedule — functions as a
delaying tactic that protects ongoing approvals from immediate scrutiny and preserves
Sunset’s momentum.
Delay is unacceptable and dangerous
Sunset is moving at break‑neck speed. Discretionary approvals for downtown
redevelopment are proceeding rapidly. Postponing fee reform until spring approval of the
Fiscal Year 26/27 Master Fee Schedule preserves the financial chokehold on appeals while
major approvals continue. That delay is not neutral; it materially reduces the public’s ability
to challenge decisions being finalized now.
Delay entrenches developer advantage. High appeal fees already operate as a barrier to
accountability. Waiting months to study and possibly change fees entrenches Sunset’s
advantage and signals that public oversight can be deferred indefinitely.
Delay magnifies fiscal and civic risk. Rapid approvals without independent fiscal scrutiny,
combined with punitive appeal fees, shift long‑term infrastructure and maintenance liabilities
onto residents while insulating Sunset and other well‑funded actors from meaningful
challenges.
Delay undermines trust. Promising a future study without immediate corrective steps looks
like procedural theater designed to deflect criticism, not to fix the problem.
Sunset’s role is central and pervasive
Sunset as de facto City staff. Sunset is performing management and operational functions
that should be the City’s responsibility, reducing the City’s independent technical capacity and
institutional judgment.
Sunset as de facto Planning Commission. Sunset’s projects and preferred urban form are
dictating San Ramon’s existing, current, and future planning outcomes. When a single
private actor controls the downtown land base, planning becomes developer‑driven rather
than community‑driven.
Sunset as de facto City Council. Policy choices—like fee structures and streamlined
discretionary processes (removal of most all practical safeguards to minimize political
1/30/26, 12:10 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.2 - Discussion of the City’s Appeal Fee Structure - City Council Meeting - November 25, 2…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r7810245845768596090%7Cmsg-a:r-324946910123521848…2/5
influence and maintain numerous public involvement opportunities as has been done with the
removal of most all references to Measure G in the San Ramon Zoning Ordinance)—are
being shaped to protect Sunset’s bottom line, even when those choices saddle the City with
long‑term fiscal liabilities from housing that is a known loss leader for host cities.
Fees as Sunset’s protective shield. The practical effect of astronomically high appeal fees
is to make it prohibitively expensive for neighbors, community groups, and independent
reviewers to challenge approvals that reshape neighborhoods and the City’s fiscal future.
Required actions and remedies — immediate and nonnegotiable
1.Publish the full Matrix study and all supporting spreadsheets now. Release the
complete Matrix Consulting Group User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Plan, including raw
data, comparable lists, allocation methodologies, and the exact spreadsheets used to
calculate proposed fees. The public must be able to verify staff’s claims.
2.Implement an immediate temporary reduction or waiver of appeal fees for resident and
community group appeals pending completion of an independent comparative and equity
study. A temporary waiver is the only credible interim remedy to preserve public access while
the study proceeds.
3.Commission an independent, transparent study immediately. The study must be publicly
scoped and must include national and regional benchmarking, contextual metrics (population,
land area, planning staff size, development activity), an equity analysis, and an explicit review
of developer concentration and conflicts of interest—with Sunset’s dominant role as a central
focus. Publish the scope, comparables list, data sources, and timeline of the new
independent study as soon as possible.
4.Require heightened procedural safeguards for projects by Sunset. For any
discretionary approvals involving Sunset, require extended public notice, an extended appeal
window, mandatory independent fiscal impact review, and additional public hearings before
final discretionary approvals proceed.
5.Adopt an interim tiered fee policy. Fees must scale by project size, applicant type, and
demonstrated ability to pay so that individual residents and community groups are not priced
out of appeals. This interim policy must be implemented immediately and remain in effect
until the independent study is complete.
6.Restore full transparency practices. All future staff reports that rely on consultant studies
must include the full consultant report, raw data, and spreadsheets as attachments and must
explicitly identify assumptions, alternatives considered, and the rationale for comparable
selection.
7.Initiate a Sunset influence review. Commission an independent review that documents
Sunset’s landholding concentration, the pace of its approvals, and the ways in which City
processes and fee structures have served to entrench and accommodate Sunset dominant
outsized influence in San Ramon. The review must recommend structural reforms to restore
independent City oversight.
Accountability now, not later
“Provide direction to staff” and a promise to revisit fees to the approval of the FY 26/27 Master Fee
Schedule is not an adequate response to a structural problem that is actively reshaping our
downtown and civic life in San Ramon. When staff hides the full Matrix analysis and presents a
narrow, engineered narrative, the public cannot meaningfully evaluate tradeoffs or hold decision
makers accountable. If the Councilmembers truly value public participation, fiscal prudence, and
ethical governance, it will act tonight to:
demand full disclosure of the Matrix study and underlying data,
1/30/26, 12:10 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.2 - Discussion of the City’s Appeal Fee Structure - City Council Meeting - November 25, 2…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r7810245845768596090%7Cmsg-a:r-324946910123521848…3/5
remove the immediate financial chokehold on appeals with a temporary reduction or
waiver, and
commission an independent, transparent study now with Sunset’s dominant role as a
central focus.
Delay is complascense. Allowing Sunset and a complicit process to dictate San Ramon’s current
and future quality of life without immediate corrective action is unacceptable.
This is serious,
Brian Swanson, AICP
San Ramon resident and taxpayer
On Fri, Nov 21, 2025 at 5:01 PM City of San Ramon <casramon@service.govdelivery.com> wrote:
The City Council meeting will begin at 7:00 p.m. on Tuesday, November 25, 2025.
The meeting agenda is now available at, https://cityofsanramon.info/4poSXjo
HOW TO VIEW OR PARTICIPATE IN THE MEETING:
The public is invited to participate in the meeting using any of the following methods:
IN-PERSON
Members of the public can provide in person comments at the meeting. To make a request for disability related
accommodation to participate
in the meeting, please contact the City Clerk’s Office 48 hours in advance of the meeting.
WRITTEN COMMUNICATION BY EMAIL
Public comments may be submitted via e-mail to cityclerk@sanramon.ca.gov. Any public comments received up until
two (2) hours prior to the scheduled start time of the meeting will be distributed to the City Council via e mail, provided
at the meeting in the red binder, and posted online at https://www.sanramon.ca.gov/public_comment.
Written comments received after the cut-off time will be provided to the City Council the day following the meeting.
Please include “Public Comment” in the subject line. In the body of the email please include your name and the item you
wish to comment on. Written public comment will not be read aloud during the meeting.
TO VIEW OR LISTEN ONLY
As a courtesy and technology permitting, the public will have the opportunity to view the meeting via one way feed by
the options below. However, the City cannot guarantee that the public’s remote access to any meeting will be
uninterrupted, and technical difficulties may occur from time to time. In those instances, so long as the public may still
attend the meeting in person, the meeting will continue. Members of the public desiring to provide comments as a part
of the meeting are encouraged to either submit written comments prior to the meeting or to attend the meeting in
person.
Zoom: https://cityofsanramon.zoom.us/j/91382842015
Webinar ID: 913 8284 2015
1/30/26, 12:10 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.2 - Discussion of the City’s Appeal Fee Structure - City Council Meeting - November 25, 2…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r7810245845768596090%7Cmsg-a:r-324946910123521848…4/5
Zoom Phone Numbers: +1 (669) 900 6833
The City’s YouTube Channel: sanramon.ca.gov/YouTube
Update your subscriptions, modify your password or email address, or stop subscriptions at any time on
your Subscriber Preferences Page. You will need to use your email address to log in.
If you have questions or problems with the subscription service, please contact webmanager@sanramon.ca.gov or visit
subscriberhelp.govdelivery.com.
This service includes a Public Alert System for San Ramon. Subscribers will receive real-time Public Safety and
Emergency Alerts both via email and wirelessly. In order to receive these time-sensitive emergency notifications,
you MUST subscribe to the service. To subscribe, please click here. For wireless alerts, text message and data rates
may apply. This service is provided to you at no charge by City of San Ramon.
City of San Ramon | 7000 Bollinger Canyon Road, San Ramon, CA 94583 | (925) 973-2500 | www.sanramon.ca.gov
1/30/26, 12:10 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item 9.2 - Discussion of the City’s Appeal Fee Structure - City Council Meeting - November 25, 2…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r7810245845768596090%7Cmsg-a:r-324946910123521848…5/5
Orchards Development Project Appeal Brian C. Swanson, AICP
Exhibit 9
Appellant’s prior public comments on the City’s
appeal fee structure - April 22, 2025
(for context regarding appeal process concerns).
Brian Swanson <briancswanson@gmail.com>
Public Comment: Agenda Item #8.1 – Adopting the Master Fee Schedule for Various
Municipal Services for Fiscal Year 2025/26 - City Council Meeting - April 22, 2025
1 message
Brian Swanson <briancswanson@gmail.com>Tue, Apr 22, 2025 at 12:34 PM
To: Clerk City <CityClerk@sanramon.ca.gov>
Cc: Council City <CityCouncil@sanramon.ca.gov>, planningcommission <PlanningCommission@sanramon.ca.gov>,
"candace.andersen@bos.cccounty.us" <candace.andersen@bos.cccounty.us>, "jen.quallick@bos.cccounty.us"
<jen.quallick@bos.cccounty.us>, senator.grayson@senate.ca.gov, michael.sponsler@sen.ca.gov, assemblymember.bauer-
kahan@assembly.ca.gov, michelle.henry@asm.ca.gov, DeSaulnier Congressman Mark
<Congressman.DeSaulnier@mail.house.gov>, sarah.jackson@mail.house.gov, janessa.oriol@mail.house.gov,
abrownstevens@greenbelt.org
Dear Mayor and City Council Members:
I am writing to express my strong objections to Agenda Item #8.1: Resolution No. 2025-036 - Adopting the Master Fee
Schedule for Various Municipal Services for Fiscal Year 2025/26, and Repealing Resolution No. 2024-051.
These comments must be visible, easily found, and accessible (limiting the number of "clicks" to access) to all interested
parties and the public in perpetuity in HTML (link integrity and functionality must be judiciously maintained, kept current,
and/or updated, as needed) and PDF format. They must exist in concert (or compiled together) with other meeting
materials, not compartmentalized separately, causing fragmentation in the importance of public comments made during
any City meeting.
The dramatic fee increases and the methodology behind setting these fees are flat-out wrong and lack meaningful effort.
As currently structured, they favor developers at the expense of resident taxpayers. Resident taxpayers already shoulder
a disproportionate load in providing revenue to the City. This overwhelming burden has only increased as of April 1, 2025,
with the additional tax paid by residents and visitors within the City due to the passage of Measure N. City Council must
reduce the disparity between fees charged to developers and resident taxpayers.
Appeal Fee Concerns and Comparative Analysis: In 2023, Citizens Against the Market Place Apt/Condo Development
(CAMPAD) paid $2,500 to file an appeal regarding the Planning Commission's improper approval of a condo project. The
proposed Master Fee Schedule now represents a $2,000 increase over that fee, with no accompanying research or sound
analysis to justify such a steep hike. When one considers that the Town of Danville charges merely about $311 for a
similar appeal and that Pleasanton utilizes a dual-rate system—charging developers a higher fee while offering a
dramatically lower fee for citizen appeals—it becomes abundantly clear that San Ramon's proposed fees are not
competitive in terms of fairness. The Council must first differentiate the fee structure based on whether an
applicant/developer or a citizen initiates an appeal. Moreover, the fee for any change based directly or loosely on
development, planning, and zoning should be scaled relative to how long the current regulation has been in effect. The
older and more established the current planning and zoning framework, the lower the fee should be, rewarding stability,
while recent, developer-led changes should incur a higher fee to discourage disruptive modifications.
Traffic Impact Mitigation and Local Construction Cost Realities: Additionally, I am deeply troubled by the
methodology used to determine the twenty-eight Public Works Traffic Impact Mitigation Fees, which rely on the San
Francisco Bay Area Construction Cost Index (CCI) for 2024, currently showing a decrease of 0.7%. Anyone familiar with
the current construction markets can attest that our region's transportation inflation, especially for city-level streets, has
exceeded 10% annually in recent years. Relying solely on a negative adjustment based on a metric more suited to
highway projects (where economies of scale often drive costs down) is wholly inappropriate for urban street paving. While
Caltrans may provide a reliable index for major highways, it fails to capture the realities of local, city-level construction
costs. For example, the Metropolitan Transportation Commission's StreetSaver tool offers more accurate local data, yet it
appears underutilized here. The result is a fee calculation that underestimates the burden on public infrastructure and
indirectly subsidizes developer interests through artificially low fees.
Influence of Developer/Construction Lobby and Internal Bias: It is particularly disconcerting that this fee structure is
being influenced so strongly by developer and construction industry interests. With the City Manager and some staff
1/30/26, 12:14 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item #8.1 – Adopting the Master Fee Schedule for Various Municipal Services for Fiscal Year 20…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r7795854101226216473%7Cmsg-a:r733066035388042544…1/3
members steeped in this industry, a clear and present bias skews the fee schedule to be pro-developer and anti-resident.
Even if citizen voting were to bring about change in the Council, such staff influences could still perpetuate unfavorable
outcomes. The current approach—favoring a one-size-fits-all increase based solely on CPI and an anomalous CCI drop—
fails to account for the local economic realities and places an undue financial burden on ordinary taxpayers while reducing
costs for developers.
Conclusion and Recommendations: The City Council must reconsider and significantly revise Resolution No. 2025-
036. At a minimum, a new fee schedule must:
Differentiation by Initiator: Establish a two-tier appeal fee system—one for citizen-led appeals and a significantly
higher fee for developer or applicant-initiated appeals.
Sliding Scale Based on Plan Tenure: Incorporate a sliding scale that reduces fees for changes to the General
Plan designation and Zoning Ordinances when the current rules have been in effect for longer.
Utilization of Accurate Local Data: Replace the current reliance on the negative CCI adjustment with a locally
applicable, well-researched construction cost index—one that may include data from tools like StreetSaver—to
capture the real-world inflation impacting city streets accurately. The City should have its own experience to rely
on, providing more cost-relevant information. The City tries to implement a Capital Development Program
continuously.
Greater Transparency and Accountability: Ensure that the fee-setting process remains independent of
developer/construction lobbying pressures so that the interests of resident taxpayers are not compromised.
Using outdated or generalized metrics—and ignoring proven examples such as Danville's minimal fee and Pleasanton's
tiered fee approach—fails to recognize local cost realities and perpetuates a system that burdens taxpayers while
privileging developers.
The City Council must take these recommendations seriously to safeguard fiscal fairness and community stability.
I also recommend that the upcoming budget workshops include a detailed explanation, illustration, and diagram of how
these proposed fees, even though they need massive revision, help fund the City's budget and detail the exact linkage
rather than only discussing rolled-up numbers that provide no practical meaning. Unfortunately, despite lip service from
the new finance director during meetings and workshops, community views regarding this year's City budget have only
been explicitly solicited via email this morning.
Thank you for considering responsible good governance and a real-world perspective.
Sincerely,
Brian Swanson, AICP
San Ramon, California
On Fri, Apr 18, 2025 at 4:51 PM City of San Ramon <casramon@service.govdelivery.com> wrote:
The City Council meeting will begin at 7:00 p.m. on Tuesday, April 22, 2025.
The meeting agenda is now available at, https://cityofsanramon.info/3EuIxwT
HOW TO VIEW OR PARTICIPATE IN THE MEETING:
The public is invited to participate in the meeting using any of the following methods:
IN-PERSON
1/30/26, 12:14 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item #8.1 – Adopting the Master Fee Schedule for Various Municipal Services for Fiscal Year 20…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r7795854101226216473%7Cmsg-a:r733066035388042544…2/3
Members of the public can provide in-person comments at the meeting. To make a request for disability-related
accommodation to participate
in the meeting, please contact the City Clerk’s Office 48 hours in advance of the meeting.
WRITTEN COMMUNICATION BY EMAIL
Public comment may be submitted via e-mail to cityclerk@sanramon.ca.gov. Public comment received until two (2)
hours prior to the
scheduled start time of the meeting will be distributed to the City Council via e-mail, provided at the meeting in the red
binder, and posted
online at https://www.sanramon.ca.gov/public_comment.
Written comments received after the cut-off time will be provided to the City Council the day following the meeting.
Please include “Public Comment” in the subject line. In the body of the email please include your name and the item you
wish to comment
on. Written public comment will not be read aloud during the meeting.
TO VIEW OR LISTEN ONLY
As a courtesy and technology permitting, the public will have the opportunity to view the meeting via one-way feed by
the options below.
However, the City cannot guarantee that the public’s remote access to any meeting will be uninterrupted, and technical
difficulties may occur
from time to time. In those instances, so long as the public may still attend the meeting in person, the meeting will
continue. Members of the
public desiring to provide comments as a part of the meeting are encouraged to either submit written comments prior to
the meeting or to
attend the meeting in person.
Zoom: https://cityofsanramon.zoom.us/j/94160555566
Webinar ID: 941 6055 5566
Zoom Phone Numbers: +1 (669) 900-6833
The City’s YouTube Channel: sanramon.ca.gov/YouTube
Regular City Council meetings are broadcast on Contra Costa Television (CCTV) (Channel 27) on Wednesdays at 7:00 p.m.
and Thursdays at
1:00 p.m. immediately following the meeting. Regular City Council meetings are also broadcast on AT&T U-Verse
(Channel 99).
Update your subscriptions, modify your password or email address, or stop subscriptions at any time on
your Subscriber Preferences Page. You will need to use your email address to log in.
If you have questions or problems with the subscription service, please contact webmanager@sanramon.ca.gov or visit
subscriberhelp.govdelivery.com.
This service includes a Public Alert System for San Ramon. Subscribers will receive real-time Public Safety and
Emergency Alerts both via email and wirelessly. In order to receive these time-sensitive emergency notifications,
you MUST subscribe to the service. To subscribe, please click here. For wireless alerts, text message and data rates
may apply. This service is provided to you at no charge by City of San Ramon.
City of San Ramon | 7000 Bollinger Canyon Road, San Ramon, CA 94583 | (925) 973-2500 | www.sanramon.ca.gov
1/30/26, 12:14 PM Gmail - Public Comment: Agenda Item #8.1 – Adopting the Master Fee Schedule for Various Municipal Services for Fiscal Year 20…
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=73ed25eff8&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r7795854101226216473%7Cmsg-a:r733066035388042544…3/3
Exhibit B
How does this fragmentation of public commenters at broadcast or non-broadcast and recorded city meetings track how
their input is or is not influencing the development, management, and operations of the City of San Ramon, especially
regarding infrastructure (transportation and broadband), planning, zoning issues, the shape the City's urban form, and
"look and feel?"
How is this electronic fragmentation ADA-compliant?
The questions above and comments below must be visible, easily found, and accessible (limiting the number of "clicks" to
access) to all interested parties and the public in perpetuity in HTML (link integrity and functionality must be judiciously
maintained, kept current, and/or updated, as needed) and PDF format.
Also, given the enormous amount of detail presented about the Orchards Development Project at the previous and
upcoming ARB meetings, why isn't providing a more detailed agenda for each meeting the respectful and right thing to do
for interested parties? I specifically asked Sunset Development Company (Sunset) representatives at the very end of the
ARB meeting on May 1, 2025, and with a nod of the head in agreement in response, assumed my request for a simple
three- or four-bullet agenda, not dissimilar from what the 2025 Budget Workshop notices have been doing, would be
provided. A bullet point agenda summary is absent at the link for the ARB meeting agenda below.
I expect formal written answers to my comments above, which should also be posted directly adjacent to these questions
and comments and all the City of San Ramon-developed meeting materials.
The following comments formally document some (not all) of my verbal public remarks to date on the Orchards
Development Project agenda item and echo my exasperated sentiment and the downright embarrassment that I have as
a City of San Ramon resident regarding the construction of the Bollinger Canyon Road (BCR) Iron Horse Trail (IHT)
Overcrossing, which was funded primarily by federal and regional funds, and a supposed resident pride inducing City
defining landmark. That BCR was widened unjustifiably in the vicinity of City Hall (which was completely contradictory to
the purpose of the IHT Overcrossing, and therefore both projects have resulted in counterproductive outcomes, making
significant waste of taxpayer funding) before the construction of the IHT Overcrossing because it was on some
grandfathered list, not evaluated for applicability in the current pre-construction context, where widening major highways
or roads is now discouraged mainly due to the well-proven traffic engineering and demand modeling outcome known as
"induced demand."
If highways and major roads are made wider, only more traffic results, translating to less throughput and slower speeds.
Induced demand is now a commonly accepted traffic engineering principle that did not exist when the City of San Ramon
negotiated the use of Dougherty Valley Settlement Agreement Funds for widening BCR and where the City of San Ramon
failed and continues to fail to maintain an active negotiating position regarding Dougherty Valley Settlement funds, a direct
result of the City of San Ramon inability to properly participate in the development review process of Dougherty Valley
from the beginning.
These contradictory and counterproductive outcomes are occurring as the Contra Costa Transportation Authority (CCTA)
and Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) continue to be derelict in asserting their land-use planning authority
and allow the City of San Ramon to proceed with the widening of BCR. The City of San Ramon (with CCTA and MTC
again standing idle) has implemented this same nonsensical, contradictory, and counterproductive carbon copy approach
for the widening of Crow Canyon Road, which is also similarly underway for the Crow Canyon Road IHT Overcrossing.
How the status quo conditions of unsafe, marginal, and uncomfortable active transportation infrastructure (especially
along the south side of Bollinger Canyon Road from I-680 to Alcosta Boulevard and in and around a supposed MTC
Priority Development Area, where Complete Streets policies supposedly exist) are allowed to exist ignorantly, arrogantly,
and perpetually. When, in fact, well-sourced and documented research and repeated real-world outcomes in all types of
jurisdictions and developments document the undeniable evidence that creating walkable environments only adds to the
economic development potential of a district. The unsafe highway comparable vehicle speeds and traffic flow along
Bollinger Canyon Road in the vicinity of City Hall, the Community Center, Central Park, the City Library, and the City
Center, all obvious civic facilities that should have a priority explicit purpose of "creating community," are only expected to
grow as a result of a $2 million grant Community Development Block Grant Program, from the U.S. Department of
Housing and Urban Development, with the California Department of Housing and Community Development
acting as stewards of the federal funding for signal coordination fiber optic cable along Bollinger Canyon Road.
Again, The City of San Ramon (with CCTA and MTC again standing idle) has implemented this same nonsensical,
contradictory, and counterproductive carbon copy approach for the widening of Crow Canyon Road, which is also similarly
underway for the Crow Canyon Road IHT Overcrossing.
All the above adds up to a predictable outcome: many new Orchard development residents will become run over by
vehicles, "flattened pancakes, repeated, and multiple popular NFL coach Gregg Knapp flattened pancakes."
Did the City of San Ramon not learn anything from that horrible, tragic outcome? Does the City of San Ramon need to be
taken to court and easily found guilty, resulting in significant financial award damages and settlement fees paid for those
lessons to sink in?
In most communities, including the San Francisco waterfront and West Oakland, transportation infrastructure, namely the
"Embarcadero Freeway" and I-980, respectively, is viewed as creating enormous social divisions within the community.
So much so in San Francisco, the removal of the "Embarcadero Freeway," which was made less costly by its crumbling
by the Loma Prieta earthquake, the "Embarcadero Freeway" was demolished, and made way for thriving traffic-calmed,
pedestrian and bicycle-friendly alternatives. While the community struggled beforehand in West Oakland, it is even worse
off because I-980 remains, and the community is perpetually socially bifurcated.
In Sunset's case, however, it proposes a significant change to all previous and ongoing development efforts. Sunset now
proposes shifting the development density from the south-north-oriented axis of Camino Ramon (the City of San Ramon's
de facto Main Street) to the west-east-oriented BCR highway to create a new district. This dramatic shift would combine
the Orchards and City Center developments and use Orchards to prop up the struggling City Center again, straddling the
BCR highway.
BCR must be traffic-calmed, not signal-coordinated solely for vehicle traffic priority, to allow for increased
vehicle speeds and traffic flow. BCR must also be safe and human-scaled, redesigned to perform at a level of
safety for district dwellers and visitors, not at an unfathomable high level of service.
The City of San Ramon must not continue implementing wasteful, contradictory, and counterproductive projects that put
human lives at risk. The IHT Overcrossing at Bollinger and Crow Canyon Roads and the Bollinger Canyon Road Fiber
Optic Signal Coordination projects rely primarily on federal funding through various state and regional agencies, with only
a marginal portion of funds provided by the City of San Ramon.
Thank you for considering a responsible real-world perspective—a systems-based approach—and for ensuring
accountable, good governance of the City of San Ramon.
Sincerely,
Brian Swanson, AICP
San Ramon, California
On Fri, May 2, 2025 at 2:33 PM City of San Ramon <casramon@service.govdelivery.com> wrote:
The Architectural Review Board meeting will begin at 2:00 p.m. on Thursday, May 8, 2025.
The meeting agenda is now available here.
Update your subscriptions, modify your password or email address, or stop subscriptions at any time on
your Subscriber Preferences Page. You will need to use your email address to log in.
If you have questions or problems with the subscription service, please contact webmanager@sanramon.ca.gov or visit
subscriberhelp.govdelivery.com.
This service includes a Public Alert System for San Ramon. Subscribers will receive real-time Public Safety and
Emergency Alerts both via email and wirelessly. In order to receive these time-sensitive emergency notifications,
you MUST subscribe to the service. To subscribe, please click here. For wireless alerts, text message and data rates
may apply. This service is provided to you at no charge by City of San Ramon.
City of San Ramon | 7000 Bollinger Canyon Road, San Ramon, CA 94583 | (925) 973 2500 | www sanramon ca gov
From:Lisjan Nation
To:planningcommission
Cc:Lauren Barr
Subject:Agenda Item 8.1: Orchards Development Project
Date:Tuesday, February 3, 2026 2:30:04 PM
***| EXTERNAL EMAIL: Think before you click and do not open attachments unless youknow they are safe. |***
Dear Commissioners,
We are writing because we are concerned that the Orchards Development Project is being
pushed forward without Tribal consultation. It is impossible to determine whether this projecthas the potential to impact Tribal Cultural Resources, and therefore whether it may have a
significant effect on the environment for the purposes of CEQA, without Tribal consultation.
The CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist states, "The 2040 General PlanEIR determined that the effects on archaeological resources are only known once a specific
development has been proposed because the effects are highly dependent on both theindividual development site conditions and the characteristics of the proposed ground-
disturbing activity. Consequently, damage to or destruction of cultural resources could occuras a result of development under the proposed 2040 General Plan. In order to ensure that
development within San Ramon does not have a detrimental effect on archaeologicalresources, each future project would need to be assessed once the project location and design
concept is available."
The same is true of Tribal Cultural Resources; effects on Tribal Cultural Resources are onlyknown once a specific development has been proposed. For this project, a cultural resources
report was carried out to assess whether CEQA exemption was appropriate or whether culturalresources could be impacted. However, the equivalent to this report for Tribal Cultural
Resources -- Tribal consultation -- was not carried out. As a result, this project maysignificantly impact Tribal Cultural Resources and may not be eligible for a CEQA
exemption.
We respectfully request the opportunity to consult on this project and determine whether it hasthe potential to impact any of our Tribal Cultural Resources. We appreciate your
consideration.
'Uni (Respectfully),
Lucy Beyhan, Cultural Resource Manager IIConfederated Villages of Lisjan Nation
Packet Pg. 86
Co
m
m
u
n
i
c
a
t
i
o
n
:
O
r
c
h
a
r
d
s
P
u
b
l
i
c
C
o
m
m
e
n
t
2
(
C
O
N
T
I
N
U
E
D
I
T
E
M
S
-
O
P
E
N
P
U
B
L
I
C
H
E
A
R
I
N
G
)
Exhibit C
Brian Swanson <briancswanson@gmail.com>
RE: Orchards Appeal (April 7, 2026) — Clarification Requested on Agenda Packet
Materials, Staff Report Scope, CEQA/Ethics Framework for Council, and
Fair‑Hearing Guardrails
1 message
Alicia Poon <apoon@sanramon.ca.gov>Fri, Mar 27, 2026 at 2:44 PM
To: Brian Swanson <briancswanson@gmail.com>, Lisa Schlotz <lschlotz@sanramon.ca.gov>
Cc: "City Attorney (public)" <cityattorney@sanramon.ca.gov>, "City Clerk (Public)" <cityclerk@sanramon.ca.gov>
Mr. Swanson,
Thank you for your correspondence on the Orchards appeal.
Please see my responses below in bold red to your questions.
Sincerely,
Alicia
Alicia Poon
Assistant City Attorney | Office of the City Attorney | City of San Ramon
7000 Bollinger Canyon Road | San Ramon, CA 94583
direct: (925) 973-2529 | main: (925) 973-2549 | fax: (925) 275-0650
e-mail: apoon@sanramon.ca.gov
From: Brian Swanson <briancswanson@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, March 26, 2026 12:24 PM
To: Lisa Schlotz <lschlotz@sanramon.ca.gov>
Cc: City Attorney (public) <cityattorney@sanramon.ca.gov>; City Clerk (Public) <cityclerk@sanramon.ca.gov>
Subject: Orchards Appeal (April 7, 2026) — Clarification Requested on Agenda Packet Materials, Staff Report Scope,
CEQA/Ethics Framework for Council, and Fair-Hearing Guardrails
***| EXTERNAL EMAIL: Think before you click and do not open attachments unless you know they are safe. |***
Ms. Schlotz,
Thank you for your March 5, 2026 email, which served as the formal notice of hearing for my appeal and confirmed the
hearing date, time, location, order of proceedings, presenter time limits, and submission deadlines.
I am writing to request written clarification regarding the following instruction in your email: "Agenda Packet Materials:
Any items you wish to include in the official staff report and agenda packet must be emailed to the City Clerk no later than
Exhibit D
Monday, March 30, 2026, by 12:00 p.m." Because this appeal concerns a long‑horizon discretionary approval and the
City's California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) posture, the clarity of the staff report and the integrity of the process
matter as much as the hearing itself. I am also trying to avoid a process in which the appellant is effectively forced to
"train" the hearing body on foundational CEQA and planning ethics concepts under a 15-minute presentation limit. At the
same time, the staff controls the framing of the staff report and the appellate record.
To avoid misunderstandings and to protect fairness and impartiality, please forward this request to the appropriate
departments (Community Development and the City Attorney's Office, as applicable) and provide a written response. I
am comfortable receiving responses from the department(s) responsible for each item, but I request that you remain
copied as the Deputy City Clerk and procedural point of contact.
First, please clarify what it means to "include" items in the "official staff report and agenda packet." Specifically, does the
March 30 deadline mean that appellant submissions will be included in the agenda packet only as full, unedited
attachments (for example, in a clearly labeled "Appellant Submittals" section), or does it mean staff will summarize,
characterize, respond to, or otherwise incorporate appellant materials into the staff report narrative and
recommendation? If staff intends to summarize or characterize any appellant materials in the staff report, please confirm
whether the City will also include those appellant submissions in full and unedited in the agenda packet so the City
Council and the public can verify staff's characterization against the original text, rather than relying on a paraphrase.
Items timely submitted in support of the appeal will be included in their entirety. Submittals exceeding 20 pages
will be linked to the City’s website and made available to the Council along with the staff report. Staff’s
attachments will be similarly linked to the City’s website. The staff report will include your appeal letter as an
attachment, not a link.
Second, please clarify what the City will produce for the appeal hearing as a written work product and what the City
Council will be asked to rely on. Will a staff report be prepared for the appeal hearing, and if so, will it include a staff
recommendation regarding how the Council should rule on the appeal? Will the City Attorney's Office provide any written
legal/analytical memorandum to the Council regarding appeal issues? Will the City prepare draft findings for the Council
(whether affirming, modifying, or reversing) and/or any written "response to appeal grounds" document? If the answer is
that none of these written products are required, that is important for the public record, because the City's procedures and
deposit‑based appeal framework otherwise remain opaque as to what analysis is performed, by whom, and what
documentation exists beyond the hearing itself.
The City will provide a staff report with a discussion of the appeal points and recommendation on the ruling.
Draft findings consistent with the recommendation will be included. If the Council does not follow the staff
recommendation, the Council will continue the item and direct staff to draft findings consistent with its ruling for
adoption at the next Council meeting.
Third—and this is central to my concern, please confirm the City's expectations regarding the CEQA framework presented
to the City Council. I want to be explicit: I am not responsible for providing CEQA training to the City Council, and I do not
believe the appellant should be placed in the position of having to educate the hearing body on foundational CEQA
requirements and disclosure obligations within a 15‑minute presentation slot. Staff and counsel must provide the
framework the Council needs to make a legally defensible decision. My appeal raises fundamental CEQA issues and
disclosure obligations that cannot be responsibly evaluated without a clear written framework, including but not limited to
thresholds of significance; what a Statement of Overriding Considerations means in a relied‑upon (tiered‑off) program
Environmental Impact Report; when tiering is allowable and when it is not; the City's use of CEQA Guidelines section
15183 for Orchards; what "peculiar characteristics" are and are not; how the City must apply the updated Climate Action
Plan and the City's greenhouse gas thresholds/guidance framework; how the City must incorporate regulatory baseline
changes (including Ordinances 529 and 534); how the City must incorporate newly approved, more detailed contextual
projects and development agreements in the cumulative setting; and how mitigation must be feasible, fully enforceable,
and effective—especially over a phased, long‑term buildout. Please confirm whether the appeal staff report and/or City
Attorney materials will provide a written CEQA decision framework addressing these items as they apply to Orchards,
including the specific CEQA determination(s) and findings the City Council will be asked to adopt on appeal.
Staff will provide the same analysis to the City Council that was presented to the Planning Commission, plus an
analysis of the appeal points. The City Council is positioned to consider the facts entered in the record both
before and during the appeal by staff, the appellant, the City’s expert technical consultants, and other interested
parties, and it will apply those facts to the legal requirements governing both the appeal and the underlying
project at issue. You are welcome to submit material for the record that you believe will assist Council in
reaching a decision regarding your appeal.
Fourth, I request the same clarity regarding professional ethics standards that directly bear on fair-hearing expectations in
discretionary planning approvals. The American Planning Association (APA) Ethical Principles in Planning and the
American Institute of Certified Planners (AICP) Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct substantially overlap with my
CEQA concerns because they address the integrity of decision-making, the fair presentation of information, meaningful
public participation, and independent judgment. To my knowledge, the City Council has not received formal training or a
clear briefing on how APA ethical principles and AICP ethics expectations apply to planning decision‑making bodies (the
Planning Commission and the City Council) and to City staff (especially AICP‑certified planners) in the context of
discretionary approvals and CEQA determinations. If the City is expecting a fair appeal process that does not function as
staff defending staff's prior posture, then the City should be prepared to explain, in writing, what guardrails it will apply to
ensure transparency, fair dealing, independent judgment, and a balanced presentation of the appeal issues to the
Council. Please confirm whether the appeal materials provided to the Council will include a brief written ethics/process
integrity framework that addresses the applicability of APA/AICP ethics principles to the appeal process and decision-
making.
The City will conduct the appeal hearing as an administrative hearing that provides due process and the
opportunity to be heard by the City Council, which sits as an impartial decision-making body. Decisions will be
made based on facts in the record, which is publicly available to all parties. To the extent that you wish to include
the additional material described above in support of your appeal, you are welcome to provide it to the City Clerk,
and such material will be included in the record.
Fifth, please clarify the parity and timing of the applicant's submissions and the staff's responses. Is the applicant subject
to the same March 30 deadline for inclusion of materials in the staff report and agenda packet? If the applicant submits
materials after March 30, how will those be handled (for example, as "late correspondence"), and will the appellant
receive equal and timely access to any applicant submissions and any staff responses that are provided to the City
Council before the hearing? I am concerned that early deadlines—without clarity on how staff will treat submissions—
create an inherent disadvantage to the appellant by giving staff additional time to characterize and frame the appellant's
materials. In contrast, the appellant has no comparable opportunity to review, correct, or respond to staff's framing before
the agenda packet is finalized and published.
Applicant and Appellant will be subject to the same rules regarding submittals. All parties will have the
opportunity to review and respond to the staff report and other evidence in the record through the close of the
public hearing.
Sixth, please clarify how the City will handle the administrative record for the appeal in a way that does not shift
record‑assembly burdens onto the appellant. I request confirmation that the City will compile and maintain the complete
administrative record for the appeal (including the Planning Commission record, the filed appeal, all submissions received
from all parties, the staff report, and all materials relied upon by the Council), and that the agenda packet will include a
clear index identifying where appellant materials are located and what materials staff and the Council will rely upon.
Without a clear index and clear treatment of appellant materials, the process risks becoming one where the appellant
must anticipate and counter a staff narrative without knowing in advance what will be written, what will be relied upon, or
where the appellant's materials will appear in the packet.
The City uses best practices in maintaining and organizing records pertinent to every project. If this challenge
proceeds beyond the current appeal, the parties can discuss the assembly of the administrative record and index
at that time.
Because the March 30 deadline is approaching, I would appreciate a written response sufficiently in advance of that
deadline so I can make an informed decision about whether to submit anything beyond my already‑filed appeal and, if so,
how to do so without undermining fairness and impartiality.
Respectfully,
Brian C. Swanson, AICP
69 Ayamonte Court
San Ramon, CA 94583
(925) 785-4013 - mobile
On Thu, Mar 5, 2026 at 1:21 PM Lisa Schlotz <lschlotz@sanramon.ca.gov> wrote:
Mr. Swanson,
Thank you for confirming your availability. Please let this email serve as the formal notice of hearing for
your appeal.
Hearing Details
Date: Tuesday, April 7, 2026
Time: 7:00 P.M.
Location: 7000 Bollinger Canyon Road, San Ramon, CA
Order of Proceedings
1. City Staff Presentation
2. Appellant Presentation
3. Applicant Presentation
4. Recess (as needed)
5. Rebuttal (if time was reserved)
6. Public Comment (3-minute limit per speaker)
Presentation Guidelines
Each presenter is allotted 15 minutes. If you wish to provide a rebuttal later in the hearing, you must
reserve a specific portion of your 15-minute window at the beginning of your initial presentation.
Deadlines for Submissions
To ensure your materials are processed correctly, please adhere to the following deadlines:
Agenda Packet Materials: Any items you wish to include in the official staff report and agenda
packet must be emailed to the City Clerk no later than Monday, March 30, 2026, by 12:00 P.M.
Hearing Visuals (Slides/Handouts): If you intend to use a digital presentation or provide handouts
during the hearing, please email them to the City Clerk by Friday, April 3, 2026 by 4:00 P.M.
Additionally, please bring 12 hard copies to the hearing for distribution to the participants and the
public.
Please let us know if you have any questions regarding these procedures.
Sincerely,
Lisa
Lisa Schlotz | Deputy City Clerk | City of San Ramon
7000 Bollinger Canyon Road |San Ramon, CA 94583 | www.SanRamon.ca.gov
T: (925) 973-2561 | F: (925) 275-0650 | E: lschlotz@sanramon.ca.gov
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA
November 12, 2024
WE PROVIDE EFFICIENT DELIVERY OF QUALITY PUBLIC SERVICES THAT ARE ESSENTIAL TO THOSE WHO LIVE AND WORK IN SAN RAMON
David E. Hudson, Mayor • Scott Perkins, Vice Mayor
Mark Armstrong, Councilmember • Marisol Rubio, Councilmember • Sridhar Verose, Councilmember
Council Chamber 7000 Bollinger Canyon Road REGULAR MEETING AND CLOSED SESSION – 7:00 PM
Agenda Questions: Please contact the City Clerk (925) 973-2539 or cityclerk@sanramon.ca.gov
Please refer to the end of the agenda to review options for participation in the meeting.
Unless stated otherwise on the agenda, every item on the agenda is exempt from CEQA Guidelines Sections 15060(c), 15061(b)(3), 15273, 15378, 15301, 15323 and/or
Public Resources Code Section 21065.
1.CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL
2.PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
3.ANNOUNCEMENTS
3.1 Changes and Additions to the Agenda
3.2 If you wish to speak under Public Comment or regarding an agenda item please
fill out a speaker card located in the back of the room and submit it to the City Clerk.
4.PUBLIC COMMENT
Members of the audience are encouraged to address the City Council on any non-agendaitem relating to the business of the City Council. Comments are limited to three (3) minutes,
or less time if a large number of speakers are anticipated. A speaker may not allocate their
time to another speaker. All remarks shall be addressed to the City Council.
Comments from the public on non-agenda items may also be submitted by email to
CityClerk@sanramon.ca.gov. Comments received by email will not be read aloud; however,
they will be forwarded to the Council for their consideration. If you wish to present yourcomments to the public, you may do so in-person during this Public Comment period. NoCouncil action can be taken at this meeting on issues raised during public comment.
Exhibit E
2 City Council Meeting – November 12, 2024
During public comment, members of the public are permitted to address the City Council
only on the following:
Any non-agenda item relating to the business of the City Council.
Items that are on the Consent Calendar, including requests to pull an item from theconsent calendar and the reason why you wish to pull the item or items. Please note
that the decision to remove the item from the Consent Calendar is strictly at the
discretion of the City Council.
Requests for Future Agenda Items.
Special Presentation Items under Section 6 of tonight’s Agenda.
Items that are not on the agenda and are within the City Council’s jurisdiction.
5.CONSENT CALENDAR
Consent Calendar items are considered routine and are acted upon by the City Council with asingle action. Members of the audience wishing to provide public input may request (by email to
the City Clerk or under Item 4 Public Comment) that the City Council remove the item from theConsent Calendar. Members of the public may request that items be removed from the ConsentCalendar, however, the decision to remove the item is solely at the discretion of the City Council.
With respect to the approval of resolutions and ordinances, the reading of the title thereto shallbe deemed a motion to waive a reading of the complete resolution or ordinance and unless thereis a request by a Council member that the resolution or ordinance be read in full, further reading
of the resolution or ordinance shall be deemed waived by unanimous consent of the Council.
5.1 Minutes of the City Council Regular Meeting and Closed Session - Oct 22, 2024
Recommendation: Approve Minutes
5.2 Resolution No. 2024-102 - Authorizing the Mayor to Execute an Agreement with JD Partners Concrete for On-Call Concrete and Sidewalk Repairs in an Amount Not to Exceed $499,999 for a Two-Year Term Ending December 31, 2026, with the Option to Renew the Agreement for Up to Two Additional Successive One-Year Terms
Recommendation: Approve Resolution No. 2024-102
5.3 Resolution No. 2024-103 - Authorizing the Mayor to Execute an Agreement with Earl Adams Tile-Coping and Plastering, Inc. DBA Adams Pool Solutions for the 25 Meter Lap Pool Replaster, as Part of the San Ramon Olympic Pool Equipment
Replacement Project (CIP 925479) in an Amount Not to Exceed $329,279,
Funded by the Infrastructure Maintenance Fund (618)
Recommendation: Approve Resolution No. 2024-103
5.4 Resolution No. 2024-104 - Accepting Offers of Dedication and Certain Park
Improvements for Sunrise Ridge Park and Rose Garden (Parcel G and Parcel H,
Respectively) of Subdivision 9342 for Maintenance, Releasing the Project Surety, and Accepting a One-Year Warranty Bond (Lennar)
Recommendation: Approve Resolution No. 2024-104
3 City Council Meeting – November 12, 2024
5.5 Ordinance 526 - Amending Title D (Zoning), Division D2 (Allowable Land Uses and Zoning Standards), Chapter III, Section D2-13, Table 2-6 To: 1) Allow
Commercial Recreation Facility – Outdoor Land Use with Approval of a Use
Permit in the City Center Mixed Use and Downtown Mixed Use- South Zones; and 2) Amend the Definition of “Commercial Recreation Facility – Outdoor” Under Title D, Division D8 (Glossary) of the San Ramon Municipal Code
Recommendation: Waive the Second Reading and Read by Title Only and Adopt
the Ordinance 526
5.6 Ordinance 527 - Repealing and Replacing Title B, Division B6 (Health, Sanitation and Environmental Quality), Chapter IX (Living in Vehicles) of the San Ramon Municipal Code with Chapter IX (Encampments on Public Property)
Recommendation: Waive the Second Reading and Read by Title Only, and
Adopt Ordinance 527
6.SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS
6.1 Recognition of Jenyth Jo Gearhart-Utchen for her 6 Years of Service as SanRamon's Poet Laureate, and Introduction of Jaz Sufi as San Ramon's new Poet
Laureate by Adam Chow, Recreation Supervisor.
6.2 Proclamation Recognizing Robin Bartlett for his 20 Years of Service to the City of San Ramon. Introduction by Brian Bornstein, Public Works Director. Presentation by the City Council.
7.DEFERRED CONSENT ITEMS
8.UNFINISHED BUSINESS
8.1 Minute Order No. 2024-007 - Approving the Dissolution of the EconomicDevelopment Advisory Committee, Housing Advisory Committee, Innovation and Technology Advisory Committee, and Transportation Demand Management Advisory Committee
Recommendation: Approve Minute Order No. 2024-007
Staff Report by Christina Franco, City Clerk
9.NEW BUSINESS
9.1 Resolution No. 2024-105 - Adopting Objective Design and Development
Standards for the Review of Qualifying Multi-Family and Residential Mixed-Use
Developments
Recommendation: Approve Resolution No. 2024-105
Staff Report by Cindy Yee, Senior Planner
4 City Council Meeting – November 12, 2024
10.CITY MANAGER'S AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS' COMMENTS /MATTERS INITIATED
11.CLOSED SESSION
11.1 Convene to Closed Session Pursuant to California Government Code § 59457 toPerform the Evaluation of the City Attorney.
11.2 Pursuant to California Government Code § 59457 to Perform the Evaluation of the Manager
11.3 Report on Closed Session
12.ADJOURNMENT
I hereby certify the agenda was posted 72 hours before the noted meeting. This agenda is posted
in accordance with Government Code Section 54954.2(a).
Dated: November 8, 2024
5 City Council Meeting – November 12, 2024
HOW TO VIEW OR PARTICIPATE IN THE MEETING: The public is invited to participate in the meeting using any of the following methods:
IN-PERSON
Members of the public can provide in-person comments at the meeting. To make a request for disability-related accommodation to participate in the meeting, please contact the City Clerk’s Office 48 hours in advance of the meeting.
WRITTEN COMMUNICATION BY EMAIL Public comments may be submitted via e-mail to cityclerk@sanramon.ca.gov. Any public comments received up until two (2) hours prior to the scheduled start time of the meeting will be distributed to the City Council via e-mail, provided at the meeting in the red binder, and posted online at https://www.sanramon.ca.gov/public_comment.
Written comments received after the cut-off time will be provided to the City Council the day following the meeting.
Please include “Public Comment” in the subject line. In the body of the email please include your name and the item you wish to comment on. Written public comment will not be read aloud during the meeting.
TO VIEW OR LISTEN ONLY As a courtesy and technology permitting, the public will have the opportunity to view the meeting via one-way feed by the options below. However, the City cannot guarantee that the public’s remote access to any meeting will be uninterrupted, and technical difficulties may occur from time to time. In those instances, so long as the public may still attend the meeting in person, the meeting will continue. Members of the public desiring to provide comments as a part of the meeting are encouraged to either submit written comments prior to the meeting or to attend the meeting in person. a.Zoom: https://cityofsanramon.zoom.us/j/98251028910Webinar ID: 982 5102 8910b.Zoom Phone Numbers: +1 (669) 900-6833c.The City’s YouTube Channel: www.sanramon.ca.gov/YouTube
Regular City Council meetings are broadcast on Contra Costa Television (CCTV) (Channel 27) on Wednesdays at 7:00
p.m. and Thursdays at 1:00 p.m. immediately following the meeting. Regular City Council meetings are also broadcast
on AT&T U-Verse (Channel 99).
ATTENDEE CONDUCT
There will be zero tolerance for any person addressing the Council making profane, offensive and disruptive remarks, or engaging in loud, boisterous, or other disorderly conduct, that disrupts the orderly conduct of the public meeting. Specifically, it is important for all speakers to adhere to the following guidelines for participation in this meeting: a.No profanity or obscenity.b.Refrain from personal threats or attacks.c.Refrain from hateful epithets and demeaning language based on any person’s race, religion, sexualorientation, ethnicity, gender, or disability.d.Respect all people that are present or watching.
At the discretion of the Mayor, a speaker may forfeit speaking time for any of the following reasons: a.Exceeding the allotted time to speak;b.Yelling, screaming, or other behavior that renders this Council unable to continue the meeting;c.Excessive profanity or slander;d.Specific threats or “fighting words” that incite violence; ore.Speech that is outside the subject matter jurisdiction of the Council or the specific agenda item inwhich you are speaking.
While the City of San Ramon ensures the First Amendment rights of its citizens, we do not accept nor endorse any offensive or hateful comments made during our meetings. The City of San Ramon celebrates the diversity of our community, and we strive to be a welcoming and open community for all.
CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT
DATE: November 12, 2024
TO: City Council/City Manager
FROM: Christina Franco, City Clerk
By: Christina Franco, City Clerk
SUBJECT: MINUTE ORDER NO. 2024-007 - Approving the Dissolution of the
Economic Development Advisory Committee, Housing Advisory Committee,
Innovation and Technology Advisory Committee, and Transportation
Demand Management Advisory Committee
RECOMMENDED ACTION
Staff recommends for the City Council to formally dissolve the Economic Development
Advisory Committee, Housing Advisory Committee, Innovation and Technology Advisory
Committee, and Transportation Demand Management Advisory Committee.
BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION
Committees are formed by City Council, serve at the pleasure of the Council, and are intended to
assist the Council. In general, they are tasked with analyzing matters within a defined scope and
providing advice or recommendations to the Council.
It is appropriate for the focus area and responsibilities of committees to change from time to time
to reflect the evolving nature of the community and the Council’s needs and interests.
Committees should be structured to be reflective of and in alignment with Council goals,
objectives and major initiatives to provide a clear and transparent path for the community to
participate in public discourse, and to ensure that the City Council advisory needs are being met.
Each committee has a lead staff liaison who is responsible to manage the committee, including
preparation of agendas, staff reports, and agenda packets; meeting management; subcommittee
work; meeting follow up; and administration and management of records. Other staff assist the
lead liaison as needed.
The City Clerk’s Office is responsible to coordinate recruitment for all committees; develop and
provide training for staff liaisons and committee members; maintain webpages; develop and
maintain templates and the commission handbook; administer and coordinate filing of reporting
documents; and provide technical assistance to staff liaisons and committee members.
8.1
Packet Pg. 47
The Council expressed interest reviewing the purpose and operations of committees to determine
if the focus of and tasks assigned to committees are best structured to help Council fulfill their
governance responsibilities. Staff is proposing for the Council to approach the review of the
Committees in a phased approach to create the most efficiencies.
The first phase of this process is to formalize the dissolution of the Economic Development
Advisory Committee, Housing Advisory Committee, Innovation and Technology Advisory
Committee, and Transportation Demand Management Advisory Committee.
By formalizing the dissolution of the committees, it will allow Council to effectively focus on
the other committees and the potential of reformatting or folding in any pertinent items from
those committees that are being dissolved. Staff would like to emphasize that because the four
committees are being dissolved now, the Council can still consider the charges of the committees
to either reformat, restructure, or create a new committee that better serves the Council’s goals,
objectives, and priorities in the next phase of this process.
Background on the Committees
Economic Development Advisory Committee:
On March 30, 1987, the City Council established the San Ramon Redevelopment Advisory
Committee. The Committee was formed as a citizens’ advisory committee to act as liaison to the
Redevelopment Agency. In 1995, it was determined that the Redevelopment Advisory
Committee and the Housing Advisory Committee had similar goals and objectives. Thus, it was
determined that it would be in the best interest of the City to merge the two committees. On June
27, 1995 the San Ramon Redevelopment Agency and City Council approved the merger of the
Redevelopment Advisory Committee and the Housing Advisory Committee and assigned their
functions to the Economic Development Advisory Committee. On February 1, 2012, in
accordance with State legislation all California Redevelopment Agencies, including the San
Ramon Redevelopment Agency, were eliminated.
The purpose of the Committee is to advise the City regarding policies that will accomplish goals
and objectives specified in the City's General Plan including the Economic Element and the
Economic Development Strategic Plan (EDSP). The City’s General Plan including the Economic
Development was updated in 2023, almost 28 years since the committee’s charge was last
reviewed.
The charge of the Economic Development Advisory Committee is;
A.Recommend to the City programs to help stimulate business activity, retain existing
businesses, facilitate expansion of existing businesses, and encourage new businesses to
locate within the City.
B.Review and make comments as necessary to the City on proposed policy changes.
C.Review commercial development plans and make comments to the City and developer(s)
8.1
Packet Pg. 48
on the project plans. Serve as advocacy group for commercial developments that serve
community needs and meet community standards.
D.Communicate with the City and the community-at-large regarding economic
development projects and programs.
On December 13, 2023, the committee met for a special meeting and voted to sunset the
committee with the hope that the City Council will reinvent the committee by adding value or
create a new committee in line with today’s goals. The Committee has not met since then.
The Planning Commission will take on the responsibility of advising the City regarding policies
that will accomplish goals and objectives specified in the City's General Plan including the
Economic Element and the Economic Development Strategic Plan.
Housing Advisory Committee
The Committee was formed by the Redevelopment Agency Board at the May 14, 2002 meeting
by the adoption of these By-laws.
The purpose of this committee is to advise the Planning Commission through Planning staff
regarding policies that will facilitate the implementation of housing programs and to create and
retain housing in the City of San Ramon affordable to households with incomes below 120% of
the area median.
A.Provide advice regarding affordable housing programs, guidelines and policies consistent
with the Housing Element of the City of San Ramon General Plan.
B.Provide advice regarding opportunities for the development of housing affordable to
those households with extremely low, very low, low and moderate income.
C.Assist staff and the Planning Commission to promote greater public understanding and
acceptance of affordable housing.
D.Provide advice regarding the expenditures of funds that are set aside for affordable
housing programs.
E.Make recommendations to the Planning Commission and staff regarding affordable
housing preferences and program eligibility criteria.
F.Provide advocacy for establishing and maintaining a diversity of housing types and
opportunities in the City of San Ramon.
On January 25, 2024, the committee met to discuss the committee’s goals and objectives. They
discussed dissolving the committee and voted to recommend that the City Council consider
dissolution of the Housing Advisory Committee given the changes of housing laws and state
legislation. The Committee has not met since then.
The Planning Commission will continue to facilitate the implementation of any housing
programs and to create and retain housing in the city affordable to households with incomes
below 120% of the area median.
8.1
Packet Pg. 49
Innovation and Technology Advisory Committee
The Committee was originally established by the City Council on October 22, 2019. The purpose
of this Committee is to advise and report directly to the City Council on activity regarding their
charge as described below, as needed.
A.Advise the council on maximizing our potential as a city where technology fuels
opportunity, inclusion, engagement and innovation for all.
B.Advise the council on policies, initiatives, and practices that will enhance the City’s
ability to tap into innovative ideas to improve quality of life for the residents of San
Ramon.
C.Assess emerging trends and technologies and for their potential impacts on the
community.
D.Provide recommendations and policy guidance to the City on “smart city” practices such
as enhancing cyber security, promoting digital inclusion, improving mobility, enhancing
public safety, developing communication tools, and pursuing economic opportunity.
E.Follow legislative developments and funding opportunities for Innovation and
Technology projects and provide feedback to the City Council.
F.As requested by the City Council or staff, evaluate regulatory and statutory compliance
with any franchise or other agreements between the City and technology providers and
make recommendations to the City Council.
The Committee has met a total of 13 times and cancelled 17 meetings over the past four years.
The Committee has struggled to get off the ground and gain momentum on any project under
their purview. ITAC’s meeting dates and agendas items are in the table below. Staff is
recommending dissolving ITAC, and if Council chooses to do so can review the charge during
the next phase of this process.
Meeting
Date Agenda Items
3/3/2020 Committee Introductions, Election of Chair/Vice Chair, Brown Act,
Committee Bylaws and Future Agenda Items
7/7/2020 Committee Introductions, Conflict of Interest Discussion, City Update,
Budget and Operations Under Covid, Initial Committee Goals Discussion
8/4/2020 Conflict of Interest Training, Overview of Geographic Information System
9/1/2020 Proposed Committee Bylaw Update, Overview of Police Dept use of
Technology
10/6/2020 Intelligent Transportation System, Future Agenda Items
3/2/2021 Brown Act Training, Overview SR Library Wi-Fi Hot Spots and Pi Lending
Program, Roundtable Discussion and Research Report Out
8.1
Packet Pg. 50
6/1/2021 City Communication Overview, Roundtable Discussion and Report Out,
Election of Chair/Vice Chair
9/7/2021 Meeting Schedule Review, Roundtable Discussion and Research Report Out
12/7/2021 Fiber Optic Master Plan Discussion, Roundtable Discussion and Research
Report Out
6/7/2022 Update Intelligent Traffic Singal Program, Update Fiber Optics Master Plan,
Election of Chair/Vice Chair
11/1/2022 Fiber Optic Master Plan Proposal
6/20/2023 Brown Act Training, Election of Chair/Vice Chair, The Role of ITAC
3/5/2024 Goals and Objectives
Transportation Demand Management Advisory Committee
The Committee was established by the City Council in January 1988. Unfortunately, due to the
impacts of COVID-19 on commute patterns and the institution of work-from-home, it has been
difficult to maintain and recruit committee members. The last meeting was held on November
18, 2021. The last quorum was at the September 20, 2021 meeting. The Policy Committee
reviewed the dissolution of the committee and recommended for staff to proceed to Council for
consideration to dissolve the committee.
The purpose of the Committee is to provide ongoing input to the City on the provision and
delivery of Transportation Demand Management activities and services. The Committee's main
objectives are to:
1.Develop recommendations to the staff, and City Council on the delivery of TDM
programs, activities, services, and policies.
2.Coordinate and monitor the implementation of the Citywide TDM effort in order to
achieve reductions in employment-related single occupant vehicle traffic.
3.Recommend to City Council improvements in City services and facilities to assist
employers in reducing single occupant vehicles.
4.Implement commute alternative programs.
5.Coordinate TDM efforts with all employers and complexes in the City.
6.Coordinate TDM efforts with local and regional agencies as designated by the City.
7.Serve as liaison between the City and business community.
8.Schedule and implement at least one commuter transportation event by hosting an on-site
Commuter Fair to help promote commute alternatives to employees and/or tenants.
Committee members will be required to host at least one Commuter Fair a year. If not,
this shall constitute voluntary resignation from the Committee.
9.Committee members must provide support to coordinate and/or participate at the annual
Bike to Work Day Energizer Station.
8.1
Packet Pg. 51
The Transportation Advisory Committee has the capacity and ability to provide input to the City
on the provision and delivery of Transportation Systems Management Program activities and
services. Staff recommends that the Council approve the dissolution of the Transportation
Demand Management Advisory Committee. The Council will be reviewing the Transportation
Advisory Committee during the next phase.
Next Phases:
Phase 2 will be reviewing the remaining committees to consolidate, reformat, restructure, or
create a new committee that better serves the Council’s goals, objectives, and priorities.
Phase 3 will be expectation for boards, commissions and committees, including committee
structure, scopes, and workplans.
Phase 4 will be the development of the recruitment and appointment process.
On October 22, 2024, staff gave a presentation to the City Council outlining the background and
process to formally dissolve the Economic Development Advisory Committee, Housing
Advisory Committee, Innovation and Technology Advisory Committee, and Transportation
Demand Management Advisory Committee. The City Council took action to continue this item
to the November 12, 2024 City Council meeting to allow for more public outreach. Additional
outreach included an email to 8,400 subscribers and a posting on the city’s NextDoor account to
53,000 neighbors.
FISCAL ANALYSIS
Historically, the City has not conducted time estimates associated with managing a committee or
peripheral resources allocated, except for one committee. That estimate was conducted in 2023
and found 273 hours annually at a cost of $22,703. That time value should be considered an
approximation and not perfect.
Assuming an annual cost of $22,703 for each committee if it were fully operational, staff
approximates a time value savings of $90,812. Therefore, Council taking this action allows
department directors to reassign support staff to other critical priorities and service delivery.
These time audits are rough estimates intended to be helpful data when assessing priorities and
resource allocation. They should not be construed as formalized desk audits, which are more
costly and time consuming to generate.
STEPS FOLLOWING APPROVAL
Staff will inform all committee members of the action the Council has taken. Staff will begin
preparing the staff report and materials for the next phase of the process.
8.1
Packet Pg. 52
Orchards Project
CEQA Guidelines Section 15183 Consistency Checklist
FCS
Appendix I:
Transportation Supporting Information
Exhibit F
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Memorandum
Date: November 10, 2025
To: Stephanie Hill, Senior VP of Development, Bishop Ranch
From: Andy Kosinski, PE and Ashlee Takushi, RSP1, Fehr & Peers
Subject: Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis
This Technical Memorandum presents the effects of the Orchards Mixed-Use Development
(“Project”) at 6001 Bollinger Canyon Road in San Ramon, California on vehicle miles traveled (VMT).
The Project proposes a mix of single-family housing, multi-family housing, and retail uses to replace
a corporate headquarters campus, which is currently vacant.
Because the Project’s density is consistent with the development density established in the City’s
2040 General Plan, the Project’s VMT has already been analyzed and disclosed in the 2040 General
Plan EIR. That EIR disclosed a Significant and Unavoidable VMT impact and provides Mitigation
Measure TRA-2, which reduces VMT impacts through the application of TDM measures and project
design features that would reduce VMT and participation in a regional VMT impact fee program or
exchange/banking program, if and when one is implemented. [Note to Reviewer: we understand that
no project-level VMT analysis is required due to the Project relying on the 15183 exemption. The
below project-level analysis has been prepared for use in case there is a "peculiar characteristic" of
the project which means it does not generally fit within the GP EIR analysis.]
The project-level VMT analysis results in the following impacts:
•Residential Component: Less Than Significant With Mitigation as follows:
o Integration of affordable and below market rate housing
o Providing community-based travel planning
•Retail Component: Less Than Significant
An analysis of the cumulative impact on VMT of the Project’s residential component was not needed
given the Project’s significant impact is fully mitigable, nor was it needed for the retail component as
the Project’s impact is less-than-significant.
This memorandum begins with a project description, followed by the analysis methodology, and
finishes with the impact analysis.
Fehr&Peers
Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 2
Project Description
The Project includes construction of 230 single-family detached residences, 138 single-family
attached residences, 58 accessory dwelling units (ADU), 2,084-units of multi-family housing units,
and 125,000 square feet of retail, which is assumed to be regional-serving in nature. While some
ADUs are anticipated to be built at a later time, we assumed that all ADUs will be built at opening to
present an analysis that is consistent with other project analyses. There is an existing 1,397,520
square foot corporate headquarters campus onsite that was vacated in late Summer 2024 and will be
demolished as part of the Project.
Overview of SB 743
California Senate Bill 743
On September 27, 2013, California Governor Jerry Brown signed Senate Bill (SB) 743 into law and
started a process that changed the way transportation impact analysis is conducted as part of CEQA
compliance. These changes include elimination of automobile delay, LOS, and other similar measures
of vehicular capacity or traffic congestion as a basis for determining significant impacts under CEQA.
According to SB 743, these changes are intended to “more appropriately balance the needs of
congestion management with statewide goals related to infill development, promotion of public
health through active transportation, and reduction of greenhouse gas emissions.”
In December 2018, the State Office of Planning and Research (OPR) completed an update to the
CEQA Guidelines to implement the requirements of SB 743. The Guidelines state that VMT must be
the metric used to determine significant transportation impacts. The Guidelines require all lead
agencies in California to use VMT-based thresholds of significance in CEQA documents published
after July 2020.
The OPR Guidelines recommend developing screening criteria for development projects that meet
certain criteria that can readily lead to the conclusion that they would not cause a significant impact
on VMT. The OPR Guidelines also recommend evaluating VMT impacts using an efficiency-based
version of the metric, such as VMT per resident for residential developments and/or VMT per worker
for office or other employment-based developments.
On July 15, 2020, the Contra Costa Transportation Authority (CCTA) adopted criteria, standards, and
thresholds for the assessment of VMT (CCTA, Approval of the Vehicle Miles Traveled Analysis
Methodology for Land Use Projects in the Growth Management Program, July 15, 2020). The
methods and thresholds adopted by CCTA follow the guidance and recommendations of OPR
pertaining to the implementation of SB 743.
As the City of San Ramon has not yet formally adopted its own VMT criteria, standards, or thresholds
at the time this report was prepared, this assessment follows current OPR and CCTA guidance
related to VMT.
VMT Screening Assessment
Fehr&Peers
Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 3
According to CCTA’s Technical Procedures,1 screening thresholds can be used to quickly identify
projects that can be expected to cause a less than significant impact without conducting a detailed
study.
VMT impacts would be less than significant for a project if any of the identified screening criteria
outlined below are met:
1. CEQA Exemption – Any project exempt from CEQA is not required to conduct a
VMT analysis.
2. Small Projects – Small projects can be presumed to cause a less-than-significant VMT
impact. Small projects are defined as having 10,000 square feet or less of non-residential
space or 20 residential units or less, or otherwise generating less than 836 VMT per day.
3. Local-Serving Uses – Projects that consist of local-serving uses can generally be presumed
to have a less-than-significant impact absent substantial evidence to the contrary, since
these types of projects will primarily draw users and customers from a relatively small
geographic area that will lead to short-distance trips and trips linked to other destinations.
4. Projects Located in Transit Priority Areas (TPAs) – Projects located within a TPA can be
presumed to have a less-than-significant impact absent substantial evidence to the contrary.
5. Projects Located in Low VMT Areas – Projects located within a low VMT-generating area can
be presumed to have a less-than-significant impact absent substantial evidence to the
contrary.
Criterion #1: CEQA Exemption
Per the “CEQA Processing Approach for the Orchard Project in the City of San Ramon, CA”
memorandum dated March 20, 2025, and prepared by FCS, the Project’s density is consistent with
the DMU-S designation under the City’s 2040 General Plan, which makes the project eligible for a
State CEQA Guidelines 15183 consistency analysis. The City’s 2040 General Plan EIR determined a
significant and unavoidable VMT impact with TDM measures outlined in a mitigation measure, noting
that feasible TDM options listed in the EIR to reduce VMT below CCTA thresholds shall be
implemented for individual projects facilitated by the 2040 General Plan.
The Project description is consistent with the land use assumptions evaluated in the General Plan
Environmental Impact Report (EIR). The Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) analysis for the Project was
conducted using the same methodology and thresholds applied in the General Plan EIR, and is thus
consistent with existing analyses conducted for the Project.
Therefore, it is reasonable to conclude that the Project is able to rely on the General Plan EIR impact
analysis, impact disclosures, and statements of overriding consideration per CEQA Guidelines 15183.
This provision requires that the project be subject to any mitigation measures identified in the
General Plan EIR.
[Note to Reviewer: we understand that no project-level VMT analysis is required due to the Project
relying on the 15183 exemption. The below project-level analysis has been prepared for use in case
there is a "peculiar characteristic" of the project which means it does not generally fit within the GP
EIR analysis.]
1 Contra Costa Transportation Authority. November 2022. Technical Procedures. https://ccta.net/wp-
content/uploads/2023/01/CCTA_Technical_Procedures_Nov2022.pdf
Fehr&Peers
Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 4
Assessment Result: Criterion #1 potentially met, with analysis in Criterion #5 provided to support a
CEQA Exemption under State CEQA Guidelines 15183.
Criterion #2: Small Projects
The proposed Project includes construction of 230 single-family detached residences, 138 single-
family attached residences, 58 accessory dwelling units (ADU), 2,084-units of multi-family housing
units, and 125,000 square feet of retail.
Assessment Result: Criterion #2 not met.
Criterion #3: Local-Serving Use
The proposed Project includes retail that is anticipated to draw regional trips.
Assessment Result: Criterion #3 not met.
Criterion #4: Transit Priority Area
Based on the definitions cited in the criteria, a transit priority area means a site within a one half-mile
area an existing major transit stop or an existing stop along a high-quality transit corridor. A ‘major
transit stop’ is a site containing an existing rail transit station, a ferry terminal served by either a bus
or rail transit service, or the intersection of two or more major bus routes with a frequency of service
interval of 20 minutes or less during the morning and afternoon peak commute periods. A ‘high-
quality transit corridor’ means a corridor with fixed route bus service with service intervals no longer
than 15 minutes during peak commute hours.
Four County Connection fixed route buses, Route 35, Route 96X, Route 97X, and Route 335, stops
within a half-mile of the proposed Project site. The bus stop within a half-mile of the Project site does
not meet the requirements of a major transit stop. Route 35 and Route 96X run on weekdays with 30-
minute service intervals. Roue 97X runs on weekdays with a 60-minute service interval. Route 335
runs on 40-minute service interval. The proposed Project is not within a half-mile of an existing high
quality transit station or an existing stop along a high quality transit corridor and therefore not located
in a Transit Priority Area.
Assessment Result: Criterion #4 not met.
Criterion #5: Low VMT Area
An analysis is required to ascertain whether the Project is located in a low VMT area. The analysis is
presented below.
VMT Analysis
As shown above, the project does meet the criteria to rely on the General Plan EIR findings per CEQA
Guidelines 15153 provisions. The General Plan EIR disclosed a significant and unavoidable
transportation VMT impact and identified Mitigation Measure TRA-2, which reduces VMT impacts
through the application of TDM measures and project design features that would reduce VMT and
Fehr&Peers
Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 5
participation in a regional VMT impact fee program or exchange/banking program, if and when one is
implemented.
[Note to Reviewer: we understand that no project-level VMT analysis is required due to the Project
relying on the 15183 exemption. The below project-level analysis has been prepared for use in case
there is a "peculiar characteristic" of the project which means it does not generally fit within the GP
EIR analysis.]
VMT Impact Thresholds
The San Ramon General Plan includes the following threshold of significance for a project that
replaces existing VMT-generating land uses:
- If the replacement leads to a net overall decrease in VMT, the project would lead to a less-
than-significant transportation impact. If the project leads to a net overall increase in VMT,
then the CCTA Technical Procedures thresholds should apply.
If a less-than-significant impact is not identified using the above threshold, the following analysis
should be conducted:
- For housing projects: the project generated Home-Based VMT per resident constitutes a
significant impact if it is higher than 85% of the Home-Based VMT per resident in the subject
municipality or 85% of the existing countywide average Home-Based VMT per resident,
whichever is less stringent.
- For regional-serving projects: the project generated VMT constitutes a significant impact if
the baseline project generated total VMT per service population is higher than 85% of the
existing countywide average total VMT per service population.
Projects that are unable to mitigate their project-specific VMT impacts to less-than-significant levels
require a Cumulative VMT analysis. Cumulative VMT impacts should be considered significant if there
is a net increase in the total study area VMT normalized to the number of people within the study
area, when comparing cumulative without project to cumulative with project conditions.
Project-Level VMT Analysis Results
Total VMT
The City’s General Plan criteria require analysis of total VMT for a redevelopment project as a first
step. Total VMT provides a broader view of how a project affects overall travel demand at a regional
scale and helps to understand the absolute impact of the project on the transportation network. Table
1 shows that the construction of the Project would increase total VMT at both the county and regional
levels, therefore a Baseline VMT analysis using the per capita method is required.
Fehr&Peers
Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 6
Table 1. Total VMT Results
Scenario Existing no
Project1
Existing with
Project
Net
Change
Net Increase in
VMT?
Total Countywide VMT 26,454,736 26,470,444 15,708 Yes
Total Regionwide VMT 171,019,826 171,066,607 46,781 Yes
Notes:
1. Assumes Corporate Headquarters is fully occupied
Source: CCTA Travel Demand Model, Fehr & Peers, 2025.
Baseline VMT Analysis
Fehr & Peers used the CCTA travel demand model to estimate average daily vehicle miles of travel
for the proposed Project. Per CCTA guidance, daily home-based VMT per capita and home-work
VMT per worker was used to evaluate project generated VMT for the project.
The weekday daily average home-based VMT per capita for the Project, city, and county, and project
VMT per service population2 are presented in Table 2. Our analysis assumed that the existing
corporate headquarters was fully occupied for Existing no Project conditions. Based on this analysis,
the Project is estimated to generate 16.7 home-based VMT per capita, exceeding the applicable
threshold. The Project is estimated to generate 3.7 VMT per service population, which is below the
applicable threshold.
2 Service population is residents plus workers plus retail visitors.
Fehr&Peers
Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 7
Table 2. Per Capita VMT Results
Geography 2024 Base Year
Residential Land Uses1
City of San Ramon Average VMT 18.7
Contra Costa County Average VMT 17.1
15% below city average VMT (least stringent) 15.9
Project TAZ VMT 16.7
Below Threshold? No
Regional Serving Land Uses2
Countywide VMT (Existing no Project) 47,989,039
Countywide Service Population3 (Excluding Retail Visitors) 1,605,206
Countywide Estimated Retail Visitors4 1,253,329
Countywide Service Population3 (Including Retail Visitors)4 2,858,535
Countywide VMT per Service Population 16.8
15% Below Countywide Average 14.3
Project Total VMT 15,408
Project Estimated Retail Employees5 250
Project Estimated Retail Visitors6 3,970
Project Service Population3 2,360
Project VMT per Service Population 3.7
Below Threshold? Yes
Notes:
1. For residential land uses, the VMT metric applied in this analysis is Home-Based VMT per Capita.
2. For regional serving land uses (i.e. retail uses), the VMT metric applied in this analysis is Total VMT per
Service Population.
3. Service population is residents plus workers plus retail visitors
4. Estimated by converting countywide retail employees from the model (78,925) to square footage using
a ratio of 2 retail employees per ksf (employee factor derived from ITE Trip Generation Manual, 11th
Edition, by dividing the trip generation rate per ksf by the trip generation rate per employee for LU 820
Shopping Center (>150k), which is the most similar land use with the available data to make the
calculation). The resulting square footage was then converted to total trips by applying the 67.52 daily
automobile trip generation rate per ksf from the ITE Trip Generation Manual for LU 821 Shopping Plaza
(40-150k - no supermarket), from which employee trips were subtracted assuming two trips per
employee per day (an inbound and an outbound), and then assuming an average of 0.5 visitors per
remaining daily auto trip based on the fact that each visitor makes two auto trips (an inbound and an
outbound).
5. A ratio of 2 employees per ksf was applied to 125 ksf of project retail. Factor derived from ITE Trip
Generation Manual, 11th Edition, by dividing the trip generation rate per ksf by the trip generation rate
per employee for LU 820 Shopping Center (>150k).
6. For the project retail visitor estimate, the retail ksf was available directly (125 ksf), and was converted to
total trips by applying the 67.52 daily automobile trip generation rate per ksf from the ITE Trip
Generation Manual 11th Edition for LU 821 Shopping Plaza (40-150k - no supermarket), from which
Fehr&Peers
Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 8
employee trips were subtracted assuming two trips per employee per day (an inbound and an
outbound), and then assuming an average of 0.5 visitors per remaining daily auto trip based on the fact
that each visitor makes two auto trips (an inbound and an outbound).
Source: CCTA Travel Demand Model, 2025; Fehr & Peers, 2025.
This baseline VMT for the Existing with Project scenario is above the Home-Based VMT per Capita
threshold. Therefore, the Project is expected to have a significant impact pertaining to Home-Based
VMT, if not mitigated.
The project VMT per Service Population for the Project scenario is below the VMT per Service
Population threshold. Therefore, the Project is expected to have a less-than-significant impact
pertaining to Regional Serving VMT.
VMT Mitigation Measures
The Project’s home-based VMT per capita would result in a significant CEQA transportation impact.
The Project would be required to mitigate just over 5 percent of its home-based VMT to result in a
less-than-significant impact. The mitigation measures to reduce home-based VMT to less-than-
significant are summarized in Table 3.
Reduction of residential VMT is primarily achieved through implementation of Transportation
Demand Management (TDM) Programs. TDM refers to strategies that motivate alternatives to
automobile travel, either through positive incentives for walking, biking, and transit, or through
adding additional costs to automobile use at the project site. Fehr & Peers developed the TDM+ tool
that estimates a percent reduction in VMT due to a single TDM strategy as well as the combination of
multiple TDM strategies. TDM+ incorporates the effects of numerous land use and design strategies
as well as various travel incentives and disincentives. The VMT reductions applied in TDM+ are based
on strategies identified in the Handbook for Analyzing GHG Emission Reductions, Assessing Climate
Vulnerabilities, and Advancing Health and Equity, California Air Pollution Control Officers Association
(CAPCOA), August 2021.3 The TDM+ tool was used to analyze the Project’s VMT reduction potential.
Attachment A documents the TDM analysis assumptions and calculations, and Attachment B
includes excerpts from the CAPCOA Handbook documenting each strategy.
3 This report is a resource for local agencies to quantify the benefit, in terms of reduced travel demand, of
implementing various TDM strategies.
Fehr&Peers
Bishop Ranch Orchards VMT Analysis | 9
Table 3. VMT Results
Measure Description
Project
Implementation
Effect on VMT
Reduction
Maximum
VMT
Reduction
T-4. Integrate
Affordable and
Below Market
Rate Housing
This measure requires below market rate (BMR)
housing. BMR housing provides greater
opportunity for lower income families to live
closer to job centers and achieve a jobs/housing
match near transit. It is also an important strategy
to address the limited availability of affordable
housing that might force residents to live far
away from jobs or school, requiring longer
commutes.
-3.9%-28.6%
T-23. Provide
Community-
Based Travel
Planning
This measure will target residences in the
plan/community with community-based travel
planning (CBTP). CBTP is a residential-based
approach to outreach that provides households
with customized information, incentives, and
support to encourage the use of transportation
alternatives in place of single occupancy
vehicles, thereby reducing household VMT and
associated GHG emissions.
-2.3%-2.3%
Total Project VMT Reduction from TDM1 -6.1%
Reduction Required to Reduce Project VMT Below Threshold -5.0%
Note:
1.Total Project VMT Reduction is a multiplicative reduction
Source: CAPCOA Handbook for Analyzing Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reductions, Assessing Climate
Vulnerabilities, and Advancing Heath and Equity, California Air Pollution Control Officers Association (CAPCOA),
2021, Fehr & Peers, 2025.
Based on the Handbook for Analyzing GHG Emission Reductions, Assessing Climate Vulnerabilities,
and Advancing Health and Equity, implementing the strategies in Table 3, i.e. Integrate Affordable
and Below Market Rate Housing (assuming 387 of the 2,084 multi-family units are affordable), and
Provide Community-Based Travel Planning, would reduce the Project’s home-based VMT by 6.1
percent.
The General Plan EIR disclosed a significant and unavoidable transportation VMT impact and
identified Mitigation Measure TRA-2, which reduces VMT impacts through the application of TDM
measures and project design features that would reduce VMT and participation in a regional VMT
impact fee program or exchange/banking program, if and when one is implemented. The TDM
measures proposed above comply with and are consistent with the General Plan Mitigation Measure
TRA-2.
Assessment Result: Criterion #5 not met for Residential but met for Regional-Serving Uses.
Fehr&Peers
T-4
Locational Context Urban, Suburban
Scale of Application Project/Site
Type of VMT affected: Project-generated trips
Max VMT reduction:28.60%
Percent of multi-family units permanently dedicated as affordable 18.6%percent user input (default value = 0-0.286)
Percent reduction in VMT for qualified units compared to market rate units -28.6%percent constant (default value = -0.286)
Change in VMT -5.31%percent reduction
Sources:
Land Use - T-4. Integrate Affordable and Below Market Rate Housing
This measure requires below market rate (BMR) housing. BMR housing provides greater opportunity for lower income families to live closer to job centers and achieve a jobs/housing
match near transit. It is also an important strategy to address the limited availability of affordable housing that might force residents to live far away from jobs or school, requiring longer commutes. The quantification method for this measure accounts for VMT reductions achieved for multifamily residential projects that are deed restricted or otherwise permanently dedicated as affordable housing.
(1) Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE). 2021. Trip Generation Manual. 11th Edition. ITE 2021. Available: https://www.ite.org/technical-resources/topics/trip-and-parking-
generation/
(2) National Center for Sustainable Transportation. Affordable Housing in Transit-Oriented Developments: Impacts on Driving and Policy Approaches. April 2017. Available:
https://escholarship.org/uc/item/487994z4
Formula: % Change in VMT = Percent of multi-family units permanently dedicated as affordable * Percent reduction in VMT for qualified units compared to market rate units
Attachment A
FEHR t PEERS
Adjustment to T-4
T-4 Integrate Affordable and Below Market Rate Housing
A -5.31%Unadjusted Change in VMT from T-4
B 368 project single-family units
C 2084 project multi-family units
D 2 factor of SFH VMT per household / multifamily VMT per household
(this is conservatively high)
E -3.9%Adjusted Change in VMT from T-4
E = A * C/(BD + C)
Value "A" above applies to multifamily housing only and we need to convert this
to a VMT reduction for all residential.
Affordable units will be located solely in multi-family buildings, which have lower
VMT per household than SFH, therefore in the calculation below we not only
account for zero reduction in VMT for single family homes (SFH) but also apply a
factor to account for SFH VMT per household being higher than multifamily pre-
any TDM measures.
T-23
Locational Context Urban, Suburban
Scale of Application Plan/Community
Type of VMT affected: Household trips
Max VMT reduction:2.30%
Residences in plan/community 2510 residence user input (default value = 0-99999)
Residences in plan/community targeted with CBTP 2510 residence user input (default value = 0-99999)
Percent of targeted residences that participate 19.0%percent constant (default value = 0.19)
Percent vehicle trip reduction by participating residences 12.0%percent constant (default value = 0.12)
Adjustment factor from vehicle trips to VMT 1.000 unitless constant (default value = 1)
Change in VMT -2.28%percent reduction
Sources:
Trip Reduction Programs ‐ T‐23. Provide Community‐Based Travel Planning
This measure will target residences in the plan/community with community-based travel planning (CBTP). CBTP is a residential-based approach to outreach that
provides households with customized information, incentives, and support to encourage the use of transportation alternatives in place of single occupancy vehicles,
thereby reducing household VMT and associated GHG emissions.
(1) Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC). 2021. Plan Bay Area 2050, Supplemental Report. (forthcoming)
Formula: % Change in VMT = - ( Residences in plan/community targeted with CBTP / Residences in plan/community ) * Percent of targeted residences that
participate * Percent vehicle trip reduction by participating residences * Adjustment factor from vehicle trips to VMT
FEHR-19 PEERS
Attachment B
B
B
100%
•-
B
C
C
B
5,000 residences
5,000 residences
Exhibit 1
CEQA Findings and
Statement of Overriding Considerations
for the
San Ramon 2040 General Plan
Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Sections 15091 and 15093
and Public Resources Code Section 21081
The Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR) prepared for the update to the San Ramon General
Plan, including eleven respective General Plan elements, amendment to the San Ramon Village
Specific Plan, repeal of the North Camino Ramon Specific Plan, and the San Ramon Zoning
Ordinance update (collectively referred to herein as the 2040 General Plan) consists of errata to the
Draft EIR and Response to Comments on the Draft EIR. The Final EIR identifies significant environ-
mental impacts that will result from implementation of the 2040 General Plan. The City of San
Ramon (City) finds that the inclusion of certain mitigation measures as part of approval of the 2040
General Plan will reduce all but the following significant impacts to levels that are less than
significant: transportation (project-level and cumulative impacts related to vehicle miles traveled
[VMT]). No feasible mitigation measures have been identified to reduce these impacts to a less-
than-significant level or mitigation measures have been identified but would not reduce impacts to
a level of less than significant; thus, these impacts will remain significant unavoidable impacts of the
2040 General Plan. These impacts will be overridden due to specific considerations that are
described within this document.
As required by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), the City, in adopting these CEQA
Findings of Fact (Findings) and Statement of Overriding Considerations, also adopts a Mitigation
Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP) for the 2040 General Plan. The City finds that the
MMRP, which is incorporated herein by reference, meets the requirements of Public Resources
Code Section 21081.6 by providing for the implementation and monitoring of measures intended to
mitigate potentially significant effects of the 2040 General Plan. In accordance with CEQA and the
CEQA Guidelines, the City adopts these findings as part of approval of the 2040 General Plan.
Pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21082.1(c)(3), the City also finds that the Final EIR
reflects the City’s independent judgment as the lead agency for the 2040 General Plan.
Consideration and Certification of the EIR
In accordance with CEQA, and on the formal recommendation of the Planning Commission following
notice and public hearing, the City Council certifies that the EIR has been completed in compliance
with CEQA. The City Council has independently reviewed the record and the EIR prior to certifying
the EIR and approving the 2040 General Plan. By these findings, the City Council confirms, ratifies,
and adopts the findings and conclusions of the EIR as supplemented and modified by these findings.
The EIR and these findings represent the independent judgment and analysis of the City and the City
Council. The City Council recognizes the EIR may contain clerical errors. The City Council reviewed
the entirety of the EIR and bases its determination on the substance of the information it contains.
The City Council certifies that the EIR is adequate to support the approval of the action that is the
5.9.a
Packet Pg. 148
At
t
a
c
h
m
e
n
t
:
A
.
R
e
s
o
l
u
t
i
o
n
N
o
.
2
0
2
3
-
1
3
2
,
c
e
r
t
i
f
y
i
n
g
t
h
e
S
a
n
R
a
m
o
n
G
e
n
e
r
a
l
P
l
a
n
2
0
4
0
E
I
R
,
w
i
t
h
E
x
h
i
b
i
t
s
1
t
h
r
o
u
g
h
3
(
2
0
2
3
-
4
2
:
D
ra
f
t
G
e
n
e
r
a
l
Exhibit G
subject of the staff report to which these CEQA findings are attached. The City Council certifies that
the EIR is adequate to support approval of the 2040 General Plan described in the EIR, each
component and phase of the 2040 General Plan described in the EIR, any variant of the 2040
General Plan described in the EIR, any minor modifications to the 2040 General Plan or variants of
the 2040 General Plan described in the EIR and the components of the 2040 General Plan.
Absence of Significant New Information
The City Council recognizes the Final EIR incorporates information obtained and produced after the
Draft EIR was completed, and that the Final EIR contains additions, clarifications, and modifications.
On the recommendation of the Planning Commission following notice and public hearing, the City
Council has reviewed and considered the Final EIR and all of this information. The Final EIR does not
add significant new information to the Draft EIR that would require recirculation of the EIR under
CEQA. The new information added to the EIR does not involve a new significant environmental
impact, a substantial increase in the severity of an environmental impact, or a feasible mitigation
measure or alternative considerably different from others previously analyzed that the City Council
declines to adopt and that would clearly lessen the significant environmental impacts of the 2040
General Plan. No information indicates that the Draft EIR was inadequate or conclusory or that the
public was deprived of a meaningful opportunity to review and comment on the Draft EIR. Thus,
recirculation of the EIR is not required. The City Council finds that the changes and modifications
made to the EIR after the Draft EIR was circulated for public review and comment do not individually
or collectively constitute significant new information within the meaning of Public Resources Code
section 21092.1 or the CEQA Guidelines section 15088.5.
Severability
If any term, provision, or portion of these Findings or the application of these Findings to a
particular situation is held by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, void or unenforceable,
the remaining provisions of these Findings, or their application to other actions related to General
Plan 2040, shall continue in full force and effect unless amended or modified by the City.
5.9.a
Packet Pg. 149
At
t
a
c
h
m
e
n
t
:
A
.
R
e
s
o
l
u
t
i
o
n
N
o
.
2
0
2
3
-
1
3
2
,
c
e
r
t
i
f
y
i
n
g
t
h
e
S
a
n
R
a
m
o
n
G
e
n
e
r
a
l
P
l
a
n
2
0
4
0
E
I
R
,
w
i
t
h
E
x
h
i
b
i
t
s
1
t
h
r
o
u
g
h
3
(
2
0
2
3
-
4
2
:
D
ra
f
t
G
e
n
e
r
a
l
“Provide a safe and reliable transportation network that serves all people and respects the environment”
DISTRICT 4
OFFICE OF REGIONAL AND COMMUNITY PLANNING
P.O. BOX 23660, MS–10D | OAKLAND, CA 94623-0660
www.dot.ca.gov
October 13, 2023 SCH #: 2022060549
GTS #: 04-CC-2022-00714
GTS ID: 26840
Co/Rt/Pm: CC/680/VAR
Cindy M Yee, Senior Planner
City of San Ramon
7000 Bollinger Canyon Road
San Ramon, CA 94583
Re: San Ramon 2040 General Plan – Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR)
Dear Cindy M Yee:
Thank you for including the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) in the
environmental review process for the San Ramon 2040 General Plan. We are
committed to ensuring that impacts to the State’s multimodal transportation system
and to our natural environment are identified and mitigated to support a safe,
sustainable, integrated and efficient transportation system.
The Local Development Review (LDR) Program reviews land use projects and plans to
ensure consistency with our mission and state planning priorities. The following
comments are based on our review of the August 2023 DEIR.
Project Understanding
The proposed project is to adopt an update to the San Ramon General Plan, including
eleven respective General Plan elements, amendment to the San Ramon Village
Specific Plan, repeal of the North Camino Ramon Specific Plan, and the San Ramon
Zoning Code update. The 2040 General Plan would provide the framework for
development up to 10,155 net new residential units and up to 347,339 new non-
residential gross square feet. This project area is bisected by I-680.
Travel Demand Analysis
With the enactment of Senate Bill (SB) 743, Caltrans is focused on maximizing efficient
development patterns, innovative travel demand reduction strategies, and
multimodal improvements. For more information on how Caltrans assesses
Transportation Impact Studies, please review Caltrans’ Transportation Impact Study
Guide (link).
>ĞƚƚĞƌϯ
ngng ng
ϯͲϭ
2-8
5.9.a
Packet Pg. 206
At
t
a
c
h
m
e
n
t
:
A
.
R
e
s
o
l
u
t
i
o
n
N
o
.
2
0
2
3
-
1
3
2
,
c
e
r
t
i
f
y
i
n
g
t
h
e
S
a
n
R
a
m
o
n
G
e
n
e
r
a
l
P
l
a
n
2
0
4
0
E
I
R
,
w
i
t
h
E
x
h
i
b
i
t
s
1
t
h
r
o
u
g
h
3
(
2
0
2
3
-
4
2
:
D
ra
f
t
G
e
n
e
r
a
l
Exhibit H
Cindy M. Yee, Senior Planner
October 13, 2023
Page 2
“Provide a safe and reliable transportation network that serves all people and respects the environment”
The DEIR states that the operational Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) impact of the 2040
General Plan would be significant and unavoidable. Caltrans encourages policies and
programs related to land use and circulation that increase density, improve regional
accessibility, and reduce VMT. For additional TDM options, please refer to the Federal
Highway Administration’s Integrating Demand Management into the Transportation
Planning Process: A Desk Reference, Chapter 8 (link).
Multimodal Transportation Planning
Please review and include the reference to the Caltrans District 4 Pedestrian Plan
(2021) and the Caltrans District 4 Bike Plan (2018) in the DEIR. These two plans studied
existing conditions for walking and biking along and across the State Transportation
Network (STN) in the nine-county Bay Area and developed a list of location-based and
prioritized needs.
Please note that any Complete Streets reference should be updated to reflect
Caltrans Director’s Policy 37 (link) that highlights the importance of addressing the
needs of non-motorists and prioritizing space-efficient forms of mobility, while also
facilitating goods movement in a manner with the least environmental and social
impacts. This supersedes Deputy Directive 64-R1, and further builds upon its goals of
focusing on the movement of people and goods.
Thank you again for including Caltrans in the environmental review process. Should
you have any questions regarding this letter or for future project referrals, please
contact LDR-D4@dot.ca.gov.
Sincerely,
YUNSHENG LUO
Branch Chief, Local Development Review
Office of Regional and Community Planning
c: State Clearinghouse
nd
ϯͲϭ
d
ϯͲϮ
2-9
5.9.a
Packet Pg. 207
At
t
a
c
h
m
e
n
t
:
A
.
R
e
s
o
l
u
t
i
o
n
N
o
.
2
0
2
3
-
1
3
2
,
c
e
r
t
i
f
y
i
n
g
t
h
e
S
a
n
R
a
m
o
n
G
e
n
e
r
a
l
P
l
a
n
2
0
4
0
E
I
R
,
w
i
t
h
E
x
h
i
b
i
t
s
1
t
h
r
o
u
g
h
3
(
2
0
2
3
-
4
2
:
D
ra
f
t
G
e
n
e
r
a
l